This is in old town Fort Collins so finding parking can sometimes be a challenge. We were fortunate to find something two blocks away. It was Sunday afternoon, but we were after the lunch rush. I was with my husband and daughter for a late lunch. It seemed like there were very few staff on hand. We were greeted and seated promptly, though. I like the layout of the menu with the pictures for their burgers. We started with an order of the cheese curds. It came with chipotle ketchup and we asked for a side of chipotle ranch as well. My daughter chose the Hangover Burger which consisted of a beef burger with American cheese, fried egg, bacon and maple syrup all on a "bun" of two glazed donuts. She paired that with a Unicorn Shake, a mixture of vanilla ice cream, strawberry, cherry and rainbow candy. She loved it! My husband went for the Cream Cheese Jalapeno burger. A beef patty piled high with red onion, shredded lettuce, cream cheese, jalapenos, roasted poblanos, bacon and chipotle aioli. We did question the source for their shredded lettuce and our server explained that it was locally sourced. He thoroughly enjoyed his burger. I went for the Poutine Burger. It was also piled high on a beef patty with greens, red onions, beer-battered cheese curds, demi glace, garlic aioli and crispy sweet potato ribbons. Delish! I would get that one again, for sure. I understand it was due to shorter staff, but the six top behind us was cluttered with the remnants of the previous diners throughout our time there as was a large group space behind it. It seemed as though there were only two people handling customers, food delivery and clean up and they seemed overwhelmed. That was my only caveat for the experience. Our table service and interactions with staff were great though. read more

Walked up.... Had to wait awhile! And the server saw us! Weird!! Got seated... burgers were ok... nothing special Kiddos Ordered shakes... came out plastic cups.... Was expecting in the big glasses! Would have been nice to know it wasent like that. read more

When I heard about the donut burger at Stuft Burger Bar, I had to try it! The hangover burger came with a sweet and savory combo of patty, fried egg, and bacon on a glazed donut. I added lettuce and jalapeños for an added crunch. If you're not into donut burgers, their regular bacon burger is also really good. The burgers are a bit smaller than I thought. Definitely try the garlic parm fries and seasoned fries! The chocolate milkshake was the perfect way to end the meal. Servers were friendly and efficient! Parking is self park on the street and you can explore the downtown area while you're there! read more

Great stop for a simple, classic burger! I loved the pretzel bun on mine and the sweet potato fries were good too. Service was fast and friendly. We sat out on the patio because the inside of the restaurant was quite hot in July read more

Stuft A Burger Bar - Classic cheeseburger with pretzel bun - Burgers Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

Build your own burger! My friend used to go to school in Fort Collins and so she really wanted to go back to this place when she was in town. You get to create your own burger or try one of their own signature burgers. Parking is street parking or you can try and park in one of the lots in the surrounding areas. We were seated right away and placed our drink orders too. Next was the fun part! My friend taught me all about the build your own burger and how we get to choose our toppings and burger and bread. But I could also have picked a signature burger off the menu. I did a classic cheeseburger with Parmesan garlic fries. I chose a single 1/3 pound beef for the patty, with a brioche bun, with American cheese, and bacon aïoli sauce. I didn't realize the bacon aïoli sauce was gonna be spicy, it had a little kick to it so I had to scrape the rest of it off, but the rest of the burger was great! The fries were nice and crisp and had plenty of Parmesan cheese and garlic. I always hate it when they skimp out on the toppings for the fries. I thought it was a little pricey, and looking at their signature burgers, I definitely could've picked one of those and it would've been cheaper. But that's on me for not looking ahead. I think if I'm back on that side of town, I would definitely try going again. read more

See all

Would definitely return to Stuft again if in the mood for a burger! The burgers were very flavorful and cooked perfectly. The French fries were well seasoned and crispy on the outside. The service was fast even during a Saturday afternoon. It is a little small inside so you might have to wait a bit during busier times. read more

See all

Great burgers, friendly staff and good beer selection. Recommend highly. This has become a go to for a good burger for us.

