I've been stopping at this fish market after my North Fork runs for fresh seafood forever, and…read moreevery single time I tell myself, "Next time I'm eating lunch here." I think I did once... but apparently I completely forgot about it. Well, I finally sat down and ordered the lobster roll, and now I'm wondering what took me so long. I can't believe I slept on this lobster roll! If you know, you know ;summer doesn't officially start for me until I've had a great lobster roll. As of Summer 2026, this one is my favorite. The lobster was fresh, the mayo-to-celery ratio was perfect, and every bite was exactly what I want in a lobster roll. Safe to say I won't be waiting this long again. I'll absolutely be back!

Can't rate the food. We called ahead in early afternoon for a takeout order. We were told 45…read moreminute wait. We showed up a few minutes early and were told by the counter person that (a) that our order hadn't been started yet and (b) that we were told it would be an hour when we called and we were early. And there was an edge in her voice. So we went to run an errand and came back 25 minutes later and the order still hadn't been started yet. So it's now more than an hour from the time we ordered and now we are in freefall. So we cancelled the order - with more attitude from a different counter person. It wasn't so much the delay in the order - things happen. But it was the attitude that accompanied it that was most off putting. It felt like a learned behavior.

Never answers their phone. Went out of our way to buy fish here and they were working on catering a…read morewedding with nothing to sell to the public. I wouldn't call this a fish market. More of a fish "maybe".

Alice's fish market is a true Greenport gem. The prices are unbeatable and the quality is…read moreexcellent. Bought our dinner from here for the second time in two days (can you tell we're fans?) Yesterday, we ordered two 2 lb lobsters and 2lbs of Cod. For no extra charge you can get the lobster steamed and partially broken down (made easy for you to crack open and get down to business ty v much) Naturally, we opted for the pre-steamed/broken downfare and passed on the live option. I absolutely love lobster but I don't think I could ever cook (kill) one, myself tbh. This weekend, we were going to go into town for oysters and wine but upon yelping the prices (average price of $3/oyster aka yeah right. No thanks, buddy. When you can get great $1 oysters at many reputable NYC restaurants you find this to be lowkey insulting) we decided we should buy our own bottles and check out Alice's oyster offerings. Jot this down: most liquor stores in Greenport/Southold/Mattituck carry a variety of bottles from various north fork vineyards so wine not stock up. Of course, Alice's did not disappoint! They sell a dozen oysters for $12.50. So basically I could buy three dozen oysters (roughly) for the price of one dozen in town. If you give them an hours notice they'll even shuck them for you free of charge. Hosting an event? Alice's offer a raw bar party option where they'll set up a raw bar table and prepare the oysters/clams etc. in front of you at your event. So to sum up this super long review, Alice's is wonderful, attentive and of the highest quality. Go check them out on your visit to the North Fork

Great food, a comfortable vibe, and a friendly and well trained staff made for a great dinner…read more I went for the oysters friskafella. You should too

Nice little spot with great service and great ambiance. Resturant was nice and portion sizes were…read moregood. Went with a couple friends - had both cocktails and apps. Had shishito and burrata. For entree had cod ramen.. a little different than usual but very large and good. Overall recommend

I do not no why Billys only has 3 stars that is sooooo wrong…read moreWait Staff is a 10 Bartenders 10 prices are very fair ! Food was great !!!! Thank You All for 3 Great Meals And Drink And Music !!!! Barry

A fun spot to share with friends! Started with drinks and a bucket of steamers. Yum, so good…read more The fried calamari also hit the spot. We all had steamed lobsters next. Service was great. Music was fun and we'll have to come back!

I had the pleasure of dining at Noah's on Sunday evening with two of my college girlfriends, and…read morewhat a wonderful experience it was! We ordered several dishes to share so we could sample as much of the menu as possible. We started with a half dozen oysters featuring three different varieties. They were incredibly fresh, and we loved every one of them. The accompanying sauces were the perfect complement. From the Small Plates menu, we ordered the watermelon salad. It was a generous portion and absolutely delicious. Perfect for a warm summer evening. I especially loved the combination of arugula, fresh mint, and both yellow and red watermelon. The cocoa nibs were an unexpected touch that added wonderful texture and flavor. It's not something I ever would have thought to add to a watermelon salad, but it worked beautifully. I can't wait to order it again. Next came the Long Island calamari frito misto with rock shrimp. The lightly battered calamari and shrimp were perfectly crisp, and the addition of fennel added a unique flavor that elevated the entire dish. It was simply superb. We also shared the red crab tacos. There are three tacos per order, which worked out perfectly since each of us could enjoy one. This was another standout. I love crab but usually shy away from mayonnaise-based salads. Whatever they did with this crab salad completely won me over. It was light, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. The Long Island Duck BBQ, served with pulled duck, cheddar grits, and scallions, was another pleasant surprise. I wasn't quite sure what to expect, but it was outstanding. Every bite was packed with flavor, and the creamy cheddar grits paired perfectly with the tender duck. It was another creative dish that showcased the kitchen's talent. We also ordered a side of baby spinach so we'd have a vegetable to round out the meal, and even that was perfectly prepared and very flavorful. When I say everything was exceptional, I truly mean it. Every dish arrived beautifully presented, at the perfect temperature, expertly seasoned, and bursting with flavor. Our server, Jennifer Farino, kept everything running seamlessly despite all of our shared plates and courses. She was attentive, friendly, and made the entire evening even more enjoyable. My friends ordered Hugo Spritzes while I enjoyed a raspberry Stoli Cosmopolitan. The cocktails were outstanding as well. Kudos to the bartender! When it came time for dessert, we asked Jennifer to surprise us with her selections. While every dessert was delicious, my absolute favorite was the cinnamon sugar beignets with bourbon caramel dipping sauce. They were warm, light, and completely irresistible. I could eat them every day! In fact, I'd happily return just for those beignets. We originally had an indoor reservation, but when we arrived we were fortunate enough to be seated outside, where seating is first-come, first-served. It couldn't have worked out better. The weather was beautiful, making for a perfect summer evening. Even the background music was thoughtfully chosen and played at just the right volume, creating a wonderful atmosphere. From the food and drinks to the service and ambiance, everything about our evening at Noah's was exceptional. We all left saying the same thing: this was one of the best dining experiences we've had in a long time. Noah's has truly set the bar high, and we can't wait to return.

