I recently visited Sundae Afternoon after seeing Instagram content. The shop is cute. They use ice cream made by Ice Cream Club, which is based in Florida. I sampled one flavor that I thought was decent, but I decided to order the Red Velvet Cake flavor which looked good and tasty. I liked the Red Velvet Cake flavor. It was a bit of a cheat code in the best possible way. I mean -- combine ice cream and one of the best cakes, and you're ahead of the game. The waffle cone was good too, but it had a big hole in the bottom. Luckily, I noticed Dixie cups on the counter. So I just placed the cup under the cone. Service was pleasant and efficient. Sundae Afternoon was a good ice cream shop and is worth visiting. I wouldn't say it's with the top tier CT places though. Four Stars read more

See all

There is another ice cream shop in town offering up premium ice cream, frozen treats, milkshakes and cold brew. Make your afternoon, a Sundae Afternoon. Upon arriving, the ladies serving you were the sweetest. Offering us a taste of the ice creams, announcing their specials and pointing out pre-made frozen treats in a separate freezer across from the main counter. The main counter has all the hard ice creams on display. They have hard ice creams from The Ice Cream Club, a company from Florida. This is my first time trying this ice cream and different the other ice cream shops in the area who serve Giffords Ice Cream, Praline's Ice Cream, etc. They have a few dairy-free options too. I got two scoops of the Stellar Coffee flavor. The ice cream was light, rich coffee flavor with a thick fudge swirl and a generous amount of mini dark chocolate coffee cups. My husband tried the Strawberry Shortcake Bomb, their take of the Good Humor bar. There was strawberry ice cream in the center, wrapped in vanilla, and rolled in the strawberry shortcakes pieces. They had other fun flavors and treats like a Neil's Donut Ice Cream Sandwich (would love to try this next). Sundae Afternoon is in a great area that we pass by often. It's next to a Subway and across the street from the Yalesville Veterinary Hospital. They have dog friendly ice cream treats too. For a small shop, it's very open. The dining area is spacious, walls painted in a fun, bright orange color. Can't wait to see more of Sundae Afternoon and what they have in store when the weather heats up! read more

See all

Wonderful homemade ice cream with many interesting flavors! Cheerful space and great service!

I had stopped by here on the first hottest day after sitting on the highway for hours..Kids outside playing enjoying their treats and inside was cozy and welcoming And was surprised by their Pistachio Almond CREAMY confection it was...YUMMY. Was welcomed again yesterday, post surgery needed help and the Lady in charge came to my rescue, on a cool down evening she passed me a delicious double scoop of Strawberry cheesecake and OMG.. The service couldn't be better, the welcoming smile couldn't be sweeter and the product..well..that goes without saying DELISH. COME BY ITS FAMILY-FRIENDLY read more

This is a terrific little ice cream shop. Wide variety of inventive flavors. Very friendly staff. A clean, large and welcoming space to sit and enjoy dessert. Ample parking. Very kid friendly. My first impression was that it was kind of expensive, but everyone I was with told me I was being a boomer and that ice cream is just expensive now! I tried there graham cracker flavor, which was very good! I will definitely be back to try other flavors. read more

I would give 3.5 stars if possible. I thought the ice cream was made in-house, but learned it comes from somewhere in Florida. I understand that you're competing with some well-entrenched competitors and need to set yourself apart, and having something other than Pralines or Giffords is nice, but may not be enough. Reading the description of the shop and why the owner created it, I was very much looking forward to trying it out. It's housed in an old dry cleaner shop and redone very well, very clean and bright and welcoming. With such a personal story I expected the owner to be a bit more exuberant about helping guests, especially during the first week open. To be completely fair, I'm only guessing that the person who helped me was the owner because it was just after opening and during the first week, so, I would think the owner would be there. She was friendly enough, offered a taste of whatever I wanted, but then turned her back and was not very interactive or communicative. One pet-peeve I have about ice cream shops is that they hand you a cone and then you have to reach into your pocket to pay. It's not easy to do and can get quite messy. Easy solution-have an ice cream holder by the register! Guess what, they have an cone holder near the register, however, if was full of some type of chocolate lollipops. I order the garbage can flavor which was vanilla base with 7 different chocolate candies mixed in. It was good, not great. It was lighter than most premium ice creams, which many may prefer. There were plenty of chocolate candy pieces and a decent portion size, but still quite expensive. Updating my review based on the owner's feedback, which I appreciate. I had no idea the ice cream was not made in-house, which would explain why it was light in flavor and mouthfeel. Regarding expense, I would say it's even more expensive for a product not freshly made in-house. I wish you every success. read more

See all

Sundae Afternoon is such a gem to Yalesville area! It's tucked in the parking lot across from the vet for easy access off rt 68. -Some flavors change which is always nice to go back and try something new! -The owner is very nice and personable. -The space is open and clean. -The ice cream is delicious, thick yet creamy and flavorful. -Novelty items like ice cream donut sandwiches and strawberry shortcake bombs make the menu fun, too. Sundae Afternoon? At the rate I'm going it's more like Thursdae Fridae and Saturdae too haha! read more

Great new ice cream shop in Yalesville. Friendly staff and lots of great interesting flavors to choose from. They have an ice cream donut (w Neil's Donuts) and a homemade choco taco. Pup cups, too. read more

See all

Amazing service, everyone was sooooo nice to me and my dad. The ice was so creamy and delicious, everything was very affordable. All there was a play area for little kids. A very calm and simple setting, I don't know why but I ,ove the color of the walls, also I love that idea of a trivia question for a free toppping, I got it right. read more

Excellent ice cream! Family ate so fast I couldn't get pictures. We highly recommend Sundae Afternoon, even with a few good places in town they manage to stand out. Building is also very nice atmosphere. read more

Had a great cone and brought a treat home for me and one each for my fur babies. Lovely and clean, displays are so appealing, it's hard to decide what to get... so I got one for the ride and one for the freezer. read more

Clean, Knowledgeable staff and great Ice Cream! Plenty of parking and conveniently located off Route 150 and Route 68. I will be back again! read more

Friendly, happy customer service. The ice cream is delicious, with many choices for everyone's taste buds. And there is both indoor and outdoor seating, which provides choices. read more

came home after buying my toasted. Coconut ice cream had my dinner and added some fresh pineapple. What a nice ending to a night. They have the best ice cream. read more

Sundae Afternoon - Absolutely amazing ice cream, Toasted coconut. I added fresh pineapple like a frozen, frozen piña colada. Their ice cream is one of the best - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Wallingford, Connecticut

The chocalate icecream i had was really good. There are a few table and chairs inside. I'll definitely be back soon.!

Nice addition to Yalesville/Wallingford, very friendly staff and great ice cream. I don't believe it's made on site, but still good stuff. Give them a try. read more