Sully's has the best burgers I've had in Idaho, in fact ever! Better than Snake Bite by a wide margin and even better than Big Jud's. You gotta get here quick! Ambience: Clean, well decorated, feels like a pub but a clean one. Staff: lovely and lively wait staff, wonderful food for a fair price, good portion sizes generally. Kristina is cheerful and awesome and her Bento cakes are incredible! Well balanced burgers: I keep coming back for the taste and the size of their 1/2lb burger is just right for us hungry boys! The slap yo granny is my favorite!!! It is sweet, savory, a little sour, and spicy from the pickled peppers, the tiniest hint of bitterness from the greens. The sweetness of the blueberry compot balances the spice and fat from the burger rather exceptionally. And the house made pickles are the bomb. Very messy though especially with a beard lol. The best and most balanced burger I have ever had!!! It's so good I've been around 10 times and almost always get the Slap yo granny lol. I'd miss it to much to try anything else. The samurai burger and russian cucumber is great if you want something fresh but not sweet, the humongous fungus is another really good one. Fries: The epitome of a homemade Idaho fry, but not to greasy which I appreciate. The sidewinder fries are epic and my favorite, and the waffle sweet potatoes fries are great as well. Although the $2.50 up-charge I don't love, especially for the size of the fry. For the upcharge I wish you got a little or a lot more. The regular fry is adequately portioned. They have a really well seasoned made in-house fry sauce that is delightfully smoky and sweet, and balances out the fries very nicely. It is one of the best fry sauces I've ever had, and I have had a lot of them. Constructive criticism: For the up-charge on the unique and tasty fries add a few more or lower the charge a bit. It's the only thing that feels a bit scamish as I've walked away several times feeling like I could have had just a few more I would have been satisfied. I'm willing to admit that's a me problem possibly, that being said I'm not a fatty, I'm actually a small dude, so take that for what it's worth. The Men's bathroom needs a couple updates, a divider for the urnal for privacy for the shy guys, and for those of us who don't want to see some crusty private bits walking in the door. And a privacy bar to fill the gap in the stall, of which you can see into the stall right at the person on the lue, in a slightly larger manner than feels safe, especially for children's safety, it not exactly appetizing for how delicious of a restaurant this is. And Extra points awarded for some of the cool shows playing on the tv's, especially The Bob Ross Channel. The parking is adequate but it is downtown and spots do get full so you may have to look around. read more

See all

First visit. Very nice pub in downtown Idaho Falls, Irish music playing in the background... we went for a late lunch, getting a pastrami sandwich called the Rachael Sammich and a smoked ribeye french dip sammich. We're not into fries of which there were many options, but you could upgrade to a salad, Caesar salad, or soup of the day. The sizes were enormous! We immediately asked for a to go box, and placed half of each sammich into it. The upgraded sides were great, so we ate them all. The soup was clam chowder; first I'd had in years; it was very tasty and a delightfully little spicy. We split the other half sammiches between us; I found the pastrami to be excellent, the french dip good, but nothing to distinguish itself. When a first visit makes us want to come again, that's always a good sign! read more

See all

After a long 11 hour drive we were starving. We decided to stop in and grab a bite to eat. Everyone was warm and welcoming when you walk in the door. My daughter was excited to see they had pool tables available if you got a drink or dined there. That made her day. The waitress was super sweet. She held a pool table for us because she knew my daughter wanted to use it. That was super nice. We ordered burgers and chicken tenders. The burgers are insanely monstrous. I couldnt even finish a quarter of it. They were very good. The fries were slightly disappointing being we are in ID I thought they would be better. Maybe it was the way they were cooked. My daughter enjoyed the chicken tenders. They too were massive and way too much to eat. The portions are very generous here. The prices are reasonable considering portion sizes. We enjoyed our time and food we would definitely come back of we were back in town! read more

See all

The burgers are especially good. We met friends here on this visit and had a great time catching up. The ambiance is great to have multiple conversations going at once!! The service was good too!! read more

The atmosphere was fun. Loved the music playing. Service was great! I was apprehensive about trying the slap yo granny blue. Boy am I glad I tried it, the blueberry and jalapeño counteract each other and works well together. The Rachel is an awesome sandwich as well. Sauerkraut and pastrami was delicious. The French dip was delightful as well. Will return again! read more

See all

Staff super friendly and helpful. First time in the quaint little pub is clean warm and inviting. The food is amazing but bring your appetite. The portions are very generous. We had the sour hen and huckleberry lemonade. So delicious read more

