I had not been to The Grill in ages, and my husband had never been, so we tried it on a Friday night. We were greeted and seated very quickly. Husband had the pork chops ($16.99) you can choose 2 sides and if you like, they'll make them BBQ Or Cajun. He chose Cajun. There were two giant pork chops on the plate. He said they were thick & juicy, and perfectly cooked. Definitely pleased. I chose the Smothered Monterey Jack chicken ($15.99) with broccoli & garlic mashed potatoes. The breast was small, but VERY tasty! Covered in cheese, sautéed onions & mushrooms. The garlic mashed potatoes were good too! Our service was good and the manger came around to see how we were doing. I noticed he visited several tables to see if everyone was happy. Overall a very good visit and we'll be back. The four stars is because they have several burger, chicken, & specialty sandwich options, that sound wonderful, but they only come with chips. If you want fries or onion rings, you have to pay $2.79 extra, on a burger that is already $12. Plus extra .79 cents for "deluxe," Which includes, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, and pickle. I feel like (with all the many restaurants that offer combos) this is a little disappointing. We will still return, because what we had was very good. But if we want a burger or hot sandwich, we will go somewhere that offers side options, included in the meal. read more

The Grill - Pork chops (Cajun seasoning) w/ rice pilaf and mac n cheese. - American Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

See all

I went with a party of 14. We were promptly seated and served. I had the fried grouper, with their signature fries and slaw. The food arrived hot. The slaw didn't stand out, but was hand-cut, and acceptable. The fries were uniquely flavored, and delicious! The grouper was cooked nicely, and was also very good. Drinks are rather pricy, but the food was a very good value. Everyone liked what they were eating! Staff was courteous and attentive. I would strongly recommend! read more

Food was tasty. Atmosphere was fine. Wait staff nice and cordial. Owner made us nervous pacing up and down. If he wants to watch his staff, just stay by the hostess desk. It's ok to ask us how are food was, but not necessary. Honestly, we couldn't relax. He needs to chill!! We will be back to eat, but if he continues to pace, we will go elsewhere. Too many good restaurants in Indy and surrounding areas!! read more

Super tasty! Their chicken tenders are top tier and they have a wide variety of food options!

I didn't expect too much from The Grill as a typical bar-food restaraunt (not usually my fave), but a friend and I were out nearby and hungry after a day of thrifting and wanted something local instead of a chain. This place was a pleasant surprise and really hit the spot! It was pretty empty when we arrived, but we were there for a late-lunch/early-dinner. They have lots of tables, but seemed like they were spaced well so it wouldn't feel too crowded even if they were busy. The menu had a lot of options and I settled on the Blazin' Chicken Breast sandwich and upgraded the side to fries instead of potato chips. My friend got a buffalo chicken salad and we split some breaded mushrooms too. Everything came out in a huge portion, hot, and delicious! You never really know what you're going to get when it comes to fries, but I was so happy with these ones--every single fry was perfectly crispy! Service was good too and if I lived closer to this area of town, I think it'd be a regular stop for a quick, satisfying meal. read more

The Grill - Blazin' Chicken Sandwich, breaded mushrooms, and a buffalo chicken salad - American Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

See all

I'm torn on this restaurant. The food is good, the service is good and the restaurant seems clean (the smell of bleach hits you at the door). However, it's insane to charge for toppings on a sandwich. A tenderloin should come with lettuce, tomato, mayo, and onion- this place charges you for it. Also, their sandwiches don't come with fries, they upcharge you for those as well. I will say, the tenderloin is very good. Just wish they didn't nickel and dime you. read more

Our gathering at 'The GRILL' Friday Night was also a lot of laughter and memories being shared. After chatting for a while, it was time to order. Nancy is having the "Worlds Best Tenderloin" Sandwich; Premium Pork Centercut Tenderloin, hand breaded. Served on a toasted bun with your favorite garnishes (Lettuce, Red Onion & Mayo). I went with the "Prime Rib French Dip"; shaved Prime Rib on a Hoagie Roll with sauteed Onions, Provolone Cheese. Served with warm Au jus & Chips. Ava is our server and she is taking care of all 26 of us keeping the waters & iced teas filled along with reorders of drinks. Needless to say she earned the "Dollar-Bow-Tie" Award and loved it (and of course, a Very Nice Tip). read more

See all

Ava is THEE BEST SERVER!! Reasonably priced, great food with an even better server. Super recommendations read more

