Thanks to Sugar Hill Subs for this amazing feast for watching the Bills game! Their Buffalo pizza is legit from Buffalo. The crust is just like being up there, their wings are awesome and they're true WNY natives. They were so friendly and so helpful. They even have beef-on-weck, Sahlem hot dogs and Buffalo chicken tenders subs! We can't wait to continue to get more delicious food from you guys! Sugar Hill/Buford residents- you HAVE to check them out. You won't be disappointed! read more

See all

We love this place. It has become a weekly must have. If I worked closer I would be here daily. The food is fresh, good and at reasonable prices. Mike and his daughter, Maddie, run the place and they are great people. Mike also does daily lunch specials and new pizza flavors all the time. You have to try this place! It's worth the time and trip. read more

See all

Excellent Buffalo New York style subs and pizza. The business is under new management and is no longer owned by the Indian family. Instead it is being run by a family from New York, they are keeping the signs the same because they do serve subs as well as pizza. The place is a great place for the casual diner to stop for a slice and an ice on a busy day. read more

The bald man who owns this place is RUDE. Believe the other reviews that say that. No customer service skills. If you're going to call yourself owning and operating a place requiring people skills/customer service skills, you need to actually have them. Not to mention, the food here has been absolutely disgusting to match that attitude as well. We tried to give them another chance and it's just straight up gross. The biggest thing was no seasonings on the gyros like how do you NOT have any flavor on something like that . We know you won't, care but we aren't coming back. read more

Worst pepperoni pizza I have had in years. Do yourself a favor and forget about this place, it's not worth your time or money.

Pizza is wonderful. Love their pepperoni!! Definitely worth driving over to get it!

Delicious Subs and very polite service. I am so glad to see this place is still open after transfer of ownership. Great little "hole in the wall" place to eat. I also love how it is so bright there. I have to try the pizza soon! read more

Sugar Hill Subs is a mom and pop owned sub restaurant that's been around the area since 2010! The owners Anjali and Ron are amazing lovely people and always strive to provide the best quality and service to every customer. I've always seen this restaurant driving by, but once i visited I was hooked! I have become a regular and come every week. There is a wide range of subs, but don't let this deter you from the quality as it is amazing! Anjali ensures they always provide fresh vegetables, a local sourced bakery, and high quality meats! The prices are competitive or even cheaper than neighboring restaurants. There is a daily special rotating sub where you get a sub, with chips and drink at a surprisingly low price. My favorite subs are the Italian, Baja chicken, and cheese steak! Fridays and Saturdays they have a special where they have rotating Indian foods for their special and it's absolutely fantastic. I cannot recommend this place enough! read more

Sugar Hill Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Sugar Hill, Georgia

I wanted a quick sandwich before playing poker (cash then tourney) at Little Kings & Queens. The ratings for this place were excellent, so I went. What really stood out: mom and pop sandwich shop where everyone is friendly. Superb customer service! Tough to find. The other thing that stood out: superb bread. My sandwich was a 4.5 of 5. Cleanliness of restaurant was a 3 of 5, but that gave it character. Customer service and value both easy 5 of 5. Recommended. read more

See all

If you're from Buffalo I would definitely NOT recommend this place. The food was horrible and the owner was very rude. Not sure what he meant by don't tell your friends because we don't need lines around the corner of your friends. The remark was kind of raciest, but maybe I took it wrong way. I never seen a Buffalo slice of pizza with 4 pepperoni ( my friend had 3). As you can see from the pictures this is not Buffalo pizza or subs. How do you make a steak sub with no grill?? I will eat at Subway any day before I eat here again. read more

Sugar Hill Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Sugar Hill, Georgia

See all

Not family owned anymore our beloved couple sold the restaurant due to health reasons and not only did the buyers belittle them they changed everything and raised the prices will not be returning ever and would hope our loyal customers won't either also they charge extra for toppings so sad they won't make it read more

Sugar Hill Subs - Cover shot - Sandwiches Near Me - Sugar Hill, Georgia

Went here on a whim and it was delicious! My girlfriend and I agreed this is our new sub place!

Six years of best of yelpers can't be wrong! As others have testified its a mom and pop shop with Indian( not native American) roots. The owner lady and her husband appear to be the salt of the earth type. Ambiance is clean and quiet with no distracting music. I had the chicken shawarma made fresh to order. Every Friday there is a "special" Indian dish. I will definitely be back to try! read more

See all

The pizza and subs we had (meatball, turkey club, ham) were excellent. Their food is authentic. Mike and employees are so friendly and personable. They involve the kids making it a family experience. We will definitely be back. I highly recommend them! read more

This is legit one of the best sandwiches I have ever eaten. If you want good food go eat here.

My 1st time here. The Ruben hoagie was perfect. Right amount of ingredients, tasted smooth good. The "meats" pizza was awesome. Tasted great. GO BILLS read more

Stopped by today to meet the new owners and have lunch. The turkey sub warmed up with all the toppings was SO good. The sub rolls have that crunchy top/soft inside thing going. Super nice people and it's so clean inside. I'll be a regular customer! read more

Had dinner at sugar hill subs with my family the other night her greek salad is her version, but the taste and the look were outstanding. Love all her food is very tasty. Billy Oliver read more

Sugar Hill Subs - Went and ate dinner the other night she made me a wonderful greek salad! Love it. Billy - Sandwiches Near Me - Sugar Hill, Georgia

My wife and I came by for lunch today for the first time since new ownership took over. We were very impressed! Still has that local family owned vibe and some new features to the menu. The ingredients on our sandwiches and the bread were fresh and delicious. Looking forward to trying out the pizza next time! read more

