Solid spot, flavorful and fresh food. Love that they use B&E chicken! Will def go back, if you go on a weekend for dinner be sure to make a reservation as they are always packed. read more

Had lunch here for the first time today with friends. Food and service were excellent. Great ambience and all of the staff were accommodating and friendly. Kudos to our waiter, Mauro, who was awesome. Ask for him the next time you're there!! Highly recommended! read more

This spot is so cute! First time here and I ordered the Milano it was amazing. Everything looked so good next time I'll try the ravioli. The staff were friendly and helpful if you want a well made lunch this is a good spot I will definitely be back with some friends read more

Suprema - Italian Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Casual BYOB with the most delicious food & friendly staff. I love the decor with exposed brick, high rustic ceilings and string lights. It is a warm and frIendly space. We had a party of 4 & had Fried Calamari/ Shrimp, Baked Clams & grilled Octopus for appetizers. Daily fresh specials all looked great! We had Rib Eye Steak with cutest pear shaped potato croquette, Pasta, , Chicken Parm., Veal Chop Milanese & Eggplant. They were ALL amazing. Anthony makes the best Red sauce around!! Can" t wait to go back to try the pasta with fresh spicy crab! Dine in or take our for lunch & dinner. Must try ! read more

Great spot for lunch! Everything I've had from here has been spot on. Fresh quality ingredients, good service, and delicious espressos. Rice balls are excellent, Sandwich specials are really good and salads have a lot of flavor. Only negative would be the portion sizes are not huge but satisfying enough for lunch. One of my favorites in Rutherford. read more

Came here for lunch the other day and was really impressed to find such a delicious hip spot in NJ ! I spend most of my days in NYC so finding a good quality food spot is more of a challenge in NJ than NYC. I loved the food - had the artichoke salad with grilled chicken. The service, however, was subpar. Our waitress was inattentive and we had to ask for utensils, napkins , etc... definitely not the service we expected from a new upcoming spot. read more

This place is new to Rutherford and boy does it fit in perfect! The service is always great, the food is absolutely delish. Everything from the sandwiches to the deli selections. And such a cute little spot for lunch...haven't done dinner yet but I'll be back for sure!! P.S. Add Chicken Parm to your menu!!! read more

Suprema is a very cute cafe with good food and excellent service. The environment is super clean and relaxing. Staff are friendly. I had a latte and sandwich, both were very good. I really liked the sandwich. I got the Milano sandwich, and it's definitely one of the best chicken sandwiches I've had. The ingredients were all very fresh. The chicken was well cooked, juicy and tender. There were no excessive dressings and I was able to taste the flavors of each ingredient on an oven toasted bread. I'd definitely recommend checking this place out. read more

See all

My wife and I have been enjoying the sandwiches here for a year and finally stopped in for dinner last week and this our new favorite restaurant in town. We ordered: - RIce Balls - these are a must, best I've had - Burrata Salad - Always a classic, served with seasonal Heirloom Tomatos - Caesar Salad - Really great - Chicken Francaise - Excellent The portions were very generous and we had more than enough food for the two of us. Having been to every restaurant in town I feel confident saying this is the best dinner we have had. We will definitely be back to try everything else on the menu. read more

I work close by and I come here pretty much anytime I don't have the chance to go home for lunch. The food is always made extremely fast which is surprising because they're always busy. Every sandwich I've had is wonderful! I think their eggplant sandwich might be my favorite, always really crispy and the right amount of everything. If you don't like sandwiches their salads are also delicious. I love that they also have a showcase with food you can just throw in a container and eat back at the office (meatballs, grilled veggies, pasta salads) I had dinner here once and got their spaghetti carbonara. Super tasty! And don't leave without trying their rice balls!!! You will not be disappointed! read more

Suprema has been recommended by numerous friends. I was not disappointed. The appetizers were fresh and delicious especially the rice balls. The dinners were all fresh and hot. We were a table of 14 so we shared. The pasta was sooo good. The veal was delicious. The short ribs were to die for. The desserts were out of this world. Mauro and his crew made us feel at home. They were attentive and courteous. I would highly recommend Suprema. I can't wait for my next visit Patty P read more

Found this spot while researching lunch spots in Rutherford and I have to say the decor, ambience, food, and service was spectacular. It looked even better in person compared to great ig pics and the sandwiches were neat and tasty. Would definitely recommend for a great lunchtime spot read more

$15 for a sandwich... the prices have been increased to ridiculous numbers. The size of the sandwiches are small.

