This is what Im always hoping for and forever disappointed. Not today, at the Pie Shop Amish Bakery is the real deal! The staff are fantastic and baked offerings over the top butter filled goodness. Brush Creek's homemade cheeses, particularly curds are a perfect protein balance to off set the sweet treat. Creamery read more

See all

I ordered avocado toast and instead I received avocado less toast and got two pieces of white bread, jam and bacon! The best compliment I can give this place is that the bacon was excellent ! read more

The food is really good recommend if in area kinda expensive but pizza is good. Cinnamon rolls are incredibly good danish are really good too and milk shacks are incredible read more

I have visited a couple of times in the last year. Both times have been disappointing. When I initially wrote my review a few years ago, the food was great and reasonably priced. I can't say the same anymore. I purchased a piece of pie to go. Their pie slices used to be $4, now they are $6. They are nowhere near the same size I had previously. The peach pie I purchased was a tiny slice that could be eaten in 4-5 bites, and was nearly flat, which meant there wasn't much peach filling. I could have gotten a better dessert elsewhere. The least expensive sandwich is a grilled cheese for $10. The most expensive is a steak sandwich for nearly $20! They also were out of pizza when I visited. So, shrinkflation has found it's way to Pie Safe Bakery. While the ambiance is great, I am not sure I will not be back soon. read more

The turkey sandwich.... WOW. This is the best sandwich I have ever had. The bread is so soft and warm. The actual shop is so welcoming and cute I could spend hours here. Will 100% come again this was the best lunch spot ever. Also get oatmeal raisin cookies. We had to literally get more they were that good. read more

The Pie Safe - Turkey sandwich, chicken salad, steak sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho

See all

Pizza was outstanding and cherry pie delicious. We will be returning!! Interesting big brick oven in the center of the building for the WOOD FIRED PIZZA . read more

The Pie Safe is our go to ! we know what ever we get will be fresh and tasty ! All there goods are made in house local sourced clean products ! Service excellent very kind friendly people read more

The best pie shop I have been to! They have amazing pies and lattes. They are baked daily. They also have jams, cheeses, handmade kitchen cooking utensils (spoons, cutting boards) and children toys. Every time I go to visit family we visit the shop. It is definitely a must! You won't regret it. read more

See all

Excellent cinnamon roll with thin dough layers, not too sweet, perfect spice and soft frosting, moist dough - goes down perfect with coffee and cream at the sunny storefront window. read more

The Pie Safe - Cinnamon roll - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho

Good old fashioned fresh pies. They are all good. Sandwich's and soup excellent. A must try.

Love this restaurant. These crêpes were a breakfast special, but I wish they were on the menu year round because they're so delicious! The service and ambiance is also amazing. This is a must try if you're in the area read more

The Pie Safe - Nectarine and raspberry crêpes with a fresh fruit smoothie - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho

Every time you walk in the door it's like you're walking into a different era of peaceful, small town charm. The quiet gift room will steal your attention for hours with all its locally homemade goods and crafts. In the dining area you will find shelves of homemade jams, jellies, pickled goods, teas and honey. The menu changes with the seasons but a few good staples are the lattes, homemade kombucha, cheese pizza and fruit smoothies. Excellent breakfast burritos and avocado toast will make for a great weekday breakfast and on the weekends they have specials which are very special!! You can always call ahead and place a to-go order if you're in a hurry! read more

The Pie Safe - New menu at the Pie Safe - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho

All I have to say is wow. This place is in the middle of the no where in ID but has an amazing ambiance and a cool home goods gift shop. The breakfast burrito was very good and the cheese danish was one of the best pastries I've had in a while. 10/10. I also saw they do wood fired pizzas that I wish I got to try. If you are during through or staying close by must swing by. read more

I moved to Deary in 2009, but moved away in 2015. Just this past year I moved back here and in my absence The Pie Safe has opened! What an asset it is to the local community. I honestly have not had anything on the menu that I didn't like, but my favorites are. Breakfast menu: Breakfast burrito Pancakes and sausage Biscuits and gravy Lunch: ALL pizzas! The parking fills up pretty fast and the lines can get long, but I promise it's worth the wait. read more

The Pie Safe - My nephew enjoying his cinnamon roll - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho

