We dined here to celebrate a birthday and had reservations. While the restaurant was very busy and clearly popular, the food unfortunately didn't live up to our expectations. Aside from the appetizer selection, I didn't particularly enjoy the meal. My family loves pasta, but the dishes we ordered were mediocre and felt like something I could easily make at home. I was also confused by the "specialty" pasta section on the menu, as most of the dishes didn't include protein. Only one pasta listed it clearly, and we had to ask our waiter for clarification on the others, which was a bit frustrating. That said, the wait staff was kind and friendly, and helpful. The pasta was edible, just not memorable, and the overall selection didn't impress us. I may not return, but it's worth noting that the restaurant was very busy while we were there, so it's clearly a favorite for many just not the right fit for me. read more

We always forget about how great this place is for a non chain Italian option. We called ahead and heard that they're pretty booked up but we took a chance anyways. When we got there, a number of tables were open and we were seated right away. Our server was friendly and quick to help while also giving us time to read through the menu. We had a few bottle of wine as part of the rewards program so that was pretty neat. The back room we were in was a little cramped but we appreciated getting our breadsticks and salad pretty quick. By the time our entrees were delivered, we were almost too full to have any. You won't leave here hungry! Great stop yet again and we will definitely keep this one in the rotation. read more

See all

Let's start off with the positives! The food at That's Amore really is good. We have the vegetable ravioli in a lemon cream sauce, and the flavors were fantastic. The breadsticks and salad are a perfect starter for the meal. Another positive is that our server was quite attentive and the meal came quickly. The initial restaurant experience left quite a bit to be desired unfortunately. I joined the waiting list ahead of time and there was still a bit more to go - no problem! But when the hostess took us to a table, she brought us to a booth, suggesting that I could just sort of keep the kids contained in the booth. I have a two-year-old and a one year-old, they need high chairs. I understand if they didn't have that type of table ready, but it was unrealistic to expect that we would make do in a booth and I would have preferred they had just said we need to wait a little bit longer for the correct type of table rather than packing up, going to the booth and then needing to go back to the waiting area. Luckily my toddler was fine with it, but that definitely could've gone differently. When there was a table ready, the highchair had to be in a certain place to keep it out of the aisle, which I do understand, but it did add some complexity for me with how I had to be spaced out from the kids. The highchair and the booster seat were very dirty and our server was happy to clean them when I pointed it out, but I do feel it's something I shouldn't have to ask. Overall, the food was excellent, and we enjoyed the actual dining, but the experience was not friendly for children or the parent. I am of the opinion that children are people too, and should be able to eat out with their parents (as long as it's in a way that the dining experience is nice for everyone in the restaurant!) so this is maybe not the restaurant for that for us in the future unfortunately read more

That's Amore - Italian Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

I continue to love That's Amoré. My mom and I went for a late lunch and early dinner last Sunday afternoon. I got my usual chicken Marsala and opted for veggies as the side. My mom got the beef short rib bolognese. I tried some of hers and it was delicious. As always, we enjoyed the breadsticks and salad. We ended our meal with a slice of carrot cake. The cake was moist. The frosting was amazing! As should be obvious from my previous reviews, I'll be back! read more

See all

We had food catered for an event! An array of pastas and a HUGE salad available. Antipasta skewers and bruschetta also catered for the event. Food was absolutely delicious and I'd love to check out the food in person as well. I saw the staff come and deliver the food and seemed like they had it seriously well controlled. Id order from here read more

You know it's good when your wife says, "I think I need to have some 'That's Amore' Lasagna"! So, Lasagna it was. with the (L) portion being so huge, she got two more meals out of the entree at home. I had Chicken Primavera because my diet doesn't allow tomatoes, and the lemon-flavored sauce was excellent. Price, quality, and service make it a favorite. Not sure if the "rat-pack" theme says anything to younger generations. read more

