I've been to The Dakota three times now, and the experience has been pretty consistent each visit. The food is very good, I genuinely have no complaints there and have enjoyed everything I've ordered. The prices are reasonable for what you get, which is definitely a plus. That said, the atmosphere can be a bit loud since the bar is right next to the dining area. It gives more of a lively, social vibe than an intimate one. I also noticed that the staff can come across as having a bit of an attitude both toward customers and sometimes with each other. I wouldn't take it personally, it just seems to be the overall tone there. I would highly recommend it for a fun night out with friends girls' night, boys' night, casual group dinner. But it's not the place I'd choose for a romantic dinner, and if top-tier customer service is a must for you, this may not be your favorite spot. Overall: great food, fair prices, fun vibe just go in knowing what to expect. read more

The Dakota - Pubs Near Me - Hilton, New York

See all

Always great food and friendly staff. Bartenders will make you any drink you ask for.

We went here for the first time as a family and loved it! Great food that was family friendly, and a nice dining room. My toddler loved his pasta, I had a great prime rib, and my husband enjoyed his chicken riggies.our service was great too! read more

We decided on the The Dakota Grill for dinner last night. We got there around 5:30ish. We walked in the hostess seated us at a table as the place was starting to fill up and all of the booths which I would've preferred were saved for reservations. Our waitress came to the table a few minutes later and took our drink orders which was ice water with lemon and I ordered Moscato I had 2 glasses before/ during/ after dinner and so did he with his Tito's Vodka and raspberry iced tea. she was new and busy I think she said she'd only been waitressing there for 3 days. She was pleasant and was really trying to do a good job and in my opinion she did. So she came back with our drinks and took our orders. He got a bowl of the lobster bisque soup and I got a small salad for our appetizers and then a short time later our dinners came out. I got the Sicilian Arancini which was good it didn't have pecorino Romano in it and that's what I'm used to but they were hot and good. I got 4 and I ate 2. I never eat all of anything lol! I had the remaining 2 for lunch today and with anything that has red sauce in it- it always tastes better the 2nd day. And he got the blackened fish with French fries and Mac salad. He didn't finish his dinner either the portion sizes are big and reasonably priced. The place is big enough, it's a nice place to go to on occasion something different. read more

The Dakota - Sicilian Arancini - Pubs Near Me - Hilton, New York

Would you believe $1 uncharge for gravy on your mashed potatoes? Unbelievable. The waitress didn't tell me there was an uncharge for a salad or gravy on my mashed potatoes. But an uncharge for gravy? I don't know whether to be mad or amused. Mad. The salmon was overcooked, dry. The waitress was bored, didn't care about us, unfriendly, had to be reminded twice to bring sugar. $1 for gravy. Won't be back. read more

My favorite place to go for trivia night and broccoli French is amazing. Fast and friendly bar service always from Matt read more

See all

Tables are a bit crammed in but the food was excellent! Fish fry was great and so were the Gnocchi's (homemade) drinks were reasonably priced. Live music as well! read more

My wife had fishfry. I had fra divalo. Mine was decent, sauce a bit watery My wife fishfry she said was okay. I tested it, and fish was mushy inside the breading. But the place is LOUD. Can't really have any conversation read more

The Dakota is like any other bar/restaurant. eh. It has a nice ambience when there aren't drunk people ruining your time. The food is alright but if you are looking for actually good food might as well splurge a little and go somewhere actually nice. read more

Amazing place! The food is delightful and very tasty. A nice wide variety of choices. One of my favs is the pesto bacon chicken sandwich! The service is quick and very polite. Also very honest about what's good. :3 The restaurant is splits between a bar and a dining area. Very clean and nice bathroom. 10/10 highly recommended!!! read more

My husband and I stopped in for dinner and I wasn't sure what to order as there are a lot of options. I went with the linguine and white clam sauce and it was just lacking any depth of flavor. The sauce seemed watery. My husband liked his burger though so maybe I will try that next time read more

