Just minutes before the staff lunch break, we were seated and our lunch order taken. The service was excellent as well as the steak burrito. The margaritas and ambiance are unparalleled. This is a must visit to complete the East Hampton vibe! read more

A good spot for low key food and a strong drink. The margaritas are pretty good here. Those of you in. Your 20s will love this place because they have a bit of a heavy hand with the liquor. I felt buzzed after half a drink, and I'm no lightweight. The service is average (this is a good thing) The ambiance is very casual. I could see why most people in their 20s would love this place. I usually rate a Mexican spot by their Carne Asada tacos but they don't have them here. They Americanized it and call the skirt steak tacos. I wouldn't call it true Mexican, but I wouldn't knock it either because a lot of people don't speak Spanish out here so I can understand why they did it. The Parrot burger was decent. Perfectly cooked and tasty. 3/5 (good score). read more

The Blue Parrot - The Blue Parrot Burger - Mexican Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Food was mid but the worst part was that the service was horrible and then after we endured through this horrible experience we had to face a 20% automatic tip (btw I wanted to tip 1% cause it was shit). Tipping yourself out of my wallet is incredibly disrespectful. If I'm ever back u can tip this dick. read more

Recently visited the Blue Parrot for dinner, always a favorite spot on the east end for the best in Mexican. B Friendly/personable employees, food is consistently outstanding and the drinks don't miss. The prices are on the steep side, even for the Hamptons. Definitely recommend! read more

original waitress brought us water but never returned to take our order. Finally we flagged down another waitor who took our order. prices were high which I would not mind if the food was good. The food was generously portioned and the presentation was nice. However the taste was extremely bland - literally had No Taste! and we did not enjoy our meals. We sat at a table but noticed that the bar was pretty full. perhaps they get more of a drink crowd than guests that come there for good food. paid the bill and do not plan to eat at again. read more

Mexican food is my thing!!!!!!!!! So on my ride out to East Hampton my friends and I stopped in here. It was def. a little busy and I was def. a little under dressed but it was time to eat..... The three of us walked up to the hostess and we were seated instantly which was great considering it was about 7pm on a Saturday night with a busy crowd. We sat down ordered some beers and guacamole and patiently awaited both. Guacamole was really good, had a heavy hint of mine which I didn't mind at all. The chips were your average old out the bag type which I'm not a huge fan of but it's still a chip so of course I'm eating it. We also had some calamari which tasted a little too fishy for my liking but was cooked very well. I ordered the chicken avocado sandwich with regular fries. It was good but nothing that really wow'd me. Just cheese on grilled chicken and half a sliced avocado. The fries were good and very salty which hit the spot. I will say this place was pricey as hell foe not the most knock your socks off food but I mean we are out in the hamptons, bring your wallet!!!! read more

The Blue Parrot - a person cutting a cake - Mexican Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Poor quality and flavor. I believe this place has never had authentic Mexican food. It tastes like something you'd find at a road side Mexican food truck. read more

PICKUP ORDERS BEWARE - orders are automatically charged 20% gratuity without any forewarning (say goodbye $50!) At first I thought it was an innocent mistake with the Toast app since the line item on the receipt labeled "auto-gratuity". So I went back to the front desk to ask for a refund, and the woman at the front said was the RUDEST restaurant staff I've ever met. I asked 2 questions in a friendly manner "can I get a refund, because we didn't eat here?" to which she responded that the 20% is auto-added so then I followed up with "could you override it?" and it triggered a rant of increasing volume starting with that she couldn't override it, that she put the 20% gratuity there because people here don't tip for pickup orders, started yelling variations of "do you not want to show gratuity to the people who cooked your food?" And so on. She said that "something" says that pickup orders $250+ are subject to 20% tip, but I assure you it's not the Toast menu. What a disappointing way to end our day. read more

My go-to Mexican restaurant when out East. The food is fresh and not over-sauced. The prices are fair and you don't feel like you are getting the typical Hamptons up-charge. They built out a great outdoor space to accommodate social distancing and servers are still masked. I had the fish tacos which were excellent! The fish was not overly battered and not greasy! I thought it must have been baked! My friend had a burrito which was so fresh and huge! I'll be back! read more

Popped in for a quick dinner. It was crowded and so noisy that we couldn't hear one another even though we were sitting right next to each other. The food was just OK. It was definitely under-seasoned. read more