Sully's GastroPub - The sour hen amazing - Burgers Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

This is a funky little place. Feels a little old and dated, but in a historical way, not a bad way. There are numerous screens showing sports, and a large one that showed funny videos, trivia questions, etc. It was fun to talk about the questions before the timer on the screen ran out and it showed the answer. They have mostly burgers and sandwiches, but also steak, salads. I had the "Rachel" which is essentially a Rueben sandwich (pastrami on rye with sauerkraut and thousand island dressing). It was disappointing. They use a much thicker bread than most, and stuffed it with so much pastrami, that it was impossible to pick it up and take a bite without everything falling out, and the bottom slice of bread was soggy. i was never able to get one bite that had pastrami and sauerkraut and bread. I was there to relax and dealing with this big mess was too much work! It was way too much food. I could only finish one half of the sandwich. I noticed lots of other people left with take home containers, so clearly I'm not the only one. I enjoyed a nice peanut butter stout. Service was good. Our waiter checked on us regularly. read more

Sully's GastroPub - Rachel Sandwich and side salad - Burgers Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

I love great food, to me Sullys is one of the best we have in IF. My wife had the spicy chicken sandwich and I have a Reuben both were amazing! Portions were fantastic. They kept our drinks full and the owners made us feel welcome! 10 out of 10 highly recommend! read more

Great tasting food, service was stellar and ambiance was perfect! Best Gastropub in the nation!!! Comfortable, clean, great music, seating was all brand new, great variety of brews and incredible atmosphere. Must visit!!!! read more

Sully's GastroPub - Burgers Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

See all

Oh boy!!!! my wife and I went there after elections and it was very excellent! The food, the service everything was fantastic most of all when they brought our two burgers out, which was the slap your granny and pastrami burger. The appearance was something out of a favorite bar I used to go to when I was in Germany. The meat was succulent and tender. The pastrami was smoked perfect too. I wasn't too powerful and the french fries were divine they brought out some different sauces to dip in. I do recommend. The blue cheese. I tried a sliver of my wife. Slap your granny burger, and the blueberry complemented that half slab of ground beef so fantastic. We enjoyed playing aTrivia game that was on the television while we waited for our food. I like that comfort of the booth that I sat in. You could actually lean back and feel the padding behind you to sit comfortably. Everything was just a great dining experience and encourage anyone with a great appetite for excellent beef to go try this place out.. read more

See all

Have been wanting to try Sully's Gastropub for a while and finally made it. Just sorry it took so long! Food was great. My hubby and I split a Rachael with their home cut fries and were very glad we did! We both left food on our plates. The sandwich and fries were both excellent and, to Sully's credit, even got my husband's stamp of approval on the fries. He's been bemoaning the lack of what he considers good french fries, essentially in Idaho. The sandwich stayed hot the entire meal which is unusual. The sandwich was large and made me glad I had not gotten the sandwich on a brioche bun: I would not have gotten my mouth around it. Got to listen to Irish music while we ate but that could have been a little louder for my taste. I didn't count how many televisions were in the area we were seated in but each one had a different show. Only one had close-captioned on, though. The 4 star rating is because the portions we had were way too large for one person and the leftovers would not have re-heated well. Had we each gotten an entree' we would have thrown away the equivalent of one of them. read more

Terrible food, service, and atmosphere. Gave it a second chance and will not try again. If you like waiting 50 minutes for a drink, a loud/obnoxious atmosphere, and wilted salad and burnt burger then go here. read more

I could say we love Sully's because of the great food. I could say we love Sully's because the atmosphere is relaxing and fun. I could say we love Sully's because the staff are terrific and makes us feel welcome. I could say it so I will: great food, great atmosphere, great people. You should go. read more

See all

Stopped in at Sully's for dinner while passing thru town. Wife and I had the french dip with the smoked brisket with the spicy mustard. Best french dip we have ever had. Our son had a similar sandwich which included mild peppers. It's the sandwich just below the French dip on the menu. He said his sandwich was better than ours. Fries were crispy and not overcooked. Staff is friendly and met our needs. Great selection of beer and I found a new favorite irish stout, O'hara's. Wife and son enjoyed their chocolate hazelnut porter. read more

Put in a writing bowl and make that place that happen in spot an attraction nobody else has everybody has pool. Everybody has booze. Nobody has a riding bull and waitresses and waiters and chaps and cowboy hats. Do it millionaire status around the corner baby read more

I have eaten here twice now and both times the food has been good but not outstanding. One of our party, on our latest visit, ordered the fish and chips and it was previously frozen....Costco style...nothing special. You would expect better from a restaurant like this. We will give them another chance though and hope for the best! read more

My husband and I have been there a few times. Each time I've left super happy! I get the "Slap Yo Granny" burger and the Parmesan garlic fries. Soooooo delicious. My husband likes to try something new each time we visit. We both agree it is our favorite destination. I have had people recommend other establishments in the area, but we feel that this place is a gem that we would recommend to anyone living or visiting in the area, first. read more

Excellent patty melt and fries. I was introduced to Fry Sauce. Service was top notch! I'd recommend it. Go check them out.

