Order Sugarwitch Takeout or Delivery
Sugarwitch Photos
Sugarwitch Popular Desserts
SUGARWITCH ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Sugarwitch
Recommended Reviews - Sugarwitch
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Greeted as soon as we walked in. We had fun looking at all the goodies and making our choices. I love the aesthetic and vibe, the decor and building are lovely. When my son said he was too full to get the gooey butter cake ice cream sandwich he wanted, they told him how many more weeks it would be available and also said they have red velvet gooey butter cake cookies, and he immediately ordered one to go, and thoroughly enjoyed it later. Everything was great.
Cute little shop. I've visited their booth at the farmers market, but this was my first time at the shop itself. Their ice cream sandwiches are the main thing they are known for, but I stopped by specifically for their beignets. The beignets I ordered were freshly made, so quite good. Be warned, though, they are donut sized, unlike a lot of places where they're more mini donuts. I had leftovers. Worth a visit if you're in the area
This was so good! Grabbed a sandwich at the Tower Grove Farmer's Market this opening weekend and it was as good as everyone says! The brownie was delicious and the portion size was perfect- not too big or too small!
This place so delicious! I loved seeing all the premade ice cream sandwich flavors they had! They even had a Thai tea ice cream flavor that sounded amazing, but it was an ice cream sandwich made with Rice Krispy treats so as a vegetarian I was bummed I couldn't try that flavor since they were premade. Other than that, all the other flavors were vegetarian, they even had vegan and gluten free options. Personally I had one of the special limited flavors and it was tiramisu, and wow, it was so scrumptious. Even the chocolate they drizzled on top of the ice cream sandwich was so rich and delicious. You could tell they used quality ingredients. Plus the atmosphere of the place and the kindness of the staff, I had a wonderful experience! The only downside was that there wasn't much seating! Outside there was one bench and a table for two. We had 7 people in our party so most of us had to stand around but no one was complaining cuz the ice cream was so good! This area didn't seem too busy and there was a decent amount of street parking available. Highly recommend checking this place out!!
This is a cute little shop that makes some amazing treats! Options sell out, so go early if you have your heart set on something specific. Server was nice and explained that to some folks that were bummed out. We got a couple of different treats to share and they were all very tasty! If you get the chance to try their products at the store or when you see them at an event, do it!
Oh my goodness, you have to fly on over to Sugarwitch because it is absolutely delicious! You can tell they take great pride in their ice cream and creative witchy theming. If you need further encouragement to go out for ice cream, visit their Instagram to check out their seasonal offerings. I tried the cookie dough ice cream and blondie sandwich and it was chef's kiss.
Sugarwitch is freaking incredible. I essentially go monthly because they have so many options and inventive flavors. The staff is phenomenal and a great spot if you want something outside the ordinary of ice cream. You can't go wrong with an ice cream sandwich or a queen cone; their waffle tacos are also great. I love that they have a rotating seasonal menu and then a consistent selection of their core ice cream sandwiches. They also have coffee and teas, floats and seasonal beverages. They also host several events throughout the year and you can find them at the Tower Grove farmers market! They also collaborate with other local businesses and it is so fun to go to those events. I can't recommend this place enough!!
I've never had a bad ice cream sandwich or ice cream taco! They coin themselves as a little gay ice cream shop in St. Louis with treats named after witches. Unique and whimsical eh? Love them! Everyone is soooooo nice and helpful! Their shop has secrets. Before they moved in, it was the oldest continuing run bakery in St. Louis! Cool! Just cool! Made from scratch, sustainably sourced and made with so much love! Oh and Molina says thank you so much for her pupcups!
Only the best ice cream sandwich of my life! I tried Sugarwitch for the first time from their food truck at the Babe Made Fest 2024 at Knotting Hills event venue. It was so great. The texture and temp were perfect even with being served outdoors. The service was quick and friendly. The presentation is cute and neat. It was delicious. I'll be trying again! The Hilda is a seasonal pumpkin pie ice cream flavor but I would eat it all year long. The graham cracker toffee was excellent.
