Loved the old school vibe of the diner itself. Old unrestored diner that was made in Paterson NJ. Walk in and it was busy!! Counter in front of you with grill on the other side of it and booths against the front windows. Outside seating also. Waitress was excellent. Coffee cam quick and was good. Normal diner breakfast meaning not foofy. Normal eggs potatoes pancakes etc. However they make a great omelet called the Zito........ Omelet w corned beef hash, bacon, and American cheese inside! Never have I had CBH as an omelet filling and never combined w chopped bacon and cheese! It was incredibly good if you're a hash fan. Busy place w lots of action....... It's an d blue collar diner that time forgot that I'm glad I came across!! Waitesss was on point and nice!! Great place!!!! read more

This is an old dining car that first opened in 1941 in Elmira and then was brought to Horseheads in 1974. Vintage sliding wooden door to enter the dining car. Either sit at the counter or in one of the booths or even at a few tables outside. A waitress brought our menus promptly and was friendly and prompt throughout. They serve breakfast and lunch until 2 p.m. We opted for breakfast. I had the cinnamon French toast and sausage. My friend had the 2 meat breakfast plate with eggs, toast, home fries, and sausage. Both were decent, and surprisingly the coffee was excellent. If you are in the area check this place out. The ambience alone is worth the visit. read more

See all

Really cool spot, they don't make em like this anymore! True slice of Americana...we had the french toast, bacon, and a Ham & Cheese omelette, all of which was superb! Was very busy and don't think they take reservations, so you may have to wait for a table, but I think it's worth it. read more

The food was fantastic, the service was great, but the best part was probably the ambience, this is a quintessential old school diner breakfast for early birds and working men. It was awesome, don't eat in a franchise, eat here with real people. read more

Unfortunately, this business is not wheelchair accessible. The entrance and facilities are not accessible for individuals with mobility challenges. While many small businesses may be grandfathered under certain ADA provisions, that does not mean they should not make an effort to be accessible. read more

Don't get me wrong. I've eaten here before when I was healthy and the food is great but the building is not ADA compliant. I stopped today and I couldn't even get in read more

Fast service and fast food service. Some nice breakfast eats. Small diner car restaurant! read more

See all

This diner is a slice of the past. The food and service was really good. Nice to find a place where you can just come in sit and have a cup of coffee and some good breakfast. Felt like a time capsule in the train cart. read more

The food was very refreshing. The best meal I've had in awhile- the sourdough is so fresh and even tastes like wheat. Ordered an omelette. Very nice, quaint gem. The staff was cool too. Thank you read more

A great classic 1940s diner, with pocket entry doors and awesome atmosphere. The menu is classic American style and service was really good. Put it on your diner tour of Southern NY read more

Excellent food! Friendly staff. Steak and eggs done to perfection. Would ear there again! Really delicious.

This is a tiny, old-fashioned diner. Very friendly, but when we showed up at 7AM we had to wait for a booth. By eight is was less crowded. There are also seats on an outdoor patio. it is the usual diner food, but well done in a friendly setting. read more

My family loves the place. It's neat eating in an old rail car. Anyone who's a train fanatic will love it as it looks great. It's clean and nice but still antiquated in a good way. It does mean there's limited seating and they are often really busy. Food is always great. We often go for breakfast but once went for lunch and had awesome BLTs. Staff is always friendly and attentive. Highly recommend for the Horseheads area. read more

IMMEDIATELY hit by the stuffy smells but understandable since it's a small place. It wasn't that busy and took the waitress 10 min to come over. One item we ordered was THE BIG PANCAKE. I then see the disgruntled and angry cook place a pre-made pancake on the grill to warm it up as our other food was cooking. Hash browns under done and bland. Bacon underdone and rubbery. 1 out of 2 eggs cooked well while the other yolk was shriveled up. The waitress was a bitch from the start. She only bothered to come back with the bill. She asked us how it was and we were honest about the pancake and said the rest was good (even though it was not). She made a face as if to argue with us with disagreement and confusion. She did ask if we would like him to "make another one.". I then said as nicely as I could, "well, I think the problem is if you reheat one instead of making it, it isn't too good." She then said, "oh no, we make them fresh to order." Anyway, between the smells, disgruntled cook, terrible food and bitchy waitress it's safe to say we won't be back. I will add the car seat on the floor with a new born baby steps away from the cooking station and bar stools was a new one for me. read more

Prices were great for a large amount of food, and my meal tasted great! The service was quick, and the owner and rest of the staff were very friendly. read more

Yalll, add this place to the list as a must for breakfast!! The service was very good! Our waitress was very nice and attentive. I got the Bases Loaded with Hash browns and Taylor got the Big Papi Omelet. It was all good but the hash browns were my favorite! They were so good! Taylor's omelet was stuffed full! The servings are big here so bring your appetite! The setting is so unique and has so much character! Would rate this a 5/5 all across the board. read more

The Diner - The Big Papi Omelet - Diners Near Me - Horseheads, New York

My husband and I waited at the door and it took at least 5 minutes before either one of the two waitresses to acknowledged us. My husband tried to get the waitresses attention but she ignored him until she was ready and then stated that she doesn't respond when people talk to her as she is walking away?! My husband even gave her a compliment. She then provided our check and my husband put his card on top of the check at the end of the table. She put the card reader in front of me. I then moved it in front of my husband so he could sign. We gave her a 20% tip anyway because it's just who we are. We said goodbye and no one would acknowledge us but the owner. It's a disheartening feeling to feel unwelcome as we were really looking forward to having a positive experience. read more

ridiculous hours that dont accommodate everyone and finally when i make time to try this food its terrible, poorly made, completely unappetizing in general wouldnt try it again read more

Great little diner I found on Yelp here in Horseheads NY. A real old stainless diner with real food that's real good! Service was great and the food was great!! Spinach, ham cheese omelette was awesome. Fresh spinach made it, along with fresh cut home fries. I'd return in a heartbeat!! read more

The Diner - Omelette! - Diners Near Me - Horseheads, New York

See all

Everything was delicious. Even though it was a busy Saturday morning the service was still quick. I had the Munson sandwich. Very tasty. Chicken and waffles were good. Bambino breakfast was huge and delicious. Can't wait to go back. read more

Great little place 20 of us showed up for breakfast The waitress couldn't have been friendlier or more accommodating. Cook cranked out plate after plate in record time. All hot and tasty. Would definitely recommend you give it a try read more

Great western omelette and fries. Do not eat home fries they were like croutons. There is a little wait time.

