So I did go back, walked in, walked out. Business owner didn't just "mess up"...this is his policy, to not have bathrooms available for customers, and being rude about it. Avoid. read more

Superior Chocolates - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Amazing Chocolates Great selection Very friendly Awesome layout So beautiful to visit during the holidays read more

See all

Their Chocolate covered caramels are outstanding!!! I would definitely recommend. Good variety.

So many wonderful chocolate creations to choose from! Jackie answered all my questions!

I went in to get a gift for someone but I'm not much of a chocolate lover myself (translate that how you wish lol). The shop though a little festive with a few flags isn't what I expected. See, I confused chocolate with candy = children. I almost expected a fun-park atmosphere. Lol. Being there reminded me of being in a library sort of. It was very quiet and mausoleum like before the sales attendant approached me. The store is huge.The shelves are neatly and expertly stacked and I was a bit afraid of touching the products. Here and there I noticed plaques with some history of the store/brand and chocolate. The two saleswomen were pleasantly chatty with me as I their only customer perused the aisles. I saw a wide assortment but like I said I'm not a chocolate connoisseur so I didn't know what the hell I was looking for except that chocolate is supposed to be a sexy gift for someone who likes it. As expected, it's a bit pricey so my tip is if you have cadbury/lindt pockets please come prepared to browse and smile. I did The End. read more

See all

Embed review Write an update Edit review 4/11/2020 My family has relied on Superior chocolates from the time when they had a small store in Richmondtown, through their much larger warehouse and now to their final destination. My most recent order was placed remotely alas, but included in the box, was that free chocolate bunny! Thank you Supreme Chocolatier, May you long continue to delight Staten Islanders. A long time fan. read more

This was so impressive! The amount of chocolates they had just made you want more. The customer service was excellent selection was even better. What we bought was fresh and delicious!! I would love to go back to watch them actually make the chocolate for you had that ability to watch it for dissipate. This was definitely worth the drive read more

If you are looking for fresh homemade chocolate this is the place to go it is a hidden gem on Staten Island that most residents are not aware of. read more

Best place for chocolate in Staten Island. Nice asorotment to. If you any were near it I would recommend it. They treat and no matter what the are never snappy. Atmosphere is nice. read more

Great chocolate and an old Staten Island business! I expecially love all of the foil wrapped chocolates!!

You can't buy Bavarian Mints anywhere else in the world. For that reason alone, this company is a treasure. Machinery problems caused some disruption in supply and web-page responsiveness late last year; but, all is back to normal--thank Heaven! read more

I give them a 0...there website for online ordering has been down for weeks and no one answers the emails that i have sent....

A quaint little place. They have a great selection and it's nice to be able to peek into the back to see the factory part of the establishment. read more

See all

Perfect to buy some hostess gifts for the holidays (chocolates shaped like menorahs). I can see that if you're planning a wedding or a bridal shower or similar, this place has customized chocolates for every guest. We stumbled upon this because it was down the block from the hotel where we were staying on Staten Island. As we drove toward the hotel, we saw a billboard "Chocolate Outlet" so walked over there immediately after checking in! We had the pleasure of meeting the owner. He kindly gave us an excellent recommendation for an authentic Italian meal that evening on Staten Island. If my son in NY ever gets married, I know exactly where to go for the rehearsal dinner goodie bag items. read more

This is hands down the number one location to pick up anything for your chocolate related needs. From seasonal items to an organic selection, Supreme has everything you could possibly desire. I go there with my family every holiday to pick up their holiday items. Everyone always looks forward to visiting because of the immersive factory experience you can see behind the glass. The staff is super friendly and the store is beautifully decorated! read more

I've not visited the store but my mother in law got me and my wife a big selection of chocolates from this place for easter. I grew up in Western Europe, on Dutch, German, Swiss and French chocolate. REAL chocolate. Most "chocolate" in the US is not actual chocolate. The fine print on the packaging will actually say "chocolate flavored candy". Hersey's is mostly filler and chemicals. It's a travesty that that became a standard here. The only chocolate I buy in the US that is true chocolate and affordable is the bright pink Swiss Chocolate bars from Trader Joes (which is imported from Switzerland). However, the chocolate from Supreme Chocolatier blew my mind at the first bite. Real deal chocolate! No mystery ingredients. Tastes the way chocolate should taste, and the way chocolate tastes in Europe. I'm going to have to go visit the store and stock up soon. read more

The place looks big and sterile. But I was convinced by my friend who was with me during my visit there that their prices are reasonable (he knows for sure as he bakes cakes & uses chocolates & similar materials in his business). The old lady was friendly but not the other one who completely ignored us (hence I wasn't excited to buy more stuff other than a plastic full of square dark chocolates-----they tasted good!). read more

I shop online and am impressed with their service and selection. They are the only place to get Bauer Bavarian Mints, my mother's childhood favorite. They have a large selection of different holiday treats (Easter, Valentine's, Christmas, etc). Their prices are much better than most candy companies. The last order I received had a thank you gift enclosed - a chocolate rose and a bag of candy. The raspberry filled chocolates were awesome. read more

The chocolate tastes great. It is wrapped in imaginative foil paper, and I come back every Easter to load up on chocolate Ladybugs, Kittens, Parrots, Eggs, Bunnies, Cats, and lots of other cute things. It's so much better than the usual crappy Duane Reade stuff. It reminds me more of the German Easter chocolates of my childhood. The store is huge, so it's never too crowded, an, as I mentioned, it's quality chocolate! read more

I have not visited Supreme Chocolatier but I have had an experience ordering from them through their website. I am planning an 85th birthday party with a theme. One of the major points of this party was a specific candy that is hard to find. As luck would have it Supreme Chocolatier had the exact brand of candy that we needed. I ordered candy at the end of July and thought I would have plenty of time to receive it (three weeks). After 2 weeks I sent them a message asking about my order as I hadn't received it. The reply I got back was terse and telling me that they had emailed me regarding the order telling me that the company that makes the chocolates would not begin production again until September. I never received that email. I think it's possible that it ended up in my spam folder. Why am I writing a negative review? Well, I would have expected a phone call follow up when they didn't get a reply from me after two weeks. Now, I am throwing a party and I don't even have one of the key items for it. I am so disappointed in Supreme Chocolatiers, their terse customer service, their lack of follow up and their lack of care. I won't be buying from them again even of they have the candy I need. Two starts because they do have a great selection, if you're even able to get what you order read more