I love the fluffy Sicilian slice. It was soooo airy and really reminded me of what scarrs used to…read morebe. Personally I didn't love the elote sauce, it was a bit too salty for me. The regular slice was good, but could be a bit more crispy. It is quite thin and I think their tomatoe slice might be better with more marinara sauce. Overall I think this is a great pizzeria and very family friendly---saw like three strollers. I would come back to try the tomatoe slice and the Sicilian again!

Best slice I've ever had. Got a plain and pepperoni slice here and both were excellent. Crust is…read moreperfectly crispy and tasty. The sauce is great, really nice flavor. And they have the right amount of cheese (not too much)! You don't realize how good a slice of pizza could be, will definitely be back. Small store but they do have seating and are very friendly. Easy to pop in for a slice.

Stopped by around 5:15pm on a Friday and it was super empty, only 2 other people in the restaurant…read morewith no line. Staff were so friendly and helpful! The texture of the pizza is fantastic! Fluffy, thin, and crispy. The pizza was great but did not have enough mozzarella sadly. There a couple slices that barely had any cheese and was mostly just tomato sauce. It would've been amazing with a little more cheese. We also got the butter beans as a small plate but those were sooo disappointing. It felt like they had just opened a can of beans and put some salt and pepper on top?? Please do not get these. Especially for $15. Beans are the reason the rating is a 3 not a 4.

Great artisnal style of pizza. Came in at 9pm. And the restaurant was still lively…read more Great Playlist of music and wine selection was extensive. Love the acidity of the sauce and the crust was great. Wil definitely return. Reservation is highly recommended.

Tony's has the best pizza with a crispy slice and that sweet sauce and salty cheese. True Brooklyn…read moreslices served fresh and delicious. Specialty square slices are what dreams are made of. Get the Sicilian square slice if they haven't sold out of it. Get the spaghetti and meatballs if you want to live forever.

The pizza was burnt and you know not fresh! The day was extremely hot and the inside was like an…read moreoven. I should have gone with my instinct to leave. Gave the local place the opportunity for my business. Since it was so hot I asked for a cup of ice. I was charged $1.04 for a less than half a cup of ice. If I sat in the restaurant would the water be free? Warning ‼ with all the restaurants on graham- never ever again!!

At least a 4.2 for this place because PG's NY slices are better than most I've tried in Manhattan…read more Overall first impression of Paulie Gee - Oh gee, a C rating from the health department but it seems like it's been outdated. But overall, the place was pretty clean to me. The front is hotter, the back with more tables and seats are well air-conditioned. The cheese slices look like a big tampon with an extended crust that's 2" long without sauce. I've never came across a slice with this look in the city, but these cheese slices are definitely bigger than my face and I am for it. The sauce is not overly sweet and bottom is evenly baked. There are lots of regulars there and the line didn't stop the second we walked in. And people order in pies. The pizza is great and they even have squared ones and vegan options. The only complaint I have about this pizzeria is the fact that you gotta order it via a cashier, where the lady likes to talk. I find that slowed down the line a bit, and if you're pregnant and feeling hot and bothered like me in the store, you're not gonna like it. Otherwise, I'd definitely recommend the pizza, either eat it in the back where it is cooler or take it across to the park from the shop.

Have been meaning to try Paulie Gee's and I finally made it…read more I don't agree with anyone who has them in their top ten or anything crazy, but it is a very solid slice. I got the vodka and pepperoni sicilian. Both were delicious. Next time I would probably skip hot honey on the pepperoni. It was messy and the slice tastes fine on its own!

The Burrata pizza is mind blowing. It looks pretty & calls you to demolish it. There's a giant blob…read moreof burrata right in the center that you gently cut & smother the creamy cheese. The sauce is great too, although I would have liked a spicy kick as the creaminess from burrata makes the sauce a little bland. Biggest complaint for this pizza is the crust. It's way too thin and simply cannot hold the weight if the burrata. So it gets challenging to eat it. We also ordered Old Bay fries which were decent. Burrata lovers head to Macchina now!