Huge disappointment. The gentleman at the table next to us had what appeared to be wayyyy too much alcohol and projectile vomited in our direction with some of it splashing under our table/shoes. We moved our table to the bar after helping the gentleman. When we received our food my salmon was dry and the mashed potatoes and broccoli was cold. I would have sent it back but the person I was with hates when people send food back. His lasagna was over cooked. Fortunately nobody was very hungry after the vomiting on/near us. Management didn't even offer a free drink. read more

I emailed the Dakota 2 weeks ago and never received a response. I even explained in the email that I did not want to rush to a negative review. My email to them that went unanswered: "I contemplated writing google and yelp reviews based on my experiences at your restaurant/bar but before I do, I feel the professional thing to do is to share them with you first. As a business owner myself, I am very aware that things happen from time to time and that no business is perfect. Additionally, I realize there are unethical competitors out there who will write fake/false reviews to make a company look bad. With that said, I have to tell you that I am beyond disappointed with your place on several levels. These are my last 3 visits to Dakota; My wife, myself, and another couple met at Dakota for a few drinks and something to eat. We sat in the bar area at a table that felt like it was going to tip over and it was never made clear that we needed to wait for a server. I decided to go to the bar and ask the bartender if I could order drinks. She was not overly friendly (pretty much 95% of the job requirement) and told me we had to wait for a server. We did and eventually, a server who was working both the dining area and the bar made her way to us. We ordered drinks and did not see the server for a very long time. My friend went up to the bar to get another round and was met with a bit of hostility from the bartender who said we were supposed to order from the server. He explained she did not come back so the bartender very reluctantly let us buy drinks (yes, you read that correctly, we wanted to give you money). We wanted to order food and my friend and I flipped a coin to see who had to ask the bartender because neither of us wanted to. I lost the coin flip and asked the bartender who got mad and left to find the server. At this point, the server was bitter too and took our order like we were bothering her. We ordered pizzas, ate them (they were ok) and left to go to another place. -------- Some time went by and I chalked up that bad experience as an isolated incident and returned to the Dakota a few weeks later with my wife. We sat in the bar area again and ignored as all the attention was on what appeared to be a "regulars" sitting at the bar. With no server around I rolled the dice and waited for the bartender to stop talking to the regulars so I could order drinks. This time it was "ok" to order from the bartender and not wait for a server (keeping us guessing and uncomfortable). We ordered a salad and a couple of appetizers all of which were thrown together as fast as possible and were well below average in taste and quality. We both agreed this was our last trip to Dakota. --------- On to my 3rd experience which was yesterday (7/20). I convinced my wife to give Dakota one more try, this time we would eat in the dining area and it would be better. My wife, me, and my son showed up and the hostess asked if we had reservations. We said no and she continued to look at her book and finally said "ok come with me". We expected to see a full house based on what and how she said it and upon entering the dining area, there was a total of 6 people. ????????? Regardless, we sat and the waitress, a very pleasant younger female took our drink orders and told us about the specials. She came back and took our food orders; Apps: Sicilian Arancini: it was fine, nothing to tell your friends about but nothing to complain about. Coconut Shrimp: terrible. frozen product dumped in the fryer and served with cocktail sauce? who serves cocktail sauce with coconut shrimp? A simple mango based sauce is what should be served with it. Entrees: Wife: Filet with baked potato and broccoli: rubbery filet, dry, overcooked potato, unseasoned broccoli (2 tiny pieces) Son: Dakota Burger w/Fries: soggy, messy, fair at best. Me: NY Strip, salad, broccoli: The steak was inedible, extremely tough, very difficult to cut, not seasoned, thin, and everything you do not want a steak to be. Unseasoned broccoli (2 tiny pieces). Over $150 with tip! read more

I love it here the food is great and it's a nice environment. The service is great as well and I've never had any issues. Totally recommend

