Cancel

Open app

Search

The Bagelry

4.5 (167 reviews)
Special Hours • Closed
Updated a few days ago

Order The Bagelry Takeout or Delivery

The Bagelry Photos

THE BAGELRY ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Bagelry

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

The Skillet + BLT
Sarah M.

My sister and I stopped in here on Monday before our drive back to Indy. It was so nice to have a warm breakfast after shoveling the snow away from my car and packing everything up from the Airbnb above. The inside is small, with no inside seating options. They have drip coffee, bottled drinks, etc, but no lattes or anything like that. The staff were friendly, the food was made quickly, and it was hot and delicious. The only thing I wish is that each side of the bagel still had a cream cheese smear on it, but otherwise an excellent bagel sandwich. I got a breakfast bagel and my sister got a lunch bagel and she loved hers as well. It was also cool to see that they use Tinker Coffee beans from Indy for their coffee!

Trinity G.

Such a cute place. This location is to go style so you order it at the counter. I ordered the pizza bagel with pepperoni and it was so good!! The service was fast and everything was reasonably priced. I had heard good things and it didn't disappoint!

The GECCO no egg
Marissa P.

Forever my favorite bagel Everytime I visit I get it the gecco no egg I think I've had at least 50 hahahha I am loyal and miss it since I live out of state but LOVE IT FOREVERRRR

PIZZA bagel
S F.

Fan for life. Great food. Amazing service. Dynamite staff. Please open Thursday-Sat nights.

If you want something quick this is the place to go. They have decent options and were priced well. The staff was friendly and the food was done quick. Would definitely return if in the area.

Inside
Ailin J.

Came Sunday morning around 10am and I thought it would be packed so I ordered ahead but maybe people were still sleeping and this place gets busier towards 11? I was a little sad I ordered ahead because even though my order was correct, it definitely doesn't hit the same as ordering it fresh in line. I enjoyed the wide variety of bagel sandwich options and that you can design your own egg or regular bagel sandwich. I do think the bagel is a little on the hard side and not as squishy as I had hoped but still cool the bagels are made fresh.

BLT no Mayo on Asiago bagel with onion & chive cream cheese
Renae D.

This is a great place. It was really busy. People coming & going the whole time we were waiting on our bagels. When you walk in you go to the left to order. Then wait on the right side or for picking up to go orders. I got the BLT no mayonnaise on an Asiago Bagel & added the onion & chive cream cheese. The bacon was cooked perfectly & I loved the flavor of the cream cheese. My husband got the sausage egg & cheese on an everything bagel. He really enjoyed his too. We will definitely go back sometime when in town. They had Really Great prices too. I will note there isn't a restroom. Just a heads up.

They know how to wrap it
Carol L.

As a native New Yorker. Here in Cincinnati I am always on the hunt for a real bagel. Not just any bagel but a bagel with lox and all of the other items they go with it. Baby when I tell you I found that at the Bagelry, I mean that. The lox sandwich was EVERYTHING! Can't wait to try their other offerings,

Lox
Emily A.

This is such a cute bagel spot! The people working were so happy and nice. Bagels were delicious and came out very fast. I highly recommend. One thing I will mention is that there is no seating. I cant wait to go back and try the other sandwiches.

Aubrie H.

Loved the ability to order online. Only took about 10 minutes and everything was ready when we arrived. Made fresh, hot when we arrived and great flavor. The coffee was also really nice. This is a great place for a quick breakfast.

Everything bagel with sausage
Brian E.

Fun Indy bagel shop in OTR....bagels are delicious with great crust and chewy inside. I tired a local favorite Goetta for the first time, not sure what to expect. It was an interesting meat grain mixture with nice flavor and texture . The fact that they source their coffee from tinker in Indianapolis is a plus. Being that it is in OTR parking isn't the easiest but that's to be expected. Will be back.

Rosemary bagel with onion and chive cream cheese

See all

8 years ago

Bessssst place in the city for bagels!! Hands down and its local so support them and eat allll of the delicious homemade bagels you can!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 5 of 5

Ask the Community - The Bagelry

You might also consider

Carl's Deli - 23. The Carl's Country Club

Carl's Deli

4.4(278 reviews)
4.5 mi•Hyde Park
•$$

I have heard so much about this place recently and I love a good sandwich so I know that I had to…read morestop in ASAP. I stopped by for a quick lunch during the week and wanted an easy to-go sandwich. They have a medium sized menu but a lot of different options which makes it a bit hard to pick haha! I decided on a reuben sandwich with all of the fixens inside. I was surprised that I was the only one in there because of the amount of rave reviews. It was a small quaint little place. The employees were suppperrrr nice and gave me a lot of time to think about my order. The vibes in there were very cool with fun music and just overall a good time. Now onto the Reuben. Holy cow! It was juicy and very flavorful, with the perfect amount of sauerkraut. The bread was toasty and the sandwich was nice and warm but not too hot. I think this will be a new spot for me for lunch!

This was a happy accident. I was on a day trip with Matt and Michael and where to eat lunch became…read morea bigger problem than anticipated. Essentially for me I had waited too long to eat and the idea of waiting longer was a non starter for me. Sandwiches are not my go to food outside the house, it seems silly on some level. However, the sandwich I had was fantastic and well balanced. There was a good amount of everything without it being too much. Sometimes it's too much. This was great. They also had good, homemade or freshly made sides like potato salad and other salads you could get. It was great.

Photos
Carl's Deli - Order counter

Order counter

Carl's Deli - RoRo's cookie

RoRo's cookie

Carl's Deli - January 2025

See all

January 2025

The Bagelry - bagels - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...