Stopped by with a couple friends for a quick bite and some cold beers. First off we sit in the bar at a high top. I'll just say this - the bartender was less than professional. That's saying it nicely. She was not well groomed and didn't represent this place at all - as a matter of fact, I would say that she was on the edge of gross. Every time she came out from behind the bar, she was shoving french fries in her face. She needs to be replaced. The food was good, overpriced but everything seems to be that way today. Service was outstanding from our server. She was very helpful, very attentive and did a good job. The ambience was OK. It wasn't a cleanest restaurant I've ever been in, I promise you that. But they got the job done for burgers and beers. I probably wouldn't go back, but if you don't do anything else, replace the bartender. I don't know what was going on, but she needs some direction. read more

Attended this locale with some close friends of mine and wife on the lighting ceremony night. For context, this place was pretty busy. The price of this place is just so excessive for the quality. I got the triple threat burger for $20. It was alright. The patties were a bit thin and seemingly unseasoned. The buns were soggy with oil. The cheese was flavorless. I also got the $9 banana milkshake. It was alright but nothing to write home about. It was just an expensive meal for dive bar quality food. The ambience was alright. We sat in the outdoor section and they had some fires which were nice. The inside is all wood and felt like an average bar. The server was nice and was as attentive as she could be given the context. 3/5 Additionally, the portions feel small for what you are paying for. I wouldn't object to coming here again but only if someone else was paying. read more

Food was good but service was horrible. Waitress made multiple snarky remarks and was very rude.

Burgers are trash. Their frozen pre made patties that are dry dry. The cheese curds are absolutely bomb tho. i would go back for the curds but never again for the burger. Staff seemed like they could care less aswell. Five guys is 10X better save your money!!!!! read more

Great burger, great fries, cold beer, and great service. We will be back soon to try more options. Thank you.

I visited this restaurant for the first time a month ago. We were seated fairly quickly. Our waitress was sweet and attentive. The food was good. They did have beyond burgers avaialble if you are vegan. I got it without any bun, though I think they had gf buns available for extra charge. The music was a little loud in the restaurant and it was hard to hear the other folks that i came in with. Prices are also VERY expensive! I bought myself a beyond burger and my son a burger and paid over $60 and there were no fries or salads...... That being the case I likely wont come back. Was happy to give this place a try though! read more

Might be my new favorite burger place! The restaurant was small but comfortable. 5 Stars for the food! They have a great selection of burgers. I ordered the Black and Bleu Burger and it was amazing! Cooked to perfect and bursting with flavor. I haven't had a bleu cheese burger this good in a long time. French fries were also cooked to perfection - so crispy and light! I ordered the garlic parmesan fries and they were pretty tasty flavor-wise but needed more garlic. My husband ordered the Brat Burger (Burger of the month) and said it was really tasty. The kid's burger was good, but could have been cooked more. Service was just okay. Our waitress was attentive at first, but once our food came out, she disappeared. We really wanted salt for our fries, but never saw her again until the end when she offered more water and our check. So that part was super unfortunate. read more

Stuft A Burger Bar - Burgers Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Did not bus their tables until at least an hour has passed with food and crumbs just sitting there. Completely empty, yet our food was ice cold when served and took a whole hour. 100% was forgotten about on the line, missing items like cheese and sauce on burgers?? When you're a burger bar?? no silverware so my grandma genuinely unironically had to skewer her sandwich with the toothpicks !! and we payed 100 dollars!!! for four people!!! come on man read more

Food was mid. Burger was overcooked and sloppily put together. Fries were decent but definitely not the "best". Probably wouldn't go back for the food. HOWEVER, service was exceptional. One waitress taking care of the bar and the whole floor by herself. She was killing it. read more

Moaned out loud that burger was so damn good. Best burger I've ever had omg, and the place is so nice too! Our server Emily deserves a special shout out, she's so fun and kind!! Love this place, will be coming back soon read more

Waited for some time to be seated, 15-20min, server did walk by aunt and I; We were not acknowledged by her at all. When she finally spoke to us she seemed extremely disinterested in working. I got a chocolate chip cookie milkshake. Was extremely disappointed. It tasted like straight milk with chucks of cookie, had no good thickness to it. Really just seemed to be visually appealing only and not for consumption. We ordered fried pickles. They were very flavorless and needed some sort of seasoning to save them. The ranch we asked for was bitter and sweet. My burger was supposed to come out medium well. Came out well done and very dry. The bacon was chewy and didn't have much for flavor. Menu wasn't specific, I asked for pickles and they were actually fried. Menu needs to be more specific or better options. Fried or not fried. My aunt ordered a build your own chicken sandwich. She said it was very dry and flavorless. When she asked for buffalo sauce it came on the side and not on the sandwich, which is not what she asked for. Only good thing we had were Pepsi and the fries. Would not recommend, unless you hate food. Extremely disappointed. Take your taste buds and money elsewhere. Our meal was not at all worth $75. read more

