Had a least 3 taxi drivers and several locals recommend this place. Couldn't not go and so glad we…read moredid! We were warned don't get talked into another place by competitors. The restaurant was clean, service friendly and inviting, food was delicious. From the ribs, conch, fish/chips and burger. There was 6 of us and everyone was delighted with their selection.

This is the Nassau location, where all the locals go. Loud and fun we got there right before the…read morecrowds. We ordered a lot of different items. The fried crunch was an a light pattern. Very tasty, the lobster sandwich was huge and delicious, the fish and chips was amazing with the batter and a fresh fish, my wife and I each had lobster. All dishes come with two sides we all got plantain some of us cut rice and peas, another got macaroni.. service is friendly but when it gets busy, just be patient and wait

Conch fritters weren't hot and fresh. The conch salad and Haitian Griot were fresh and delicious…read more The service was spectacular.

If I could leave zero stars I would. This was by far one my most disappointing experiences at a…read morerestaurant. My first time visiting the Bahamas and this place came highly recommended by a few locals. This place needs a major overhaul and upgrade. The most pleasant thing here was the server's attitude. Although he had a good attitude, the service itself needs improvement. We waited too long for drinks and food, we even ordered extra shots and soft drink that never arrived, we ended up canceling that order due to how long we waited. Let me not get started one the food! The kitchen messed up the food order, switching the sides, giving me my husband's sides and him mine, and they missed the mark in taste and flavor! Grilled grouper came out with pieces of spicy salmon. Did they run out of grouper and sub with salmon? No one knows. Ordered coconut rice, got peas and rice instead, and the rice was hard. Could not eat this. Fried plantains were overly ripe and under fried. Garlic mashed potatoes, missing the garlic and tasted like day old potatoes. Could not eat this. Vegetables, probably was the only thing cooked properly. Conch fritters, mostly batter and no conch. Unbelievable when the island is known for conch. After one bite, we could not eat this. Grilled snapper, barely any flavor, with a few bites tasting rank. After a few bites, I felt nauseous and could not finish the meal. After leaving, I spent the rest of the night vomiting due to stomach upset from this place. Bahama mama and bahama papa, tasted like sweet juice, not enjoyable. We left most of the meal and drinks on the table due to lack of flavor and service. Went to the manager to give our feedback and he did not seem surprised of what we said. He did remove the conch fritters from the bill as an apology. To the owners of this establishment, you need to do a better job! Spend some time to upgrade your ambiance, train your staff (I saw the buss boy drop spoons and forks on the little grass carpet, picked them up, instead of taking them to the kitchen to wash, he used a damp cloth to wipe them and wrap them back in tissue). Hire new chefs or train the chefs you have.

This review is of Cafe Matisse located in Nassau, The Bahamas…read more For some reason, it's not listed on Yelp, but it definitely should be! Cafe Matisse is located on Bank Lane. It's an upscale and glamorous restaurant with garden seating as well as indoors on the main floor or upstairs. It's eloquently decorated and posh. The service and food is top shelf. Pricey, but you definitely get what you pay for. If there's one special restaurant on your to-do list, Cafe Matisse is it.

Upon entering you're greeted by an enormous antique elevator no doubt shipped over from France but…read moreit's just for looks I think. Up the stairs and you enter the most charming bar and lounge area that also has an open air patio overlooking the walk below. The dining room is bright, elegant and Colonial. What we had: French onion soup was amazing, just like in France and it was hot not lukewarm like other reviews suggest. Lots of cheese and I could share with my hubby or eat alone as a meal! The Nicooise salad was also very good, and just the right size for a starter. Lots of fresh ingredients and generous amounts of fresh tuna. Delish! Main course: Branzino was amazing! Simple yet tasty grilled to perfection, crispy skin and topped with olives, red onions and tomatoes over a bed of pea purée. Herb crusted snapper also very good, large portion very fresh. Served overtop tomato purée. We also ordered a side of broccolini which was good but some of the larger pieces were a little tough. No space for dessert! Next time! Servers are all very nice and very fast! I think a little longer break in between our appies and main would have been better and we would have had room for dessert. I highly recommend coming here when visiting Atlantis, the food if fabulous, you get what you pay for and much better than some of the other restaurants here. I didn't mind paying for this meal it was on point.

