I got a recommendation to try this place out, it's a smaller bagel shop in a strip mall. Inside is clean. There were three girls working the counter but it was pretty backed up behind the counter with all the orders. We had to wait about 5 minutes for a bagel with butter not toasted. When I opened the bagel in the car I was very disappointed on how little butter they put on it. It was obviously rushed. The bagel itself was good but super dry without butter. read more

The Bagelry - Bagel with butter. Allegedly - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

See all

Talkin bout some seriously tasty Bagels people. Excellent firm shiny texture on the outside and flavorful fluffy inside plus toppings that stay on both sides. I've always thought that what makes a very special place special is an equal amount of friendly service, a quality product, and damn good coffee - check,  check,  and triple check. The Bagelry most definitely has it going on. Come And Get Your Munch On!! read more

See all

Stopped in after the gym to order an egg and Taylor ham sandwich on an everything bagel. It was prepared quickly and was good. Full of flavor. They had a large selection of bagels I don't normally see in other places. Will deff be back in again after another class. read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

See all

Service is always fast and friendly. Pretty good bagel spot on my way to work! they offer iced cold brew that I get from time to time & it's not bad! read more

The bagels are first rate. There are many bagel places in Morris County that are good but I give these bagels the highest rating. They are also one of the few places that makes bialys the right way - big, plump and with lots of onion in the middle. As for the whitefish salad, that's disappointing. The price is rather steep and for what you're getting way overpriced. I've had my share of white fish salad in various places and I'm almost 100% certain that this is the same as sold at Costco or from the company that makes it for Costco. More like a spread. Had I purchased it from Costco, it would be fine for me but nothing out of this world. But when I'm basically purchasing the same thing here and paying triple the price, something's wrong. I'd appreciate a response from the owner. read more

No stars if I could.....Service was terrible. The older lady at the register had the worst attitude I have seen, right down to her body language. Once order was done she shoved bag across counter like she couldn't be bothered. The whole experience was chaotic and unpleasant. Bagels were subpar, I have had better at Manhattan Bagels and frankly they are lacking too! read more

I just tried The Bagelry for the first time after receiving a recommendation to try it. I enjoyed the everything bagel as it was soft, wasn't too dense, and had the everything seasoning on both sides of the bagel (which is rare). I look forward to returning and trying more items from their menu, specifically their breakfast sandwiches! read more

The Bagelry - Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

I ordered this: a sesame bagel with lox, cream cheese, tomato and onion. What did I get? A burnt poppy bagel with lox spread, tomato and onion. There are 5 bagel places in a two mile radius of where this place is. Not going back. read more

I would enter this shop after going to the doctors ordered a egg salad with lettuce and tomato on a pumpernickel bagel when I came home I had a seeded bagel with very sparse egg salad and lettuce and tomato. It was $16 and some change I will not be going back there the girl who took my order was not very friendly, so I will tell my neighbors who love bagels if they want a better bagel than I got to go to time out for a bagel in Mars Plains read more

So today I decided I wanted to go to the Baglery and I called them I was on the phone for over 5:00 minutes and I just think that it is ridiculous that it would take 5:00 minutes to place a order and just for one bagel and when we got to the parking lot still waiting we look inside and there is no one in here and I mean like 2 people. The lady that took our order was not that happy I guess she didn't wake up on the right side of bed but she does need work on that and not roll her eyes when she has to do her job. read more

I was craving a chicken salad bagel sandwich. I stopped by and placed my order which was supposed to be a plain bagel with Chicken salad on it. To say the least I'm absolutely livid and disappointed. I don't understand how anyone could mess up preparing my order. It's not like. My order was complicated or anything. Simply get a plain bagel and add the chicken salad to it like a typical bagel sandwich. And to make things worse I'm Out 13 dollars and some change and I'm very hungry and now I have no choice but to find something else to eat. I have allergies that prevents me from eating the sandwich that I didn't order. I know it was a mistake coming here I will simply not return here. The ambiance of this place was that there was hardly anyone in there and both workers were distracted by there phones to notice me. I used to like this place but over time it's gone down and prices are going up and up. read more

The Bagelry - Rye Bread Chicken Salad - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

Nice breakfast and lunch spot for bagels, sandwiches, and wraps. The quality of the food is great. They don't offer a lot of vegan options. Server are super nice read more

amazing bagels, perfect mix of soft on the inside with a slightly hard shell and huge sizes! read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

