We were surprised how big the inside was. The prices are reasonable and the food was good. We split a pizza to have half and half toppings after we couldn't make up our minds and the cashier said they could easily split the pizza. Great solution. read more

Stevie's Pizza - The solution when you can't make up your mind. - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

It's okay. Nothing special. Shame Arizona on west side really doesn't have good pizza

A pretty good pizza spot with a nice lunch deal. There was a nice balance between the sauce and the crust. I enjoyed the pepperoni but wasn't a big fan of the sausage. The flavor was pretty good, just not anything great. The atmosphere was welcoming. The staff were friendly and helpful too. If I was in the area I would come back to grab a couple slices for lunch. 3*** = Good but no separation from similar restaurants read more

See all

I've been coming here at least once a week forme about 5 years in the winter. We're snowbirds from oregon. Almost every time I bite into a pepperoni and Italian sausage with jalapeños, I just shake my head being amazed at how good it is. I love pizzas from about 3 places here and in oregon, but I think this is my favorite. read more

Stevie's Pizza - Pepperoni, Italian sausage and jalapeño and a nice cold kilt lifter. - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Tried the $12 Chicken parmesan sub with mixed results. The bread was soggy and the sauce was average, but the cutlets themselves were good. They were sliced on ths sub. Wouldn't get it again. read more

Stevie's Pizza - $12 lunch - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

I have been coming for years . Love their eggplant, pizza is always satisfying. The staff is just amazing! read more

The service and the food are both great. We live near here and definitely need to get over here more often!! read more

Stevie's Pizza - We did a make your own, pepperoni and sausage with green peppers on half. Delicious. - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Solid Pizza Place in Vistancia. I got a chicken parm sub and some cheese pizza to split. The sub was pretty good overall, but the pizza was the star of the show. It was cooked pretty well and the cheese tasted fantastic. My only feedback is that the crust was a little too crispy for my liking. Overall great spot! read more

The worse pizza I ever had and paid a lot of money for it. Not the kind of place I would sit down and eat.

I'm frequently in this area for business and will always stop here for lunch. Always the pizza/drink combo. Always tastes great. Well seasoned and cooked just right. Today I thought I would change it up and asked for the Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich. Man o man. I'm from South Jersey and I know what a Philly is supposed to taste like. Stevie's nailed it! Delicious! read more

The white pizza is always awesome . I love far from location so by the time I get home I put in oven to reheat and it's still Soo yummy!

I ordered dinner for my family and me, which was 2 pizzas, garlic bread, and 10 boneless wings. I ordered online, and it said the order would be done in 35 minutes. We arrived a bit early so we went in to get drinks at the Safeway next to the restaurant. We shop around for a bit and then go into Stevie's to pickup the order. At this point it's about 50 minutes since we ordered and I was told the order was not ready. I asked the eldest employee on staff tonight (06/07/2025) if they were running behind and she told me that the order just didn't print out for them. This was a bold faced lie because I saw the young girl at the front bring my pizzas out before she noticed the garlic bread and boneless wings were not prepared. They then started making these items, where we had to wait with a car full of kids for another 10 minutes. They finished the order bagged it up and tied it. I checked the pizzas and they were fine so we went on our way. We got home, sat down to eat and when we opened the wings they were completely opposite of what we ordered. They gave us traditional bone-in wings instead of boneless. I assume this happened because they were scrambling due to being so late on the order already. When called all they could do is credit us a 10 pc boneless wing for our next trip to them. My family will be taking our business to Barros or Vs tap room for good pizza from now on. read more

Their spaghetti is delicious and you get a lot of it. My son loved their pizza. It's hot when you get it. The people are courteous and friendly Definitely worth the price read more

There Margarita Pizza and even their Cheese pizza is really good. Closest so far to the real NY Style pizza. Would highly recommend trying them. We order from the one in Vistancia. One more thing there cannoli's are great too. read more

Not only are they all so kind, but they're accommodating. My son has celiac disease so he can't have gluten. He can't even have cross contamination of gluten. They washed everything and cleared away anything that might have it in it and made him a pizza! IRS so hard to good service, let alone excellent service. Thank you all for doing this for him and not making him feel like a nuisance. Celiac is serious and can become deadly. I appreciate the seriousness you took in it. Well done! Highly recommended! read more

OMG The worst pizza ever. ordered and was told it would be an hour for delivery. Came and completely cold. I mean not even slightly warm. Spent $48.00 for a large pizza that was just terrible. Called to complain, and the little 16 year old answering the phone spoke with the new owner who told me to never order for delivery again if I couldn't handle a cold pizza. The pizza was terrible. dont order from them. THEY SUCK read more

Pizza could've been a lot more fresh, I ordered a Supreme slice and I got one of the slice from the case with bell pepper added with heavy cheese.. kinda unprofessional, pizza kinda tasted old. Probably won't come back to this place. read more

I definitely had to leave a review today based on the customer service that I've received consistently. As a native New Yorker I'm really hard on pizza makers and this place does not disappoint. Each time I come in the order is correct, the food is exceptionally great, and the people are kind. Today a young lady helped me out to the car after seeing me struggling with my cups and my pizza lol. I really appreciate that extra effort. Good customer service goes a long way with me. OMG and try the zeppoles. Thank you! read more

Stevie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

The pizza is terrible. Worse than frozen. The sauce and cheese are awful. This is the second time I tried their pizza. Never again.