From server recommendation and ordered the jalapeño bites for an appetizer. Only order if you want fried cream cheese. Almost no jalapeño in it. Just a few fine diced jalapeño bits rolled in a cream cheese ball breaded and fried. I now have my daily dose of 1 pound of cream cheese. read more

Stuft A Burger Bar - Burgers Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

See all

This place. Man. The amount of gourmet burgers were insane. Let alone the thousands of options for customizing your own burger with all of the choices they had for build your own. I got the sweet and spicy Hawaiian. Good lord was it amazing. It was sweet and spicy and all of the things. The pineapple on it is fried. Two sauces were amazing. The garlic teriyaki WOW. It had a kick to it but it was the best kind of kick. So delicious. The frites were amazing. Loved the seasoning on them. My husband got the black and blue. Loved it. Our one friend got the same one I got. The other made his own. The cheese curds were decent. They could have a light breading. But good. Great drink selection. Nice staff. Fast service. We would go back for sure. read more

See all

They really knocked it out of the park when my girlfriend and I stopped here on the way to Casper. We got two burgers and they were fantastic. They were so good in fact that I asked to speak to the cook. Andy came out and he was very professional. Would recommend. read more

Stuft A Burger Bar - Burgers Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

Waited 45 minutes to get the wrong order which was pretty crazy given we were one of five customers. The waitress was quick and kind to correct the issue, but our order came back wrong again and one burger was undercooked. We just dealt with it at that point. It may have just been a bad night but paying $40 for two burgers, fries, and a drink after a half off discount for that food does not seem worth it to me again. read more

The place is crazy expensive. Burgers are good. Fries are ok, there was only one waitress working. It was slow at first but then got packed. I've been here before and had a really good burger, this one didn't blow me away, although it could've been my choice of toppings. Service was very very slow, not the waitress fault they weren't staffed better. She did the best she could and was friendly. The absolutely bonkers thing is I can't afford to eat here! For me and my 2 boys, 3 burgers, 3 fries, one app of cheese curds and two small sodas was 89 bucks... read more

I never usually leave reviews on negative experiences but I have to speak my mind on this. I have now been to the place 3-4 separate times and every time I go, the same problem occurs: the food is cold, bland, and leaves an incredible hole in my wallet. The actual restaurant has decent atmosphere and the service is meh, but I can usually look past that...but when your food is expensive AND sucks? Inexcusable. The fact that I have tried 4 different burgers (at 4 different price points) and not a single one had any flavor, anything to set them apart, is abysmal. I cannot fathom spending that on a burger when I can go to literally anywhere else cheaper and know that it'll be better. read more

Burgers are real good here, and the parmesan garlic fries too. I haven't been in to Stuft in a bit here but last time I went, I ordered my usual of the Texas Two-Step and parmesan garlic fries. Though the food was good, the service, on the other hand, was lucklaster. I had to call for another server eventually to cash me out, as I was running late to head back to work from my lunch break. read more

I ordered the spicy bison burger and it is very much worth the cost. The Parmesan garlic fries were good as well but not as flavorful as I had hoped. Service was amazing. It seems like a great place to hangout later at night as well! read more

I had very high hopes for this restaurant, unfortunately the neat looking menu is the best part... ingredients listed on the menu are not what is actually in the product. When mentioned to the server she was quite graceful and removed the item from the check. What really did it in was when I went to the restroom and the cook came out of the stall and didn't wash his hands after using the restroom. Great concept, terrible execution of the menu, and unsafe sanitation practices. read more

Food was good, but asked for a burger with no onions. They brought me a burger with onions - the server took it back to the kitchen and removed the big pieces and brought it back to me saying there was only one onion sliver. I pulled a pile of onions off the same burger and left the pile on the plate. Still got charged full price for the burger. Service is terrible, bordering on contemptuous. read more

