I've been a few more times and the size of the ice cream has improved greatly. Some of the new flavors are very interesting. Best ice cream in the area. Service is always quick and friendly. Some seating indoors and plenty outdoors. They always have great looking pastries too but their ice cream is so good that I'm never able to eat anything else. read more

Old Bishops Farm isn't a new business however they reopened this weekend and it was my first time there! Love how there's room to walk , it's clean, there's fresh veggies, and pretty flowers and pumpkins of all sorts to pick ! Even fruit picking .. in this case apples! Staff was great! My dad ordered a pumpkin donut and I just had a small home made ice cream. It it was delicious! There are 2 different areas to purchase bakery items and Ice cream which is nice . Keeps lines separate and not too long. There's tables outdoors where you can enjoy ! We enjoyed the ride. It's kind of in between residential area in Cheshire but easy to get to. read more

See all

Ice cream was great Donut was phenomenal Service even better!! Large property with lots to do!! Eat deserts then walk it off!! read more

Old Bishop Farm - Strawberry donut - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

See all

If all the best places go above and beyond the norm, everybody else needs to keep up or they can't be considered one of the best. Fair or not fair, that has to be true. For me, Old Bishop Farm suffers in this comparison with other top CT ice cream shops. My wife and I ate dinner in Cheshire. As I often do, I did a Yelp search for interesting nearby food businesses. That's how I discovered Old Bishop Farm has a 5 Star Yelp Rating for Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt. Yelp identifies Old Bishop Farm as a bakery and Farm Market as well, but this review exclusively focusses on the Homemade Ice Cream part of the business. Old Bishop had about 15 fairly standard flavors. I ordered a single scoop of Cookies and Cream on a sugar cone. My wife ordered a small cup of Cherry Chocolate Chip ice cream with Hot Fudge. The young man who helped me gave me exactly what I ordered - a rounded single scoop of ice cream. I'm attaching a pic of the cone to my review. I assume this is a standard single scoop cone for Old Bishop Farm, although I guess it's possible I was helped by a newer employee. Either way, I don't visit any other ice cream shops that define a single scoop that way. I can't remember when an ice cream shop gave me a smaller quantity of ice cream for a single scoop. It looks like a Kid Size. Maybe other places charge more too. In any event, an ice cream place is fighting an uphill battle when they hand you a visually uninspiring cone compared to other places. The ice cream was fine. It didn't stand out compared to other places I visit, but I generally only go to high end places. It's possible that the other aspects of Old Bishop Farm's business help justify its Five Star Yelp rating. But with all the great CT ice cream shops, I can only give Old Bishop Farm 3 Stars for its ice cream. read more

See all

I love it here. We have been going since I was a kid and I'm 72 now. It was always a very special trip. I have some items in my home that came from there. I love it and I think you will , too! read more

This is the best ice cream in the state of Connecticut. It's made right on the premises. If you haven't tried it you're definitely missing out. It's also a farm and you can buy all the vegetables you need there. This place is a gem. read more

New owners, walked in to get some fresh fruit, and the first thing I noticed was that all varieties of apples were $6.00/pound. I've been to all the best farms in the northeast and I've never paid more than $3.00/pound. We used to be regulars here when it was the previous owner, but after seeing that now they have the audacity to charge almost double we will never be back. What a shame. read more

Old Bishop Farm in Cheshire is a perfect getaway for a fall day starting with the scenic farm filled with pumpkins, cornstalks, gourds and many decorations on the farm for photo taking. When you go inside for coffee & to watch them make cider donuts, or for ice cream and deserts, you cant ignore browsing through the gift shop. A fun day. read more

See all

Great home made ice cream and baked goods. Some seasonal staff didn't pack the ice cream pints appropriately so that was sad but not enough to dissuade us from returning. The owners are wonderful. read more

A hidden gem here in Cheshire! We were looking for a pick your orchard and we stumbled upon one of the best that we've been to here in CT. The staff were super friendly and answered all our questions that we had as 1st timers. Adorable country store with very unique gift ideas in addition to locally sourced produce and a candy bar sure to please all ages! Make sure to save room or stop by again for their delicious homemade ice cream and milkshakes! They certainly have something for everyone. We can't wait to come back for blueberry & apple picking! read more

Old Bishop Farm - Covered outside seating on the deck in addition to inside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

See all

Lovely place to pick up fresh and local produce. Their veggie chips are addicting and delicious!