Some of the food is okay, but they are so cheap about everything, that it just kinda sucks there. The silverware is maybe the worst I have ever seen.....other than plastic. The hand wash faucet puts out less water than I thought was possible. The hand dry towel is so small....just shows how cheap of a place they got. The workers are good, they try to do what they gotta do. read more

The service is very good. Their food is also very good. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone. They have a very large selection of food. read more

I have driven past The Grill multiple times and have been meaning to stop in, I finally got the chance to on Sunday. I was thrifting with fellow Yelper Merry and we worked up an appetite, we stopped in at around 4/4:30 in the afternoon. The restaurant was empty when we arrived as expected due to the time, and we were offered our choice of a table or booth. The staff that greeted us were welcoming and friendly. Many more people tricked in for dinner while we were there, majority of which seemed to be regulars as the staff greeted them by name which was lovely to see. Our server came to the table immediately and asked if we had any questions, as we had never been I asked what the popular items were and what she enjoyed. She shared that their onion rings are the most popular appetizer, but her favourite were the wings. We ordered a spicy chicken sandwich, the crispy chicken salad, and the breaded mushrooms. Our food came out quickly but not so fast that we questioned the freshness. I customized my salad and had the chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, which the kitchen accommodated without hesitation. Portion sizes are large, and the food is tasty. The menu is extensive and I had a hard time deciding what to choose, this is a place to go if you have a group with different meal preferences. There is a dining side and a bar side, I may venture out to the bar side and watch the Super Bowl and try the wings and onion rings. read more

The Grill - Crispy chicken salad, customized with buffalo sauce. Breaded mushrooms. Spicy chicken sandwich. - American Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

See all

We LOVE this place! We always have spectacular service and the food is AMAZING! It is one of the best run restaurants we have seen around here and we are avid bar rescue watchers. This owner knows what he's doing. My girls love the Our Famous Nachos. I typically get a grilled or fried chicken salad, both are great! My fiance says their chicken tenders are the best ones around hands down... even better than Ale Emporium. I would encourage you to try this place out although they are always pretty busy so come early. read more

Group of 16 came for lunch. Our experience was very mixed. Some liked their meal but 3 were so bad they sent theirs back (two taco salads were inedible) Waitress was unconcerned and didn't offer any additional options. Manager never came to check after taco salad returns! I ordered steamed broccoli. Came out cold and mostly raw. Asked for properly steamed broccoli. Waitress left. Came back with plate and asked me to scrape my broccoli onto the plate. She brought it back microwaved and grossly shriveled! When I took it to manager, he was completely unfazed. Very poor customer service. While some meals were good, the wait staff and especially the manager were subpar at best. No way to run a restaurant. read more

In the past we have always had a good experience with food and service at the Grill in McCordsville. I went there for lunch recently and ordered cottage cheese, a wrap, and iced tea. When the cottage cheese came I put a spoonful in my mouth and started to chew and heard my teeth cracking. I stopped chewing and spit out a hard piece of plastic. I flagged down my waitress and after showing her what I had found she asked if I would like another dish of cottage cheese. I said I did, but decided not to eat it. The waitress showed the piece of plastic to the owner and all I heard was the two of them chuckling. They may have been discussing something else but the appearance was that he didn't care. He did not even come over to discuss the issue or apologize. As I finished the rest of my meal my iced tea was getting low and the waitress refilled my glass out of a pitcher. I noticed a dark object floating in my glass and pulled it out with a fork. It was a huge dead fly!!! At that moment I decided not to finish any of the food I had left. It was pretty disgusting to think about what the rest of my food may have been exposed to. After this incident the manager still did not come to my table to discuss what had happened. The waitress told me she was going to discount my meal but all she did was take the iced tea off my bill. We will not be going back. Hopefully they clean up their act. read more

See all

Fantastic grilled buffalo shrimp!, absolutely delicious. Always great service and friendly staff.

A friend told me about it and I have been several times. Love the grilled tenderloin, fried mushrooms and onion rings.

Their chicken tenders and ranch are some of the best in the area! Lots of parking in a strip mall setting. read more

The Grill - tables and chairs in a restaurant - American Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

See all

We meet family the first Tuesday of the month to try tenderloins and this was the intent! However, they had several lunch specials for $8.79 and it included your drink. Couldn't pass it up! The food was delicious and large servings. You will not leave hungry! The dining room was very clean. The staff were very friendly! A great place to go anytime! You will be glad you did! read more

Every time I've been to The Grill, I've wanted to like it, but I haven't. I've tried their loaded tots, potato skins, chicken sandwich, shrimp, and French onion soup. Nothing is exceptionally great. The service isn't usually the best either. Today I paid $19.42 for two tiny cups of French onion soup. I'm very disappointed that this local restaurant is not that great. read more