I decided to try this place while my sister, who loves it, was out of town. The unlimited breadsticks and salad are definitely fan favorites, and I can see why! The breadsticks were warm and freshly made, and the salad had an amazing dressing and tasted fresh. I also appreciated that they sell their own salad dressing, which was a nice touch. I tried the Ketel One martini, which was delicious, and overall, the service was good, though a bit slow on the lower level. We ordered the Crabby Chicken and the Chicken Parmigiana & Lasagna combination plate. The Crabby Chicken was okay, but could've used a bit more seasoning to bring out the flavor. Unfortunately, the Chicken Parmigiana and Lasagna weren't our favorites - the chicken was a bit dry and lacked flavor kind of tasted not that well done, though the marinara sauce was tasty. I'd come back to try other menu items, especially with the breadsticks and salad on the side. The hostess was also very welcoming and friendly, which made for a pleasant visit overall read more

See all

The Prime rib is a great and a good value. Their service is very solid and accommodating. Drive up window for pick up ,helps when you have mobility issues. read more

We had a family and friends gathering and the overall experience was good. The food and drinks were average sized portions and reasonably priced. The only problem was with a large group it gets very crowded downstairs. read more

Had a huge Italian beef sandwich with perfectly cooked French fries and was not able to eat it all. The flavor was superb and came with a complimentary salad with bread sticks. My wife had the mushroom ravioli and said it was the best she has ever eaten. Mushrooms cooked perfectly and the sauce was creamy with amazing flavor. Our waiter's name was Ergi and we highly recommend him because he has a great personality and friendly character. We liked him so much that we gave him a 40% tip and he was worth every penny. Yes we will order those again. read more

This place is amazing! I have always likes it but has improved. The food was fantastic and the service was warm and fiendly. The burgers are fanastic. Salad and breadsticks are not to be missed. Order dipping sauce on the side ao fun and yummy! The pastas are great. It is a special meal all the time. Highly recommend. read more

A group of five of us went to That's Amore for lunch. One plus right away is that they agreed to give separate checks. if the waitress did not know an answer to someone's question, she willingly checked with the kitchen. I ordered eggplant spinach parmigiana, which turned out to be excellent. Before our entrees came they served the table an excellent fresh garden salad and breadsticks to share, which was a nice touch. We were served in a timely manner, except for one of our group who ordered lasagna whose entree came late. The waitress presented us each with our bills. It took her quite a while to run each of our credit cards, but we were not in a hurry. When our group arrived at 11:30 (with a reservation) there was no wait. When we left the place was full and people were waiting. The parking lot was packed, with good reason. The food was very good. I will definitely return. read more

That's Amore - Eggplant Spinach Parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

An institution if you're in Milwaukee. TA is the Olive Garden of local Italian places, without the microwaved food or big corporate ownership but with just as yummy salad and breadsticks. The Alfredo sauce is top notch and the meatballs are more than good also. If you want to leave full and with a to go box, check out that's amore. You won't be disappointed. read more

Everything was so good best prime rib best eggplant best calamari I've ever had I worked in restaurants for 30 years tried a lot of food everything was 10/10 I can't wait to go back and try more read more

I love the salad/breakfast all you can eat!! The spaghetti with meatballs were great. Everyone loved all the food. 3 stars are because we made a reservation for 7, and our server was mad to serve us. Her tone and manner was extremely rude. At the end without us asking, and we weren't even done eating, she dropped off 5 to-go boxes and put them on top of the salad!! Her wait times were so long, and we had to find her. She was overall horrible! read more

I flew in from out of state to take my friend of 30 years out for dinner for her retirement celebration. We had a 5 pm reservation. 1 hour and 10 minutes later, our plates were not cleared yet, a blonde hostess/manager told us since we were finished, they need the table for waiting guests. Not an option to move to the bar. Just leave. This restaurant is the place my friend wanted to go, but I would never go back. We found another great Italian restaurant down the street. We were welcomed in and had a great time at the bar enjoying desserts. read more

