The dining room needed a refresh, it was clean though I am not a Benedict person but i did order the classic egg Benedict person but this is the best I have ever had. The poached egg was perfect. The potato's were crisp (as I had ordered). Service was excellent. The price was comparable to other restaurants. All in all, I would recommend it to anyone and I will go back read more

Tonys Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Looking for a great little breakfast joint that is locally owned and operated? Looking foar good food at a good price? Tony's is it. Never a wait and the food is always hot and tasty. read more

Tonys Cafe - Interior photo of Tony's - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Tony's Cafe is a relatively small, family owned breakfast/brunch restaurant located in a fairly nondescript strip center in Fishers. I must confess, and this is a bit of a generalization, that my experience has mostly been that when visiting a brunch restaurant you mostly forget about the "unch." In other words, when breakfast is the emphasis one should focus on breakfast. Tony's is along the lines of places like Lincoln Square, etc. They serve breakfast all day (closing at 3pm) and also serve lunch. I arrived on a Sunday about 1pm. I was in the mood for lunch, however, I was also a bit hesitant. I'd hoped to go to CR Hero's (located in an adjacent strip center), however, they're closed Sundays. Thus, I ended up at Tony's. Tony's has a full breakfast menu with all the usuals along with a lunch menu of sandwiches, burgers, chicken options, etc. I'm always on the lookout for a decent breaded tenderloin for my good buddy and fellow Yelper Rick G., so I opted for a breaded tenderloin with fries. This building has a handful of accessible parking spots along with curb cuts at both ends of the building. Tony's Cafe is toward the west end of the building. However, those spots were taken and I parked at the other end. There's a double-glass door entryway and then you're in the dining room. There's a small hosting area to the left - this is also where you pay. Service was friendly in a quiet way. I have to admit that the tenderloin was a bit of a disappointment. It was very mid-range. It came on a toasted bun with the usual tomato/lettuce toppings. It wasn't bad. It wasn't good. It was just sort of "meh." The fries, which are not crinkle-cut as pictured on their website, were also definitely mid-range. I was for sure wishing I'd opted for a breakfast selection. The iced tea was fine and in a decent-sized glass, though I was never offered a refill (a major faux pas for this iced tea lover). The bill came in at just over $15 without tip. I would not even think about ordering this meal again, though I likely would return and try breakfast since the atmosphere was fine and the service was friendly if unremarkable. The atmosphere? It's an opening dining room with booths on the side and tables in the middle. It's fairly nondescript, however, it's also definitely clean. I did not check out the restrooms on this visit. I was easily able to find a wheelchair friendly table and there was decent space between tables. Overall, this was a full-on mid-range experience. It definitely wasn't as solid as I'd been hoping going into it, however, it was a decent meal. Again, my gut told me to go for breakfast options and I likely should have listened to that. Business was modest, though it was getting near the end of the day when I finally left right around 2pm. read more

Tonys Cafe - Breaded tenderloin and fries - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Decent hole-in-the-wall restaurant with a wide variety of menu options, attentive service and great prices. A special today was Pork Chops (cooked to order - medium and pink for me) and eggs over easy. My side was a bowl of creamy grits. Tami chose the oatmeal with blueberries and bananas. Good coffee, good service. read more

Excellent service, great home - cooked food in a homey setting! Recommend the great daily menu read more

About our third time here ALWAYS amazing! This time I got some coffee OM goodness the only other coffee I could drink black was the coffee at our coffee shop. DELICIOUS! Tried The Greek Skillet, I have some comments. I took off the green pepper 'cause personally I don't like peppers, but the onions... kinda take away the flavor of everything else. Gyro is AMAZING! It's never too crowded, it's comfortable and the service I always great! Tony's, keep doing what you're doin' read more

See all

This place is family owned , and worked by the family. We love going here for breakfast on the weekends. The food is excellent and the service is quick and kind. read more

We decided to go here after waiting way too long somewhere else for brunch. We came around 1pm on a Sunday and had no wait for 3 of us to be seated! The waitress was friendly and attentive. We ordered several food items as we were starving from trying to be seated at another restaurant for brunch. Our food was perfect temperature and came out in a timely manner. Portions are good size and prices are very reasonable here. I would definitely recommend this place for breakfast or brunch. I love corn beef hash and they alot of corn beef hash options. I only suggest more veggie options for skillets, why only green peppers? What about the red, orange and yellow peppers? There was parking readily available out front of the restaurant. The bathrooms were clean. read more