The Grill - French Onion Soup - American Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

One of my favorite places for a breaded tenderloin near New Palestine, IN! The owner, Robert, was there the day we went in, he works hard to ensure all of his customers are having the best experience. The tenderloin is thick and juicy and the breading was near perfect! Everyone (-1) at our table had the fried tenderloin and enjoyed them! The green beans were also really tasty. My husband had the chicken fajita and said it was also very good. read more

I ordered the jerk wrap and the wrap only had a few bites of chicken and NO flavor. Jerk is supposed to be spicy. So not only that, there was no flavor at all. I asked for a full serving of chicken and the server rolled her eyes and said there's chicken so I asked for an additional side of chicken. It was brought out with no flavor. I asked for a side or the jerk sauce or marinade and she took the chicken and brought it back out with seasoning salt. So disappointed in my food. My sweet potato waffle were good though. Can confidently say that I won't be returning. Not only was my food not good, the service wasn't great either read more

The food here is always good, no matter what I choose! The staff is very attentive, especially the manager/owner.

I'm not sure where the people who had a bad experience ate at, but it doesn't seem like it was The Grill. I have lived her for 3-1/2 years and in that time, my aunt from southern TN (yes TN) and my parents from southern IN make regular trips to eat here. I have also family who have been in the area for more than 25 years and only went to The Grill to meet up for meals. They've been here MULTIPLE times now. The only reason they came up here to watch the April 8th eclipse is because I promised them lunch from The Grill. While at first glance, the menu seems a bit pricey, the portions justify the expense. Between us in the past few years, we've had the Nachos (definitely can feed a family of four!), appetizer platter with chicken "fingers" (more like the whole hand!), fried mushrooms, fried pickles, potato skins, hamburger steak, sirloin, filet mignon (on steak nights), chicken alfredo, steak bites (kids menu), fish and chips, fajitas, taco salad, fajita wrap, oriental wrap, philly cheesesteak, french dip, buffalo shrimp, fried chicken sandwich, wedge salad, pepperoni flatbread, Strawberry salad (M-Th lunch special only), make your own hamburger, pork tenderloin sandwich - and, last, but not least, onion rings....These are hands down the BEST onion rings I've ever had. We ALL order and pay the upcharge. Their ranch and baja ranch are homemade and phenomenal! Since we've eaten through most of the menu, we've settled on our faves and "go-to's" are: Pork Tenderloin sandwich, Fish and Chips (subbing onion rings for chips) Philly Cheesesteak, Oriental Wrap and Fajita wrap with Steak instead of chicken, and Pork Tenderloin sandwich. We always have left overs to take home. The pork tenderloin is as big as your face. The service is always top-notch. Every waitress has taken time to chat a bit. We always get refills to go at no extra charge. We don't know the owners, but they are always there and things run smoothly. The only issue I've ever had is when I ordered the build-your-own burger. I wanted a regular bacon cheeseburger and ordered the BBQ burger without the BBQ sauce. It ended up with the sauce, which was good, but it's not what I wanted. The manager fixed it right away and even topped off my onion rings. read more

This place has really gone down in quality. I would recommend the breaded mushrooms, but that's about it. Very disappointed in the poor service, super lackluster salmon, pizza, burger and explanation of side items - our table of 4 was summarily disappointed. Oh and if you order a side item of the California "Medley," don't order the side of Broccoli - the "Medley" is about 95% broccoli, with two small carrot pieces and two super-oil saturated zucchini slices - when this was brought to management's attention, they acted unaware of any issue. I asked for a side of Rice Pilaf then, and never received, but was charged for the added side item, not realizing this until after the sale was complete. All around a big disappointment. read more

The one thing I miss the most about living in McCordsville is this place. It's different and secluded from everything. I can be sure to go here and never run into anyone I know, makes me feel free but also the food is awesome and so are the people. Thank you so much for making this a nice place to be. read more

I had high expectations because some coworkers were raving about this place, and to be fair if you don't have any dietary restrictions it might be amazing, but my experience was very bleh. I ordered the buffalo chicken sandwich on a gluten free bun with a side of fries instead of chips. Generally I don't like to order gluten free buns because they fall apart, so I asked for a lettuce wrap and was told they couldn't do that. But later someone from my party later asked for additonal lettuce for themselves and they brought her a plate of lettuce leaves. So they have they can do a lettuce wrap, they choose not to. When I got my order they didn't substitute fries like I had asked or bring the side of sauce. On a positive note- they have good fries and play decent music. read more

Excellent breaded tenderloin, mushrooms, and onion rings at reasonable prices. We'll definitely be back.