Food is just so so. My wife had Veal Parm. The Veal was gristly and just not a very good piece of meat. Just not the same place it was some years ago. read more

Great food! Went with a group this time. I have been to this restaurant many times over the years and I think their food is great. Their staff is great. It's a pretty facility. It has a nice outdoor seating area decorated with flowers. They play a lot of music from the rat pack and there's lots of pictures on the wall of the rat pack and other scenes from Italy. I have never had a bad meal here and today when we were there the group of five of us everyone loved what they ate. They used to have these pork specials on Thursday and they had this one pork dinner. I can't remember what it was called, but it had two pork chops and there was potatoes and I think there was green peppers and green olives and other stuff in it, it was wonderful and one of the best meals I have had. Sadly, they don't make it anymore. It's still a great restaurant, the meals come with salad bowl and breadsticks. They Have a great bar. They have room for parties. It's a great place in Hales corners Wisconsin. read more

Without a doubt when someone wants to meet for happy hour and appetizers this is 100% my go to place. You know the place where you always order the same thing and the consistency and service and price bring you back kinda place. That is without a doubt That's Amore! Calamari, shrimp Capri and eggplant roll-ups are the perfect trifecta. Start with a Manhattan and then then order the house wine. If you have room for dessert the tiramisu is the bomb! read more

That's Amore - Italian Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

See all

This is decent Italian restaurant that I have been to a few times because I like the food and they have special offers for the customers like a $10 off coupon when you download the app. You get $10 off on your birthday good for 2 weeks before your birthday and 2 weeks after your birthday. I currently have a free bottle of wine on my next visit so the perks are pretty nice especially when perks are not the norm now of days. read more

See all

Delicious prime rib along with fried eggplant appetizer. Busy on weekends so make a reservation or take a chance early or late. read more

See all

Had a wonderful meal again at That's Amore! When I made the reservation I didn't even realize it was Sweetest Day. We sat at the exact time our reservation was made! Kayla was our server and she was outstanding! When we go back we will definitely ask for her!! Thank you for the enjoyable experience!! read more

Nice place to spend some time and foot is good too, try soup and salad with your meal

Wonderful Italian restaurant!We always eat downstairs and take advantage of happy hour and dinner menu.Food is very good, drinks and wine are also very good, and modestly priced! Staff is amazing! Very attentive and helpful. I strongly recommend this restaurant!!! read more

That's Amore is our favorite fish fry place. We often take another couple or group of friends who have never eaten here before and it becomes their favorite spot, too! Last night was no exception... everything from the delicious bottomless salad, fresh hot breadsticks, side of garlic butter pasta and the FISH was so delicious. I love that you get a choice for your side, breadsticks instead of the standard rye bread, and salad instead of coleslaw. This fish fry is truly the best EVER! read more

Compliments to the chef. I ordered a medium rare 8oz filet. The filet was very tender and flavorful. Love the garlic noodles too. Service was excellent on 10/2/25 at 215pm. Will return for mouth watering filet read more

Food was Good Waitress Trish was Excellent BUT the Hostess needs To Not Be So RUDE and treat Customers with RESPECT.

Great service and great food. Our waitress was patient and waited for us to finish our starters before putting in our main

We hadn't been here in years due to the poor service and rude waitress. We went back only to be yelled at by the manager and told that they don't accept reservations and that she'd put us on the list. We actually had signed up for their wait-list online. My group of 5 people decided we'd rather spend our money elsewhere. I like the food, but if you can't get in and eat it because the staff is unprofessional then that's an issue. read more

Delicious, generously portioned and quickly served food. I have enjoyed all the entrees I have tried. Most recently I enjoyed the mushroom ravioli as well as the salad and breadsticks. Sylvia was efficient, accurate and such a genuinely friendly server. She suggested the carrot cake to top off my meal and I am so glad I took her advice!!Fantastic! read more