Don't eat here! They burnt our bagel to the point it was inedible and refused to rectify the situation. And to top it off there was a hair when you removed the bagels! This place used to be good but has drastically gone downhill. read more

I order from The Bagelry pretty often, so it's time for an update! Initially I had only tried bagels but I've come to be a pretty big fan of their sandwiches. The sandwich list is huge and has all sorts of cold cut / chicken options. Sandwiches can be made on a bagel, in a wrap or on a roll. I'm pretty partial to a turkey wrap which comes stuffed with lots of meat and cheese. All sandwiches also come with a side of coleslaw and a pickle! Service is pretty speedy, and if you order at the counter you can expect to only wait a couple of minutes. My only complaint - the foil that they use to wrap the sandwiches sheds little teeny pieces of foil all over the sandwich. I just had to spend a few minutes picking out the foil, and I really hope I didn't eat any. They might want to consider changing up their packaging. The sandwiches are still great and I will continue to order when the sandwich (or bagel) craving hits. read more

See all

We started ordering our breakfast bagels from here because it was randomly recommended by Yelp. I love how many options there are for customizing: bagel type, level of toasting, cheese, etc. I also love that real cheddar is an option! The bagels are HUGE with perfect texture; we always order a few extra to have around. They've become a weekend staple! read more

We drove here before going into the city on a Saturday morning. We came because my wife was excited about the varieties of cream cheese (I think she wanted nutella or something), but I enjoyed the huge everything bagel with huge amounts of chive cream cheese read more

The Bagerlry is always a go to when in the area. The bagels are always fresh and delicious. On the weekend they offer special bagels, like a French toast flavor bagel and they offer an array of cream cheese flavors. Definitely a go to! read more

Loved that they have vegan options! Got the whole wheat everything flagel with scallion vegan cc!! Quick and delicious read more

The Bagelry - Whole wheat everything flagel with vegan cream Cheese! - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

Nice bagel place. Decided to drop in after donating blood this early morning. Grab a bite to eat. Greeted with a smile. Friendly staff. Nice assortment of bagels but less a few I actually like. They have some muffins and pastries that look good as well. Joe products chips and drinks is a huge sell in here. The have a few tables you can eat at. So I decided to stay and enjoy it. I did not say salt, peper and catchup nor was I asked. Thought about it after gotten the sandwich. The sandwich was actually good minus the S,P,C. I like the not so hard egg. And the sausage actually had a good taste. Melted cheese makes this a winner for me. As I say. Many seem to know the place. The many that ran in and out with a pre order. Makes staying in the go a quickie in and out. Definitely a place I see getting crowded in the morning traffic. But they are able to still get you put within mins. When in the area I can see this being my stop and eat. read more

The Bagelry - Sausage, egg and cheese on toasted Cinnamon raisin - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

See all

I order from here enough times to wonder how I've never written a review before this. This is pretty much my go-to spot in the Morristown area. They have friendly and quick service and they make a good Taylor ham egg and cheese. I do wish they had maybe another slice of pork roll in there instead of just 2. Dining is no frills but clean. Their bagels also freeze well to be reheated later in a toaster oven. Used to be that if you came in right before closing at 2pm you could get some free extra bagels so they don't waste any but I haven't seen much of that lately. read more

The Bagelry - Taylor ham egg and cheese on everything - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

Ordered: Turkey Bacon Egg & Cheese (~$7): on an everything whole wheat bagel (scooped out) (+$1) with breakfast potatoes (+$1) Medium Vanilla Latte (~$7): with almond milk Aya's take: I have been meaning to try The Bagelry for the longest time! I'm torn with rating a 3/5 or 4/5 since I really wanted to like it. I was craving a breakfast sandwich and made my way over before starting my day. I initially ordered my sandwich with avocado added to which there is an upcharge. They later told me they didn't have avocado, so I substituted it with breakfast potatoes. Secondly, I had asked for the insides to be scooped out (not an unusual ask), and when I got my bagel, all of the insides were clearly still there. I can say the remaining ingredients - turkey bacon, egg, and cheese - were fresh, tasty, and delicious. I would've have preferred the avocado and given that they have breakfast potatoes (not hash browns), I wouldn't get it next time. The Vanilla Latte is steeply priced for a regular drink. It didn't have good flavor; I would stick to a regular coffee/tea or bottled drink. I did love the cup design and message! I would love to give The Bagelry another chance but for my first time here, it was unfortunately a letdown. read more

The Bagelry - Medium Vanilla Latte (~$7) - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

