Sexy Sammies is nestled in Johnston Plaza which has a lot of great eats and this place had good rating on Yelp and Google. It has nice outdoor seating with a cornhole play area. Walking in you see a clean restaurant, welcoming music and a dark moody atmosphere. The ladies at the front were nice and welcoming. Their menu has everything a chicken tendie fan could want. Sandwiches, tenders and salads with a variety of flavors, seasonings, and hotness. They also have grilled and veggie options for the chicken as well. The chicken was fresh and juicy that pairs nicely with their pickles and sauces ("sexy sauce" was my favorite). The highlight for me was the Fancy Sam sandwich which had mac and cheese, see pic. At this point I was ready to give them a 5-star rating; However, there were a couple issues. Firstly, their fries and mac and cheese by themselves were lacking. They were both bland that relied heavily on the sauces to be good and the fries I was served tasted old. Second, both my salads were missing several key ingredients, wontons and bacon respectively. In a competitive area for food but very solid chicken place that I could see myself eating at again. read more

See all

First time eating here. I do like to have the option to order from a screen but I also like to be able to order from a person as well. The front feels a bit cold in that tyete are 3 screens... no person to order from or cash register. We ordered and it took a bit to get our food but we were not in a hurry. There are several tables to sit and eat as well as covered outdoor area. The food came out hot and was very good. The chicken tenders were good size and were tender and tasty. The fries were seasoned and good. There are several sauces and we tried 5 of them. The house sauce was our favorite. For drinks, you get your cup and serve yourself. They had Thai Tea which was a nice option. The portion sizes are generous. There are salads, sandwiches, tenders and a few different sides. Good place for some chicken. Go check them out. read more

See all

The way our experience started might have been a sign. The ordering kiosk didn't work and someone had to come out and take our order the old fashion way. She couldn't make it work either. The food was OK. Not much different than other chicken tender places. The sandwich was dry. Nothing remarkable or sexy about the food. Regretfully, the price was outrageous for the quality of food and service. Won't be back. read more

See all

Delicious, juicy chicken. Service was quick - ordered to go and everything was packaged well!

Absolutely great chicken sandwich, love the Thai tea as well, good price, good service. I'd give it a 5/5

Sexy Sammies puts any other wing/chicken stop to shame. Their chicken actually tastes like chicken, lightly breaded and full of flavor. The staff is always friendly and attentive. Highly recommend! read more

Sexy Sammies Johnstown - Dining Area - Chicken Shop Near Me - Johnstown, Colorado

Sammie's is the best chicken around! Excellent service every single time! I have been waiting to make this review for a while but I just wanted to be sure that I was right. After 2 years of eating at Sexy Sammie's, it is by far the best and most consistent chicken restaurant in northern Colorado. Everything on the menu is amazing. My girlfriend and I have shared so many good memories at Sammie's and have always left asking ourselves when we were coming back because it's that good! Thank you Sexy Sammie's you are our favorite restaurant read more

Amazing!!! Thank you Alex & staff for the great service and delicious meal!! I appreciate you accommodating my lettuce wrap request." CFL", yes! Customer for life!! read more

Sexy Sammies Johnstown - Chicken Shop Near Me - Johnstown, Colorado

See all

Service was amazing the man at the front greeted every single person coming through the door. They got through the line fast offering kiosk ordering as well as person ordering. I got the new "girl dinner" which is so clever. Tender fries and a salad! The store was clean, great space. Highly recommend. read more

Sexy Sammies Johnstown - New menu item combo "girls dinner" - Chicken Shop Near Me - Johnstown, Colorado

Food was alright. Probably slightly over priced. The main issue is I ordered my food, then went to the liquor store for booze AND and Firestone to shop for new tires. In that time there was zero progress on my food. I still came back to the shop and waited 15 more minutes after shopping elsewhere to get my food. There were a total of 6 other people in the shop... this was not a busy time. Please never come here if you have anywhere else to be. 1+ hours for a sandwich is bullshit. read more

We tried sexy samies for the first time . It wasn't bad . For it being our first time it was a bit different than chick-fila . But trying new foods is always good. We enjoyed the service it was a bit confusing at first when we ordered on the kiosk but the staff showed us how to do it. read more

Staff was friendly and very helpful, restaurant was clean, service was quick and food tasted really fresh. They had a good selection of food and drinks. We ordered the BBQ Bacon Jalapeno Sam, the K-Sam, and the Nashville fried pickles. Those pickles were the best fried pickles I've ever had! Spicy but realllly good flavor. The BBQ Sam was so good! My husband and I ended up just sharing that sandwich. The only downfall was the K-Sam, the soy sauce was super overpowering, it just takes over. We found it super salty and just unpleasant to eat. So unfortunately that sandwich was a waste :/ Other than that, we would definitely recommend! read more

We got the chicken tenders - original. They were okay. Overcooked and Dry. The Nashville hot tender was good. Fries and Mac and cheese were good. Mac and cheese is different than any other place I've gotten it. Service was friendly and good. Sauces were really good. read more

literally how was this almost $12 so mid everything was soggy the fries were ok probably would've been better if they weren't drenched in sauce like that read more

Sexy Sammies Johnstown - Chicken Shop Near Me - Johnstown, Colorado

See all

We just ate here again for the 2$ special they ran. What an amazing job the staff did at keeping the table clean and the soda area with condiments clean and organized. Cleanest bathrooms for fast food I've ever encountered...especially for how busy they were. And to the kitchen: Bravo - out of the ball park tasty. Well done to all the crew! read more