I emailed them months beforehand and they had me fill out a form with food preferences and…read morerestrictions. We ate here twice. Both times, the chef came out and spoke with us. The bread was vegan. The chef also made an appetizer of heirloom tomato "salad" with vinegarette cucumber&olives, as well as brussel spouts. On the menu, the brussel sprouts had honey and cheese. The ones we received were sweet, but it seemed to be a slightly watery brown sugar mix vs agave vs maple syrup. I didn't think it tasted like honey but I haven't had honey for 10y. ‍ Also the waiter assured us it was not honey. However, we ordered this again the 2nd time and in conversation with the chef, I found out he was not aware honey is not vegan. I kindly educated him and recommended he assume vegans don't eat honey unless they state they do. He made our brussel sprouts the 2nd time with salt/pepper. We again ordered the tomato salad. Both times, the main was a special Beyond meat meal with baked potato and broccoli. The first one was more steak-like, the 2nd was more like a skillfully cooked Beyond burger patty. I never liked red meat and haven't had it since 2008, but both meals were still pretty good. Also had some bites of veganized steak frites (has gluten), but they were a littl dry. For dessert, we had sorbet both times. Overall, the chef was Michael and was EXTREMELY kind and caring. He did not get defensive about the honey issue and truly wanted to learn/improve. He made sure we were happy both times and even said goodbye after our meal.

The only reason I will give 2 stars instead of 1 is because of the service. Our waiter was…read morewonderful and it's not his fault the food is bad and the atmosphere is extremely noisy, like a cafeteria. The ambience: 0/10 due to it being extremely loud and not peaceful at all. It sounds like a noisy high school cafeteria. The food: 0/10 due to the taste being bad AND the price extremely high for what you get. We paid $80 for 1 filet mignon. Definitely not worth it. The baked potato was so overcooked. I feel like it had been cooking for days. It was dark and mushy inside. The Caesar salad was flavorless. The lettuce was wet and the dressing not tasty at all. There were 3 of us and our bill was over $500 for a noisy dinner with bad food. Take a pass on this steakhouse. You will regret going here.

Food was great. We shared conk fritters across the family. Cary and I had their seafood tacos…read more Both were great. The atmosphere was super on their open air seating area. Nice place. Sorta basic white that you see around the island. It's on the beach so it's both special and expensive. But it's the Bahamas and almost everything is expensive. Service was S L O W... very much so... we waited a long time for our drinks, so long that we were checking at the bar to see if someone forgot them. That may have happened. Food was equally slow. Not just Caribbean slow maybe twice as slow. And the place was not crowded at all.

This is a beautiful restaurant. The decor is all white and blue- it reminded me of Greece…read more The view is amazing! This is why you come here. Service was friendly and leisurely so don't come if you're in a rush. Island time! I had sushi which was tasty and presented nicely. I had a great Blue Sail cocktail as well. This was perfect for a nice lunch in the Bahamas!

Walked up to Katsu-Ya last minute and were discouraged by the crowd, but we were seated within 15…read moreminutes. We were taken to a back outdoor room and didn't realize how huge the place is. We were worried we'd be forgotten, but the service was impeccable. Our waiter Kamal was amazing; attentive, fast, and exactly what we needed since we were starving. The food was excellent: miso cod, spicy tuna on rice, egg fried rice, yellowtail jalapeño sashimi, chicken gyoza, chicken teriyaki with fried rice, and cake.

We had a great experience at Katsuya, the food and overall atmosphere were excellent, and we really…read moreenjoyed our meal. Everything we ordered was delicious and beautifully presented. The vibes were great and so was the service. Always so packed and hard to get into. The only downside was dessert. We tried the chocolate ball, and it had an alcohol flavor that we didn't expect, it honestly wasn't enjoyable. Since we were dining with kids, it would have been helpful if our server had mentioned that or recommended a more kid friendly option. Aside from that, everything else was fantastic, and we'd definitely come back--just skipping that dessert next time.

We had a lovely meal of grouper on the beach with a very quick and friendly waitress. However, we…read morewitnessed a incredibly rude old tourist speak to the waitress like an arrogant lord in front of our table. The people on Eluethra are nothing but kind...there's no need to be the ugly, disrespectful tourist.

