Popped in for a breakfast. Great bagel sandwich, good coffee, good service, good price. There's even good parking! Sandwiches were made to order, so they took a minute to receive. Bagel "flavors are the old school standards. Nothing bougie or over the top. It's the classics here and they're fresh and chewy. My only complaint is no seating. Take your breakfast and go. read more

Really good breakfast sandwiches! You can order sandwiches to have one or two eggs. Service was also quick. Owners are very nice and welcoming. read more

Tenafly Hot Bagels - Bacon egg and cheese on sesame seed bagel - Bagels Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Ordered traditional bacon, egg, & cheese. I got there the order was not ready. Finally received my order and the bagel was stale. The eggs had shells in them. I will not be back, wasted my money! read more

I got a scallion everything bagel. For four dollars it was a great price. The cream cheese gets really liquidy, which I prefer my cream cheeses to be more thick. Nice service. You need to spend five dollars or more to use a credit card. read more

Amazing bacon, egg & cheese bagel! Everything was fresh, the bacon was crispy, the egg was perfectly cooked, and the cheese melted just right. The bagel itself was soft and delicious. Great taste, generous portion, and friendly service. I'll definitely be back! read more

My go to bagel spot. Consistent and always delivers fast and quality . Try it out . Happy new year read more

Tenafly Hot Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

This review is specifically for their bagels. I got an everything bagel, toasted with vegetable cream cheese. On the plus side, it was quick and easy to order. However 1) the bagel itself didn't taste very fresh (bit hard / stale) 2) bagel wasn't fully toasted 3) seasoning of the bagel needed more flavor 4) the cream cheese itself was fine to good read more

Love these bagels. Awesome cream cheeses, great sandwiches. Parking lot right next door. Owners are lovely

5/10 Bacon egg and cheese need more egg. Cream cheese bagel need more cream cheese and more solid cream cheese less liquidity. Bagels need to be a little bigger for the price. Was not bad their just wasn't enough of what got ordered very small portions read more

Surprise bag was generous mix of fresh/delicious bagels. Staff was very friendly and helpful.

Bagel was decent. We arrived at lunchtime and there were very few bagel flavors left to choose from. Husband's roast beef sandwich didn't have much flavor. read more

I just picked up a surprise order from Tenafly Bagels using the Too Good To Go app. I ended up getting 13 assorted bagels (including a flagel and a bialy) for $3.99!!! Everything was delicious. What a bargain! The cashier was very courteous and polite. Would definitely purchase from there again! read more

Been going here for years and I will continue to do so. Prices are reasonable here, staff is nice, and they make great bagels. They seem to care about their business and customers here. read more

Great bagel shop! Fresh soft bagels and quick service and they wear masks while preparing your food which is a plus these days!

Very good service. Does the job and does it well! Owners were fast and efficient. Support the local business!! read more

Tenafly Hot Bagels - Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Really good. Blueberry muffin and bagel with the cream cheese & lox spread are 2 of my favorites.

You can never go wrong with a lox, cream cheese, tomato, and onion bagel!!!! The bagel was nice and crispy on the outside and soft and chewy on the inside!!! The bagel ended up being a lot smaller than i thought it would be, especially since the lox bagels i usually get are pretty massively stacked. Still delicious though! Ended up being around $9:50. read more

See all

Stopped by tenafly hot bagels and had one of the best breakfasts I've had in a while. Lox sandwich was a nice mix of lox, cream cheese, crunchy onions, salty capers and chewy bagel. All of their cream cheeses are made in house and you can tell. If you stop by, you have to try the homemade original croissant - I loved that it was more doughy than other croissants and the inside part was so chewy and flavorful. Simple, but amazing great bagel shop for breakfast sandwich or bagel! Highly recommend for anyone in the area! read more

Tenafly Hot Bagels - Lox sandwich on everything bage - Bagels Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

My go to bagel store when I'm in the area. Quick service (although it does get busy during lunch time when the kids are in school) so i usually call ahead of time. Friendly staff and reasonable prices. I usually just get their bagels but they also make sandwiches and wraps. Definitely recommend this place! read more

Great bagels and great prices! People love their ham/bacon egg cheese bagels. They aren't as expensive as other bagel places and they're very quick. Overall a great place! read more

Tenafly Hot Bagels - Bacon egg cheese - Bagels Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Yes!! Bagel sandwiches!! Yes!! Just do it! I went 2 days in a row while visiting the area! The danishes are delicious too.

This place really exceeded my expectations. The service was very fast and very high quality. The owners were also very nice and provided excellent service. Definitely would visit again. read more

This place is a hidden gem, super clean, and the bagels are always fresh. Most importantly, the staff is amazing and the owners always have a smile on their face and deliver a high-quality product. The price is are very reasonable compared to the area and everything just seems fresh here. I started coming here after having an encounter with a rude and obnoxious worker at celebrity bagels. It is the best decision I ever made. I have never had an order go wrong or an unpleasant encounter with anyone at this location I would highly recommend the flavored cream cheese, and definitely would recommend the Flagels as well. read more

Happy to see that they have good reviews. It's deserved. They charge 5 bucks for a sandwich that costs me 12 up the road. Small, humble bagel shop with relaxed employees. I'll be back! read more

Visited today, June 4, 2020 and found several people going in without face masks. I waited a few minutes before going in and I asked the woman behind the counter why she permitted these customers to order and she denied that there were any without face masks. I would not patronize this business. read more

Excellent staff and excellent bagels (crispy on the outside, soft on the inside)....not much else to ask for in a bagel shop!