I picked up 2 to share pies on my way home recently. I had called pretty close to closing for a…read morepick up order and the staff were really kind about it and still agreed to make it. I got the Burrata pizza and the foraged mushroom pizza. They both hit the spot after a long day, especially with such a last min order placement. The ingredients tasted fresh and they were both really filling.

This is a small spot and maybe can fit about 20 people at the tables and more at the bar. The staff…read moreis very accommodating and sat us promptly at the last 2 open seats. We arrived just before the rush. The salad was fresh and the pizza delicious. I especially liked the white pizza and would love to eat here again when in the area.

Two stars so they take this review seriously and not maliciously. A lot of problems with this place…read morethat I had been wanting to try for a long time, but was left very disappointed. First off, waited over 15 minutes for a glass of wine and a beer and a shot. Mind you the place was not crowded. Fine things happen I understand. Secondly, the cheese "bar pie" we ordered, was horrible, I'm not be hyperbolic. It was disgusting. Seemed to have been frozen dough? The dough was not thin, and the center was visibly uncooked when taking a slice. Third and finally, the wait staff was also bad. I order a bar pie, eat one and a half slices, don't ask for a to go box, ask for the check and they just think that's normal? As a former server, waiter etc, if you see someone doesn't touch the food AND THEN doesn't ask for a to go box AND THEN don't ask if they had a problem, that's an issue. I don't want to give a bad review for the waiters. Maybe they know this place is mismanaged but at the same time, do the right thing. In this area, a place like this will be dead in 4-6 months with all the issues they have. There are at least 4 pizzas places a stones throw away that put this place to shame, it's a NOs general for me dawg.

The food was excellent and so was the service! Great salads and pizzas! Ambiance is cute and cozy.read more

We just left this place with my stomach turned upside down! I found a life roach in our salad. If I…read morecan give them a 0 star I would. How disgusting we were celebrating the 4th of July with a nice dinner & completely ruined it. I just hope I don't get food poisoning now. I don't know how this business is still in business. Just be careful and look at your food before eating it.

Got the New Haven ish pizza, vodka, and their white…read more For me personally Vodka: 5/5 New Haven: 4/5 White: 2.5-3/5 (the rest of the group I was in really liked this one, but I just found it too sweet) Overall though it's a good pizza place and they have other pizzas as well definitely recommend giving it a try!

We decided to stop by after a YouTube influencer ranked this as her #5 pizza spot in the…read moreneighborhood. And honestly? The pizza was good. We tried the jalapeño and garlic, plus the pepperoni with hot honey. Super thin crust, around $36 a pie, and definitely enjoyable. Today, we ordered again through Square, their preferred online ordering system. When you open the site, you're greeted with multiple warnings: orders are only ready at the selected pickup time, all sales are final, and so on. I placed my order without realizing the earliest available pickup was 7:40 p.m. About an hour and ten minutes later. That's on me. With two hungry kids at home, I should have paid closer attention and probably ordered elsewhere. I texted the number listed on their website to see if there was any flexibility and received this response: "Hey sorry I'm trying to explain it as clearly as possible I'm not trying to be curt. We don't take phone orders. We can't change pickup times. The shop is slammed right now that is why the next available pickup is 7:40. That is when your pizza will be ready." Borderline Pizza Nazi? Maybe. But I get it. They have a business to run, margins are thin, and efficiency matters. What I found ironic was that the pizza wasn't actually ready at 7:40. Pickup ended up being about 20 minutes later than the promised time. So, Chrissy, if you're reading this: I'm trying to explain it as clearly as possible I'm not trying to be curt, but the pizza was ready 20 minutes after the pickup time I was given. Look, the pizza is fine. The operation is clearly busy. In this town though, great service and great food go hand in hand. Surviving's easy, thriving's going to take some doing. Good luck with the pizza business. I will not be eating here again.