Just okay, overpriced but everything in this area seems to be. Can get much better quality Mexican for much cheaper in Manhattan for comparison. Ordered a shrimp quesadilla, guacamole, chicken burrito, Diet Coke, and margarita. Cost me $89 LOL. Can't get behind these absurd prices. The shrimp in the quesadilla tasted a little too fishy for me so I ended up poking it out. The guacamole was good. Boyfriend enjoyed the margarita said it was strong and the chicken burrito was good. Margarita is $17 which once again is ridiculous. This isn't a cocktail bar in Manhattan. Only way I would ever go back is if someone else pays for my meal and even then I would be a little annoyed. read more

The Blue Parrot - Guacamole - Mexican Near Me - East Hampton, New York

my boyfriend and i went here for our weekly date night. both have never been. we're both full and content and the staff was great. it's a little expensive for what it is and i don't recommend sitting near the bar, it got very crowded and loud. there was a private party which also blocked us from sitting outside. if we go again i think we will go during the week or earlier in the day to avoid the crowds. it wasn't amazing but it wasn't the worst i've ever had. read more

The Blue Parrot - a table of mexican food - Mexican Near Me - East Hampton, New York

In 2019 we had a wonderful experience here! Elegant and delicious food with fun margaritas! This summer cafeteria style with a few picnic tables. If not yuck the person who greeted us said simply "order from me and I'll hand you the food which you can eat where ever you want! Really were walking! Big disappointment here. Why have such an inept fool greet your customers? read more

I don't mind paying hamptons prices for quality food but this place missed the mark. 20 dollars for a bland quesadilla and 24 dollars for small portion of enchiladas with dry chicken. Will not be back. read more

The Blue Parrot - Carne asada quesadilla - Mexican Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Pretty pricey for "street tacos" but I think typical for East Hampton's pricing. The portion sizes were still good at least. One note - if you order the tacos (3 tacos per order), you have to have all 3 tacos be of the same flavor (i.e. all shrimp, all fish, all chicken, etc), you can't mix and match. The drinks are strong which is a plus. For two people, we did an order of the 3 tacos, a veggie quesadilla, split guac+chips, and two margaritas. The bill came out to $112 before tip. read more

This place is awful. Tacos were dry and had virtually no meat. Same thing with the burritos. Price to value ratio way off on this one. You can do much better. read more

Keep reading the negative reviews about the prices . Funny how everyone can afford a house share here in the Hamptons but can't afford dinner. Honestly the shrimp or fish tacos are amazing, only problem is trying to decide which is better ! If you like your margaritas then make sure you order the spicy watermelon. Holy cow it's spicy and strong yet refreshing all in one. The tequila is infused with peppers so it kicks like a mule. The staff are great and its a fun place to just kick back after dinner or play some table tennis. Enjoy ! read more

The Blue Parrot - Mexican Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Friendliest welcome in East Hampton! Great food, great service. The nachos SLAPPED! We really loved it and will be going back again before we leave! read more

Small place with amazing food!! We actually had lunch there 2 days in a row Both days we had nachos which are HUGE and soooo good. Share with 4people at least. Steak tacos and fish tacos were to die for and the street corn off the cob was the finisher !!! Wait staff were awesome! Highly recommend read more

It's a hard pass. Prices are wild for what the food is. Not terrible if there's literally no other option in the moment but if you're craving tacos there's plenty of other East End options. read more

Been here a few times, not impressed. Overpriced and staff are straight up rude, had all too many bad experiences to go back read more

Fish Tacos were amazing!!! Hit that lunchtime hunger proper. The Guacamole was super fresh tasting and I was left satisfied. Great value for the Hamptons in my opinion. This place is fast becoming my regular spot for lunch and evening drinks with friends. The vibe is super chill even though it gets real busy and the fresh flowers everywhere are a nice touch. read more

The Blue Parrot - Fish Tacos and Guac - Mexican Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Good evening yelpers, wether just to eat some chips and guacamole, drinks, or for a full meal, this establishment is inviting, upbeat, and all around a hoot. From the bubbly, fun, and kind waitresses, to the hospitable and hilarious bartenders, this place is never dull. The food is fantastic and delicious. Whatever your mood is this restaurant will not disappoint. The staff are incredible. read more

