Best start to finish meal I've had in a minute. Gracie is a gem. Every recommendation she had was…read moreperfection. Grab the corner seats at the bar. Start with the tuna. End with the cookie. Order everything else between. 10 stars.

As the sign on the bar suggests, we found "real" serendipitous joy here. Happened upon this bar…read moreafter walking around town post-dinner. Drinks are great and a lively, friendly atmosphere.

The Nautilus in Nantucket is an easy 5 stars. The energy is fun and buzzy, the space feels cozy,…read moreand the whole menu is built for sharing. Every dish that came out was packed with flavor, super fresh, and really creative - the kind of food that makes you want to order "one more" just to see what else they can do. Cocktails are just as impressive and pair perfectly with the food. Service was spot on - friendly, knowledgeable, and great with recommendations without ever feeling pushy. It's the perfect spot for a special night out on island, whether it's a date, a celebration, or just treating yourself. Definitely a must-visit in Nantucket.

Wow wow wow!!! Do not miss this spot on the island!! We came for our anniversary weekend and we…read morewere blown away by the whole experience. The drinks were phenomenal, but the food!! Scallion pancakes were a good start with a great dipping sauce. Yellowfin tuna wraps were super fresh and once again the sauces were insane. Steamed pork buns were delicious! But the best part of the night was the blue crab fried rice!! Highly recommend! Next time we want to try the duck when we come back.

I slipped into Sister Ship for a pre-dinner cocktail while recently on a business trip. This…read morerestaurant is a perfect spot to cozy up for some dinner and drinks. The bar area is stylish and comfortable, seating just a few. There's is a beautiful outdoor patio that wasn't open due to weather while I was there, but I've heard great things about the patio when it's open. I ordered the Faraway Mermaid (tequila, lime and jalapeño) and it was delicious. The menu consisted of unique options for food, but I had plans to eat elsewhere. Sister Ship is located in the Faraway Hotel, which is a cute boutique hotel, that I would love to stay at if I'm ever back on the island! Lentz_explore

Sistership is such a great spot -- the food is delicious, the vibe is fun, and the space is…read moreabsolutely beautiful."

Proprietors has quickly become one of my favorite spots on Nantucket. The steak tartare was…read moreinsanely good--super fresh, perfectly seasoned, and plated beautifully. The fried mushrooms were crispy, addictive, and full of flavor, and the chicken was cooked perfectly tender and juicy. On top of the great food, the service was warm, attentive, and on point the whole night. Definitely a must-visit if you're looking for a delicious, well-executed meal on island.

This was probably the best meal we had in Nantucket. Overall, we enjoyed the creative dishes and…read moregood tasting food! The cocktails and cocktails were good also. My favorites were the little gem salad (everything just worked so well together and I loved the cubed cheese croutons) and the lumache pasta. The Parker roll with caviar was pretty good but sad we had to share. The fried broccoli was fine. The steak came overcooked - we asked for medium rare but it came out medium - still not bad though. I will say it wasn't super comfortable inside. The chairs and booths were uncomfortable and tables were very cramped so although the food was good, we were sort of itching to finish and leave. The restaurant looks like it used to be a house, which seems to be the theme around here. Overall, definitely one of the better spots to eat on the island!

It is located bar the center of town on the second floor. The signage is limited. If you did not…read moreknow it was there you would walk right by. Upstairs there a barroom and a couple of dining rooms. I would not imagine they could have so much seating. I had the octopus and pot belly. The octopus was tender. Given how hard it is to cook octopuses this was an accomplishment. Then I had the venison, cooked rare. It was delicious. I would return anytime I was on the island.

Solid 4 star review. Oran Mor is one of those restaurants that I end up returning to every…read moresummer/every other summer for a few reasons. 1) You can usually get a last minute reservation. 2) The vibes are old Nantucket, located upstairs in an old brick house; it's dark and gives off that vibe that at any moment, a captain of a whaling ship will settle up next to you at the bar. And lastly, 3) the food. While meals historically have been a mixed bag, the food overall is a sure bet. Additionally, I love that the Oran Mor is more of an older crowd. I'm in my hanging with a 65 year old+ chic granny more than a 20 something year old influencer era. Ok, some more details. My batched cocktail off the menu was great - the cherry rickey. I love all things cherry and this hit home with a perfect mix of cherry and boozy flavors. We went with the snail app, the special crab pasta and the potato crusted fish. The crab pasta was solid, with the pasta being cooked perfectly. A tad bland, but that could just be the dish was more focused on that crab vs heavy seasoning. The fish was delicious, but disappointment came in with the sides. Sides are usually my favorite part of any dish, and the eggplant was burnt and ultimately kind of inedible and the veggie medley or whatever it was, was indeed a bit sad and underwhelming. My husband and I both were like womp womp. Even the additionally ordered creamed spinach was more of a creamy spinach soup vs spinach which we also would not order again. No dessert because Juice Bar be like around the corner. :) Service was great. We have been seated in the dining room and by the bar, and I appreciate both vibes. Overall, solid. Nantucket dining can be hit or miss with rezzies hard to find, so if Oran Mor is a possibility, I don't think you'll be disappointed (maybe just with the sides!).