Good location for watching the sunset and typical Bahamian seafood shack. The food was good and is…read morethe usual Island fare. We tried the lobster seafood platter for two. The cracked conch was good and although they usually only serve it for lunch, they accommodated us for dinner which we appreciated. The rice and peas was not so good and dried out a little - probably left over from the lunch service I guess. Drinks were good, especially the Pineapple Express cocktail. The wings were good and spicy. Unfortunately like most outdoor places on Eleuthera, the "no-see-ums" were out in force and repellent is required, they keep a large bottle available for guests. Service was good and attentive and accommodating. The prices are high as is most places on the island which I realize most things are imported etc., but I never really understood the prices of the fish being so high when it's local, but worth a visit. The irony is that the prices are not that much different (lower), to the fine dining restaurants around the island.

Not a good representation of Jimmy's legacy. Went here for lunch, it was not busy at all. Had the…read moreMahi sandwich. Took forever for the food to come out and the sandwich would've been good, but the bun was stale and the fries had been sitting out a while as they were less than warm. Service was not very attentive or pleasant. Sodas are $4.50 and refills are $1.50. Total for the meal, all in, was $44. Restaurant was a bit grungy. Bathrooms are located through the gift shop and are poorly maintained.

Topic: Jimmy Buffett's Margaritaville Bahamas Date: 5/14/25…read more Quality: 6/10 Value: 5/10 Service: 2/10 Timeliness: 6/10 Atmosphere: 3/10 Total: 22/50 Note: This is a longer review as there were a few issues we experienced with this location. As a major point within our meal - a guy with a broom and dustpan smashed and killed a giant centipede by the entrance while we were eating, not exactly appetizing. This took him over a full minute of hitting it on the ground while the entire restaurant was watching him do so. He actually broke the dustpan, he was hitting for so long. One of the most absurd restaurant experiences of our life. Watermelon Margarita 5/5 (Great drink) Piña Coloda 4/5 (Needs more pineapple) Chocolate Banana Colada 4.5/5 (Came back for this one) Steak Sandwich 4/5 Fresh Fish Tacos 4.25/5 Side Caesar Salad 0/5 (The salad smelled and tasted like feet, salad came warm, couldn't keep eating) We told the server about the Caesar salad who recommended we order it next time with cheese on the side. I NEVER send food back. In my entire life, maybe 2 or 3 times. For transparency, Caesar salads are my favorite type of salad and I've eaten no less than 100 of them in my life, many from different establishments. This was the first one I've experienced like this. We were still charged for the side salads that we hardly could touch. This was not a very pleasant experience service-wise, the drinks were good however. If you order the drinks as to-go you get more in them, just a little tip.

The Fry Fish area!! Oh Andros stood out too me because it…read morewas the only restaurant that had a good crowd of people dinning in on a rainy day. The portion of the food was a very generous amount. Our hosts/waiter Big Mama was very knowledgeable on the food menu and the drinks. All our food was freshly made and took little over 20 minutes to be made. I order the seafood pasta and from the heat and the quality of the pasta I know it was freshly made me for. My husband and sister both order the same plates and the amount of food they received on their plate was generous. Big mama made us try their signature bahiama drinks and they where delicious. I order the fruit punch for my daughter and she loved it. Overall you can't visit Bahamas and not visit Oh Andros. This is part of Bahamas and a major/important stop if you enjoy feeding your stomach well.

Had a nice lunch here today. We ordered:…read more Conch fritters Tropical conch salad - huge & delicious!! So good!! Fried snapper dinner - comes with 2 fried snappers & 3 sides (had rice, macaroni & cheese, and potato salad) Cracked lobster & conch combo dinner, which also came with 3 sides (had rice, coleslaw and plantains) I don't normally like conch fritters because they are usually mostly batter. These were really good! They were a cross between Jamaican fried dumpling and festival with a few chunks of conch. 4 of us shared everything and we had a lot of rice, some of the lobster and the plantains leftover. Service is slow so make sure you're not in a hurry to get back to the cruise ship or anywhere else.

This is an affordable place here at the Atlantis property. Ordering a slice is really like two…read moreslices for $7 but after the tax & gratuity it comes out to $8.75. The pizza was pretty good! Eating area is only outdoors which is great. We tried the Greek, Meat Lovers & Cheese pizza & all were good. The crust was yummy. Definitely a great place to save some money while you're here at Atlantis especially if you have kids.

Nothing special…read more Stopped in on the day we checked in and on another day for a slice in between events scheduled close together. The pizza was mid-tier pizza and the wings were about the same, but it worked for when we needed something quick to curb the hunger. Can't say I'd necessarily recommend as it was just so-so, but it beat eating at the chain restaurants that I could just as easily find off resort.