Loved the blue Parrot. Will be returning and recommending. loved the steak tacos especially. But enchiladas great too. best queso ever. must go. read more

Im beyond appaled at this place and management. Its a shame because the food is good. HOWEVER, the service sucks. A server not sure of her name but brunette literally assaulted a customer and refused to apologize. The poor young girl she soaked with soda was literally harassed and egged on by the waistaff, and managment was totally unprofessional. I will NOT be giving them any buisness. read more

I wanted to love this place, but service did not compensate for the lackluster menu. This place has a lot of potential. Great location, beachy & laid back vibe. I expected more, unfortunately, they did not deliver. Hamptons is in dire need of really commendable places to eat. I truly do not like giving one star, but please you gotta raise the bar. read more

First time there, ordered pickup online. Kitchen was busy so the stated 30 mins turned into roughly 45-60, but having been in the restaurant industry can understand nights turn crazy. All items on the receipt stapled to the bag had been checked off, so we didnt check the contents in the bag standing there. Got back to our house 15 mins away, an entree is missing and half the supplies needed for fajitas. The first guy I spoke with offered zero value at all, namely, we can take off the entrees and re run the card. Sure, I won't eat dinner tonight because of a mistake from the restaurant. Then I spoke to the manager, Ashleigh, who didn't even hesitate to say we will remake both dishes, I will drive them to you, and throw in 2 additional margaritas for the hassle. That's why she's a manager and the other guy is not. As for the food, solid. I've had better Mexican but its East Hampton prices so not surprise there. When picking up the food, the outdoor seating looked like a great spot, just have to hope something is open when you're there. read more

DO NOT GO HERE. Terrible service. Rejected REAL IDs because the bartender never saw out of state licenses before. The manager then patronized us saying we'd have hard times getting drinks at other places with our REAL IDs. Guess they didn't need the business. read more

This is one of the "cheaper" spots in East Hampton, but definitely way overpriced. They forgot to give our table our chips and salsa that we ordered, so they gave it to us on the house. I ordered the shrimp tacos. Although they were tasty in flavor, the shrimp was kind of rubbery and did not taste fresh. I actually got a slight allergic reaction later which happens to me when I eat not-fresh seafood. It's not "authentic" Mexican food by any means. The tacos are not double wrapped, there's no cilantro, etc. The sangria tasted like fruit punch and essentially had no alcohol in it. We were there at the height of dinner time, and were brought our bill before we were even finished. We felt rushed to leave so they could use our table. On the plus side, the music was good and they had legit hot sauces. read more

The Blue Parrot - Shrimp tacos - Mexican Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Great vibes, great food, great service! Super nice waitress, good chips and salsa, and lovely music outdoors. The only downside was when a drunk old guy started regaling me about his glory days as an LSU baseball player, but the chicken nachos I was devouring as I tuned out his 1955 "SEC leading" batting average made up for it. A bit pricey, but if you want good Mexican and/or to get away from "fresh Montauk lobster" getting shoved down your throat that would cost an arm and a leg, this is your place. read more

I hope this place goes out of business. In fact, I hereby pledge any skills/talents/effort I can muster to anyone who will open a Mexican restaurant (including Taco Bell) in a block vicinity of Blue Parrot with the sole focus of putting this deplorable excuse for a restaurant out of its misery. The steak tacos which I ordered (via recommended by our incompetent server) were atrocious at best. It tasted as if the steak had cooked for the entire 1hr and 30min - which I waited - in a garbage can. Our served forgot our order initially and then proceeded to lie to us (about how long he forgot it for. Note to server: it's quite obvious that you forgot our order for more than "5 or 7 minutes" when you bring us apology guacamole 1hr into our wait.) It's difficult for me to further convey the frustration, anger and utter resentment that I feel when the name Blue Parrot is mentioned. read more

Pretty sad. This place used to be good, and we've come here several times a summer for the last 3 years. Alas, as of this summer they have modified their menu in order to jump on the Hamptons bull market bandwagon and double their prices. Totally ridiculous. Goodbye, BP. read more

Extortionately priced mediocre Mexican food that in any other context would be laughed off the table. Unfortunately, however, in East Hampton, it is the lesser of the dining evils. At least you can get a salad for under $20 here, unlike many of the other surrounding cafe trend havens where lunch entrees can easily creep up to $30 and beyond. However my $14 Oaxaca salad consisted of lettuce, a few cherry tomatoes, a few waxy strips of cheese, a thin avocado dressing, and a few soggy pieces of tortilla. Very disappointing. The Irish waitstaff provide a bit of intrigue, but the novelty of the place doesn't make up for the poor experience. read more