See all

Fantastic breakfast or lunch place. They have excellent omelets and pancakes. Club sandwiches are terrific. Friendly staff and service is great. Try this neighborhood spot over the local chains. read more

1) I love brunch. It's by far the best meal and I won't hear otherwise from anyone 2) it's so fun finding new locally owned spots and I'm really glad I ran into Tony's! The place is fairly big and open and the menu has many traditional options, but also some more interesting things like what I ordered! I found it absolutely delicious and a worthwhile restaurant to stop in and try! Eggs Benedict biscuits and gravy read more

Tonys Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Good food and service. Small place that's very clean. Breakfast and lunch. Only had breakfast. Will definitely try lunch next time

I wish you could give half stars. This place has been open, maybe a year... probably longer. Strip mall parking. Bare bones interior. Really bare bones. We were seated immediately on a Saturday at 10 am which was nice but we waited quite a while for our food. Diner food feel and reasonable prices. My omelette was paper thin and not fluffy at all. The Swiss cheese tasted like a processed slice. The toast, pancakes, skillet and hash browns were good. I love dives but this place needs to work on their ambience. Would I go back to try something else? Sure. They have a large menu and daily specials. read more

See all

You can't beat Tony's for a quick, solid, fair priced meal. Everything I've had from Tony's has been satisfying. Great local breakfast/lunch place. I'm always surprised when the place isn't packed. Maybe it's not bougie enough for the area? Terrific for take-out! read more

Been a few times now and is always delicious! It is a small gem of a place in the Geist/Fishers area! They have a huge menu for breakfast, brunch, lunch and dinner, whatever you are looking for! Never over crowded, so no line like everywhere else in Fishers and Geist! We always go for late breakfast and get varies skillet combos always a hit, pancakes soft and fluffy, chicken tenders perfectly crispy for the kids, grits smooth and creamy, and coffee is great as well! Will keep going and bringing new customers. read more

See all

We selected Tony's cafe to cater an event and "WOW"...super impressed. The owner was so easy to work with and the food was over the top fresh & delicious. Hand-breaded chicken tenders, huge garden salad (with delicious homemade ranch dressing), assorted wraps and one of the best fruit salads with strawberries, blueberries, cantaloupe, watermelon and pineapple...all fresh cut. Highly recommend if you are looking for a caterer...and you'd be supporting a family owned local business. read more

Food is okay but nothing special. Service is okay and people are nice. The prices are a bit high for size of say the Omelettes. The best part of this restaurant is the location is easy for kids to go alone and feel like big stuff! Overall good place read more

The South of the Border Skillet was perfect balance of all ingredients with the eggs being a perfect over medium as well. Fresh wheat toast Their Belgium Waffle was deliciously crisp with good maple syrup. Strong Black coffee was great I will be back! read more

Tonys Cafe - Delicious Perfection - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

The cafe is located in a strip mall. We walked in on Saturday morning around 9am and maybe we were the first customers. Soon few other tables were filled but it didn't get busy. I had a country fried steak skillet. It was good. Restaurant looked clean and staffs were friendly. read more

Tonys Cafe - Country fried steak skillet - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

The staff was nice and attentive, and the food was tasty and cooked well. Great local spot!

Stopped in for breakfast on Saturday. Place was not very crowded. Service was slow and food was cold. Would not return. read more

We loved everything about this place. Family owned and operated. Kind and attentive service. The food was delicious and came out quickly. The menu had a variety of breakfast options. Perfect food portions and great prices. We will definitely be back. read more

Food was bland at its best . The order was not same as described on menu - We ordered the burger and this did not include tomatoes and lettuce - menu states it includes tomatoes and lettuce . Waiter would not add tomatoes and lettuce. Service was slow and waiter did not come back and follow up on our food . was disappointed with the service and food served . I will not come back here again as there are other restaurants that provide better service and food . read more

We went here for breakfast last Saturday morning after seeing a positive review on the local Fishers neighborhoods online forum / board for this newly-opened restaurant. Glad we gave it a shot given it's a new, local eatery, but they have a lot of improving to do in our book. We were seated in short order by the young hostess, but it was at least 7-8 minutes before our server (the one and only server for the entire dining room) came to our table. We took that opportunity to place both our food and drink orders at that time. Hubby chose the biscuits and gravy platter, which includes two eggs cooked to order along with hash browns, and I opted for the Portuguese omelette with grits as the side. [Note: if you want cheese added to the omelette, you'll need to ask.] After a few bites, we agreed that the food lacked flavor as well as seasoning. We ate maybe half of our meals and then waved down the server for our check. We did not ask her for to-go containers. If Tony's wants to survive, I'd suggest increasing customer-facing staff (i.e., more than 1 server for the entire dining room), increase customer service 'touches' (i.e., quickly acknowledge newly-seated customers, take drink orders immediately, check back within a few minutes of food being served, etc.) and improve the quality and taste of your menu items. Lastly, Hubby noticed they were not wiping down hardcopy menus between customers. That should be a given during these times. read more

