This place is great. I love the pizza. The subs are great but the wings are show stoppers. The empanadas are super. They serve the the best Columbian food. The people are great. So nice. Live to make you feel at home. Can't wait to go back read more

Tato's Pizzeria and Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Mauldin, South Carolina

Just terrible! We waited over an hour as they kept extending the time for delivery. They delivered plain cheese pizza when we ordered a multi topping. The Caesar salad was shredded like Cole slaw. It was all inedible. Of course when we called to complain they were closed. Don't ever order from here! read more

Unbelievable what they delivered to my hotel. Threw it away after one bite, cardboard with cheese! Have had better from Walmart frozen section! Would not recommend ever!! $49.68 terribly spent! read more

Tato's Pizzeria and Restaurant - Ice Cold Pizza from 5 miles away! - Pizza Near Me - Mauldin, South Carolina

Great pizza. Met the owner Jon and he was a wonderful person. Fantastic service from Alexa. We also had the wings which were cooked exactly as we requested. Only issue is that the restaurant ran out of ice. Maybe next time, run to a gas station and buy a few bags. We will be back soon for another pizza. read more

We used to go to Tato's when Tato owned it. We tried again last week and it was a total mistake. Service was non existent. We ordered waters and appetizers and waited 15 mins for a bottle of water to be brought to us and questioned about what apps we wanted:( we left. We will miss Tato! read more

Awesome food, Great service! The pizza, wings, and service here is fantastic. This place is always consistent every time we order here.

Tato must have sold the business: the building has been renovated and looks great but the pizza sucks. Please disregard my previous review. Portobello and spinach pizza was canned mushrooms and sparse spinach. You couldn't taste anything because of the ridiculous amount of cheese. Tatos Supreme used to be a perfect blend of fresh vegetables and some meat. Now it's a meat pizza that really sweet. Bottom line: I wasted $28. read more

See all

Great empanadas delicious Pizza was like really good cafeteria pizza though which is weird but works . read more

Get pizza!!!!! Nice customer service as well! We picked our pizza up , called it in and very fast pick up!

worst customer service the ladies in the front rude af and the food ass never recommend,

It's was cheesy, flavorful and satisfying. We tried empanadas, Columbian pizza, papas frites and tostones . All was a 10/10. Only critique is tostones could've been a bit crispier and i would personally choose the beef empanadas (it is shredded beef w potatoes) with their verde sauce. Service was genuine and fast. Ambiance is giving homey, welcoming and easy. Highly recommend bringing people to share this food made with love. read more

See all

I ordered delivery from here today. Everything came just as described. I got my order sooner than the expected time! Everything tastes really good! Will definitely order again in the future read more

My husband tried this place a couple years ago and thought the pizza was pretty good and the owner was very nice. We went as a family a few days ago and I can't get over how bad the food was. The pizza had so much cheese and canned mushrooms. Would be much better with less cheese and fresh ingredients. The chicken parmesan sub was just chicken fingers, canned sauce, and covered in so much cheese i couldn't eat it. The description on the menu did not say it was made with chicken tenders or I would've never ordered it. The food also came out at all different times. First my husbands pizza, then my sons chef salad, then my sub much later after they were both finished eating. I'm sure the Colombian dishes they prepare are much better but their Italian choices are not good. Even the employees Door dashed McDonalds while we were there. read more

We stop by here every single time going south on I-85. We usually ordered to go since we're always crunch on time. Our order always came out hot and perfect. Cashier and owner are friendly, welcoming and super helpful. They have the best empanadas. Our two little ones always finished a small cheese pizza. It's a perfect size for them to share. Bandeja paisa is not the menu but just ask them. The chicharone is so good! Highly recommended! read more

Tato's Pizzeria and Restaurant - Bandeja Paisa - Pizza Near Me - Mauldin, South Carolina

See all

The ajiaco is not ajiaco, the pizza dough is the frozen one. It really didn't meet my expectations.

Great pizza great value! Lots of cheese and toppings. Would give 5 star if they switched to fresh mushrooms Irregardless, we will be back :) read more

The pizza and empanadas were AMAZING. Service was fast and friendly and as a first time visitor would be here every day if I lived there. Don't walk, run to Tato's read more

Tato's Pizzeria and Restaurant - Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mauldin, South Carolina

Food was amazing. We tried the lava cheese, calzone, and fries. Definitely going back!!!

Husband ordered me the three cheese pizza for carry out and a chicken parm sub for himself. The three cheese pizza was supposed to have feta, mozzarella, and shredded cheese on it. Instead I got mozzarella and cheap American cheese singles. The underside of the pizza was partially raw as well. It definitely needed more time in the oven. Husband's Parmesan chicken sandwich barely contained any chicken (actually we're not even sure there was any chicken on it there was so much sauce swimming there) and his fries were soggy. Definitely very disappointed. They could've at least said we don't have all of the cheeses to make the three cheese pizza and offered a regular cheese pizza instead. read more

Tato's Pizzeria and Restaurant - Partially raw underside as well - Pizza Near Me - Mauldin, South Carolina

See all

They used my fiancées debit card to purchase services off dirty websites and also Amazon. Their food is sloppy and meat was tough. They have a fly problem as well. No one speaks or understands English. Prices were too high. read more

Early dinner at 4:30. This is going to be my new spot for a relaxed early dinner. Tato himself is the absolute best customer service you can get. The empanadas were so yummy with the classic side salsa for dip. Buffalo chicken pizza was perfect and not overpowering, I prefer no olives. Also ordered the Hispanic food that Tato recommended and that was a great item to have. You can't beat the prices and quaint little space for an early meal. read more

Tato's Pizzeria and Restaurant - Beef and chicken empanadas - Pizza Near Me - Mauldin, South Carolina

See all

We have gotten pizza to go from this store three times and I will never go back again. The pizza is pretty good but not worth it for the customer service and prices. The last two times we ordered food it appeared as if they forgot to make the food and we waited more than a half hour once there for them to make the food we were picking up. The last time I ordered a large pepperoni pizza at 6pm and it wasn't ready until 7:30pm when we were told it would be ready at 6:20, no apology and $18 for the pizza, definitely not worth it! read more

Food was original combinations, and very tasty. It's a smaller place, but enough parking. Service was kind of slow that day, but with one server on 10 tables it's understandable. read more

Great pizza! They are fast and always friendly. The outside doesn't look like much sometimes but inside is clean and perfect.