The Blue Parrot - The Oaxaca salad, with a few soggy strips of tortilla and waxy cheese. $14. - Mexican Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

So despite having read horrid reviews, I always hear so much about Blue Parrot that I figured they must be off....we came by over mem day weekend, really hoping to love it, as we're staying nearby this summer. Alas, our experience was similar to many reviews (and we didn't even have any of the extremely overpriced food). Just wanted to drop in for a margarita, and they were kind enough to give us a table despite only drinking. Sadly this is where the positives end. Now I expect everything to be expensive in both the hamptons and west village, but at least generally the quality reflects the cost. Upon walking in, some wasted case on his way out knocked over a bicycle in front of us, and other onlookers, but rather than picking it up, muttered "thats no good," and stumbled on. My boyfriend picked up the bike, but this was a good indication of things to come... We didn't see our server for maybe 15 minutes, and he knew we were only ordering drinks, so hardly needed a lengthy time to peruse the cocktail menu. The first thing I attempted to order was out (naturally), and so we ordered the blueberry margarita and rum punch, both at his recommendation. My blueberry marg was absolutely horrendous, tasted like cheap tequila and bathroom cleaner, to the point where I literally couldnt drink it and forced at least half upon my boyfriend. His rum punch was gone in about 2 seconds flat, as he claimed it was virgin (and this is a lightweight. he's wasted after one shot). The waiter eventually came to ask if he wanted another, which of course he didnt as it was sugar water..so he said no...the waiter was all 'those are dangerous right?!"...um, only if the danger is of leaving stone cold sober and pissed off. After forcing my boyfriend to chug the majority of my nasty drink (which he also hated), and seeing the pricing for a burrito (20ish???), and confirming that the service and drinks were appalling, we made the decision that we wont be returning. It's too bad, due to both proximity, and the cute key west vibe they have going on (love key west). also the entire place filled of smoke while we were there, so my hair and silk blouse reeked afterwards, as though i had been at a campfire or bbq. An added bonus. read more

tried this place last summer! Was it worth the money? No Will i return? Probably Not i think this is one of those places which if you decide to go - you should go to on a weeknight as they seem to have better food/service (they probably get overwhelmed when its busy) Wish they all had a system like La Fondita but they dont I will probably go to La Fondita or the Hideaway for mexican and not return here read more

This place is a little over-priced. $6 for chips and salsa is ridiculous when they are complimentary everywhere else. Another $6 if you want a side of rice, another $6 if you want beans. Got the carne asada tacos for $10. It was 2 small tacos. They actually weren't bad. Probably the best value on the menu. The bartender was really nice and cool. The waitress we had could have paid a little more attention to us though. Not a bad spot. read more

Unless you think nachos and quesadillas = Mexican food, beware. Decent tequila selection. Mad 'tude at the door. Place looked 1/2 full and they wouldn't let us enter to chill at bar, we had to stand outside for 10 minutes till some goon allowed us to go drop money at bar. So this restaurant is owned by Ron Perlman, Renee Zellwegger, and Jon Bon Jovi. Those rich fuckers charge $16 for a burrito smaller then one from Baja Fresh. I understand it's the Hamptons, and they can get whatever they ask, but their prices are actually insulting for the quality of food they put out. FWIW; the music was solid. but, I doubt i'll return. read more

Food was good Margaritas excellent Place is understaffed Hard to get a drink The bartender was overwhelmed by the crowd Our waiter rushed us through our meal Took my plate off the table and I was not finished Asked us to leave our table even though we were still drinking But obviously not eating As our plates had been removed Rude Rude read more

Blue Parot. I didn't like the place one bit... never understood why it was so packed... I must say I wanted to like it. I liked the building, I liked the theme... just NOT the food; and the service was just as awful... read more

I mean it's Mexican in New York- it's as good as it will get! So I am giving it 4 stars. Margaritas- $16 each. ARE YOU KIDDING ME?! However, corn is fab! Lobster tacos (on special) were fabulous. It's great, it's seasonal- so it will be closed soon enough. read more