See all

The Bagelry is definitely one of my all-time favorite bagel places, up there with Goldberg's in Glen Rock. Really good texture, thickness, and the perfect amount of cream cheese (I know this is totally subjective) every single time. I also really like their cream cheese selection as they tend to have a couple of unique ones, like cheddar jalapeño. The only "negative" thing I would say is that the wait can be long, even if you're not getting anything fancy or toasted and just want one bagel with cream cheese. It's never been a quick in-and-out experience there, at least, for me. But that won't stop me from giving five stars for all of the great stuff they bring to the table! read more

The Bagelry - Everything bagel (not toasted) with the perfect amount of veggie cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

Probably one of the best spots for a bagel in Morristown. I ordered a pork roll egg and cheese on a sesame bagel. The bagel itself was delicious. The meat and cheese inside was flavorful and honestly everything you could hope for in a breakfast sandwich. Food came out fast. The place was very clean and I was happy with their COVId precautions. I would totally recommend for breakfast! read more

The Bagelry - Pork roll egg and cheese on a sesame bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

See all

Bagels are 4 out of 10... The place is clean. People are friendly. ISSUE I HAVE IS THEY DO NOT OPEN UNTIL 7:00a.. So I will not be going here.. read more

I came to this spot to order breakfast for some clients. I parked in the plaza parking lot when I arrived. When I walked in I walked to the cashier and ordered a bunch if things and the turkey bacon and egg bagel and asked for no cheese. It wasn't too expensive for everything. I paid and waited for about 10 to 15 minutes or so. I grabbed everything and left. The office was pleased with the food. I will say this place did come through in the clutch, but the downfall came when I opened my sandwich and seen they put cheese on my sandwich. I had to drive all the way back and wait for another. The sandwich wasn't bad tasting when I did get to try it. All in all I had an ok experience. read more

See all

New Jersey is known for it's amazing bagels, and every town has no less than five bagel stores. But The Bagelry has quickly risen to the top of our Go-To list in the whole of Morris County. Their storefront is super cute, with a few small tables inside, and it's well decorated in a very farm rustic chic style. You can order bagels, bagel sandwiches, eggs, and pastries. Bagels are $1 each or $11 for a Baker's Dozen. Whatever they do to their bagels, they are light and delicious, with tons of variety. I always get a salt bagel with taylor ham (can you tell I'm a Jersey girl?!) and it is cooked to perfection. In addition to going into the store to order, you can also call in orders and then pick them up. Very convenient. read more

Here's the deal: great bagel store in a cluster or stores. They have a great variety of bagels & grill times ( sandwiches etc..). They also have really good coffee!!! Also section of tables to sit outside on a nice day !! There's a few top notch bagels places in the area ... this place is on that list!!! read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

The bagelry in cedar knolls is my favorite bagel shop. I go there because the bagels are delicious the breakfast and lunch sandwiches are delicious. Everything is fresh. There is a great variety of sandwiches. They even cater. The owners Anthony and Abe are wonderful. They are kind caring hardworking serve the community by donating bagels to churchs to sort out and deliver to the hungry. They really care about all the customers and the community . Their staff is exceptional. Hard working. I go there first because im happy being greeted like family then for the delicious food. Please support them. read more

Super soft bagels, their sandwiches are amazing also. This rating is purely based on their food. Their Taylor ham is sliced super thin and crispy with a little char (like how it shouldn't be a for a Taylor Ham Egg n Cheese sandwich). The bagels are fluffy and even stay well for the next day. Would highly recommend if you're anywhere within 10-15 mins driving to go here. We have a bunch of bagel shops closer to parsippany but still prefer The Bagelry read more

The Bagelry - Awesome bagels - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

See all

Came here to get lunch fot my wife and myself. As I went to my car, Anthony came out in the POURING rain to doublecheck that the sandwich was right. Now that's GREAT customer service! read more

The Bagelry - Blueberry bagel with turkey bacon, Swiss cheese, and egg whites - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

See all

Bagels are big! My son was a huge fan. Crowded bagel shop is always a good sign. I enjoyed it for my first time, I would like to come back and try a dine in or just explore the menu a little more, but I'm happy with the bagels! read more

The Bagelry - Everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. HUGE! - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

See all

There is nothing like a fresh, doughy bagel. The Bagelry does it right! I am a simple, traditional guy - TH no cheese on a plain bagel with nothing on it. I feel you can truly appreciate the sandwich if you don't add anything to it. And if you need to toast it (which you don't have to do here) then the bagel needs some work or if that's you thing fine. Delicious coffee. Friendly staff. Quick. Plenty of parking in shared lot. Open early. Prices are right on point. Enjoy! read more

AMAZING!!! Owners are very personable. And Manny is the best. It's always a pleasure to go there. Highly recommended!!!