I seldom write bad or negative reviews, so this one flummoxed me a bit…read more The appetizer was this wonderful cold mussel dish, with spices and a light oil. Just a nice, artisan dish akin to something you'd get in New Bedford or Fall River. Fantastic. 5-Stars. Now their lobster roll. Imagine a hot dog, OK, and now imagine one of those little Jimmy Dean breakfast sausage links for size comparison. The volume of finely shredded lobster meat, that was also warm in that hot dog roll was smaller than the Jimmy Dean link. 0-Stars. My recommendations for a "good" lobster roll is to go anywhere else on island. I'd recommend Sayle's Seafood, The Nantucket Lobster Trap or Stubby's. In fact, I'd just stay clear of the Club Car altogether, it is one of those places for the self-focused New York / Miami new [vulgar] money jet-set that treat the island like their play-thing... you know, you see their empty beer cans in the morning around town. That's my story, and I'm sticking to it.

Club Car Nantucket is an absolute 5-star go-to me. It's such a unique, lively vibe in the historic…read moretrain-car setting, with that classic Nantucket energy that feels special whether you're popping in for lunch or settling in for a full night out. The service is always on point (Bridget always takes care of us--she's genuinely so nice), and the food never misses: the lobster Cobb salad is fresh, loaded, and perfectly balanced, and the croque madame is pure comfort (savory, cheesy, and even better with the egg). And don't sleep on dinner, Club Car turns it up even more, and their steak frites is the best!

My wife and I were excited to try this place. She ordered the crab rangoons were actually very…read moregood. My wife ordered a raspberry drink and it was terrible. I ordered the Korean short ribs and the sauce smelled so offensive that my wife asked to leave before I could finish 3 short ribs. One water, one alcoholic drink, one order of short rib appetizers, and one order of 4 crab rangoons= $76.00. Do yourself a favor and get 4 bags of chips from the liquor store not far from there. I wanted it to be awesome- it just wasn't. The young lady that served us knew we were not happy, and her service was good. We still tipped her well, the food was not her fault.

Good drinks, live music and night life. Did not try any food but the bartenders were awesome, and…read morethe margs were on point! They have a patio to hang on in the summer all night long. Turns 21+ around 10pm.

We were here when it opened up in June of '25, and never have been disappointed. They will close…read moreafter Stroll, but hey, many things do on ACK. Fresh coffee and lemon ricotta pancakes - to die for! We always had breakfast here... worth the walk if you're staying in town. Great service. Great music. Light, airy and clean environment. Highest recommendation!

The location of the restaurant is great, sitting near the water, but the menu is a bit incongruous…read moreand I think the restaurant could do better by focusing on a theme or their strong suits. Dishes were very expensive and not well prepared in basic ways. We ordered several dishes: * steak frites - steak was overcooked. *linguine with clams - clams were great. The noodles were extremely overcooked and stuck together in a sheet *cavatelli - noodles were gummy and dish was over salted. I understand the restaurant is only a few months old. Hopefully they can improve as they gain more experience.

We came here twice with a large group and young kids…read more Very kid friendly. The outdoor seating in the back is perfect for groups with young kids. They took us as walk ins both times during off-peak season for lunch. The food and service is great. The cocktails are also very good. The menu is American with some noticeable Asian fusion influence. Would definitely come back here again.

Exactly what I was looking for in a midday snack and drink. Super bright and upbeat music pumping…read morethroughout. The bar is large enough where you can typically find a seat - also, has TVs!

A beautiful venue and a holdover from the past. Events are held here, likewise you can just catch a…read moreflick. Not expensive by ACK standards. Enjoy, and take a picture of your spouse next to Mister Rogers.

Stunned to be charged $3 "service fee" to buy a movie ticket in person! So wrong in so many ways.read more