Quite a change from the old Starlight…read more Creative, well executed small plates and main dishes. Beef tartare was excellent, and the Tuna Sashimi Bowl hit the spot as well. Service was solid and prompt; the overall "price/value" relationship is arguably the only fly in the ointment...fine dining pricing in a "bar style" atmosphere, even by Nantucket standards. Will come again, though.

What an awful experience. First off why do I need to provide an ID to eat dinner at 8:30, that's…read moreridiculous! Secondly, we weren't done with dinner and this server decided it was time to clear our food out of the way without even asking if we were done. Don't really want to go back. Pretty cool environment though.

My friends and I stopped at Rose and Crown after a day of strolling the streets of Nantucket and…read morebefore we had to get on the ferry. The bartender was very friendly and we got served right away. The beers were great-- I love a hoppy IPA and my friend also enjoyed her cider. The appetizers were standard and definitely hit the spot. Easy spot for a quick bite, good drinks, and great people watching.

A comfortable pub right off Main Street. Nice selection of tap beers and the menu looks pretty…read moregood. We had the smoked bluefish pate with crackers which was DELICIOUS

A generously portioned bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich served on a buttery croissant with a side of…read morecomplimentary crispy hash browns-all for Under $15 in Nantucket!? That's a rare find. The Club Car Restaurant, housed in a restored 19th century railroad car, serves delicious breakfast and lunch in a unique setting without breaking the bank-something that's hard to come by on the island. This spot is definitely worth a visit.

After reading the other one-star review, I don't expect this review will get a response either…read more However, I'm posting it so other people are aware and hopefully don't end up in the same situation. I have been trying for almost a year to contact The Club Car about an experience I had. I have called multiple times, left messages, and emailed, but I have never received a response. I made reservations at The Club Car's sister restaurant, Nantucket Tap Room. My confirmation text said my reservation was at The Club Car, so I called right away. I was told not to worry because they are sister restaurants and the confirmation "just said The Club Car." On the day of our reservation, I called the Tap Room just to confirm. That's when I was told I did not have a reservation there and that it was actually at The Club Car. Thankfully, the manager was able to get us a table at the Tap Room. When we arrived, I asked the hostess if The Club Car had been notified, and she assured me the reservation had been canceled. I had a wonderful dinner with my husband and son. We spent well over $400 and left very happy. Then I received my credit card statement and saw a $75 no-show charge from The Club Car. I immediately called and was told a manager would contact me. No one ever did. Nearly a year later, after multiple phone calls, voicemails, and emails requesting a refund, I still have not received a single response. The reservation mix-up was frustrating, but what has been even more disappointing is the complete lack of customer service afterward. I understand that mistakes happen, but charging a customer a no-show fee after your own staff assured them everything had been taken care of, then ignoring every attempt to resolve it for almost a year, is unacceptable.

Really enjoyed the Tap Room. Ate outside on the patio on a beautiful evening. The service, food and…read moredrinks were excellent.

Great popovers and service was fantastic. Nice little spot to sit outside. No reservations. Easy.read more

Is it $18 for a mudslide that you could make at home for cheap? Yes. But is it a place you think…read moreabout fondly when looking back at Nantucket? Also yes. A mandatory stop every time we are on the island, but usually just for one drink. If not looking for the mudslides (which, why are you even here??), the Surf Report is a nice refreshing drink made with local vodka!

I came here for drinks after reading they had the #1 mudslide on the island. It was good, but I…read moredon't see where the hype was. My friends and I also ordered food and it was just pretty average. Between four meals and 8 drinks, it was over $300 which wasn't worth the quality overall. The ambiance is fun and lively and staff is ok. I wish our waitress came by more quickly. Not sure if I'd come back.

Very popular and loud place!! The bar area outdoors is lovely with the garden decor and lights…read morestrung around. There were SO many people here; looked like a college crowd. The food was delicious and expensive. We had the asparagus salad and summer salad. Both were delicious and fresh. Steak frites were delicious and the serving size was decent. Duck carnitas was the hit! The duck was delicious and tender. The toppings (pickled onions, pickled veggies, salsa) with the corn tortillas were just right. You prep your own tacos with all the fillings. This was our favorite and we enjoyed the unique concept to use duck! It was an expensive meal but worth it! Service was great. I took more photos but realized they were quite blurry due to it being dark out and I didn't give my phone enough time to capture the photo. I wanted to eat!!! I would definitely come again.

Wonderful seating service, great ladies with a great sense of humor…read more Seated easily on a Wednesday with no wait; there were about three other sets of patrons, two younger collegiate types, and an older jet-set like ourselves. This being 1:00 pm too. Or, The Whale boasts a great wait staff who are accommodating and professional, as well as being just plain nice. A very clean establishment. We started with the crudités as an appetizer, and we both had the asparagus salad as our lunch - to die for! Very, very good! Priced nicely, and no negatives whatsoever. This place is always packed for dinner, so we were glad that on a Wednesday we were able to waltz in for luncheon. A must do when on island.

Worst experience. We are 26 and it was DEAD bouncer took my friends ID and wouldn't accept it even…read morethough it's 100% legal and legitimate. Rudest and most unnecessary encounter for our last night in Nantucket,

I was asked to leave just for speaking Portuguese on the phone, even though I was quiet and the…read moreplace was empty. There was no valid reason for this other than the language I was speaking. This kind of behavior is unacceptable and clearly discriminatory. If you're not a white American, you're not welcome here. Don't come this place is not for you. Do Not go to this place! They are very racist if you are foreign National.

always great hostess/waitressing staff that is professional, friendly and great. My real kudos is…read moreto the chef. from the duck to the steak he knows how to cook

Great place for a quick drink before hopping on the ferry. Off the main drag so less busy and less…read morenoisy. Ample bar seating available and drinks were strong. Staff was limited but still well attended while we were there and they were friendly.