We came in on a Wednesday afternoon, no one was in the restaurant so we thought it was closed. After a couple minutes of waiting my brother went back and saw a server in the back and asked if they were open (he asked very friendly and nicely as my brother is one of the sweetest people) and the waitress said yes in a huff and when my brother turned back and walked towards the front she rolled her eyes at him. I made eye contact with her and she rolled her eyes again. My brother didn't realize she did that and she seated us, tossed the menus on the table and walked away. I looked at my brother and said let's go. And we left. Won't be going back again. The burgers could be great and it could have been just an off day but the waitress was so rude to my brother who is a gentle and sweet soul that I would never go back there. We felt like an inconvenience, why would I want to spend my time and money there. read more

Came here to celebrate my anniversary after driving 45 minutes to Colorado and sat down waited 30 minutes and no one came to ask us for drinks or food or anything but yet the tables around us that came in after us had gotten their appetizers and drinks right away and the servers definitely saw us with nothing on the table so it felt very uncomfortable and weird so we left to get Korean bbq down the street ( way better ) . I've worked in fast food and restaurants and the service here was nothing I've ever experienced , just plain bad read more

LOVED THE FOOD. So delicious and the staff was so polite! its the cutest little building!

The food was amazing! I would totally recommend the glaze donut bun! AVA our server was the absolute BEST! Always on top of the drinks, put up with our rowdy crew and gave the best recommendations! Thank you tons AVA!!! read more

Very expensive for a mediocre burger, spent over $100 for 4 people. Really disappointed, I love a good burger.

Delicious burgers with creative topping choices. They were able to accommodate my large party day of ( with a couple of hours warning). I highly recommend! read more

Crispy onion rings and fries were fantastic. Burger was good as well. Nice outdoor patio for the dog and staff was quick to bring us a water bowl. read more

I have been wanting to come here to try a burger with a gluten free bun. I came and sat at the bar. It was around dinner time and it was moderately busy at this time. I noticed that the restaurant was a bit disorganized inside and that there was several table tops (including mine which was never wiped off) with messes on them and restaurant items laying all over. The bartender was nice and eventually got me a soda after he made some drinks for another table. I had to order my burger using my own named ingredients because most of the burgers had ingredients with gluten or dairy in them. My burger was a single patty with lettuce, Mayo, ketchup, mustard, red onions, applewood smoked bacon, and pineapple on a gluten free bun. See my attached picture. The ketchup, Mayo, and mustard came on the side, which took a bit longer for me to take my time and spread it on the bun before eating it. The burger tasted great, and I really enjoyed it. The gluten free bun fell apart on the bottom because of the grease from the burger making it wet. I suggest that the buns are toasted a little if you don't want that to happen. I enjoyed my burger with sprite on tap. I was thinking about getting some fries on the side, but stopped myself after I found out that there is no separate fryer. So I just had the burger. What took away from my experience here? The PRICE. I paid $20 for my burger and a sprite on tap, not including the tip. That is shameful! I could of gone to Texas Roadhouse and had a steak, two sides, and a drink for $20. Here you just get a burger and a little soda on tap. Having prices like this will make less customers come back, like me. Imagine what it would cost if I got some fries and desert? I should be able to get a burger, small side of fries, and drink all-together for $16-17. Even with a gluten free bun. My suggestion, is to go to another restaurant to get a burger. They do make a good burger here, but it's a complete rip-off and not worth it to me. read more

See all

Emily aka Linda is an amazing server! We had great food and service last night! Thank you!

Unique burgers with yummy toppings and sauces. I ordered the bison burger on gf bun. Made exactly the way I asked. The gf bun was the best I ever had. Our server Darcy was very nice and helpful. read more

The cheese curds, burgers and atmosphere, would definitely return. Ava and Fred did a great job!

This place was just ok. Came on a Saturday night for a burger and fries. I got the blackberry mojito and it was mostly ice, and couldn't taste any alcohol in it (I'm not a big drinker so I usually can tell if it's strong or weak). Husband got a beer that was flat. It's nice to fill out the little paper if you want to make your own kind of burger, so you know it'll get made how you want it. That's what I did. The veggie patty was not good though. It's nice they have a vegan option but they should hop on the Beyond or Impossible burger train. Their house made patty tastes like carrots. The fries were delicious so they get for the fries but I wouldn't go back just for fries. Husband said his burger was good and that the Parmesan fries were delicious. Covid protocols barely exist here, there are safer places to eat. No one asking people to wear masks walking to and from tables, staff with masks below nose and mouth, even while behind the bar. I always wonder if this is how a restaurant shows their safety protocols I wonder what is happening in the back where we can't see them? read more

See all