Great find! A fairly traditional New England farm/orchard stand with the addition of freshly made ice cream. The ice cream is excellent and comes in some unique flavors. We bought many of the typical items such as apple pie, apple crumb pie and cider donuts. Everything was very good. A solid addition to a very crowded market in Cheshire. In addition, they have a beautiful flower garden, a small candy selection as well as hay bales, pumpkins, gourds and other seasonal items. Overall it was a very nice experience with very nice and friendly owners who obviously take pride in reopening this place. read more

Old Bishop Farm - Apple pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

Lovely farm! So cute inside and they have the most delicious strawberries and super sweet staff, oh, and I can't forget the donuts, they are way better than the popular local spots read more

Old Bishop Farm - Lovely spot! Delicious strawberries and sweet staff! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

A visit to this historic farm and country store makes for the ultimate New England experience! The shop is honestly the most aesthetically pleasing I've seen locally, and their homemade ice cream and baked goods have that Connecticut rustic flavor you can't get anywhere else. Don't miss the pick your own options-- the PYO flower garden is my personal favorite! read more

Old Bishop Farm - Some of the store's baked-daily goods - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

See all

Super friendly staff in the charming farm store and a lovely local place place for pick-your-own. I took my 65 year old parents and my 4 year old son to go strawberry picking here. I don't know who was more delighted with the activity (ok, it was my mom), but we had a wonderful time walking around the grounds and picking the delicious berries. Afterwards we stopped at the farm store and bought some pies. The owner's wife gave us a free banana cream pie as a gift to try. Well she must have known it would hook us into returning because that banana cream pie is really something! (Key lime was awesome as well!). We were too full for their home made ice cream and donuts. Next time! Thanks for the lovely visit! read more

Old Bishop Farm - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

Very cute market for fruits, veggies, homemade pastry's and homemade ice cream! This review is for their ice cream The ice cream is incredibly light and creamy and they have a decent selection of flavors. I tried their chocolate chip cookie dough and their were plenty off chips. The only cones they offer are sugar cones. Their is plenty of seating both outside, both covered and uncovered. Ice Cream Quality: 8/10 Overall: 6/10 read more

Go to this place for ice cream! Yummy! The pies are pretty great too. I ordered the brownie Sunday and it was awesome. Warm brownie with coffee Oreo ice cream, fluffernutter ice cream, hot fudge and whipped cream. Perfection! read more

Visit this scenic family farm in Cheshire, a great place for kids and adults! Bring a lunch and enjoy eating on the front porch. Enjoy homemade donuts or ice cream after! Organically grown apples, strawberries, raspberries.... read more

See all

Amazing ice cream. So creamy and was super surprised how well priced it was. The butter pecan was just so silky.. the coffee Oreo amazing and the cookie dough is always a fave! Can't wait to go back and try the fluffer nutter. Might even bring the kids this time read more

Great Ice Cream and treats! Ideal place to bring family and check out farm and all it has to offer. Nice to see local owners create a space for the community to enjoy. read more

Great homemade ice cream, donuts, and other delicious baked goods. What else can you ask for? I love supporting this great local business any chance I get!! read more

Old Bishop Farm - a hand holding a cone of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

Our family's favorite place, cozy modern country store. The owners and staff are always so welcoming and kind. We also love their ice cream, pies, doughnuts, and most of all how they are such an integral part of the Cheshire community. read more

What a fantastic surprise. I grew up in Cheshire and just recently returned for the summer, excited to find out about Old Bishop Farm. My first visit we bought the most delicious pie I've ever tasted. It was mixed berry crumb pie. It was sugary sweet and tart as well. Heated up and magical. My second visit we got blueberry muffins straight out of the oven. Fresh blueberries bursting through the perfectly cooked muffins. It was fun to peak around the gift store side of it as well. I'll be sure to come back!! read more

Cleanest, most organized apple picking farm I've ever been to! Good, crisp apples and the pie was $22. Very plain crust with not much flavor but the inside was perfect. Pure apple flavor without too much sugar or spice flavor. read more

This is a real gem! We happened to stumble upon it in the middle of some portion of Cheshire area that I've never seen before. The selections and options are really great! Service is super friendly! And the scenic view and drive around Old Bishop Farm is really peaceful! I would absolutely suggest you try Old Bishop Farm our because it's a very underrated location all around. read more

Delicious ice cream, yummy baked goods, organic vegetables, home decor, and pick your own flower bouquets, all located in a picturesque working farm. The owners and employees are very friendly and helpful. Looking forward to to visiting again in the Spring! read more

Strawberry picking was so fun, baked goods and ice cream to die for. Everybody was very friendly and the place is gorgeous. I would recommend Old Bishop's Farm for everybody. 10/10. read more

See all

Very cute place. Small but adorable. Haven't tried icecream yet but have heard great things.

