I love this diner, they are temporarily closed due to rebuilding after a fire. They are serving…read morefood out of a food trailer at local events to gain funds to rebuild the diner. Please call them and help out.

What a great spot to grab breakfast or brunch! My husband and I had so much fun with our server…read moreAlecia, when we stopped for a late breakfast. We were able to sit at the countertop in the dining car and watch Tabby prepare meals at the grill. The French Toast special of the day was a Monte Cristo ... 2 slices of French toast, grilled ham and cheese, Dijon mustard and strawberry jam created the most flavorful breakfast sandwich! I enjoyed the loaded tater tots and half order was more than enough to satisfy my appetite. I like that they offered a smaller portion! The little wall plaques with fun sayings above the grill kept us entertained during our visit. It was a perfect ending to our birthday, anniversary, birthday event weekend (BABE WEEK!) Thanks for making our visit special ladies ... we give you SIX STARS!

Unfortunately I didn't take any pics. My wife and I stopped in on Sunday before our ride home…read moreafter spending the weekend in Penn Yan. The workers all made us to feel like family, the food was very very good. Very veteran oriented if you have served please stop there for a meal. This restaurant is very cozy I can't say anything more on how good they are there isn't enough good words to express how nice Angels is. If ever in Penn Yan I will be eating breakfast there.

Mostly a breakfast place. Throwback booths, stool counter service. Good, but not memorableread more

Never disappointed at Wagner. Great fish dinner on Friday from 4-7, but hard to choose between some…read moreof the other specials like stuffed pork chops or stuffed peppers; my favorites. The waitresses are delightful and serve promptly.

Great half size omlette. Very good portion. Quick service! Good ambience. Friendly environment.read more

Stopped for dinner on the way to the lake. Certainly won't go again. Only a few tables of regular…read morecustomers and 1 waitress, also several tables of what appeared to be off duty employees. They wrote up their own orders and took them to the cook while multiple children ran in and out of the kitchen. Their food came out while we waited over 30 minutes for 2 meals and a side salad. Hope the health inspector sees this.

Good food, fair pricing. Very welcoming. We often go on Friday nights for the fish fry. Love their…read moreBLT sandwich. Cozy.

This is an old dining car that first opened in 1941 in Elmira and then was brought to Horseheads in…read more1974. Vintage sliding wooden door to enter the dining car. Either sit at the counter or in one of the booths or even at a few tables outside. A waitress brought our menus promptly and was friendly and prompt throughout. They serve breakfast and lunch until 2 p.m. We opted for breakfast. I had the cinnamon French toast and sausage. My friend had the 2 meat breakfast plate with eggs, toast, home fries, and sausage. Both were decent, and surprisingly the coffee was excellent. If you are in the area check this place out. The ambience alone is worth the visit.

Fast service and fast food service. Some nice breakfast eats. Small diner car restaurant!read more

My wife, teenage son, and I stopped here for ice cream in early July 2025 on a very hot and muggy…read moreevening. The interior is cozy with a red Coca-Cola theme, but there's a larger area with outdoor seating in the back and drive-thru window. It was packed with folks! Service was prompt for trying their home-made ice cream. I ordered the cookies-n-cream which was good but not great. A key ingredient seemed to be missing as it was less sweet than expected. Also, it had a lumpy uneven texture that made it somewhat difficult to eat. Perhaps I had unreasonably high expectations from other places like Ben & Jerry's (in Vermont) or Jeni's Splendid Ice Cream (in Columbus, OH). That said, it's worth a visit to Seneca Farms if you're in Penn Yan. A lot of people seemed to enjoy the fried chicken.

Yes it is a little pricier for their ice cream than other places in the area but it's worth it!…read moreThey have a drive through option for ice cream which is so cool. Plenty of seating outside and there's also a fun area for kids to play.

Came by on a Tuesday night. Service was great…read more We got the pretzel bites - comes with an IPA infused cheese. I ordered the custom burger - cooked well to my liking and was a standard, solid burger. We ordered the kids chicken tenders. Fries are solid here. Chicken tenders are also good. They also have some arcade games, but they didn't have them on when we got there. They turned it on eventually.