Wow, What a great lunch place! Started out with the rice balls which were amazing. The marinara sauce it came in was just incredible. Next, I had the pasta carbonara which was super fresh and delicious. The place was decorated nicely and was very clean. You could just tell the owners take pride in their business. Overall, I would highly recommend this place and I can't wait to go back for dinner! read more

So I got lunch to go here the other day and completely fell in love with this place. I got two Milanese sandwiches and they were amazing. The chicken cutlet was thin, crispy and warm! The fresh mozzarella was creamy and so flavorful. And the bread was AMAZING. So soft and baked to perfection. This is my new lunch spot for delicious, fresh sandwiches. Seriously it was hands down the best chicken cutlet & mozzarella sandwich I've ever had. Very impressed. read more

Omg The food is deeeelicious great service must try the rice balls. Sandwiches hearty..bread is great..andrew is so courteous helpful professional friendly grrreat place 4 lunch clean..must try place if not over & over just awesome read more

What a great place!!! The food is so fresh and flavorful. Me and my husband came here before going to a concert and so happy we did! The atmosphere is cozy and we were immediately seated even though they were closing in 30 minutes. Great food, staff, and atmosphere! read more

One of our favorite local spots. BYO as is the case with most Rutherford restaurants. Generous servings, always made fresh, friendly staff, nice space & ambience. Never been disappointed. Recommended. read more

Stopped here on a whim with a co-worker to grab lunch and we were planning on staying in and eating but needed to get back to the office so we grabbed our food to go. My co-worker got a Caesar salad with chicken and the rice balls and I got the penne with vodka sauce - it was AMAZING. I have eaten a lot of penne vodka in my life but that was by far my favorite. The entire staff was also very sweet and the food came out quickly. They also cater which is something my office will definitely be looking into. Can't wait to go back and try more food! read more

Absolutely the best Italian spot!!! Definitely a must-go. Everything is fresh, flavorful, authentic, and delicious. Been coming here for take out during the pandemic and we absolutely love it. Highly recommend! read more

Fabulous dinner we had last night for my son's birthday. We had a party of 15 and everything was absolutely delicious - from the rice balls and calamari/shrimp to all the entree orders to the best cake ever! The service was wonderful and pleasant. Highly recommend! Our new favorite place! read more

The veggie platter and and appetizer with mozzarella and tomato sauce were very delicious. Of our group we had penne with shrimp, salad with breaded chicken, and a variety of the sandwiches, which were huge with half that filled each person to be able to take home the other half. read more

Suprema - Italian Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Nice ecclectic vibe that have going here. The tables were made of restored antique wood doors. Got a chicken sandwich, it was small, but flavorful. read more

We had the beet salad, and Halibut and salmon and it was great! The fish was cooked perfectly. The wait staff was very attentive and friendly! Really like this place and have had many good meals here. read more

I can't wait to go back to Suprema. Everything I've tried so far on three occasions has been amazing. The rice balls are sensational!!! One look at their IG page is all you need ... highly recommend. Manga!!!!! read more

I'm a big fan of the food here, I only wish they sold more Italian products! Love the arancinis here- absolutely delicious. Their tomato sauce here is simple, but has a robust flavor. Have had a couple of sandwiches here (all delicious) and the chicken milanese salad (warm breaded chicken on a salad - yes please!). While I was skeptical about having another Italian place in town, this is by far my favorite. I don't think they have it on the menu, but you can buy their cured meats deli style here! Prosciutto is tasty! read more

The food is fresh and of excellent quality but very expensive. My take is If you are going to spend this kind of money, why not go to a nice restaurant for lunch? read more

Nothing but great things to say about Suprema. Highly recommend coming here for lunch or dinner and even recommend hosting a private event here. I've had lunch and dinner here on several occasions and the ingredients and quality of the food they prepare is top notch! Everything tastes so fresh and is made to order. The staff is friendly and the ambience is perfect. It has that clean, rustic feel. An event I had was hosted here on a Sunday afternoon, and we were blown away with the quality of service and food. My guests were so impressed and couldn't wait to return for lunch and dinner! The restaurant allows you to setup the restaurant as you wish and we created a long farmhouse table and beautiful table scape with flowers. The place really can transform to whatever theme and design you have in mind. By the way, the rice balls are a MUST have! 5 stars for Suprema and their staff! Go give this place a try!! read more