The absolute best donuts we have ever had. Ended up going back at 8am a few days later so we could have first pick and try every flavor. The kids are obsessed. So soft and flavorful. Strawberry picking was not too far to walk to from the shop and they had tons of other baked items and specialty items in the shop. Super friendly staff. read more

I have essentially been a lifelong Cheshire resident and have seen Bishop Farm through several different owners, closures, and iterations. There are many collective memories of pumpkin patches, hayrides, apple picking, donuts, and the animal farm that adorn my childhood, but sadly this farm remained closed and in gradual neglect for many years...that is until the Torello family stepped in and breathed life back into this well loved iconic Cheshire institution. The labor, countless hours, and sweat equity that the Torellos have invested into what is now Old Bishop Farm is truly remarkable. They have breathed vitality back into the property and have made it even more special. The store has been beautifully renovated, radiates hometown Cheshire pride, and offers a variety of kitchen items and accessories. We have had the chance to enjoy a variety of their delicious homemade baked goods, which are all made on site. The donuts are particularly tasty, especially the blueberry and apple cider varieties. We haven't tried one of their pies yet, but it's only a matter of time. They've also taken the business up a notch with a fantastic ice cream shop that rivals even the most revered local institutions. Perhaps the most special aspect of OId Bishop Farm, is the revival of the farm itself. Everything grown on site is organic and the quality of the produce is unparalleled. The pick your own strawberries and black raspberries we recently purchased were truly textbook. You honestly have to come visit to understand the magic that has been preserved at Old Bishop Farm. Be prepared that produce pricing at times runs on the pricier side given that they are grown using sustainable organic prices, but the trip and money is well worth the investment to support a true homegrown business. read more

See all

Great place. Less crowded, awesome homemade donuts... Not overpriced on outside and inside merchants etc..

Do not sleep on some of the best home made ice cream made right here in town. Great, friendly staff. The pastries, pies, and donuts are amazing. You haven't lived until you've had a donut sundae. read more

I was the other half of Rene K.'s bike riding. I decided to try their "sweet corn" flavor...WOW! I got a small dish of it...and it was just right. If you have ever had buttered popcorn flavored jelly beans from a very well known jelly bean manufacturer, you would have that flavor in a nutshell. We also got to try their double chocolate and apple cider doughnuts. These were fantastic! The owner was wonderful and pointed out several facts about the building and why they purchased the farm. I HIGHLY recommend them. RUN, don't walk...and I've been told if you go in the morning, she makes those apple cider doughnuts fresh each day (at least right now, not sure about all year round), and you get them still warm...there's a line to get them, though. To say I was impressed with the decor, the building, the owner, the ice cream and the doughnuts would be a severe understatement. Check them out. You'll be glad you did! read more

After an afternoon of bike riding, decided to stop for ice cream. We were familiar with a couple of places in the area but did a search to see what else came up and found Old Bishop Farm. We tried their ice cream, delicious! The sweet corn was a fantastic seasonal flavor. I also love chocolate donuts and upon telling the owner,she gave me one to try. My husband loves apple cider donuts and she let us try that one too. We purchased donuts!! Everyone was so warm and friendly we can wait to go back! read more

Chocolate frosted donuts were delicious. Great chocolate and wonderful donut. The strawberry key lime pie is very good, too. A must stop if you are in the area. read more

Best cider donuts around made by a great, local family! We visit often for the baked goods, ice cream, and view!

Finally made the trek there and OMG, I'll be back soon! I had two scoops of ice cream, rocky road and peanut butter cup. Amazingly creamy and delicious! I'd go back just for more ice cream , but then there are the baked goods! We took home mini apple crumb and banana cream pies for Mother's Day! They were exceptional! I thought the banana cream was my favorite until I had the apple crumb! Now it's a tie! The apple crumb is like the most amazing crumb cake topping with the perfect amount of perfectly cooked apples to compliment it, seated in the perfect crust! Now I need to go back soon for a donut sundae! Oh, and I bought gorgeous fresh herbs! Too healthy to talk about in this review! The shop is beautiful, rustic and filled with adorable things to buy! I love that so much is locally made! Thanks for the tour JT! Hope that next time we get to see Carolyn! We will be back very soon! read more

Amazing baked goods! Some of the best cider donuts I've ever had and so reasonably priced.

it is a perfect place to take your kids to get icecream and pick pumpkins

I just love this farm! Everyone on the farm is so friendly and helpful. This is my go to spot to pick fruit and get some special treats. The ice cream is so creamy and flavorful. The cookies are some of the best I've had and trust me I've had my fair share ; ) Also, they have a cookie pie! YES... you heard me a cookie pie that will melt in your mouth. I had it with a scoop of their vanilla ice cream and my family didn't leave a crumb behind. I can't say enough great things about this farm. read more