I'll first say that the food was very good. Service was alright as well. What was unexpected was the final cost of my meal. I was in Idaho Falls on business and stopped there for lunch. I ordered an iced tea, a patty melt, and requested a side salad to go along with it. I was astonished when I received a $30 bill. I had no alcohol, no dessert and that was one of the most expensive lunches I have ever had whilst working. Luckily I am able to expense my meals when traveling but I would have said something to a manager if it would have been on my own dime (or at that price, gold!) read more

Love , love, love the food here. Service is also excellent. The only reason this wouldn't be five stars is the petty act of charging 50 cents for an extra fry sauce when you are paying $17 for a burger. You know you are going to do it anyway, but then it comes and is only half full! Really? It is too bad for your servers that most people are just going to take the fifty cents out of the tip. read more

We went in at around 645 on a Friday night and we were seated right away. The service was great. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. The food was delicious. We ordered the beer fries for an appetizer. The pickled jalapeños on it were great. I ordered the humongous fungus and my fiance ordered the blueberry compote burger. Both were so good. Cooked perfectly, very moist and flavorful. The Asian pickles on the humongous fungus were so good. I got a salad as my side with the Russian dressing. Salad was fresh and dressing was something new for me, but so so good. The cilantro like ranch that my fiance got was not as flavorful, but still good. The only problem id say that the food wasn't as hot as I'd like it to be. It was warm, but not hot. Overall, we will definitely be going back. read more

Sully's GastroPub - Blueberry Compote Burger - Burgers Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

See all

Absolutely awesome food and service! We stopped for lunch and couldn't be happier with our choice. We had the Sour bird chicken and the wrap! Great flavors and huge portions! If you haven't been here stop and try it! read more

Sully's GastroPub - Sour bird - Burgers Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

See all

Hands down the best food and service in town. From their burgers to the Ribeyes you just cannot go wrong. And then there's the secret menu, all you gotta do is follow them on FB. Jeff and Kristina are top notch owners and chefs and Jessica is a fabulous waitress. If you haven't been there you are definitely missing out. read more

My wife and I have gone here twice and were impressed with how good the food was. The first day, the service was a bit slow, but they had a lot of new staff and faced a good amount of adversity with kegs going empty in the middle of a rush. The server was upfront and honest and was pleasant to see the owner/managers help their staff. The burger I ordered was spot on and the Japanese BBQ sauce with the wings is addicting. The atmosphere is nice and very comfortable with large TV's for sporting events. We did come back a week later (day before St. Patricks Day) and had their specials for the day which was shepherds pie and smoked lamb which were both amazing. If any staff and owners read this, please consider adding the shepherds pie to the daily menu. No ones makes an authentic shepherds pie like yours in Idaho Falls (perfect with a pint of Guinness). The service was a lot quicker the second time we went which tells me the first visit was truly an anomaly. We will definitely be back and one day hopefully conquer the burger challenge there! read more

Whatever some perceived was wrong with this place previously must have been fixed. While in an old building, it is in very good shape. Clean (including restrooms), well laid out with plenty of room, and the food was fantastic. The hostess and our server were very friendly, helpful and attentive. We will definitely be back again! read more

Great cheeseburger and parm fries! The 1/2 pound patty was too much meat, so perhaps I'll share an entree next time.