Perusing my pictures I realized I never reviewed the great snacks my family & I had here. My…read morebrother, sister & I took my dad out to the north shore for father's day and this was one of the spots we enjoyed ourselves at. I got the Korean Style Duck Wings on special. Fantabulous! My sister ordered the Rhubarb Glazed Baby Back Ribs. Delicious! My Dad got the Local Seafood Bouillabaisse. He thoroughly enjoyed. And my brother loved his Filet Mignon Sliders. A great time was had by us all! Do stop by. Everything was unique & delicious 10-28-2025

Dined with our toes in the sand (literally). Liked the unique menu selection and thoroughly enjoyed…read morethe grilled meats and octopus. The sleeper was the bean salad! Wow. Love the fact the Food and Beverage Director (Bill) checked in with us and spent time explaining how the plates were prepared. Great atmosphere and the outdoor bar built around an old oak tree look like fun as well. We were fortunate as a group to book a time that carried us thru dusk, and a full moon rise over Shelter Island. A nice way to finish out the meal.

One of the best spots you can get to by water! Super casual, friendly staff and fantastic food!…read more Fresh, clean and reasonable!

Service was slow and it was only 5:30. Ambiance was great. We sat upstairs and it was Hot. They…read moreneeded just to put a Bucket of ice with the water they gave us. We had to keep asking. Thank God for a breeze! Food- 10/10!! Chowda, Delicious. Surf & Turf- Great! Sesame Seared Tuna- DELICIOUS. We loved everything.

I'm not usually someone who writes reviews. If something isn't right, I generally prefer to mention…read moreit to the server in the moment so they have the opportunity to address it. Unfortunately, that wasn't possible during this visit because our waitress rarely checked on us, so I wanted to share our experience here. We made a reservation and weren't sure if it specified indoor or outdoor seating, so we called ahead. We were told that getting an upstairs outdoor table would be no problem. However, when we arrived, we were told our reservation was for inside seating only and that the wait for outside would be an additional 1 hour and 45 minutes. We really wanted to sit outside, but rather than make an issue of it, we decided to stay inside. Looking back, we probably should have left. The cocktails were underwhelming, especially considering the price. The highlights of the meal were the duck wings and calamari appetizers, which gave us high hopes for the entrees. Unfortunately, the entrees were a major disappointment. Two people ordered the halibut, and while we understand halibut is a delicate fish that can be difficult to prepare, the dish lacked flavor overall. The foam that came with it tasted horrible--almost soapy--and although the rice and eggplant were good, they weren't flavorful enough to complement the fish. I ordered the tuna burger and specifically requested it cooked medium because I didn't want it to be dry. Unfortunately, it arrived very dry, was falling apart, and lacked flavor. I ended up asking for a side of teriyaki sauce just to make it enjoyable- that didn't help at all and left half the sandwich in my plate. The tuna burger was supposed to come with sweet potato noodles, but they were out-which is not an issue for me, usually. The waitress asked if I'd like a substitute. None of the suggested sides appealed to me, so I asked if I could have the sweet potato purée instead since I saw it for the duck entree. Instead, I was initially served fries. I asked the person who served me, if I can get the puree, the server was confused but eventually understood. When the purée finally arrived, it was unfortunately inedible. The texture and taste reminded me of baby food, and even adding salt and pepper didn't help. I passed it around to the other folks at the table, all saying the same thing. What made the experience even more disappointing was the service. Our waitress never came back to check on our meals, so we never had the opportunity to share our concerns while we were dining. She spent much of the evening chatting with other staff members and seemed distracted with friends and kids running around near the lobster tank. When we finished, another server brought us the check, and no one asked how our meal was or if everything was satisfactory. Overall, this was a very disappointing experience, especially for the amount we spent. The restaurant itself is beautiful, clean, and has a great atmosphere, but unfortunately the food and service did not justify the price. We left wishing we had chosen somewhere else.

Amazing lunch today. With our special little girl Sadie…read more I enjoyed the Ciopino with Pasta. A pricey but delicious and well worth it entree. My other half enjoyed the daily catch, striped bass with spinach, asparagus, corn. Delicious. Sadie enjoyed a few treats and watching LOL. Perfect service from Mae, so much thanks.

Port is a restaurant that has an inside and outside bar. We tend to gravitate toward the outside…read morebar for the fresh air and views. The Bartenders are always friendly and willing to please. The bar has a roof but is open on all sides allowing for a breeze and plenty of people watching. The drinks are cold and served in large plastic cups. Stop in for one or a meal. Enjoy!