Best pizza. An overused phrase, one that belies the taste of the reviewer, but perhaps not yours. Thick crust, thin crust? Rolled edge, stuffed edge? Sauce on top or bottom? Red or white? Mushrooms? Sausage? Pineapple? Jalapeño? Everyone has their favorite. I've tasted pizza all over the world, and there isn't one that stands out as the gold standard. But I've enjoyed most of them. Rome? Napoli? Bari? New York? New Jersey? Yes. All good. What impresses me is fresh ingredients, handmade dough, and a hearty red sauce or a perfect blend of cheeses if I do a white pizza. To that end, I found a hidden gem. The Pizza Box uses ingredients from their farm in upstate NY and those of their neighbors. The menu adjusts according to the crop. I had a garlic scape, a white pizza featuring fresh garlic from their garden, amazing portobello mushrooms, scallion, sea salt, and I added sausage. They don't sell slices, and I feared I might not finish the whole pie. I was wrong. I probably could have eaten another, it was so good! The crust was cooked perfectly, just the right amount of char, the cheese blend was spot on, and the sausage really closed the deal. Mike and his wife take pride in their food, and one bite will convince you it's worth the trip. Specials are offered depending on the crop, so keep going back. You'll thank me later. read more

See all

I was a little disappointed in the pizza. I feel like it could have been cooked a little longer. It was kind of floppy and I didn't love the cheese it felt a little low quality. What I will say is that the atmosphere inside is super comfortable, spacious, and a great place to come with friends! I love that they have a bunch of games! I'll also say the service was great, and the owner even came around and checked in on us! I would come back again to try different pizza and give them a second chance, especially because the prices are very reasonable. read more

The Pizza Box - Pepperoni Honey - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The crust was so good, my wife finished eating it. The owner welcomed us, walked us through the menu, and was all around a really nice guy. The place is a good size with a fun garden patio in the back. We ordered the margarita pizza and the al pastor pizza. Both were amazing. Great flavor, fantastic crust, no notes. We even got to try a pear, gorgenzola pizza they are trying out and it too, was fantastic. We will be back. read more

The Pizza Box is worth every penny with its inhalable 12 inch neopolitan pizzas made with 72 hour risen dough, fresh ingredients, and generous toppings! Order on their app, pick up in 15 minutes, and earn rewards point. Take it to go or enjoy in the back with their ample seating. Service is quick and friendly. Also, come round for their happy hour specials 5-7pm. On Tuesdays they have Trivia night. It's a really great addition to the neighborhood. read more

See all

I just stopped by earlier today after hearing about it on instagram and It Did Not Disappoint!!. I had the pepperoni with honey which was fire!!!. It was a very generous amount of pepperoni with the honey to finish!. So Good!!. Chef's kiss!!. Gotta try the gelato next time!. read more

See all

Literally the best pizza I've ever had. Ever. No grease, delicious tomato sauce. People are so great!

Really mean service on Halloween- not hospitable at all. Yelled at us for absolutely no reason. Pizza was fine- slow service as well

A classy personal pizza spot that Bleecker Street didn't know it needed. I know. I know. Did this street need ANOTHER pizza spot? Yes. This place serves elevated pizza. We ordered the fermented garlic, pepperoni and honey pizza. Honey on pizza is not new, but this one was beyond my expectations. It was so good I started questioning if the pepperoni cups were filled with butter. Nice selection of upstate NY IPAs and Italian sodas. Very cute decor and nice sized tables for groups. Service was 10/10. The owner and woman taking our order were kind, welcoming and attentive. I'll be back, as there are meatballs on the menu that I can't wait to try. read more

See all

This place is the best! The pizza is amazing and the people that work there are even better!! I highly recommend trying out this place. To top all of that, the ambiance is amazing! GREAT vibes!! One of the best pizza restaurants in NY! Ps. They don't have ranch. read more

The Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

New place in WV that we definitely needed. Owner, Melanie made us feel so welcome. They bring everything from their farm upstate and use sourdough for the crust. They had amazing samples to get people in the door and they have an excellent space in the back for future hosting! Add this to your list! read more

See all

Pizza was phenomenal. Very clean ingredients, did not feel bloated. The pizza felt like air but deliciously satisfying. The owner Melanie was welcoming and spent time talking to us about the business. read more