Delicious Italian-American food in a refined yet unpretentious BYOB setting. The relaxed vibe might come from the deli counter (haven't tried lunch sandwiches yet), bright and open floor plan, or friendly and welcoming staff--but make no doubt, there is clearly meticulous care going into their dishes. Whether it's a comfort food staple like a chicken parm or a more complex seafood risotto using seasonal produce, the quality of ingredients and preparation is second to none at the same price point in the area. Things like a side dish of spaghetti, that would be a quick boxed afterthought at a higher volume establishment, here elevates your main course. Highly recommend! read more

I got the same impression of the staff as U K, only I saw it differently, not stand offish but shy. It took time for them to loosen up, but they performed well. The service was polite and efficient. No reason to complain. The food was excellent. The evening menu is limited, but that helps to increase the quality. We will certainly return eager to try their sandwiches and the Rice Balls. My Lasagna was reminiscent of Park & Orchards as good if not better. read more

How lucky am I to live 5 minutes away from this delight? If you have the chance to dine here please don't miss the opportunity. read more

Everything is always fresh. The Parma Sandwich (prosciutto de Parma, fresh Mutz, and I get roasted peppers instead of sun-dried tomatoes, with balsamic vinegar) is my go to. read more

I've eaten here at least 7-8 times and while the earlier experiences were positive, they progressively declined. I suspect they are now so confident in their reputation they're less concerned with customer experience. I find it off putting they don't disclose on their menu or over the phone that they add a 3% surcharge to Credit card payments. When we ordered dinner for 8 someone made the mistake of paying with a credit card and no one thought to mention that extra fee to her. But the worst (and final) experience was over the summer. We were one of just three tables, and after placing our order we sat there for a half hour waiting for our dinner. They eventually came to explain there was a mixup in the kitchen and the food would be out shortly. 15 minutes later, somebody else said the exact same thing. It took almost an hour to be served pasta. In the time we were sitting there we watched another table be seated, give their order, eat and request their check. They apologized for the delay and told us they were going to take care of it on our check. I assumed that meant they were going to comp one of the dishes, but when the check came out they applied a 25% discount. That's when I decided I was over Suprema. I felt terrible for convincing my dad to eat there when he really wanted to go elsewhere, and on top of the service he didn't even enjoy his meal. The sauce was too sweet. Maybe it's our fault for politely tolerating the situation instead of telling them how we really felt. read more

Place very good! We had a little mis hap and they took care of it right away! So professional! Food delish!

Outstanding food, the Eggplant sandwich is delicious. I think the fried the egg plant which made it taste exceptionally well. Only thing is that it is a little expensive. read more

This place is so good! The chicken parm entree is huge and excellent, their parm sandwich is good too. The Milano sandwich is very fresh !! The restaurant is cute and cozy read more

Is SUPREME! My god I can't stop thinking about dinner here. Amazing quality ingredients, perfectly seasoned and impeccably prepared dishes. I tried a bit from everyone's plate and EVERYTHING blew me away. I'll gladly be returning (and driving over 40 mins to dine here again). read more

Great food, friendly staff, and cool atmosphere. Do it.

An amazing new addition to Park Ave. I had a delicious Roast Beef sandwich (Wednesday Special) which was fab! My friend enjoyed the Milano - the chicken was so succulent and tasty. We happily filled our bellies to max. Go now and enjoy. read more

Suprema - The decor is modern rustic! - Italian Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Great time for dinner with our group of 10. We ordered appetizers to share: Clams oreganata (excellent), antipasto tray with prosciutto, parmigiano, sausage, and burrata (prefect), rice balls (very good) and fried calamari (crisp and tender). Salad with baby greens and balsamic dressing for table was also a hit (also have had great salads for lunch!). I had the veal chop which was perfectly cooked, a few had the chicken parm and eggplant parm which are regular dishes here and at Michael's and can't be beat. Fettuccini Alfredo was rich and creamy, linguini in clam sauce with fresh clams also very good. Probably our least favorite was the sausage and broccoli rabe which was good but nothing special compared to the rest of the meals (I tasted them all, of course). Espresso and cheese cake for dessert and we were off. All in all a great meal and a fun evening. read more