New owners really did a great job renovating the place. Looks gorgeous! Food is good. Was there to listen to Lake Effect band on their outdoor patio. Great band! Great outdoor patio! Patio was full but still nicely spaced apart with umbrella tables. Ordered bacon pesto chicken sandwich with fries and wings with a cajon dry rub. Both were good and would order again. Nothing spectacular but good food. Some prices seemed expensive but that is unfortunately the times with supply and demand. Glad the wings were big and juicy and not tiny like some places. They're getting hard to find now a days. We will be back. read more

See all

The Dakota has played the backdrop to multiple lunch meetings with business partners for us, and has always had a friendly and accommodating staff! They have been operating during covid, masks and all, with menus that are constantly changing with new offerings, and familiar favorites. The lodge feel mashed up with the bourbon and whiskey barrel tables and custom tabletops makes for a great conversation piece, and just plain ole cool art! Obviously, we come for the food! Their soups so far, have been amazing! The lobster bisque is flavorful with chunks of lobster, and the French onion has heaps of onions and gobs of cheese! A favorite for lunch, the Buffalo Bill burger - is a delicious steak burger with mushrooms, Swiss, onion straws, campfire sauce and your choice of fries or onion rings. Cooked proper and the fries and onion rings are both solid. I haven't tried any of the salads or the Reuben yet, but that's a yet! Off the beaten path, but well worth driving a little out of your way! read more

The Dakota - Buffalo bill burger - Pubs Near Me - Hilton, New York

See all

I'd like to say that we had a great meal and good service, but I can't. Why can't I? Because we walked out. We were seated promptly, the bread guy dropped a basket of bread on our table, grunted something and walked away. After waiting for a server and seeing 2 tables that were seated after us get service I asked the hostess if we could get a server, but apparently she was wrong since no one showed up at our table. We left and expressed our displeasure on the way out. We won't be going back. read more

There is a plate charge to share. I picked a couple French fries off my husbands plate and they charged us. I did NOT have them split it between 2 plates I picked a few ff of his plate. She gave me a plate. Food was good but waitress was not very good read more

We went to the Dakota for dinner last night and was very disappointed. I ordered Haddock Dakota. I have had it many times here. It is supposed to come with mozzarella cheese. When the server brought it, it had cheese on it but it was sliced cheese. I asked the server and she stated that they use sliced mozzarella cheese. This was not mozzarella cheese, it was more like american cheese. The meal was very bland and did not have any flavor at all. Another thing, some diners received bread and butter and other tables (our included) did not get bread. They also had a big problem with flys. It was a very disappointing meal. read more

One of our favorite places to visit. The new owners did a great remodeling job. The food has always been good and continues to be. Great fish fry on Fridays. They also do a steak night. read more

***THE OLD REVIEWS DO NOT REFLECT THE RESTAURANT TODAY*** The restaurant has taken new ownership and has been fully remodeled. Consider it a brand new restaurant bar & wood fire grill. I HIGHLY recommend for those who had eaten here prior to the new ownership to retry the place. The layout and environment is very modern and up to date and so is the food. You get free bread that is constantly refilled! I aways order the french onion and it is DELICIOUS!!! The pizza is great and and so are the entree's. I have been there 3 times already for dinner and drinks. Servers and staff are very polite and the mens bathroom has a keg for a urinal which is quite comical! read more

I was skeptical at first after seeing so many negative reviews, but overall I have to say that our experience was positive. We went with a group of four, and we all left happy and full. First of all, the bread is addicting. It's a warm, crusty, buttery and garlicky piece of heaven. We devoured that while we waited for our appetizers and salads. We got the bruschetta and arancini, and both were very tasty. The salads were simple yet complex blends of mixed greens. Finally, the main courses. The Mac and cheese with crispy chicken was out of this world - the chicken itself tasted like a real deal cutlet and the cheese sauce was excellent. The shrimp allosandro was also stellar. The fish fry was soggy though, and the white clam pizza we ordered didn't get put in the oven in time for dinner, but it ended up being comped and it was worth the wait. My wife can't wait to go back. I'm down too! read more