What a fabulous place to celebrate with friends!! We had our team holiday event at the Pizza Box and they couldn't have been more delightful. BUT, don't let me forget to mention - THE PIZZA!!! So yummy and lots of different flavors and fun combinations. The whole Pizza Box crew from owner Melanie to Chef Michael and the whole team - their attention to detail and the care with which they prepare the amazing pizza, but also the decor and the atmosphere of the location were unparalleled. We would not hesitate to come back. They even put a welcome message on their screen for the whole group. We had just come from volunteering @ Gods Love We Deliver and it was a perfect way to celebrate the work we do. Make sure you check out The Pizza Box - you won't regret it! read more

See all

We loved our pizza at the pizza box. Very interesting toppings. And they have amazing gluten-free crust! We will definitely be back, one of the best pizza that we've had gluten-free and my husband who is not gluten-free loved it as well read more

Such a cute place and the owner is so warm. Pizza locally sourced ingredients. Love the crispiness from the oven on the edges. read more

See all

The Pizza Box has managed to secure itself as my favorite pizza in NYC just after a few visits. We live in the area and stumbled upon this spot as we were walking around and they were giving out free samples. We have since been back 3 times, and we can't get enough! The food is truly so fresh, everything is farm to table, and they have a beautiful outdoor space. This spot is a family run business, and every time we have gone you can tell they truly are passionate about the product, and they want all of their customers to have a great experience. I cannot recommend this spot enough, it is an absolute must try! read more

See all

I got the gluten free pizza and it was insane The people working here are so amazing nd thoughtful read more

The Pizza Box - Gf pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I've been a loyal fan since I had my very first pizza of theirs upstate at a local charity event the Pizza Box truck appeared at. Mike, Melanie, and Max have since been mastering their craft. Now, we are all beneficiaries of their pursuit of the perfect pizza and a strong commitment to quality ingredients. I was so happy to be invited to the pre-opening event to see the new store. It's an incredible space, has a backyard area with a live garden, and a lovely little general store. Nice touches everywhere. The pizza is.... AMAZING! My personal favorite is the pepperoni with drizzled garlic infused honey. It's been a few days since I've had it and I cannot stop thinking about how good it is. A close second is the Fiacco sausage pizza. There are no misses on this menu, they are all delicious. Good luck Pizza Box NY!!! So glad you're a little closer to home and that we can enjoy all year-round. And special thanks for making us part of your "family"! read more

See all

Counter service was ok. Pizza tasted good but nothing special especially in NYC. Side order of meatballs were waste of money. Small and likely frozen not homemade. Too many other good options to say I'd rush back when in town. read more

It is both family vibes and also a super well-oiled machine. Idk who the tall friendly guy here is (Father Pizza Box?) but he's always smiling and cracking jokes. I get dinner here like once a week after work. Really cute patio too!! read more

Clean, fresh ingredients with house made dough - make for delicious pizzas! Check this place out! read more

10/10 service 10/10 food 10/10 ambiance. I came here once on a recommendation, and the workers were very friendly and helped recommend some pizzas! The pizzas (we got 3) were perfect in size, the bread was flaky and soft, and the flavor was great, well balanced, not over-powering in any way. What really surprised me was the huge space in the back. This is definitely going to be my go-to spot to bring a group of friends. A lot of pizza places (as you know) in the city, especially in the Noho/Soho area, lack seating where you can sit and enjoy the food. This space is big enough for a huge group! We also went during the holidays, so it was so nicely decorated with a TV of a fake fireplace, nearby a lighted Christmas Tree. read more

Great tasting pizza- ingredients are on point, crust has that perfect amount of burnt/crispiness on 'em. Dining space is nicely laid out and even has an outdoor patio seating. In an island of great pizza joints, The Pizza Box is a standout! *Not to be confused with the older joint of the same name that closed years ago! read more

The Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The best pizza and people! The crust is so delicious my friends and I love the classic margarita but also their fun seasonal white pies are so good. The service is great, ambience is fun, and they have great theme nights like trivia, love island watch parties etc.. pls give this place a visit it's amazing all around. read more

The Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

If you want a slice of pizza and a slice of life or nature, go to the Pizza Box at Bleecker st. The place is really great with a relaxing backyard with towering trees. The pizzas taste good and the service is exceptional. read more

The Pizza Box - I ordered a solo pepperoni pizza for my lunch. 6 slices and good for 1 person if you are really hungry and have not taken your breakfast. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Great family owned establishment and has a great back area if you dine-in. Really good individual sized pizzas. They had a nice set up for Knicks game as well. read more

Pizzas were delicious, the girl that attended us gave us good info on their gluten free pizza. Nice seating area in the back too read more