I had their cheese at a restaurant in Spokane. It was so delicious that l got online to track it down. Then drove to Deary to get it. And then there was pie! The venue is quaint & inviting; they did a great job renovating the space. Lunch was tasty. Since then l drive down at least once a year, and it's always worth the drive. Deary is so lucky to have them! .. I'm a little jealous. ;) read more

You can tell all food in house is handmade. Every aspect of every item is enhanced by attention to detail, plus a beautiful space with lots of natural light. You don't miss any intimacy from receiving counter service, it feels like a lot of lunch dates are having a good visit. Worth the drive read more

Stopped in for breakfast and got the avocado toast with an egg with some earl gray tea. The presentation and atmosphere is clean and quaint. The food is good read more

The Pie Safe - Avocado egg toast - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho

Amazing food! Drove here from Pullman, would drive from further if necessary. The lunch and the desserts were insanely scrumptious! Will come back for sure. Prices are very reasonable. read more

The Pie Safe - Tri tip sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho

I love this place!! It's a gem. The staff is super friendly and attentive. They serve delicious Danishes, croissants, specialty coffee's and by far the best burrito I've ever had. I hope an excuse to go back to Pie Safe presents itself in the near future. Great job everybody! read more

A wonderful place for breakfast/lunch!! Kind staff and good homemade food! I always stop by when I'm in town! read more

The Pie Safe - Blueberry huckleberry pie! - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho

If you ever find yourself in Deary, do yourself a favor and stop at The Pie Safe! On multiple occasions, it's been recommended that I visit, and I finally got the opportunity to do so yesterday. I ordered the potato bacon soup and a pastrami and cheese croissant, and was able to taste test the chocolate milkshake and pepperoni pizza, as well. It looks like they offer different soups daily, and I'm grateful to have come in on potato bacon soup day! In combination with the homemade bread roll that comes with it, it was flavorful and filling. The pastrami and cheese croissant was buttery and flaked apart in my hand. There's a creamery attached to the bakery, where you can watch cheese, raw milk, butter, etc be made and processed from scratch. It's for this reason that my partner decided to order a milkshake and a pizza. The ice cream was smooth, thick, and rich, and the cheese on the wood-fired pizza was divine. My partner said that it's the second-best pizza he's ever had! The staff is patient, flexible, and kind. When I asked if I could exchange an item on my order, they said yes without hesitation. The interior of the restaurant/bakery is well kept, clean, and fun to peruse. There are homemade quilts and stained-glass pieces, candles and soaps, and much more displayed around the seating area and in the attached gift shop. I will absolutely be making another trip to Deary in the near future so that I can try more food items! read more

Wonderful experience super friendly staff.One of the best small restaurants we've ever been to. The lemon rice soup was beyond, the fresh made sandwiches with fresh cooked meats, creative spreads, the home made bread with so much flavor and texture. There coffee hits the spot, and the fresh baked pastries....yum. Add to the experience the old world feeling of eating amongst kind, competent, and gifted staff. Looking forward to the next visit. read more

Delicious food, in an old restored building. And great staff! Definitely stop by if your are ever in the area.

Great food. A little expensive but 5 stars for sure. Really good food and customer service.

Excellent bakery for breakfast and lunch. They serve reservation only dinners a couple of times a month. Much of what they sell is sourced locally and made from scratch in the house. read more

The Pie Safe - Dining room - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho

Awesome food and dessert in a tiny little town. We went out of our way to try them out and we were not disappointed.

Make the trip, it's worth it. Friendly staff, AMAZING food, and cute shop to boot! It's worth making the trip to Deary for a lunch date!

Love this place. It's a little pricey but everything I've had here has been totally worth it. Croissants and danish, perfection. Pecan pie, heavenly. Pozole soup and fresh rolls, amazing. It didn't even have meat or the sausage and really didn't need it. I didn't miss it at all. We went for breakfast one day. Biscuits and gravy, delicious. Someone else at the table got the breakfast sandwich. Everything was so flavorful and well prepared. I want to try everything there and can't wait to sign up for one of their special dinners. Check their hours before heading over. I think currently they are open 7am-3pm, closed on Sunday's and Monday's. read more

We were staying in Deary while dropping our son off at college in Moscow. We stopped in for pie one day and came back several times for lunch during our stay. Food was great and definitely homemade, cheese, pies, and desserts were all top notch. Will be back next time in Idaho. read more

Always excellent, especially the pastries, pizzas, and yogurt parfaits. Make sure you visit if you're in the area.