Weak. How long does it take to get an egg and cheese on a bagel? 10 minutes of it never prints and no one bothers to follow up on it. Apology? Not unless you push. Mostly just blank looks. Similar to when the order was taken in the first place. I know there're new, but at least pretend to care instead of chatting up the cops for 10 minutes while someone is obviously waiting for something. Unlike most bagel places that can really move a line, there's no hustle here. They're not rude, but there's no attempt to be friendly. You know there's old-Jersey places that are just "Whatta you want? Okay, here's your food" unless you're a 20-year regular? There's the modern places where everything is clean and "branded" and they welcome you with a bright cheery smile and they're really corporate and efficient? This is a new place that aspires to be the old grouchy kind. They don't even take smartphone payment. The flagel was good and fresh. I think my scone was made with some type of recycled fiberboard. Save your effort and just go a mile up the street to downtown Morris Plains to Time for a Bagel. People come from all over Morris County to go there. They compete with Alph Bagels in Randolph for the best quality. Why would you go to The Bagelry when TFAB is so close? Those people know how to move a line, and they're experts at food prep, with tons of choices. They have personality and a smile, it not at all in a corporate way. They're downtown and it feels like a community shop. No, I'm not affiliated with them and I've never had a conversation with any of the workers, I just like the place. The Bagelry? I really wanted to like this place. I often go to the Pet Supplies Plus next door, so I would love to grab breakfast at the same time. Sadly, I found the place soulless, disinterested, slow and incompetent. I don't see any attempt to care or try harder. Why bother? read more

The Bagelry - Outside. Ample parking. - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

Amazing food was matched with rude service the lady with the blue cup made me feel unwelcome and honestly convinced me to not go back. I enjoyed the bagels but not the staff. Go to Morristown bagel or Noah's where they don't treat you poorly and have reasonable prices read more

Being from NJ, I know that we're all pretty picky about our bagels... The Bagelry simply nailed the everything bagel. First off, the bagel was warm when it came out of the basket so we already know how fresh it was. The bagel was soft on the inside and crispy on the outside with little tiny crispy bubbles in the crust - it was topped with a generous amount of seasoning to give the perfect everything bagel experience in every bite. I got a bacon egg and cheese and oh man was it good. Since the bagel was still warm I didn't even need to get it toasted. The sandwich was made with two fried eggs, fresh, crispy bacon and melty cheese. Sure there are cheaper options around but I feel very confident that this is the best BEC on an everything bagel in Motown. See you guys on Sunday! read more

The Bagelry - Everything bagel - BEC - Bagels Near Me - Cedar Knolls, New Jersey

See all

Yes even it's the first time here, I love this place... first of all, huge parking spot; second, super friendly staff; third; awesome selection of bagel, cream cheese, and from the grill... everything made fresh and delicious!!! Love their everything bagel... I will be honest, when you say 'everything' bagel I expect everything (at least what I wanted) and you don't know how many places I went to, they don't put salt on the bagel... I know I know, less salt is healthier, but man, it taste so much better with a little extra salt and the crunch!!! Thank you Bagelry for putting salt on it and I am a happy camper!!! And the size of the bagel is huge!!!! I bought extra for the next day, and after I toast it, taste just as good!!!! Thank you so much!!! I am sure I will be back for more!!!!! read more

Ok, these bagels are legit. It's as if they transplanted one of nycs many fine bagel shops and placed it here in cedar Knolls. Long time picky bagel eater and these, including with the cream cheese and egg sandwiches, hit the spot every time. I don't even need to look any further. read more

It's a nice spot to get bagels if you're in the area. I ordered an everything bagel toasted with vegan cream cheese. The bagel was decent; delicious, fresh, made with just the right amount of bread, and toasted just right. I'm not sure if they make their own vegan cream cheese, but it was pretty delicious compared to other vegan cream cheeses I've tried. It was creamy, you couldn't even tell it was vegan. My only issue is I also ordered a latte with oat milk. I paid for it and they tell me that the only milk they have left is whole milk or half and half. Before ringing up a customer they should really check to make sure they have the inventory on hand before the customer pays for something they might not have. Other than that small issue, my experience at the Bagelry was pleasant. read more

See all