The Pizza Box - Garlic fermented honey pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Went there yesterday and it was amazing! I'm celiac and felt super comfortable the whole time and the pizza was one of the best gluten free deep dish I've had! Everyone who works there is super kind and accommodating! read more

Me and my partner stumbled on this place by chance honestly at first we stopped because we needed to use the restroom, and figured we'd just buy something small lol. We ended up getting pizza and it actually turned out to be really good (I don't think I've ever had a bad pizza in New York). Their fermented honey was really good ! Love a honey combo to go with my pizza But what really stood out was Audrey. She was so sweet, personable, and welcoming. We found out she was from Cali like us, and we ended up having a really genuine conversation on this random night. It's rare to come across people with that type of warm, authentic customer service nowadays, and it honestly made our experience even better. Shoutout to Audrey for being such a bright, positive energy. read more

This pizza spot is a great addition to the neighborhood. The pizzas have fresh ingredients, and the crust is yummy. You order at a counter and then there's indoor and outdoor seating options. We'll definitely be back. read more

Friendly staff, pizza was made super quick and it was delicious. The ambience is lovely and truly enjoyable experience. We truly enjoyed the Italian soda offering and how fresh everything tasted. The staff was super helpful, and kind a true feeling of being family business with care and love! read more

First off the service is INCREDIBLE. The owner is so passionate and put so much love into this place and it truly shows. The food is fresh and delicious all locally sourced, I would recommend the pepperoni with honey or the prosciutto with arugula. The atmosphere is warm inviting clean and cozy. The outside is so nice they have heaters and blankets. All at a great price. If you want a true New York pizza with great service and a stellar experience, come here!!! I cannot wait to come again. read more

The Pizza Box - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Excellent stop! Pizza was beyond delicious and pies were generously sized and the gelato was perfect for the hot summer day. But the staff was even better with great advice about the neighborhood, how they source ingredients, and making us feel at home. Will definitely be back. read more

I am a New York Pizza connoisseur, and I will say that this was legit. I don't even leave reviews like that but I had to speak up on this one. Restaurant was spacious, staff was nice and best of all they had solid pizza. Step outside getting the hyped up pizza on the block and make a stop. read more

Awesome new farm to table pizza place. Family owned and operated. Owner grows many ingredients and they put love into each bite. Space has a cool relaxed vibe with nice seating so you can sit awhile and enjoy your pizza. BTW - it looks like there may have been another pizza place here with a similar name. This is not the same business. Can't speak to them, but this Pizza Box is terrific. Another thing, I'm picky about crust. Theirs is super tasty and doesn't leave you feeling like you have to unbutton your jeans. read more

Best pizza I've ever tasted 100% loved everything amazing owner!! Service was excellent!! read more

The Pizza Box - Front - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Fabulous pizza and great service. Hosted a private party here and it was great! Fermented honey and peppperoni pizza rocked Plain cheese pizza is great And the meatballs were special read more

I stopped here over the weekend with my teen daughter who needed nourishment after sitting for the SAT. And boy, did The Pizza Box deliver! We got there right at 11am when it opened, and got a whole pizza hot out of the oven, plus delicious meatballs and yummy chocolate chip cookies. My only regret is that I didn't get to try more of their artisanal pies - so many interesting combos were on the board! Will have to go back this spring when the weather heats up for more slices and to enjoy the adorable back patio. This place is a real winner--excellent service, super tasty FRESH food and a cute design to boot! Don't wait--GO! read more

What a wonderful find. Reasonable price, delicious superior wood oven pizza, and amazing staff. Great atmosphere and the owner Mike came over to ask how everything was. Had a fabulous conversation about food, service, and life in general. Don't miss this gem if out and about on Bleaker street! read more

This new pizza place is fantastic. The quality of their farm-to-table ingredients was immediately noticeable - fresh produce (sometimes just hours from harvest), rich cheeses, and a perfectly fermented dough. And the menu changes with the seasons, so you're always getting the best of what's fresh and local. Even better, the family that owns it is incredibly kind and has a cool upstart story of starting a pizza trailer as a pandemic passion project. Highly recommend a stop here! They even have gluten free option read more

The Pizza Box - Trivia night on Tuesdays! - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This restaurant made it easy to host an important evening. Coordination was seamless, timing was spot-on, and the follow up afterwards was thoughtful! Melanie was exceptional - organized, calm and on top of every detail. On top of that - food was absolutely delicious! Our boss summed it up the best: 'Perfect evening!' read more