I have enjoyed Straw Hat Pizza in Exeter for the past five years. Last night unfortunately, that changed. We ordered a large 3 topping pizza, with the discounted coupon it cost $23. I was at once reminded of Chuck E Cheese pizza as I lifted the box lid. For those of us who remember their pizzas weren't surprised by the lack of quality. It was expected. You were paying for the experience of the little ones so you ate bad pizza. Our pizza was also reminiscent of "Drive In - Movie" pizza - the smell being the best part of a less than satisfying dining experience. Our pizza was insignificantly smeared with sauce, and the only accurate way to describe the cheese was sparse. I no longer frequent Chuck E Cheese. My kids are grown. Drive In Theaters are merely nostalgic. I prefer tasty pizza. I write this review in hopes that my experience was a fluke. Perhaps a busy night or new staff members. read more

Straw Hat Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, California

The cashier was super nice and super friendly and great! The pizza is super huge and tasted fresh with a huge array of delicious toppings like bell pepper, pepperoni and sausage. I ordered The Works. An amazing deal for $40. Loved dipping my pizza in the ranch too. Amazing crunch in the crust and generous ratio of topping. read more

Straw Hat Pizza - Super yummy The Works - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, California

I've had some of the best pizza from here and some of the worst. Apparently it depends on the dough guy. The staff is always great read more

Straw Hat Pizza - They don't have thin crust, so this was the regular pizza. The cauliflower crust wasn't this thin. - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, California

We had a large party, and this was one of the only restaurants in Exeter area that could handle it. Making a reservation was easy, they handled the food order perfectly... and everyone was very friendly. For a neighborhood pizza parlor, I don't see any way this place could be any better! The pizzas were also fresh & tasty read more

The food was fresh and hot. We ordered hot wings. They were delicious. We also purchased two salad bars very fresh they make homemade ranch dressing. The service was wonderful. They had the football game on the big screen. Everybody had a good time. Definitely would go there again. They have great customer service.! read more

We were visiting from out of town and stopped here. All the staff was super beyond nice and the food was amazing. A bottle of ranch at the table without asking?! What?! Thank you! We also got beer and wine which was great. read more

Tried the pizza and the wings. Wings were pretty fatty and pretty light on actual meat. Not very flavorful either. Pizza was at least a bit better. It was decent, but definitely nothing to write home about. Kinda dry and toppings weren't very fresh. Overall, it's not "bad" but not very good. It's just decent. read more

First off... Alexis there sucks, not great to leave a review when you're actively IN the restaurant fuming over what was most likely a mistake. Now, I'm giving this place 5 stars because I like it and would like to see it stay open because I believe this straw hat to be above your average straw hat but, the staff here is severely undertrained. They are usually overwhelmed and I've seen them make mistake after mistake. My advice? How about we staff a couple of adults. Not 16-22 year olds but how about 1 fully grown adult who has experience speaking with the general public? Anyway, do better guys.. read more

Delicious pizza! I found Straw Hat Pizza when my toddler requested pizza for lunch. The kids went crazy in the arcade, the pizza was bomb and Kristie, our server, was super sweet and helpful. We've found our new favorite pizza joint anytime we're in Exeter. I highly recommend. read more

I ordered "the works" and substituted the bell peppers with jalepenos. The pizz was really great. Soft crust, savory toppings, and plenty of them. The girl at the register was sweet and accommodating. Also, great beer selection (but I did not dine in). In my opinion, the negative reviews are not a true reflection of this pizza parlor and I question their validity. Give it a try and see for yourself! read more

Best pizza, hands down. Round Table, Me-N-Ed's, and all the other chains do not even compare. The others have gone down in quality and they're never consistent. With Straw Hat, I always know what to expect. And they're not greedy with their toppings. For example, with Round Table (Porterville) I order green bell peppers on my pizza and they put maybe one or two (if I'm lucky) small strips on each slice. Only bad thing about Straw Hat Pizza is that they don't have a restaurant in Porterville. read more

It was great, traveling thru the Central Valley, to find a Straw Hat Pizza! They chain went out of biz decades ago in SoCal. Had to stop. Tasted just the same. Same sauce. Same thin crust. Same cheese. Yum! And we could even sit down and eat at a table Only negative is served on the cheapest paper plates from 99 cent store. read more

Sooo.. this is on Visalia road... not IN Visalia...I think some of these are about the straw hat in visalia lol this one is in Exeter This pizza here has only gotten better since the new owners took over! Salad bar is bomb! And I've never been charged for ranch.. that's the other one read more

Straw Hat Pizza - I think this speaks for itself - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, California

Straw hat pizza is always very yummy, and I absolutely LOVE their huge salad bar. Great family-friendly place for a meal.

Made a online order when they were closed and didn't know it and talk to the manager forgot her name but when I was on the phone with her she was hella rude telling me that She already refunded my money but infant she didn't .... THIS PLACES LOVE TO JUST TAKE YOUR MONEY id get better service at little Cesar's than this nasty pizza place 0/10 don't recommend at all read more

Amazing place! It's got good decoration and an arcade! The pizza was delicious, and the manager was friendly! It's a great place to eat if you are hungry in Exeter. read more

My favorite pizza in Visalia area! Most of the pizza places here have greasier tasting pizza whereas pizza here is more sauces and zesty :) Also customer service is really great here read more

I have been getting Pizza here for many many years. Great pizza, friendly staff. Consistant pizza . Soda is always fresh. Salad bar is always good. read more

Pizza was yummy and the salad bar was so fresh and yummy. Thank you Lisa and Gary, it was great seeing you guys. Y'all need to go eat at Straw Hat in Exeter. I didn't even know Exeter had a Straw Hat. But since you guys took it over last November, it's on my list of favorites read more