Tonys Cafe - Biscuits & gravy platter and Portuguese omelette w/grits. Sadly, lacked flavor & seasoning. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We went for Sunday morning breakfast. We were the only ones for a bit but service, food and atmosphere will bring us back often. The portion sizes were perfect, not too much! read more

Came for breakfast this morning and waited for 15 minutes before having to get up and ask for someone to take my order. When the server came over I mentioned we had been waiting a long time and said "you lying"! Unbelievable..... Good food but definitely need to train and coach service. read more

Been coming here for over a year and we have come to expect the same consistent service and great food as day one, while remaining affordable. The atmosphere is very laid back and while it's not trendy, it's very clean. I just wish they would claim their Yelp presence! For a location that borders on 5 stars, why would you not claim your presence? It signals to us that you don't read your reviews or care about feedback. read more

Tonys Cafe - Coffee - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

We came here for the first time today and it was delicious! The wait staff is nice, and we each ordered a skillet. All three of us ate the entire skillet and our bread. The food was hot and flavorful. The prices are great too for the portions. Will be coming back! read more

Sweet place! Delicious breakfast menu! I had the South west skillet that was excellent! There is plenty of parking. We had a large group and they were very accommodating. read more

Don't let curbside deter you from eating here!! Exceptional food. Truly some of the best pancakes I've ever had. Breakfast skillet- 2 thumbs up!! read more

I discovered Tony's due to someone on our neighborhood app recommending it, so we went for a late lunch on Saturday. It's a small little spot in a strip mall at 96th and mithopper ( I know I spelled that wrong.)). I am always enticed to try a Rebeun at a new pace. This did not disappoint. Nicely grilled and thin slices meat, served with a side of fries. Hubs has a gyro which was pretty straight forward as well. Menu has a variety of sandwich and breakfast items, that I would go back to try more. #yum #ReviewsByRL read more

This place is a hidden gem! Excellent food. Try it if you're in the area. Friendly service. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Ate almost my whole meal then found a small piece of thin yarn in the omelet I ordered. Totally grossed me out!!! Told the server another lady came over and asked if I wanted something else!? I wished I didn't eat the food I had already eaten. read more

I just visited Tony's Cafe for the first time on 2/2/21. The food was fresh, delicious and wonderful!! I would say the best grits I've ever had! My aunt had the Apple Crepes and she said they were very delicious. I will definitely being going back soon with my husband so I can try other items on their menu. read more

My waffle was great as well as the sausage that came with it and my wife had a fish sandwich that she enjoyed and a very fresh salad.

Wonderful! We ordered a 465 skillet which is delicious with fresh mushrooms, onions, chicken and great portion of shredded potatoes with eggs! The other order was Tony's Biscuit and gravy platter the portions exceeded our appetites which are great for $10 each! Great Saturday location and they just opened congrats to all of you serving delish style brunch!! read more

I really enjoyed my lunch from Tony's. The tenderloin was great and it was made fresh and prepared exactly as I wanted it. My wife and kids had breakfast. The portions are big and it's all fresh to order. read more

Tonys Cafe - Dining area - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Came during prime brunch time on a Saturday but still, the service was so slow. Took 10 minutes just to get a menu and another 5 for drinks. Food....I may still be waiting when you read this. Definitely understaffed. read more

One server for over 12 tables. We waited over 40 minutes for our food. They ran out of mugs for coffee. We were seated right away but had to wait 10 minutes to be waited on. . read more

My favorite informal restaurant. Good food. Good service. Good prices. This minority-owned, family-run restaurant started during the covid pandemic when many restaurants closed down. It made it past that big hurdle which speaks well of it. It is not a fancy place to impress a date or a client. But it is a great place for a family or retiree to get a good meal at a good price. I am a vegetarian and I have plenty of options. read more

We go out of our way to eat here when driving through Indy. Super clean, great service and tasty menu. Everything is good!