Not a fan of the kiosk order at a restaurant, but this place was a little different experience. The manger was there at the counter greeted us, very friendly and professional. Helped us through the menu and asked if we needed anything. The food took a really long time to come out and needless to say the appetizer came out with the meal or at least came out with my wife's meal, my on the other hand took another 10 minutes to come out. There was a huge portion of fire pickle and although we got the mild "Sweet Heat" they were still really spicy, but man great flavor. Since my meal took so long to come out, I was full on pickles before it came, I could not finish and took home 2 out of 3 strips. The Mac and cheese was not bad could taste red peppers. Just not a fan of the kiosk order and then is asks for a tip. At this place the gentleman at the counter is the main reason this was positive experience. I'd come back and just not get the spicy supposed mild version. read more

See all

I LOVE sexy Sammie's so much, the food is so good and the fries are the best fries that I've ever had. The service is so good and friendly and even my mom liked it and she's not much of a chicken tender person. The employees are super kind and they make it so simple to order. Our food comes out really fast compared to other restaurants and the chicken is super juicy and the chicken is crispy too. The drinks are so good as well. I always get the cherry lemonade and it's one of my favorite drinks to get every time I go there. Yes the prices are a bit pricey but it's worth it. And I love the options that they give us if we only want a two piece. 5/5 I recommend this place to people who are trying to try new foods. And their bread is perfectly buttery and soft but hot read more

Chicken tenders and fries were really good and fresh! Lots of sauces to choose from; I really enjoyed the sexy sauce. Staff was friendly and the restaurant was clean. read more

The food was very good then have so many sauces to try. The manager is so welcoming he explained the whole menu and made it easy for us to order. The place is supper clean read more

My husband and I have been in several times and have never left disappointed. We have tried their salads, sandwiches and tenders. Their fries are the BEST!!! The perfect crisp, and always hot. Sauces are house made and delicious. The chicken is consistently moist, perfectly tender and outside crispy with not a thick coating. Staff is always friendly and eager to assist. Do let the kiosks fool you, the staff are ready to help in anyway. Easy, casual dining that has always been clean every time I have gone in. read more

Came here last night for the first time and we were thoroughly impressed!! Staff was super friendly and helpful the second we walked in the door. Had to take our order on the kiosk, which personally I do not mind. Staff helped us with questions we had. Got seated and enjoyed the ambiance of the place. It was super clean and the space was GREAT - it didn't feel like we were sitting on top of another group. Got our food in a very timely fashion. The salad was delicious - HUGE!!! The mac and cheese was phenomenal and paired super well with the chicken sandwich. Would definitely recommend, and we will be back! read more

Sexy Sammies Johnstown - Hot Mac 'n Cheese Sam Nashville Hot Chicken Salad - Chicken Shop Near Me - Johnstown, Colorado

I walked in and started my order at the kiosks on Saturday 11/16/24 at 5:30pm. The manager was yelling at the staff in the kitchen to "come on and hurry up!" while clapping his hands and screaming "I will turn off your music if you can't work faster" and other berating phrases. The staff should not be treated with such aggressive disrespect. I chose not to spend my money there and left without ordering. read more

Passing by on Mother's Day and decided to try something we never had. We walked in to a clean super pleasant environment. Greeted by Alex, first asked if we had been in before. When we said No, he explained the whole process, also offered to take our order if that was more comfortable. He explained breaded and grilled veggie option. He politely told everyone welcomenina and everyone good bye and thank you. The hospitality was above and beyond. Even checked on us at our table. Thank you Alex because of you. We will be back. read more

This is the best chicken shop in Colorado in my opinion. I have been to the one in Greeley many times, and this Loveland location does not disappoint. Extremely helpful staff. And flavorful, fresh chicken makes this restaurant stand out read more

We tried this place twice recently as we don't have a good chicken place near us. 1st we tried the Mac n cheese Sammie. It was ok. Pimentos were a little weird. The main issue was the chicken. It tasted dry and boring, not juicy. The second visit we just tried the chicken tenders (8). There were actually 10 on the plate. We didn't really need 8, but 4 wasn't enough. If the chicken tenders we better than the last visit, this may have been a good thing. Dry, not juicy, chicken. The ranch dressing was good. It also tasted like we were getting "B" grade chicken. Canes is way better. I am disappointed and likely will not return. read more

This place was amazing the servers and owners were very welcoming and inviting. Chicken was both juicy and packed with flavor.

This is one of our new favorites. The staff is always very kind and the food is good. They have options to order a family meal for pretty affordable. It feeds our family of 5 with one order. read more

I got the new Korean Sand. It was so Salty..... I don't know if it was the breading or the sauce but is was so salty that I could not eat my meal. Theres no way anyone would be able to eat this. Typically, the Chicken is perfect. Today was not it! read more

Super friendly server, delicious food. Absolutely will come back. Classic spicy Sammy wasn't too hot.

This place is proof that you can just shit a chicken sandwich and people will come. Everything at this place comes from a squirt or a freezer. Even the drinks suck. I don't know how you can screw up root beer but they did. I don't expect they are getting any return customers. First timers only. read more

Absolutely bomb food. Every experience I've had here has been positive. The staff is always friendly.

Yummy sandwiches! Could've been a little spicier but still had a ton of flavor. I'd go back

The food was absolutely delicious. It tasted extremely fresh and the drinks paired perfectly with the food. It was my first time at this establishment and it felt extremely welcoming. I got help with every step of ordering my food and all my questions were answered. The environment of the store was great and the lobby was very clean. 10/10 would recommend to anyone who loves chicken. read more

Outstanding customer service and atmosphere!! First review of my Yelp life but man glad I waited for this place!