The staff was very friendly and attentive. The restaurant was virtually empty when my dad and I arrived. We were told to sit wherever we wanted. When we arrived all the employees were sitting at a table chatting. It took awhile for the waitress to come and take our order. I ordered the patty melt and my dad ordered the trash can sandwich. My patty melt tasted a little odd when I took the first bite. The bread was not grilled very well so it was kind of soggy. My dad's only complaint about his sandwich was that the pastrami was a little tough. Atmosphere was nice and pleasant. It was clean. Sadly I was underwhelmed. read more

Ehh, If you like food with no flavor, this is the place for you. Chicken tastes like fish. Burgers have zero flavor. I will say service is pretty nice. Presentation is nice. read more

Best hamburger I have EVER tasted in 62 years! Slap Yo Grammy!! So good! First time here. Was hoping for a little more of an "Irish Immersion." Nice enough place just doesn't add to the overall Irish experience. Will be back!! The food.... read more

Love this restaurant, the gastro pub is a must try. The food is amazing, regardless what you choose off the menu, prepare to be impressed the food is all amazing, try the garlic fries as they are delicious. They wait staff is amazing and the restaurant is a site to see gives a really cool vibe. We love this place and highly recommend you give it a try! read more

Sully's GastroPub - The Rachel - Reuben Sandwich with fresh cut Fries - Burgers Near Me - Idaho Falls, Idaho

Great good great service. Our first time there and we were greeted with a friendly smile and very welcoming. Food was awesome also..

First time eating here, and wow! The five-o was delicious, and the fry sauce was everything fry sauce is supposed to be.

First time here. We went for my birthday - my choice. No disappointment here!!! Our waitress, Shay,was totally wonderful!!! We felt welcomed and comfortable. Very clean, open not too much wall clutter. The food - well it was excellent. I wish there was another word I could use to describe how good our meals were. We also had dessert - OMG scrumptious!!!! We will definitely return. After all, they had milk stout beer and free pool! read more

WITH A SIDE OF LIPGLOSS We have heard some good things about this place so we stopped in. It was a Thursday early evening and there were only 2 other tables. I usually take this as a sign and leave but we slugged on. Had an OK vibe for being an ancient building. Cool pictures on the wall, "the dude abides". The bathroom was a wreck and the smell of urine was potent, didn't mind the soccer game though. Ordered 2 sodas and the special, a smoked ribeye French dip with parm fries. Got half way through my drink and was noticing an aftertaste. Brushed it off and dove into the meal. It was super ok, not good or great just ok. I didn't taste any sort of smoke and it needed a cheese component to blend it all together. Back to my soda. I was struggling to understand what I was tasting so I inspected the mason jar looking glass only to find a coat of pink lipgloss all the way around the rim. I had been drinking from a dirty cup, someone else's cup!!! Now I don't know about industrial dishwashers but I feel like if it's properly cleaned the high temp water would melt lipgloss off. So then the question is, "how far do the cleanliness issues go?" I can't trust a place with my food if they can't clean the dishes. So I point it out to the waitress as I wipe hot pink lipgloss off with a napkin. She gasped and said she was so embarrassed and apologized but that was the end of it. No manager, no explanation, no discounted meal, NOTHING. We paid and left. Sadly we will not be going back. read more

Hit or miss. Been there twice. First time was good food and excellent service so we looked forward to having it again. (Choices of good restaurants are slim in Idaho Falls). The second time, food was "so-so" and the service was horrible! Wait staff had time to sit a table of friends and chit chat (including the lady I think is an owner) yet nobody had time to refill a glass of water at my table. The table of "friends" was seated next to us a good 15 minutes after us but had their drink and food orders taken before a wait staff even came to our table. Maybe we just caught them on a bad night? Will give them another try in the future, I hope it was just a bad fluke the second time because as I said earlier, choices of decent restaurants is severely lacking in IF. read more

Wow! The food is incredible and indulgent. The prime rib dip was unique and delicious. Service was friendly and helpful. I tried a new beer and will definitely be back. read more

This is the best thing to come to our town! Masterful in their execution of EVERYTHING!! The chef knows his stuff and his food combinations are mind blowing. Even went with my bestie who has Celiacs and they had a phenomenal gluten free option. We have eaten here 5-6x since they opened and EVERYTHING I have tried leaves me wanting more! The grilled cheese and soup were so amazing. So unique and so much flavor. The soup is thicker like a fresh marinara but with spot on seasoning! Fries are made fresh and cooked well. My faves are the patty Melt, The mushroom burger, or The burger with blueberry compote (I get the sauce in the side so it's not as messy)! Sorry I don't remember the exact names! Go try it for yourself...you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

I've eaten here four times, and each time been impressed by the burger. However the wait staff is generally slow and inattentive, no matter how busy or slow the restaurant is. Every time I've had to wait at least 15 minutes to get my beer served after ordering-I've nearly died of thirst each time! But the burgers are worth it, so I'll return. read more

Excellent! The beer and were great. Service friendly! Great place and atmosphere. Was also clean and inviting. As a family it was very clean too! read more

Everything from the service, food, and atmosphere was all top notch. I will definitely return next time I come through town