Fantastic breakfast place. Prices were great the food was fantastic and the service was second to none.

This was one of my favorite places in the area. Nice little place. Great staff, great food. Super courteous people. Win hands down over the Barrel Place we all know about. Go here for breakfast. What they lack in size they more than make up for in every other way. read more

Good breakfast! Simple short-order cooking. Was really busy while we were there...road construction going on nearby. Staff seemed a little stressed, which is understandable. Huge pancakes. Eggs could have been scrambled a little better--I don't like seeing so many white streaks!! But, again, they were very busy. Just a good, local diner for a good, inexpensive breakfast. They also serve lunch. Seating is limited and a little cramped...it is an authentic, albeit small, diner car! read more

We get take out quite often. My favs are the Sausage biscuits and gravy bowl or one of their ginormous blueberry pancakes!! Yummy!!

Food was great! Service was really good wait was a little long but worth it! I'd go back again!!!

Went to have a late breakfast the food was good price was reasonable. service was quick and friendly.

very cute place, but the waitress gave me a cup of coffee and just deserted me. I take cream in my coffee but had no one to ask for cream so I just sat there not drinking my coffee. After many minutes, she came back to take my order. I started to speak and she said oh I forgot something and walked away. I then sat for another length of time and watched her get drinks for other people and bus tables so finally I just decided to leave. I came back to put two dollars on the counter for the coffee I didn't drink and she finally came over and I said I don't even have cream for my coffee and she's like well I'm busy and there are other people here I can CERTAINLY go get them for you with a really snotty tone and she was really rude. if people want local businesses to thrive customers can't be treated like the worst things in the world just wanted a couple of eggs for breakfast. The ventilation I think could be improved in there as it was pretty humid and I think that affects the moods of the people that work there and the smell of the eggs on the fryer was really overwhelming. Get a nice fan to blow a breeze through there, and I think everyone will be a lot happier. read more

Small place that's super busy. All the locals we here. Service is super friendly but a little slow. Not the place to stop in if you are pressed for time. 4th star for super waitress. read more

Love this cute little place! There's probably only 7-8 booths and a bar so it's very small!!! The food is made right in front of you. This place was made out of an old railroad cart I believe. Fast service, good food, and great prices. Can't beat it. This is where all the locals go. Must try it out! I got a green omelette without green peppers and with American cheese. My dad got the same thing but with Swiss cheese. Personally we didn't like the Swiss cheese because it was kind of dull and not tasty in the omelette. But the American cheese was! I was able to substitute the toast that comes with the omelette with 1 slice of cinnamon French toast! Very delicious. read more

See all

Service was good and menu looked promising, but none of our meals impressed. I was surprised that the table one over from us left so much food on their plates. Ummmm....I get it now. Sorry. Wasn't my favorite. read more

Great service, large portions, excellently prepared. A throw back in time. Even the quaint railroad style bathroom.

Food is always good if not great, especially breakfast. Burgers are awesome. Service is always good, they all know everyone so sometimes they get shooting the breeze and forget something or someone and that's ok. All the customers know each other makes for a nice atmosphere. My favorite place in town.. read more

Pretty expensive. Not much taste to the omelette. The sausage patties were way too greasy. Cofffee not bad.

I really like diners- my wife and I came here on recommendation from a long time local. My wife had the Philly Cheesesteak w homemade fries- she loves this combo and felt this rated at least among the best and probably the best. I tried her fries and they were the best I've had. I took the lunch special: meatloaf w gravy on Mashed Potatoes w green peas- better than Mom made. I guess we're hooked! BTW, my meatloaf lasted for 3 more meals and my wife's philly cheesesteak has made it to 2 meals so far. The diner is a classic chrome diner with a certificate on the wall. Service sparkled! read more

The Diner - the best phillycheesesteak w homemake chips - Diners Near Me - Horseheads, New York

See all

Hidden little gem ,well at least to me it was .Im sure people out here know this spot very well.there were a lot of people coming out and a lot more outside waiting to be seated I'm not from around here ,but will definitely come back when i visit again.That man made my bacon with extra love!! And the waitress was super nice.. read more

The Diner - an omelet, toast, and bacon on a plate - Diners Near Me - Horseheads, New York

See all

Amazing breakfast!!!! If you're in the Horseheads area and are thinking about going to Cracker Barrel for breakfast... don't your time or money there!!! The Diner in my opinion is the #1 breakfast spot in this area! read more

The inside is small, and even more limited with COVID going on but it was definitely worth the wait. You will NOT walk (or crawl) away from a breakfast here still hungry. The pancakes are HUGE -- be aware. I like diners and the experience and The Diner didn't disappoint. They do have outdoor seating but you do need be seated by the hostess. read more

Can't tell you if the food is any good because after waiting 35 minutes for 2 egg sandwiches our incompetent waitress served our food to 2 a**holes at the counter who were in a rush and didn't mind eating food they didn't order..rather than make a scene we simply didn't pay for our coffees and walked out..Don't waste your time or money at this "SO CALLED" diner read more