Very pleasant atmosphere, the service was very good. The pizza was a bit mediocre, however

Fabulous find. Wonderful and nutritious food, stellar pie! Not too far from Moscow and Pullman. Check out the local lodging at the train depot, farm and renovated trains. A find and great option for college family weekend and graduation. read more

Best family friendly restaurant in the area! Health-conscious but delicious food! They offer homemade kombucha as well! read more

The Pie Safe - Egg and bacon breakfast sandwich! - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho

If the Pie Safe had opened in Moscow, it'd have a line out its door. If it had opened in Portland, Seattle or or San Francisco, food writers would be raving about it and it would be topping Eater's Heatmap. The fact that food this good, in a space this impressive, exists in Deary, Idaho is nothing short of a miracle. Before coming to the Pie Safe, I knew two things about Brush Creek Creamery. The first, is that that they make delicious cheese and sell it at the Moscow Farmer's Market. The second was a rumour that every time someone from the community that runs the Creamery enters a craft fair, that person wins by a mile. We figured that if people who were known for amazing cheeses and best-in-the-county crafts were going to let us try their baked goods, we should go ahead and try their baked goods. We made the drive on a Saturday morning in November, and it's hard to know where to start. First, the food. We ordered coffee and a couple cinnamon rolls, literally fresh out of the oven. A couple cinnamon rolls wasn't nearly enough, so we went back for more. Twice. The three adults in our group agreed that these were quite possibly the best cinnamon rolls we'd ever had. The three children in our group were too busy stuffing their faces to make much of a comment. When we were done with breakfast, we changed our plans for the day just so we could come back for lunch. After a couple hours of hiking around Elk Creek Falls, we did just that. This time, we ordered potato soup (the best we'd ever had), french onion soup (the best we'd ever had), a cobb salad (I don't mean to be repetitive, but again, the best we'd ever had) and a couple wood fired pizzas (which give Maialina a run for its money). That was before we saw an entirely different kind of cinnamon roll available now, so we went back for one of those. I'm firmly in the "nuts ruin everything" camp, but even I couldn't resist that pecan roll. Craftsmanship is a word that gets tossed around too lightly. But craftsmanship is at the core of everything at the Pie Safe. From the car that's parked out front, to the beautifully restored building, to the food, to the furnishings, to the quilts hanging on the walls and the strip-built canoe hanging from the ceiling. To put it another way: if Ron Swanson walked in to the Pie Safe, he would weep big manly tears of joy, and never leave. I expect we'll be spending a lot more time in Deary in the near future. read more

See all

Wonderful food, great atmosphere, and kind people. Their cheese is amazing, they have wonderful sweet rolls and danishes, as well as other delicious breakfast foods. Their sandwiches are wonderful and fresh! read more

I absolutely love everything about this place; the building, the customer service, the coffee and the food are all worth coming back for time and time again. Definitely recommend! read more

Great ambiance in an old, restored building in a charming town. Not 5 stars because the food is good but not great, and the portions are SMALL. The breakfast burrito was yummy, but tiny. The biscuits and gravy is above average. Sandwiches are fresh and tasty. Baked goods are old fashioned and spot on. Service is a little slow and not very friendly, but they get the job done. They also sell their cheeses here, which are truly amazing, but oh so expensive. A small wheel of Brie is $25. read more

The food is still great, but the reduced hours (7am-3pm) make it hard to eat here very often anymore.

Worth making a trip. Food is phenomenal. Restaurant is spotless and service is always over the top.

Almost too good to be true! Wonderful street front location in restored old 1920s gas station. We enjoyed strawberry rhubarb pie with amazing crust, alamode with homemade icecream. Bush Creek Creamery on site, watch them make award winning cheese through large windows. This place is the busiest corner in Deary, and no wonder. So worth the lovely drive from Moscow. Will return for brick oven pizzas in the very near future. read more

The Pie Safe - Rhubarb strawberry pie with home made icecream. So good! - Pizza Near Me - Deary, Idaho