Some of the worst pizza I've ever had. Everything tasted artificial. Little Caesar's is better taste for a 1/3 of the price. Trash pizza trash! read more

I drove from Lindsay thinking I was gonna get a quality product. I checked on the pizza and it looked like a baby made it. One mushroom on each slice.i went back in and talked to the guy who made it. Told him that was a disgrace. a 3 dollar pizza has more toppings. He looked frustrated and about to cry so I left the pizza there and walked out. read more

Sadly, stopped ordering from them years ago. Not because the pizza is bad, but because of customer service. I don't know if it was the owner, or what but she was rude often. Especially,calling for a delivery. If my memory is correct, they don't deliver until after 6pm. I understand that...I called on a Sunday for a delivery learning this 5mins 'til and was told to call after 6. I get it to a point..but she was Rude..so never called back again. It was the Straw that broke the Camels back for me. (Figuratively and Literally) Now I order from VIP..Pizza is Great and Service is Awesome!! read more

The pizza is great! Just the right amount of sauce, perfect crust. Not too doughy, nice crunch. Groovy twists are awesome! Salad bar is fresh. Employees are super helpful and friendly. read more

Straw Hat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, California

Pretty disappointed in the customer service; it was slow and they weren't very gracious. The pizza was cold and we showed up at the exact pick uptime... had to put in the oven when we got home. I remember eating here growing up and have gone to other locations; this was not the hot and delicious pizza we use to have. read more

We stopped here after a long day hiking at the national park. The pizza was excellent. We especially loved the crispy crust. Service was quick and friendly. Next time we're in town, we'd stop and eat here again. read more

Have never been a fan of the pizza here and this afternoon I remember why. I came in for the lunch buffet with my friend only to be told that it ends at 2. The large signs all over the store say that the lunch buffet is good until 3pm. When my friend and I brought this to the lady taking our orders attention she seemed embarrassed, flustered and unsure what to do or say. My friend told her that if they advertise until 3 then they should honor it. She just replied sheepishly, that it's management's fault for not changing the time on their menus and signs. I ended up ordering 2 small salads from the salad bar and a personal pepperoni pizza. The salad was the crappiest display I have ever seen at a pizza joint, and that's saying something. Semi wilted lettuce, olives, chopped eggs, cheese, dressings and potato salad was all that they offered at the salad bar. No tomatoes, bell peppers, onions, carrots or any other salad makings were available. The pizza came out about 10 minutes later and it looked and tasted pretty much like a tony's frozen $1.99 pizza, only half the size. Was not impressed in the slightest. My entire meal of 2 small one trip salads, and a itty bitty personal pizza was over $18! Cannot think of a good reason to return again. The only reason I was generous enough to give 2 stars is because the young lady taking our order was attempting to be friendly. read more

We ordered a chicken bacon ranch it was wonderful! The staff is amazing and gave us extra ranch and jalepenos! We loved it a home grown feel and the food was amazing! Thanks to the staff and the owner soooooo good! read more

We Love everyone who works here. All of them really take pride in keeping the place clean, and comfortable. It's funny, we go there so often the staff is practically family. read more

What a great experience! I was tired and hungry from a long road trip looking to feed my family Let me start by saying I don't write reviews however, I felt I had to write about my experience at this straw hat pizza. The staff was really friendly and truly interested in doing a great job. After placing my order I wanted to change it and they went out of their way to make me happy when they didn't have to. The place was clean and the food good at a pretty good price. I consider myself a pizza aficionado and their pizza is right up there. If you're looking for pizza in this town, I'd really suggest here. read more

I want to know for the last year and a half every time I want to have a pizza delivered it takes over an hour and a half to get it that is asinine. read more

Yuck. Decided to try it again after years given the higher rating than VIP (where we usually order). Will be going back to VIP. Straw Hat's sauce is weird and so is the cheese they use- cheddar on pizza? Tastes like it's made with the cheapest of ingredients and skimpy on toppings. Leaving this review to remind myself not to try SH again. Honestly, a DiGiorno's is better. read more

Straw hat pizza is awesome they have gluten free pizza they also have gluten free wings that are fabulous they put some really great premium beers on tap as well as your normal beer they have new owners the place is pleasant clean and they have daily specials as well as happy hour on Wednesday and Thursday night you need to go check out the new straw hat... And meet the new owners Kim and Mike read more

The pizza is not bad... but it is not the greatest either. The dough and the crust were tasty and baked just right... but the sauce and the cheese were kind of tasteless. But, it was hot and hit the spot :) And the people who work there are really nice and they did a good job of giving the place a fun vibe (juke box, arcade games, tv, posters everywhere). read more

I been going to this place every couple of weeks and tried all sorts of different topping on the pizza. This place is consistent. Pizza is always good and doesn't matter what you order. I would recommend people to try this place out when they are here read more

Pizza was pretty good,however if you wanna wait so long and watch a Netflix episode then come here lol but too much of a wait not worth it when your hungry. read more

Horrible customer service. Food isn't bad though if you don't mind waiting. Also, I went in to pay with my card and they told me to go get cash. read more

The pizza gets hard and cold within ten minutes. So if you don't eat it right there inside you might as well expect a brick to be delivered to you. read more

Excited to have Straw Hat back in Visalia. Reminds of my high school days! Pizza is fresh and tasty. I wouldn't recommend the garlic cheese bread though. It's just cheese and garlic in a sandwich roll. Pretty lack luster there but otherwise great. read more

Pizza was okay but the manager (younger lady) was completely rude. She was so rude I almost walked away but visiting family in Exeter. I would not recommend to friends or family. read more

In my opinion, the best pizza in Exeter. Good pizza/value as far as chain restaurants go. Now I know what I am having for lunch. Again.