Yes, yes, calm down, yo, I know it's been another hot minute since your boy Tony has laid down the…read morestraight dope on some joint. And, yup, the rumors are true, I am now thrice divorced. As such I am past the point in my life where I will ever be somebody's husband, but I'm more than happy to be someone's dude. And as my new lady's dude, I came up here to help her move her youngest into Keuka College this coming week. An aside: don't listen to your douchy Manhattan cousin who says the Finger Lakes "aren't quite a destination" - these lakes are legit. Anyways, it's lovely up here. Now my new lady also takes care of her oldest's six year-old during the summer so he's up here too and is a wily cat, mad obsessed with that Italian Brain Rot bag right now, and...well, let me just tell you... So we're just walking in downtown Penn Yan apropos of nothing, and there's this joint with a leprechaun on the wall called Silverbird. We all walk in not expecting anything, and holy heck this place looked like a 1970s time warp inside. But the staff was nice and the grub was decent, and what really made this a hit was the totally random vintage arcade inside. For just a few quarters you can play skeeball, bowling, and baseball pin ball until your heart's content. And hand to god, the kid didn't make one single reference to Italian Brain Rot the entire time we were there. Thank you, Silverbird. From the bottom of my bitter yet vintage arcade loving heart.

The food and service were great. I had the braised short ribs. Tender and savory. The risotto was…read morethe perfect side. I would return.

We opened a business in the area & are checking out local restaurants so we can make…read morerecommendations to our clients. We've heard mixed reviews for this restaurant, and after our own experience we definitely won't be recommending this one. The menu & prices say fine dining.... But that's not what we experienced. We had to ask for the wine list, it wasn't given to us with the menu as you would in a well run restaurant. The view of the lake would have been great, but the windows were filthy on the inside and out. My husbands steak that was ordered well done arrived blackened on the outside and literally ice cold and raw on the inside. The only person who offered any kind of acknowledgment for nearly giving my husband salmonella was the waiter but it wasn't his responsibility to apologize. My steak was cooked correctly but it was a very tough piece of meat. The price markup on the wine was OVER DOUBLE. Pretty sure our deserts were not made fresh.... They were awful. There was really no excuse for a bad experience... there were only a handful of customers. (Now we know why.) Very disappointing experience and we will not go back. I worked in the fine dining restaurant industry for decades... the main deck is very overpriced, very poorly run & desperately needs a new manager. The only positives were the waiter was good, and the risotto was very good. This place has potential with competent management & kitchen staff. We will not be back. *review copied from my Open Table review.

Without doubt, some of the best biscuits and gravy I've had!…read more Coffee was good, corned beef hash was also very good. The cinnamon donuts were amazing.

A great spot for breakfast (and probably lunch) if you're in the area. We went based on the…read morerecommendation of our AirBnB host and it was as good as promised. The recommendation said it's where the farmers go for breakfast and indeed they were there. Staff was great and attentive, food options were what you'd expect and well executed. I had the classic breakfast (eggs, meant, toast) and my wife had the sausage gravy and biscuits and they were good. Prices were very reasonable so you should have plenty left to leave a good tip.

This family-owned establishment is a great place to grab a meal, drinks, snacks, and/ or groceries…read morein Penn Yan, NY. Located off Lake Keuka, The Olney Place offers a good variety of sandwiches and other food items as well as nice craft beers in their tap room. I went here with my family and friends for lunch. My friends told us about The Olney as a great place for sandwiches and craft brews, and I was totally down for it. The Olney is a big shop with indoor and patio seating areas overlooking Lake Keuka. It has counter service. We ordered three sandwiches. One was the Mustang, the other one was Scotsman, and the third one, I can't remember. The Mustang had ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo, oil, and vinegar on an 8" bread roll. The Scotsman originally came with tuna salad, banana peppers, bacon, and tomatoes in a wrap, but I asked for chicken salad and on an 8" roll instead. The sandwiches were flavorful and delicious. Mine hit the spot. I also had a Hawaiian Punch Sour beer from Rising Storm brewery, and it was refreshingly delicious. I had a good experience and would go back here. Check out this establishment when in the Penn Yan area of upstate NY.

If you ever go here you have to get the delicious home made cinnamon rolls in the morning when they…read morefirst open. Also this place has good sandwiches would recommend the Rachel which is so good. And this place has an insane view of keuka lake when you're eating your food. Also this place is a half grocery store which you can shop and eat. Also this place has a very cool bar looking over the lake. And if you go outside by the picnic tables there is couple games including cornhole.