The bagels were excellent. I thought the prices were fair- a bagel sandwich from Panera would cost about the same and wouldn't be nearly as good. Considering how many people there were working behind the counter/in the kitchen, I thought the service was slow. I got my food to go. There were probably ten or so tables. It was cramped and very loud. Not sure if I would ever sit down to eat there to eat, but I will definitely be back to get carry out. read more

I am SO happy that this location opened in Oakley! I checked it out last weekend with my husband and we had a very pleasant experience. + Speed, Friendliness, Taste It was Saturday morning around 9:30am and, although there was a line, we were in and out in under five minutes. We were expecting it to take a bit longer, so this was very impressive! The workers were very friendly and helpful. We ordered small coffees and were handed cups. There is a self-serve station on the counter. I asked a worker for milk to put in my coffee and she pointed out that the half & half and oat milk are kept in the top right of the open cooler, which is awesome that they have these and especially that they keep them cold and fresh. Most places have coffee creamers/milk sitting out on the counter for hours upon hours. Our bagels were incredible! I love that they have a menu with sandwich options, and that they give you the option to build your own. We loved the bagels so much that we returned the very next morning! My husband got the same bagel sandwich (bacon avocado on asiago) and I decided to try a simple blueberry bagel with cream cheese. It was sooo good! We will definitely continue coming back! I also noticed that they offer ordering ahead. They place these order ahead/to-go orders on the shelves/counter in the pickup area. This reminds me of Starbucks pickup but it seemed like customers had to stand there and wait to talk to a worker and say their name. Maybe they could have browsed through the paper bags on their own but they were just being patient and polite...I am not sure. But if I was in a hurry and it was peak busy time, I would like to order ahead and be able to simply grab my order and go. Maybe some people prefer to have a worker manage this so that orders are not taken (maybe that happens?). All in all, incredible experience and I am excited to continue trying more bagels and bagel sandwiches. read more

See all

Really good bagels and sandwiches! You can tell they're baked fresh daily and they don't skimp on the cream cheese or toppings! There's nowhere to sit inside so be prepared to take your order to go! read more

Definitely one of the best bagel places in the Oakley area. On weekends it can be crowded and a little slow but the bagel sandwiches make up for that. Also makes it easy that you can preorder online. I love getting a half dozen bagels for the week! read more

They were very fast and attentive when taking my order. I tried the Garden bagel and it was very tasty! I recently have been more conscious about my meat consumption so I wanted to try the veggie option and I will definitely be coming back! I would love to try other bagels alone too as the everything bagel I got was yummy. read more

The Bagelry is known for being one of the top bagel places in the area and it is certainly for good reason! I've come to this location a handful of times, and I also usually will get a Bagelry bagel if I see it at one of the local coffee shops. They have a great selection of bagel types but generally lean more savory. They have tons of cream cheeses to choose from (or you can stick to butter like me!) and you can also make it into a bagel sandwich! There's lots of options for anyone regardless of how you like your bagel. They have an online ordering option but even if you're in-store it is super quick. I will say - if you're going around peak hours on a weekend, you're likely going to have to take it to go since there isn't a ton of seating inside. And my fiancé is from New Jersey and these are his favorite in the area (so I would say they're Jersey approved ;)) - if you're craving a high quality bagel this is definitely the place to go! read more

Stopped here after sitting at the coffee shop (Red Tree) for a brunch and it was so good. I really wasn't expecting a ton since it looks like a stop and go place but it was the best bagel I've had in a minute. I got a Asiago bagel with lox, tomatoes, and cream cheese and it was so so good. Will be stopping by again soon. read more

Such a good quick breakfast spot! I love all the different options that they offer. Definitely the best breakfast sandwich bagels out there!

One of the best bagels I've eaten outside of New York - chewy, flavorful, with the perfect hint of rosemary throughout. The bacon scallion cream cheese really makes the sandwich! SO GOOD. read more

The Bagelry - Turkey Club on toasted rosemary bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

The bagel was delicious, the staff were wonderful, and even on a busy Saturday, the wait was really quick. Not a ton of seating but enough. I'll definitely be returning read more

Amazing!!!! Great bagel sandwiches!! Tasty and great service. Easy to order and pickup. A++++

I LOVE the bagelry. Been coming here ever since they opened up their Oakley location. Only giving four stars because recently it seems like they changed their sausage supplier and it's much drier and has a weird spice note. I ordered a bacon sandwich as a backup the last time I went and the only difference was the meat yet the bacon sandwich hurt my jaw to eat because the bagel was so tough- no issue with bagel softness on the sausage. Thought it was a coincidence but today I got a bacon egg and cheese on plain and it was so tough again. I wonder if they cook it longer to crisp the bacon?? Hope they fix that or go back to their old sausage patties because I lovvvveeee this place. read more

Nice atmosphere, quick service, good location, and great bagels! I highly recommend Trey the GECCO.

Great bagels for college drop off at Xavier. The rosemary has proven especially great for cold cuts.

Took 5 minutes to order. 10 people working and nobody in line in front of me. Coffee was in a tiny cup and half foam. read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

In for breakfast a second time and it was busy. Got the Lox and Cream cheese on everything and it was perfect. Shared it and we were both happy. They had plenty staff working hard. Great place that never lets one down. read more

Visit l today was not happy with my bagel. I asked for it to be toasted. It was not and my Turkey bacon was burnt.

Bagels were fresh and very tasty. Picked up a half dozen of Everything and half dozen of Asiago Cheese. Glad to have The Bagelry in the neighborhood!! read more

This place has the best bagels in town! I love the location in OtR so I had to check out their new place in Oakley. My lox sandwich was delicious (and filling), they have all the classic bagel flavors, and their sandwiches are uniformly great. Plus the space is so pretty. The art in the bathroom is really cute! read more

The Bagelry - Lox sandwich and coffee - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Best everything bagel in the greater tristate area. L O V E D the lox Cute art and neat wall sconces (?). Attractive open kitchen area where you can watch the magic happen. Plant enthusiasts, make sure you look up. read more

See all

It's hard to find a good bagel shop that makes a variety of sandwiches, too. The Bagelry has fun combinations, or you can create your own. Of course, they have bagels and cream cheese options, as well. It was quite crowded at 10:00 on a Sunday when we went. Still, the service was very pleasant, our order came out hot, delicious, and correct. Parking and a place to sit were limited at that time of day. Still, I definitely recommend! read more

Delicious bagels and sandwiches. Can order on Uber eats also which is great and convenient

Always fantastic and well priced. Love how quickly I can get my lunch especially on busy days.

Good, fresh Bagels, just not the GOAT but some of the best here in Cinci. Their cream cheeses rock, though- those ARE the best I've ever had- esp the roasted veggie. read more

New York style bagels!!!Yum!! The texture was perfectly hard on outside & fluffy inside!

Great bagels . Good texture. Great options . Sandwiches I Had the veggie breakfast and salmon lox .

My life is changed, truly improved forever because of this establishment. I got the NYC lox bagel (salt bagel) and it is the most delicious thing I've ever had in my life. The Bagelry is fantastic, they're so kind, service is quick, and the bagels are next level. 12/10. read more

5 Stars if you want to grab a bite. There isn't really anywhere to eat (no chairs just an elongated windowsill you can stand at if you really want). I had their basic breakfast bagel w meat and cheese, and if I hadn't added other toppings it would have been under $7. That's great takeout for me! read more

The best bagel. I had the avocado bagel toast on salt bagel, it was great! Fresh ingredients and the bagel is perfect. We arrived just in time before a line was behind us. The place was almost full. We found 3 chairs by the windows and ate there. We will definitely go back again. read more