The remodeled Dakota is absolutely stunning! The vision has certainly became a beauty. We were greeted kindly by the host, bartender and almost all the staff. Nice touch. The wood fire pizza oven is one of so many amazing additions including a seasonal deck and outdoor fireplace coming soon! The decoration is brilliant and the upmost respect to the honored military servicemen and women proudly shown with pride. The menu was typical length to fit today's norm but did have a paper daily special. Prior to our entree we were delivered a warm baked bread with butter. It was great and would pair nicely with the wine selection posted in closing. Presentation was nice overall. Two entree dinners one being the bacon wrapped 3oz filets (tournedos) accompanied with a salad and the mashed potatoes as a side; however, a baked potato would be great but not available. The in house dressing was a raspberry poppyseed and a favorite flavorful introduction! The potatoes were not descriptive of its ingredients such as "loaded", "sour cream with chive" but simply mashed potatoes. I'm not familiar of what the flavors were and had a nice taste but the potatoes fell flat. The steak was a bit bitter for my liking maybe it was a marinade but I did not find it pleasant this time. The second entree was Chicken Parmesan with a side salad. The sauce was thin and the noodles were over cooked. The chicken was not the headline due to mound of seasoned cheese that was over cooked and incredibly difficult to cut through. We brought our concerns to our server whom was very friendly and she was empathetic. We disputed the bill due to what we could eat favorably shown best in the photos prior to after in closing. The chef himself addressed our concerns and gave his feedback. The bill was accounted for by the imperfections and we tipped the staff accordingly as they did well. The Dakota is such a beautiful gem to this town and has a long history. It was so nice to see how much work went into reviving Dakota. I would recommend visiting and maybe tonight was an off night with our meal, but we would gladly try again. It takes a village. read more

See all

Went to The Dakota last evening for the first time since the re-opening and I have to say that it will be my last. I ordered their version of linguine with white clam sauce as this a favorite of mine. It was tasteless, thank goodness there were clams in it otherwise it would have been like eating noodles in fish broth. My husband ordered the countryman burger which came topped with a fried egg and sausage gravy. He asked for medium, it came well and the sausage gravy was sweet?, not savory. Just to top off the experience, the waitress brought a standard Styrofoam container for the left over clam sauce, really....we had to ask for a soup container when she finally came to her senses and brought out a plastic take out container that snapped shut. Sadly, there are really no good restaurants in Hilton :( read more

Covid schmovid... this place is not following guidelines. They will be complaining when restaurants and bars are shut down again, instead of owning their responsibility in the situation. Few masks, no distancing, and capacity over 50 percent. Won't be back. read more

Last two times we came here the food was sub par. Use to be great before the remodel so not sure if new owners and or cooks ? Anyways today we went and me and my daughter both ordered the lobster bisque which was stone cold. No exaggeration it was like it sat outside at room temp. I also ordered the Buffalo chicken sandwich. The bun it was on was twice the size of the chicken and was hard to eat so I tossed the buns and used a fork to eat the chicken. Last time we ate there it was bad also but wanted to give a second chance. So much for that. Won't be back. Service however was good. Waitress was very friendly. read more

I've never had a bad meal here and the food has been excellent most of the time. I had the haddock Frenc, the sauce was spot on. My ompanion had the meatballs firenze and she loved it. The hostess, bartenders and the server were wonderful. Ill keep going back for the food, service and atmosphere. Thank you Dakota! read more

WOW!! This place is Amazing!! We had the fried calamari as an appetizer-not your traditional recipe; it comes with marinara sauce and kalamata olives, parmigiana cheese and garlic yummy. For dinner we had burgers - Cajun cheese burger with jalapeños and the Dakota Cheese Burger - made to perfection and topped it off with chocolate cake. I highly recommend coming here. A must return. read more