Sugarwitch kept popping up on my For You Page on TikTok, so being the dessert-lover that I am, I decided to finally check this place out! After reading through the other fantastic reviews, I don't want to say that I was disappointed in my experience, but I think the best way to describe it was underwhelming. Based on their TikTok videos, I can tell that this business uses really high quality ingredients and that everyone working here is really passionate about what they do. I love the concept and that it's a locally owned business. As far as my actual experience, nothing necessarily wowed me. All of the sandwiches are pre-packed and ready to go in a freezer, so I walked inside, looked at the menu, told them which flavor I wanted, paid for my ice cream sandwich, and left. Employees were nice and had welcoming smiles, but I didn't have the chance to interact with them beyond this encounter. The business itself has a really cute interior and outside sitting area. Their core and seasonal ice cream sandwiches are $6 each. Not sure if I ordered the wrong thing, but my ice cream sandwich was very basic. I ordered the Zelie, which is coffee cinnamon ice cream and fudgy brownie. It was good, but I was expecting a little something more for some reason. My boyfriend ordered the Circe, which is blueberry ice cream and lemon poppyseed shortbread. I liked it better than the one I ordered. I will say that I was impressed by the softness of the sandwich. After sitting in a freezer, ice cream sandwiches usually harden, but these were pretty soft and had a great consistency! Not sure if I need to go back and try different flavors or menu items or what, but I think I might've gone in with my expectations a little too high based on social media hype. Definitely not a bad experience, but also not the experience I was anticipating.
I have been wanting to try Sugarwitch! I am glad I finally made it here. Such a cute location and decor. When you enter you are greeted by the friendly staff who welcome you and show you the menu. They have SO many delicious options to choose from and that was the hardest part! Several offerings of ice cream sandwiches with some seasonal ones as well! I had the Mrs. Whatsit and it was phenomenal! All the sandwiches are wrapped and ready to either eat there or take some home or to your next party! Sugarwitch also has specials and novelties on their menu with sundaes, waffle tacos and pints! They have a drink menu with several coffees, teas, floats, and cold brews. I cannot wait to return and try more of these amazing ice cream sandwiches!! Get yourself to Sugarwitch asap!!
Go to Sugarwitch for a step back in time. Nostalgic location if you are an older person like me. It is located in an old bakery from yesteryear. It has not changed a lot having the same glass front cabinets, same layout as it had in its glory days. They have a freezer full of ice cream treats. Lots of sandwiches and there is a taco similar to the chocotaco. The sandwiches have a variety of flavors. They are very, very good. They also offer coffee and other drinks. Really nice place for a sweet treat! Very kind staff and they told us a bit of history about the building and business that used to be there. Very nice!
2 months ago
Stopped in hopes of picking up one of the July seasonal witches as well as trying a new one for August. The staff is so great! I was able to get the Circe from July and the Le Petite Prince from August. The flavors are so good, I have my favorites and will add the Le Petite Prince to that list. I haven't tried the Circe yet but what can't be delicious about blueberry ice cream with a lemon poppyseed cookie? Am I right?! The rest of the August menu will be calling me back to the shop and I usually pop in for my Affogato fix, too. read more
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Thank you so much, Jo! So glad you got a delicious treat! Thank you…
baby this team needs an award for the innovative flavors they serve. the flavor combos are unmatched. as soon as i came in, i was given a friendly welcome. loved all the decor and the posters inside too. their beignets were top tier. didn't get a picture of the ice cream sandwich because it was immediately demolished. they are definitely a bit small for the price, but the business takes pride doing every bit from scratch. they also collab with other local businesses, so to me, that makes it worth the small splurge! read more
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Thank you so much, Jordan! It means so much that you love our…
These ice cream sandwiches are perfection. Everything is housemade, and they create unique and delicious flavor combinations. They have classic flavors, as well as rotating monthly ones. The sandwich cookies or crusts are always spectacular and sooo buttery. The ice cream is creamy and soft. In my opinion, these are the best ice cream sandwiches you will find. read more
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Thank you so, so much! That is absolutely our goal!!
6 months ago
Greeted as soon as we walked in. We had fun looking at all the goodies and making our choices. I love the aesthetic and vibe, the decor and building are lovely. When my son said he was too full to get the gooey butter cake ice cream sandwich he wanted, they told him how many more weeks it would be available and also said they have red velvet gooey butter cake cookies, and he immediately ordered one to go, and thoroughly enjoyed it later. Everything was great. read more
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Hurray we're so glad you had a great visit! Thank you!