We always order extra empanadas. Absolutely worth it. They're delicious. If they still have the chili cheese fries - do yourself a favor and order them. read more

Good, not fantastic but it is good pizza. The owner seems like a great guy It is solid pizza, not gonna knock your socks off but not bad either It is worth eating but a 3 or 4 star is where it sits. I'm rounding up to 4 star because the owner seems like a really good guy. Not many specifics because there wasnt anything that really stood out as really good or bad. Just a good average pizza. read more

Food and service were very good. Definitely they have some of the best empanadas around. Give them a try.

Amazing food and service. Quaint and welcoming ambience. Colombian menu items with legit empenadas. Love it.

We went for the first time because of the good reviews, but the pizza was terrible! The waitress was very nice and the owner treated her really rude in front of us. The place smells bad. This place deserves "0" stars. We won't go back :( read more

New owners. The place has been remodeled. The food is delicious. I have had their Colombian food as well and its definitely one of the best in Greenville. read more

Awesome Pizza! Ordered the HOUSE pizza and a large pepperoni. On Wednesday the pizzas are 30% off!! Pizzas are brick oven and very fresh if you are use to chain pizzas you can immediately taste the difference. The lemon pepper wings that I ordered were cooked perfectly for me. The owner offered to give me a tour of the kitchen yet due to time restraints I politely declined. He offered their frequent purchasing card and knew that this was my first visit. Outside their are two picnic style table for outdoor seating. It's a mom and pop bare bones establishment that offered good food. I ordered to go but the pizza has a wow factor that can't be ignored. Will definitely return for a future visit. read more

Good food and service they have a good Colombian food and also pizzas are so yummy . read more

See all

The pizza is way too cheesy and undercooked. Wouldn't get the pizza again. The ingredients also didn't seem very fresh

Very cute and friendly local place with international flavor and flair. We had a meat lovers pizza, the special super big pizza with lots of meats and veggies, a special version of Colombian lemonade, and a Greek salad. Thoroughly enjoyed watching the gentleman hand toss the pizza-- cooked in the wood fire oven. This is not junk! This is fresh, homemade deliciousness. Don't forget to try their cinnamon bites at the end. Their secret recipe dough is fried and topped with lots of cinnamon and sugar. Perfect end to a great meal. Lots of good service, too. Step out of the box and try something different! Their menu selection is impressive. read more

In my opinion, best pizza in or around Greenville, SC. Customer service is top notch!

Horrible Experience. They use Slice for delivery. As my order was being delivered I got a text telling me that the driver had the wrong order and I should turn him back with the order. I thought that perhaps within about 20 minutes the driver would have returned and picked up my order. I was wrong. Apparently, he never returned. Slice texted me that they'd send me an email within 12-24 hours with a resolution. WTF? 12-24 hours? How about right now? So, I drove to the restaurant and on my way called the restaurant...the person on the other end was explaining to me what happened...like I didn't know. I informed her that I was coming to get my food right then...expecting that my order was still at the restaurant. When I got there...it wasn't ready. The manager was a bit huffy with me as I was mad and letting him know how mad I was. So...I sat at the table and waited while they prepared my food. And posted on social media. The food was ready and the manager stayed on the phone talking about my situation. Finally, he gave me my food and wanted to have a conversation with me. What happened to customer service? I was out my food...and my money...and both the delivery and service and the restaurant was less than stellar in their dealings with me. The restaurant kept telling me that it wasn't there fault...as if it was somehow my fault. I do not recommend Slice as a service and Tato's pizza because of the management. The food was mediocre at best. Pizza was bland in flavor and not crispy at all. The jalapenos were run of the mill - they were probably frozen and reheated. Not good. I do not recommend this place at all. read more

Saw a lot of good reviews and decided to try it. The pricing was decent so I was excited. But there really wasn't anything good from what I'd ordered. The pizza was bland. The Caesar salad was SOAKED with dressing. The chicken tenders for my kids were disgusting.. overall kind of disappointing. Might try them again.. get some different stuff. But as of right now, I can't say I'm a fan. read more

First time eating this pizza. We ordered it as a pick up. The wings were freaking awesome! So good and hot I couldn't stop eating them. I wish there would have been more in the order. I will for sure be back for these. The pizza was good, but it was dry. There wasn't a lot of sauce on it which was disappointing. If it would have had more sauce on it then I probably would rate this 5 stars. And the staff were super friendly during pick up. read more

I gave this small restaurant 5 stars because my family & I felt right at home. The pizzas are handmade & delicious. We got a pepperoni & a Hawaiian pizza. Both were delicious. My son ordered the beef & pepperoni calzone. He really exceeded our expectations! If you want some incredibly delicious pizza I would definitely check this place out! You will not be disappointed. Also the restaurant was very clean & so were the restrooms. read more

This place has great customer service. I walked in at 7:40 and even though they were closing at 8:00 the owner said he'd make me a pizza!! The pizza was as great as the service!!! Can't wait to go back and try other items off of their menu. read more