The Dakota - Pubs Near Me - Hilton, New York

See all

The Dakota is a recently remodeled and clean restaurant. The Blackened Cajun Salmon plate was nicely prepared and tasty. The Chicken French came with plenty of pasta, but the lemon-wine sauce was bland and watery. No salads were offered with dinner. Most restaurants in this price range include a house salad. A basket with a very small bread offering was brought to the table. When we asked for more bread, our waitress balked at the idea but she did bring another basket. read more

Horrible food has now become uneatable Fish taste like they soak it in oil till they fry it now chowder looks like water now bisque Is like Campbell's have Ben going for almost 15 years food was great is now the worst food in the area and surrounding area If you have gone before in years past do not expect to get the same food even service is RUDE now Dave is no where in sight so DISAPPOINTED Bryan n Only gave one star because it won't let me None so no s read more

I haven't been to the Dakota since it was remodeled. I would recommend off the start not to get the lobster bisque because it tastes like tomato soup. No lobster chunks in the soup at all! Chicken Alfredo was alright, however the chicken was very rubbery and hard to chew. I would recommend this place as somewhere to get crispy bar food, not a tasty meal. I am very dissatisfied and I will only be back to drink! read more

Just completed our first visit to The Dakota! Great experience all around. Service was excellent! All of our meals were piping hot and delicious! The grilled chicken parm was outstanding & the red sauce was perfect. Sirloin and crab cake dinner was really tasty and the steak was done to perfection! The chicken French was a hit too! Definitely on our schedule going forward...15 minute drive from Greece....! read more

Place is way too loud! Can't even hold a conversation without yelling. It's like eating dinner in someone's basement with way too many people. The steak was like eating a piece of shoe rubber. Will not go back. read more

Went there aro five on a friday but could only order off lunch menu because the kitchen was closing early. Then older couples arrived and they ordered a fish fry, not on the lunch menu. Steak sandwich was good, but I would of liked a fish fry myself. Maybe because I am not a regular. How fair is that. read more

The new updated Dakota Grill is a definite recommendation! It was busy, so service was a little slow, but like I said it was a busy Saturday night. The food was delicious, literally tried all four of the dishes ordered at our table and every single dish was delicious The staff was all super friendly, the drinks were great, all around a great place. I had never been to the "before" edition of this place, but will definitely be going back to the updated edition! Plus this sounds crazy but even the bathrooms are cool in this place lol read more

Food is absolutely amazing here! The renovation made this place look like a five start restaurant and it's a great sports bar too!

My advise to new owners is. Change everything! Dakota was famous for steaks, bring back those famous steaks. Get professionally trained Chef's read more

We came in for lunch at the bar after a memorial service in Hilton. I got the chicken pesto sandwich and my husband got the French dip and they were both delicious. The service was friendly and attentive and the remodel has made a stunning interior for this old favorite. We are excited to come back and give dinner at try!!! read more

We went there for the first time tonight and we were very impressed with the taste and quality of the food as well as the service. The owner came to our table, she was very friendly and appreciative that we were there. She spoke to every person that walked in and out the door. To me that speaks volumes. how grateful she is to her customers and takes pride in her establishment. It may look like your local small town restaurant, but the food tasted like you were eating at a high class restaurant without the high prices! I was very glad the proportions were enough to bring some home for a late snack or lunch the next day. We definitely will be back and recommend this to others. And to add there is a good beer selection! read more

Went there last night we got there at 6:25 told it would be a 20 min. Wait which ended up 50 mins. We got our soup and salad .Then we waited till 8:25 to get our dinners. Only 1 choice of steak on the menu. Which was nothing special ( fair ) . It was supposed to be 12 oz but looked like 8 oz. Mashed potatoes and soup where cold. The fish fry was very good. The rest of us had French dishes. The Broccoli French was supposed to be over Angel hair Pasta but came over Penne . No big deal but they should have told us. The Artichoke French and over Linguine instead of Angel Hair was starchy. But ok. Not great. Won't be back. Sorry. Pricey and the food was just fair. Used to be a good restaurant / value WHAT HAPPENED. read more