9 months ago
Cute little shop. I've visited their booth at the farmers market, but this was my first time at the shop itself. Their ice cream sandwiches are the main thing they are known for, but I stopped by specifically for their beignets. The beignets I ordered were freshly made, so quite good. Be warned, though, they are donut sized, unlike a lot of places where they're more mini donuts. I had leftovers. Worth a visit if you're in the area read more
This was so good! Grabbed a sandwich at the Tower Grove Farmer's Market this opening weekend and it was as good as everyone says! The brownie was delicious and the portion size was perfect- not too big or too small! read more
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Hurray! Thank you!!
1 year ago
This place so delicious! I loved seeing all the premade ice cream sandwich flavors they had! They even had a Thai tea ice cream flavor that sounded amazing, but it was an ice cream sandwich made with Rice Krispy treats so as a vegetarian I was bummed I couldn't try that flavor since they were premade. Other than that, all the other flavors were vegetarian, they even had vegan and gluten free options. Personally I had one of the special limited flavors and it was tiramisu, and wow, it was so scrumptious. Even the chocolate they drizzled on top of the ice cream sandwich was so rich and delicious. You could tell they used quality ingredients. Plus the atmosphere of the place and the kindness of the staff, I had a wonderful experience! The only downside was that there wasn't much seating! Outside there was one bench and a table for two. We had 7 people in our party so most of us had to stand around but no one was complaining cuz the ice cream was so good! This area didn't seem too busy and there was a decent amount of street parking available. Highly recommend checking this place out!! read more
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Thank you so, so much! So glad you loved your treats!! In the future,…
This is a cute little shop that makes some amazing treats! Options sell out, so go early if you have your heart set on something specific. Server was nice and explained that to some folks that were bummed out. We got a couple of different treats to share and they were all very tasty! If you get the chance to try their products at the store or when you see them at an event, do it! read more
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Thank you so much, Robert! Oof, yes, we hate it when we're sold out…
10 months ago
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Thank you so much, Katherine!!
Oh my goodness, you have to fly on over to Sugarwitch because it is absolutely delicious! You can tell they take great pride in their ice cream and creative witchy theming. If you need further encouragement to go out for ice cream, visit their Instagram to check out their seasonal offerings. I tried the cookie dough ice cream and blondie sandwich and it was chef's kiss. read more
2 years ago
Sugarwitch is freaking incredible. I essentially go monthly because they have so many options and inventive flavors. The staff is phenomenal and a great spot if you want something outside the ordinary of ice cream. You can't go wrong with an ice cream sandwich or a queen cone; their waffle tacos are also great. I love that they have a rotating seasonal menu and then a consistent selection of their core ice cream sandwiches. They also have coffee and teas, floats and seasonal beverages. They also host several events throughout the year and you can find them at the Tower Grove farmers market! They also collaborate with other local businesses and it is so fun to go to those events. I can't recommend this place enough!! read more
Business owner information
Sophie M.
We're so, so glad to have you visit each month! Thank you for your…
4 months ago
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Woohoo, thank you! The Elphaba is definitely a fav :)
I've never had a bad ice cream sandwich or ice cream taco! They coin themselves as a little gay ice cream shop in St. Louis with treats named after witches. Unique and whimsical eh? Love them! Everyone is soooooo nice and helpful! Their shop has secrets. Before they moved in, it was the oldest continuing run bakery in St. Louis! Cool! Just cool! Made from scratch, sustainably sourced and made with so much love! Oh and Molina says thank you so much for her pupcups! read more
4 months ago
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Thank you so much, Doug! That means a lot!
