I'm confused about the rave reviews. I think they have good cupcakes but they're not great. I went…read moreto a cookie exchange where people had purchased theirs and they were not very good - lots left over. But, on to the service: we decided to give it another shot, we go in, and the cashier tried to start a political argument with my husband over his benign, apolitical t-shirt that triggered her for some reason. No matter how hard he tried to deflect, she kept insisting on a response. He was nicer than he should have been and didn't let it escalate, but we aren't in a bakery to discuss government policies with a random cashier. The pastries certainly are not good enough to suffer through the proselytizing of the stranger swiping your credit card.

Best tasting cakes and pastries ever!! Very clean and super friendly staff. Don't waste your time…read moreand money on grocery store cakes because the best cake is here!

Creative, delicious drinks and incredible frozen custard! We enjoyed the "Silk Slipper" and…read morespecial-for-the holidays "Sweater Weather" coffees. The cinnamon roll was just the right sweetness, not overkill. So glad that Sourdough Cuppa Joe's revived and partners with Nana's Frozen Custard. We had the cookie custard sandwich, it didn't disappoint. Made on order, we chose the homemade chocolate chip cookies with vanilla custard. So good!! It's a small place, so not tons of indoor seating. One recommendation would be to lower the "table" (shelf) across from the counter, it's a bit too high for the chairs provided. (Not the one pictured.) Highly recommend this place and look forward to going back to try the breakfast and lunch items.

After driving by this place many times I finally stopped by…read more I got a sourdough slice and a cup of custard. They were both incredible. The service was quick and the drive up reminded me of my favorite childhood custard shop! 10/10 recommend and I will be back soon to try more.

Bread & Butter is a gem in Red Bank!…read more Great pastries, bread, service, and ambiance! Highly recommend the breakfast sandwich & the pecan sticky bread. Soooo good!

This bakery wasn't huge, but the selection of both loaves and pastries was intriguing. A few other…read morelocal products dotted the shelves. They were not speedy and there was a line, but that did give me time to eye the various options. Their cookies were impressive, and I noted a little girl asking her mother for a garam masala cookie to some disagreement. I bought one and it was well-received; the more conventional chocolate and salted chocolate chip cookies were also delicious. Progressively better were my bear claw dusted with brown sugar and filled with an indescribable fruity mixture, and my cheesy grit loaf, which was every bit as savory as it sounds. The selection was definitely worth driving up from downtown.

Cindy was super accommodating to my request for hundreds of pies for my wedding. Despite the…read moreweather, she delivered a top notch product that tasted absolutely delicious. We have used Cindy for other occasions since and always have people asking for her contact info for their own events.

Cindy is the most amazing baker we have ever known. Her cakes are something worth driving hours…read morefor. My children (now 12, 14 and 20) always ask for her cakes for events. We now live 2 hours from her but it's well worth it. Not only are her cakes the best in the world Cindy and her husband Danny are salt of the earth. Both of them are full of Faith and positive life. If you need any kind of baked goods call Cindy! Go ahead. Do it NOW!! You're not dialing why? Ok I'll do it for you ......

I love the strawberry cream cheese cake.....it's the only dessert my family wants at gatherings. If…read morethey ever have a mystery bag when you visit, grab it. Of course, the sourdough bread is the best!!!

Clean inside. Tasteless food. Extremely stuck up and snooty people working here. Parking places…read moreare difficult to find because it's right next to Mimi's Deli. Not worth waiting for parking places. Have never been treated nicely here. Staff makes you feel as if you're an imposition. Have never had food from here that tastes like anything. No flavor whatsoever.

You will literally love EVERYTHING about this bakery! The owners are absolutely amazing and loving…read morepeople!! In my opinion, they have the best chocolate chip cookies!! The cupcakes are amazing. The cakes are decorated to perfection!! Buy allllll the things! The shop is decorated sooo beautifully in all seasons/ months!

The unfriendliest bakery I've ever encountered! They acted like we were a disruption to their day…read more The girls finally came out of the back, never smiled or even asked us what we wanted. Just stood there until I asked for something. Even after paying, no "have a nice day" "kiss my foot" nothing. Tried giving them a second chance and it was the same song just a different day. I'll never go back!!!

Great cookie, ok service. nothing bad. also nothing outstanding! How many more words do I need to…read moresay

Well it's not The Cravory. Those were the best cookies ever…read more I'm not really a fan of these cookies. Half the time they're not baked all the way through and that makes for a gross cookie you could possibly get sick from. These cookies are ginormous, too. I have trouble finishing even one. My favorite is the sugar cookie that's always available. It's got a nice thickly-frosted sweet pink topping. The other cookie selections rotate weekly. I haven't liked most of them. They all seem to taste the same. Out of all the others I've tried, it seems as if something is off. The box these cookies come in must be this franchise business's biggest expense. The boxes are weirdly shaped, hard to hold without the box bending and possibly having all your cookies fall out. Hmm. I don't know, I doubt this would ever be a business model I would choose, but if I did I would do the whole store differently.

Love this new little family owned bakery. Everyone is so sweet and the food is very tastyread more