Food was great. We sat outside. It's was daughter's birthday. All entrees come with salad and breadsticks. We had the rice balls for an appetizer. All meals were very generous, lots of leftovers. Prices seemed a bit high, but everything is. Service was good, the food almost came out a bit fast, but I guess that's ok. Check it out for yourself, you will not be disappointed. read more

This is the 2nd time that I've gone in the last three months where everything was a disappointment, I figured the first time was just a miss , but this time I was excited to go after my surgery of having full hip replacement , they did not care about anybody being handicap or in a Walker , the walkways were not clear. They had dishwasher bins in the aisle and then as I was being seated, the bartender, Cody was being very mean /rude telling me you can't have a walker when I was just trying to get situated and using it as balance to get on a chair , it took at least 10 minutes, even though the bartender was yelling at me , so they saw us for a server to come over to bring water, but maybe because they didn't have any glasses cause there was glasses everywhere on the bar when there 4 people at the bar and there was lots of tables in the restaurant that were open when they told me there was a 45 minute wait but I understand nobody wants to work in the industry so they were probably short staffed. But at the bar, there was two bartenders that decided to just have conversations within themselves and not care about the tables in the bar where I was seated. We ordered two appetizers. The breadsticks came out cold and my fried bowtie was basically fried scraps. I asked if they could put the Brewer game on , there's ways of communicating politely and respectfully, which they did not do , but they just said no we don't have that , at this point, we asked the server to just pack up our dinners that had not come yet to go because I was so disgusted with with the service and the dirty looks from the bartenders and the dirty bar . Cody the bartender was wiping his sweat off as well as making drinks without even sanitizing his hands . It just was not acceptable. read more

Have been a customer since they open customer before they were open with timber. The food is just as good if not better than timber this is excellent. Food is always good. Never had a bad deal there. read more

Have not been here since before Covid, food has always been very good, had Brenda D. as a waitress, vey rude, got stuck with her once before and now again, best prime rib and all you can eat shrimp, good cocktails too, low rating is for service, food is great. read more

That's Amore - All - You - Can - Eat Shrimp - Italian Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

See all

Great food ~ great atmosphere! The garlic breadsticks and salad included in the meal was also delicious! read more

That's Amore - Chicken Picata - Italian Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

See all

The food was awful for the price, especially the soggy veal... what made this visit worse was that it was my Mom's 70th birthday and the waitress was rude. She gave us attitude the entire night from not answering a simple question of what are your soda types to not offering anyone dessert. She was definitely acting put out while serving us. We will not be returning... which is sad too because it's such a nice ambiance inside the bar & restaurant. read more

I love to go there with friends. The atmosphere was cool. Lot of Dean Martin photos on the wall. Their service was excellent. read more

That's Amore - Mushroom Ravioli is to die for. Every time I go there I must have it. - Italian Near Me - Greenfield, Wisconsin

Terrible to call this an Italian restaurant! Hardly any of the items were edible. Calamari low quality, chicken tasted old. Just plain terrible. read more

Problems started when I gave them my name for my reservation. I could see my name in the book and the hostess wouldn't accept my name. Apparently they had the wrong 1st name but correct last name. Some other woman came and looked at and they still wouldn't acknowledge it was me. Then I asked why the free bottle of wine offered to me was no longer on the app. The 2nd woman said I apparently hit the redeem button and there was nothing they could do about it. I said I didn't and then she called me "Sweetheart". At that point I told her not to call me that and she proceeded to call me that 2 more times. How disrespectful. With that, we left and will never go back again. My late husband and I used to frequent That's Amore. No more. I was there last year and was treated just as rudely as tonight. I thought I would give it another chance. NEVER again. read more

Back in March, I ordered and picked up your Mostaccioli. I have to tell you that it is one of the most tasty and enjoyable dishes I have every had. I mean, I have had other dishes from you, but this is amazing!!!! Thank You. read more