2 years ago
Only the best ice cream sandwich of my life! I tried Sugarwitch for the first time from their food truck at the Babe Made Fest 2024 at Knotting Hills event venue. It was so great. The texture and temp were perfect even with being served outdoors. The service was quick and friendly. The presentation is cute and neat. It was delicious. I'll be trying again! The Hilda is a seasonal pumpkin pie ice cream flavor but I would eat it all year long. The graham cracker toffee was excellent. read more
Sugarwitch kept popping up on my For You Page on TikTok, so being the dessert-lover that I am, I decided to finally check this place out! After reading through the other fantastic reviews, I don't want to say that I was disappointed in my experience, but I think the best way to describe it was underwhelming. Based on their TikTok videos, I can tell that this business uses really high quality ingredients and that everyone working here is really passionate about what they do. I love the concept and that it's a locally owned business. As far as my actual experience, nothing necessarily wowed me. All of the sandwiches are pre-packed and ready to go in a freezer, so I walked inside, looked at the menu, told them which flavor I wanted, paid for my ice cream sandwich, and left. Employees were nice and had welcoming smiles, but I didn't have the chance to interact with them beyond this encounter. The business itself has a really cute interior and outside sitting area. Their core and seasonal ice cream sandwiches are $6 each. Not sure if I ordered the wrong thing, but my ice cream sandwich was very basic. I ordered the Zelie, which is coffee cinnamon ice cream and fudgy brownie. It was good, but I was expecting a little something more for some reason. My boyfriend ordered the Circe, which is blueberry ice cream and lemon poppyseed shortbread. I liked it better than the one I ordered. I will say that I was impressed by the softness of the sandwich. After sitting in a freezer, ice cream sandwiches usually harden, but these were pretty soft and had a great consistency! Not sure if I need to go back and try different flavors or menu items or what, but I think I might've gone in with my expectations a little too high based on social media hype. Definitely not a bad experience, but also not the experience I was anticipating. read more
I have been wanting to try Sugarwitch! I am glad I finally made it here. Such a cute location and decor. When you enter you are greeted by the friendly staff who welcome you and show you the menu. They have SO many delicious options to choose from and that was the hardest part! Several offerings of ice cream sandwiches with some seasonal ones as well! I had the Mrs. Whatsit and it was phenomenal! All the sandwiches are wrapped and ready to either eat there or take some home or to your next party! Sugarwitch also has specials and novelties on their menu with sundaes, waffle tacos and pints! They have a drink menu with several coffees, teas, floats, and cold brews. I cannot wait to return and try more of these amazing ice cream sandwiches!! Get yourself to Sugarwitch asap!! read more
3 years ago
Go to Sugarwitch for a step back in time. Nostalgic location if you are an older person like me. It is located in an old bakery from yesteryear. It has not changed a lot having the same glass front cabinets, same layout as it had in its glory days. They have a freezer full of ice cream treats. Lots of sandwiches and there is a taco similar to the chocotaco. The sandwiches have a variety of flavors. They are very, very good. They also offer coffee and other drinks. Really nice place for a sweet treat! Very kind staff and they told us a bit of history about the building and business that used to be there. Very nice! read more
Loved coming to sugarwitch after working a long day. Able to cool off with a 'witch and cold brew! They have outdoor seating available. Also gf, df and v+ options which are clearly stated on the menu for those with dietary restrictions! I ordered the Theo 'witch which was chocolate ice cream + raspberry shortbread and a cold brew coffee! It was delicious! They offer regular 'witches, seasonal 'witches, specialty & novelty ice creams, as well as pup cups! They also offer coffee, tea and frozen drinks! Definitely recommend checking this place out. LGBTQIAA+ owned and supported. Staff is very welcoming and friendly to everyone :) read more
My fantasy loving heart couldn't wait to get to SugarWitch to try out their ice cream sandwiches named after famous witches. Cool idea and even cooler building. It is like entering a fantasy realm with pastel ice cream shop charm. It had a few tables inside as well as picnic tables in the courtyard in the next lot for decent seating for a group. The service was amazing even as I asked 10,000 questions and they pointed me to the Tara ice cream sandwich, Miso brown sugar ice cream with a milk chocolate chip blonde (drool). It was incredible, with the savory miso contrasting with the brown sugar and blonde it was truly lovely. I also tried one of their gorgeous truffles, the goat cheese truffle was the perfect mix of savory and sweet and I wish I had bought 20 of them. I did get the Peach Edith Grey float which had peach ice cream "ice cubes" and a strong sparkling earl grey as well. It was good, a bit strong for me but when the cubes melted it was divine. Honestly, I would buy a pint of their peach ice cream. read more
First time trying out this place at Finally Friday event at Laumeier Park. So glad I purchased the Tilly ice cream sandwich & hope to see Sugarwitch at another event or maybe make a future visit to the ice cream shop when I am visiting the city. Ice cream flavor had the concept of the snicker bar. I have usually preferred eating the brownies on its own and usually not as a sandwich. I wonder if there is an option in the future to order ice cream separate from the brownies. I also wonder for a future pop up event if one of the tacos can be offered along with plastic spoons? If I cannot purchase ice cream separate from brownie layers in the future pop up events, I am thinking I could at least eat the ice cream with the spoon first before the brownie layers. Hope to try one of the tacos in the future or pick up an ice cream pint to go. read more
7 months ago
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Thank you so, so much!