Over the last year or 2 the flavor of the bagels has changed ....I would say it's a good flavor....and changed for the better ..They must be bringing in NYC water....You'll Like these bagels...... read more

Very very good bagels. The best prices around they are almost 10 dollars below the other bagel places in town while keeping the same quality in food. It would be a shame to not go here for bagels. The best in town. read more

Egg and cheese bagel sandwiches....love them! It's is a weekly Saturday morning treat along with a fresh, flavorful garlicky and poppy seed bialy. Oh wait a minute, let me wipe my mouth....drooling. When I have repeat clients in the morning, I pick up coffee and a bagel with cream cheese there and bring it to then....spreading the love. Speaking of psread, the flavored cream cheeses are delicious too: walnut spread, lox spread, chive spread, vegetable spread. Is it brunch time yet? read more

First time visitors to the Northern Valley area may think that people in the area only eat bagels, as the area is scattered with bagel stores. There are 3 in Tenafly alone, but Tenafly Hot Bagels is the only place worthy of mention. Bagels are made on premise, and if you rise early enough (at 6 in the morning!), you will get fresh, hot bagels that can only be described as heavenly. As a true fan of bagels and a native of New Joisey, I know a good bagel when i have one. The only bagels worthy of competition are perhaps, bagels from H&H in the city. There is a great selection of homemade cream cheese and my favorite is the (rather simple) Veggie Cream Cheese on everything bagel. I am also a fan of their freshly-brewed hazelnut coffee, and tere is nothing like it especially on a chilly morning. Many bagel establishments in the area try fruitlessly to diversify their menus by offering way too much (with fancy names, of course), but Tenafly bagels truly specializes in bagels and they do bagels right. read more

Friendly people, great prices, quick service. This place is the best place to get your breakfast sandwich! You'll be back for more. I get a bacon, egg, tomato on garlic bagel and coffee...and get change for my $5 bill. Yummy... addendum: no more garlic bagels. Still a great nook to eat at the window, nibble and watch the world go by. read more

Only bagel show worth going to, best taste and most authentic texture. Also has by far the best chicken salad I've ever had anywhere. read more

Staff is super accommodating and friendly. Bagels are delish. Egg salad rivaled my grandma's. The better bagel joint in town for sure.

I've been getting bagels from Tfly Hot Bagels for years and years. In my opinion, they make the quintissential bagel - perfect size (be sure to ask for well-done) and texture. Their egg/taylor ham/cheese has been a staple of mine. Sadly, the quality of their fish and cream cheese has gone down over time (in my experience at least). But for bagels, this place is tops. Just ahead of Ronnie's in Hillsdale (who, by the way, makes incredible whitefish salad). read more

This is my favorite place to get breakfast bagels. They usually always have a good variety of flagels (flat bagels) here, which is nice. The service is mediocre, so don't expect friendly service. However, overall, I can't complain about how quickly they get your sandwich out to you. It's also a very small place so it's somewhere you need to go in and get out! I highly recommend getting breakfast bagels here if you're in the area. read more

I tried out Tenafly Hot Bagels today based on Yelp reviews. This is just an OK bagel. One of my favorite combinations is an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. Sure, you need many visits to brush to teeth and Listerine after, but, it's usually worth it. Lately, lots of bagel places have become really stingy with the toppings that make this an everything bagel. Well, sadly, this bagel was practically bare. At best, this thing had twenty sesame seeds, ten poppy seeds... and I think I may be too generous with those number. I've had a better everything bagel from the ShopRite in Englewood! So, I won't be going back to this bagel shop. Another thing that annoys me: they have a sign with prices on it. According to the sign, the bagel with scallion cream cheese is $2.50. They ended up charging $2.75. Even if they recently changed their prices, the shop wasn't busy- update your signage! If you really want a bagel to remember, head to BoxCar bagels at 10 River Road in Bogota... so far, the best bagel around. read more

Probably the best bagel place in town. I wish they had whole wheat everything bagels. I grew up going here periodically on weekdays and often on weekends (to purchase a dozen for the house). The weekday treat would be an occasional stop before school for an egg and cheese bags. Incredibly good. I also always loved their scallion cream cheese. Every bagel flavor is great. Perfect east coast/NY bagels here! Best hole in the wall bagel place with fresh hot bagels! read more

One of the most incredible bagels I have ever had. by far. They have a very soft and light texture to them and the bacon, egg and cheese on an everything bagel with hashbrowns was out of this world. I'm a new customer at Tenafly Hot Bagels and I know I will keep going back every morning. 100% reccomend Tenafly Hot Bagels to anybody visiting the area, or even the local crowd. read more

in town from texas and this place has the best everything bagels! i got a dozen and took them home along with a pound of scallion cream cheese. their bagel sandwiches are incredible! can't wait to come back to visit family so i can have more! very friendly service! read more

Good place . Low fat cream cheese , light tuna ,and fresh sliced nova . Bagels are normal size . Much better then toast for bagels and wraps . Bagels also taste better Imo. The prices are also very reasonable . Coffee better then toast also . So in comparison to celebrity and toast . I'd say this place is best if u want to eat bagels regularly and not gain a million pounds . read more