OMG... We went to the Grill for St. Paddy's Day. As soon as we arrived we were given necklaces and koozies .My favorite was the French Onion soup. The salad was excellent!. It was huge. My hubs had the tenderloin and chips. Very good, as per him. The Reuben was giant! My friend had the chicken fingers. First time for her and she really loved it. Our meals were great! Give the Grill a try. You'll be glad you did! read more

See all

I ordered a full slab of ribs and pain $35 with tax, $40 with tip to go. Got a half side of green beans and less than half of macaroni and cheese. Very unhappy with the sides. read more

The Grill - Sides less than half full - American Near Me - McCordsville, Indiana

As always the Grill never disappoints! Despite the fact that we showed up with a group of 16 folks the service was spot on and food was terrific! There is a reason why this restaurant is consistently busy! read more

We have eaten at The Grill twice in the last month. We were seated immediately, even though we went for lunch at noon and they were busy. The service was great and the restaurant was very clean. The food is great! We had the grouper sandwich and the tenderloin with onion rings- excellent taste! read more

I came here for dinner as part of a group on a Friday night. I had the seared ahi tuna dinner served over rice with cauliflower. I loved the tuna they did a great job of preparing the dish. The service was excellent. We even had a full bottle of Monterey wine. It was a Friday night and the place was quiet. This restaurant is located in the heart of downtown Carmel, which is a nice area to be on a Friday night. I do highly recommend coming to this place for dinner. read more

First time at this restaurant with my husband, our experience was great. Location: it's located off of a big street so it's easy to find. It's located in a strip mall so parking is very convenient. Service: service was good. Waiter was attentive and we got what we asked for quickly. Ambiance: it was very cozy and friendly. We were surprised to see many elders. I understood why at the end of our meal. Price: price is very reasonable and affordable. Daily special is something to check out. Food: food was good. Appetizer platter was a good choice for us to share. Pork chop tasted like the one that my husband cooks at home which is pretty good. I think fish dish I had was a cod and it was good. At the end of meal we understood why there were so many elders. We felt like we were served with very good home cooked meals. We really enjoyed it. We'll definitely go back. read more

See all

We had the fettuccine Alfredo and it was delicious! Best breadsticks on the East side and a wonderful salad. Highly recommend! We've never had a bad meal or bad service! We picked up our dinner to go read more

Never coming back here! I paid $3.99 for a small scoop of fries and when I asked for my money back the manager didn't want to give it to me and got an attitude for no reason. I kept the onion rings and threw up 2 hours later!! Don't come here unless you want to get sick read more

Picked up some Grilled chicken sandwiches for carryout and they were very tasty! Loved that they took precautions to keep bread fresh and not let get soggy. read more

Visiting from out of town and stopped here on a recommendation. Terrific service and delicious food. Nice ambiance, with both a bar area and a separate dining area as well as a spacious patio. Also, exceptionally clean, even the restroom which seems to be rare these days. Gives you a lot of confidence in the quality and safety of the food and kitchen! Highly recommend. read more

Let's start with the greeter he was welcoming, I said this is my first time at the restaurant he said were welcome. I'm sure you'll enjoy money back guaranteed! as long as you don't clean the plate and then ask for your money back. First couple bites. tell the story..the salmon was bone dry. It was overcooked. I don't mind that it was bland. I understand the salt content you want to add your own if at all. It had a good grill flavor. The green beans canned green beans with some bacon bits cooked in to help flavor them ..which I don't approve of. I was hoping for a fresh sautéed in a little butter or EVOO with some crunch? I know that cost more money but when you're dining out, you expect the best. I don't eat canned green beans at home! The mashed potatoes are good. I've tasted some of my friends and she said her shrimp were good and I didn't have any. I suppose they weren't over cooked which is real easy to do. Rice pilaf right out of the box. I should've ordered a potato. The silverware needs a serious upgrade there thin and flat the bottom of the barrel cheap. Would I dine there again, probably not. read more

See all

We tried The Grill for the 1st time a week ago and loved the food and service. My son had the Queso burger and said it was cooked perfectly. I had the chicken quesadillas and the flavor was excellent. Our server was great and you could tell he cared about his job. I would highly recommend trying The Grill out when you're in the Mccordsville area. read more

Great food and even better service! The ribs are absolutely delicious and bones just fall out from the meat. The menu is extensive and there is something for everyone. All the meals include generous portions. The staff and servers are very polite and attentive, and empty plates are removed immediately. read more