First timer to Sugar Hill Subs! If you are in the area looking for an upgrade to Subway, give Sugar Hill Subs a try! Its not fancy expensive gourmet subs, but it sure beats the typical subway. They have friendly service, owner was very personable and friendly. They proudly advertise their great Yelp reviews. They offer sandwiches, salads, gyros and hot dog. Even some baked goods. Will consider it again when in the area. read more

See all

I was traveling through the area about to hop on the interstate did not want to get fast food pulled up yelp and saw this place was highly rated. I was a little unsure when I pulled up, but I'm so glad I stopped. Probably one of the best Cuban sandwiches I've ever had! The proprietors are so sweet and helpful. I ended up ordering sandwich platters for a work meeting later that week. read more

My favorite sub shop in all of sugar Hill / Buford. Mom and pops shop with some delicious subs and the friendliest service! If you are in the area and looking for lunch look no more. 5/5 stars! read more

Best sub I've had in a while! I had the pulled pork added a bit of their hot sauce and it was delicious! The owners are delightful, helpful & very much care about the customers experience with their food. The price was more than reasonable which is hard to find these days. Looking forward to coming back soon and trying more of their menu options. read more

Love the service And they're so sweet the food is the best especially the soups I think anyone that loves subs should come here read more

I want to love it! I don't come here often, but this is probably my last time. The prices keep going up (everything is, I know), but the establishment is run down and untidy. I saw they scored an 80, but it was a little hidden to see the details. I like their home made falafel, and chipotle chicken is good and spicy as well. I'll just be taking a long break. read more

Absolutely fire subs and great service. Cozy atmosphere and great spot to enjoy a sandwich. Highly recommend.

Very small clean dining area. The staff was very pleasant and kind. The sandwiches were average

The food here was DISGUSTING. The place was run down, which I was like ok I'll give it a try but I bought sandwiches and salad and the meat all looked like it was old and rotten. I got my husband a CHICKEN sandwich but he said it tasted like FISH / tuna and when he looked he couldn't even tell what the meat was, it was dark like it was rotten. I got gyro and the meat looked rotten also. They make you get ice from a bucket which is very unsanitary and their coke machine didn't dispense any coke. We just threw everything away, which was a waste of money. Not sure why they have so many good ratings, must be fake. read more

Sugar Hill Subs is a gem! The owners, a sweet couple, radiate warmth. But the real stars are their subs--absolutely scrumptious. Each bite is a flavor fiesta. It's a must-visit spot in Sugar Hill, GA. read more

Decided to try this after my son was done with work nearby and really regret it. We've had subs from a dozen or so places but the 3 we got were not that good at all as 2 out of the 3 of us got sick; needless to say we didn't and have no intentions on going back. Publix has subs and they're across from this place - they're also a bit cheaper. #Buford #SugarHill #GwinnettCounty #RestaurantsInGwinnett read more

I have eaten many sub sandwiches here, and every last one of them has been excellent. Prices versus food quality are excellent. Staff who work here are very pleasant, and welcome all guests and visitors to their establishment. If you're in the Sugar Hill area, they are definitely worth checking out, as the sandwiches are mega ultra yummy. read more

Came here for the first time to pick up some dinner and wow, I first get greeted by the owner who was so sweet and welcoming. I initially came for the chicken tikka masala wraps to find out that she only makes Indian food on Fridays. Since she said I wasn't the first person to ask, she will be making it this Friday (WOOHOO!!!) She insisted I try the gyro because it is the most popular thing on the menu, and now I know why. It is seriously so yummy and maybe I'm just on a food high, but the pita bread tasted super fresh and so yum yum in my tum tum. We ordered 2 gyros 2 fries and 1 bowl of broccoli cheddar soup (I added some sriracha sauce for some spiceand OMGGGG SO GOOD). I love to support local businesses and love how friendly and great the customer service was, as well as the delicious food. I will definitely be back. read more

See all

Sugar Hill subs was such a delight! The owner was so welcoming and helpful. She was so proud of the food and options provided, which she should be! Every Friday they offer Indian inspired subs, so of course we had to take part. We ordered the chicken Marsala sub and an Italian sub. The Marsala was ordered on a white hoagie and the Italian was on a wheat hoagie. The breads were so soft and freshly made. The chicken Marsala was like eating a home cooked meal. It was light and very flavorful. The Italian was the best Italian sub we had ever had. I don't know what she added, but there was a reason it was her top seller. We cannot speak better of a sub location. Sugar Hills Sub is a family establishment, which has been around for 8 years. They proudly display the 4 years straight of being a Yelp fan favorite and their local city awards. Come out and support this amazing location. You will not regret the choice. read more

We stopped here while going through town. I would describe it as a better subway. The lady running it was wonderful. Very nice. Food was good. She said they serve Indian food on Friday. I wish we had come on Friday for sure. The place is a little beat up but was fine. I would certainly come again. read more

After living in the area for over 20 years and constantly going by I finally decided to go in and was not disappointed. Just sorry I haven't done it sooner. Wonderful people amazing atmosphere, I've been back many times and will continue to. read more

Love this mom and pop sub shop! Definitely a weekly visit for our office, the club is my favorite!

The food is great, and the owners are friendly. It's a fantastic place to eat lunch.

Absolutely amazing subs, customer service is excellent and the staff is very friendly and helpful, couldn't have a better lunch.

Love the staff and food is fresh and made to order the owners are nice and helpful and patient

Beat all my expectations!!! The sandwiches are excellent but the side menu is what brought me back!!!!