Well wouldn't you know that we would really start loving a place three months before we move back to Houston. The ice cream here is to die for and we just joined their pint club for the next two months so we are excited. Also they have new monthly sandwiches which has been really nice to try different combos. The beignets for this Mardi Gras Season have really made it for me though. They're always big and tasty and a great combo of flavors. read more
2 years ago
Sweetest spot in the city! My friends and I make a point to try the specials every month and we are always blown away. Smiling faces behind the register always give impeccable customer service. My personal favorites are the Red Velvet cone, Matcha Oreo waffle taco and the Tara ice cream sandwich! (I know Miso sounds weird in ice cream y'all gotta trust the ice cream deities they know what they're doing!) The punch card system also rocks and really pays off if you're messy like me and buy four at a time . A safe haven for queer folks in our scary world read more
Business owner information
Sophie M.
This is exactly what we hope for! Thank you for being part of our…
3 years ago
1 year ago
Came here upon the recommendation of a friend. It was a cute little store with tons of options for ice cream sandwiches and other sugary sweets. We got the ice cream sandwiches but we definitely want to come back to try the other options as well too (there was so many!). It was one worker, and we got our items pretty quickly. We got the Elphaba, which was a mint chocolate chip ice cream cookie sandwich. The brownie part was very chewy, and the mint chocolate chip ice cream section was soft and had the perfect amount of sweetness. We also got the Tara, which was a milk chocolate chip cookie base with a miso brown sugar ice cream interior. Personally, this hit the spot for me. There was a slight amount of saltiness contrast, the sweetness, and it really brought out the brown sugary flavor of the ice cream. There was something about that lingered but in a very delicious way this one also had a good amount of sweetness, and the chocolate cookie part was well balanced out by the ice cream part of it. Both sandwiches had very delightly textures to it. Overall, 4/5 stars would come again to try out the other interesting flavors. read more
The creativity in their offerings and the adorable Airstream make this a must stop in STL. We enjoy visiting on a beautiful evening when we can enjoy the outdoor seating too. We had an Ursula (vanilla ice cream with sprinkles and salty brownies), Rainbow Brite (watermelon lime ice cream with fruity pebbles rice crispie), and a Guava Cream Cheese Queen Cone (cornmeal waffle cone with guava cream cheese ice cream, guava hard shell and sugared corn nuts). OMG. All three were insane. The ice cream is the perfect temperate so you can eat them right away. They often sell out of some of their short run specials so make sure to visit early! read more
1 year ago
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Thank you so much, Saylor! We're so glad you love the shop!!
I've been frequenting Sugarwitch since they used to operate out of the airstream outside of A&O Co. All of their flavors are incredible and I love that it rotates every month so you get to try something new constantly. The new storefront is absolutely adorable and the pastries are an added bonus. I also frequent the Sugarwitch tent at the Tower Grove Farmer's Market and get pup cups for my dogs in the summer. Our whole family loves this woman owned business! read more
1 year ago
Business owner information
Sophie M.
Wow, thank you so so much! Gideon is a keeper :)
5 years ago
BEST ICE CREAM SANDWICH EVER!!! I don't know how to stress enough how good Sugarwitch is! I had a super high bar after seeing the hype all over social media and the long line every time I'm driving by.. and WOW, I see why people are obsessed! I tried all of the flavors they had available for the day and I can't even pick my favorite because they are all so good. Not only is the ice cream great but the cookie is perfect! A lot of times the cookie is an afterthought.. but not with Sugarwitch! Go asap!! And don't forget to get a pup cup for your dog! read more
4 years ago
Sugarwitch is such a magical little gem! I've been going here since they were in an Airstream outside Olio and I'm so happy they have their own brick and mortar now! Their menu is always changing and doesn't lack on creativity. I have never had an ice cream treat I didn't like there! My kids love the push pop flavors as well. Also, Sugarwitch is extremely inclusive and welcoming to everyone! read more
Page 1 of 3
More info about Sugarwitch
Ask the Community - Sugarwitch
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
2 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
3 years ago
10 months ago