Food is amazing and employees are even better! Apple says hours are until 10, had no idea they closed at 9, and I called at about 9:05 to place an order. They let me know they were closed but still took my order since it wasn't crazy!! I'm pregnant and was craving pizza all day so I couldn't be more grateful. Food was also GREAT even though they didn't have to make it for me. 10/10 all around read more

Tried Stevie's for the first time on Superbowl Sunday so they were quite backed up. It was a pickup of the only two (2) wings they offer, BBQ and Buffalo, but neither disappointed. They did their best on a busy day and we will definitely be back at a better time for them and their customers. Will try different menu items as the wings were good. Casual, counter service in a very casual atmosphere. read more

Great tasting pizza! Love the relaxation of the place and service is always great! Enjoy the game on the tv while you have some hot, fresh tasty 'zza! Great for a date or a get together with friends! read more

True New York pizza which made me feel at home. REAL white pies! Oh my gosh! I'm in heaven! Quality is great, prices are reasonable, super fast service. LOVE this place! read more

Stevie's by far coming from a New Yorker born and raised, Is the best Pizza on the west coast. The owners and staff have been the best for years, consistent in quality and service, they will always be the best.. Marty S read more

First time ever ordering take out here. Ordered a Large pizza and Wings for the family on a Friday game night. Wings were great, as you can mess up wings but very hard to do. Now the worst part is the pizza. For $3.00 per topping, they use sausage crumbs. They don't evenly distribute the toppings and the sausage itself taste like breakfast sausage which shouldn't be on pizza. The crust is hard and dry and the sauce is tasteless. A very Blan tasting pizza. The worst part is a large pizza with two toppings and 10 wings is gonna cost you over $40. I would never go back here again this pizza reminds me of being in elementary school. There's other pizza joints that are better barros which on a good day would be a eight out of 10 this is easily a four or five out of 10 for pizza read more

The food is delicious and staff is always friendly. The wings are some of the best in the area.

Great pizza. Not big and doughy. Great crisp. Perfect little place , always friendly.

We absolutely LOVE Stevie's pizza. We are so lucky they are close by but even if they weren't it is by far the best pizza, wings & ranch lol around. They also have great food, salads & appetizers. The service is always amazing. Any cheat day that anyone in my household has is always spent on Stevie's. 10 out of 10. By far our favorite and go to pizza place. read more

After a day of desert riding we decided to look for a nearby pizza place we'd never been and found Stevie's. The options in Vistancia are limited and this is the only pizza you'll find. The reviews here seem to vary. I try to look at the worst rated and see why and who is rating. While some are obviously valid with service being rude or wait times I also see reviews coming from people with only one or two reviews ever and only negative. I don't tend to take those seriously and want to give a place a fair shot. While I did see some of what the negative reviewers talked about our experience was pretty good. Let's start with the positives though because who wants to lead with the bad. While the parking lot was busy it was easily accessible and we were able to find parking even with our trailer and bikes. There is a grocery story nearby as well as coffee and other businesses. When we walked in we were greeted and given a minute to look over the menu. Options are pretty good and they also serve beer on tap. The location is small, but hold quite a few booths and tables. There are a few outside tables as well. It was quite busy and people coming and going with pick up orders and such. We decided on a large pepperoni, garlic knots and hot wings. They have both large and small pints and the glass was chilled which is a definite bonus point. The boy running the register was pleasant enough and explained it would be about 40 minutes or so for our pizza. We hoped it wouldn't take that long, but again it was busy. While waiting we heard the employee on the phone sounding like they were turning some customers away because the cook was getting overwhelmed. We were pleased to get our garlic knots and wings quickly. The wings were steaming and looked amazing. They are not baked which I love and not over sauced either. They were crispy and good sized wings with lots of meat. The garlic knots were good as well. Our pizza soon followed at about 30 minutes and the appetizers held us over so it was no big deal. The pizza had good flavor, my son was happy with the amount of pepperoni and crust was a bit crispy and not soggy which I liked. So on to the negative. I heard a little attitude from the counter employee when people picking up orders came in at their told pick up time to food not being ready. There's nothing to argue if you told someone good would be ready and it's not just apologize and thank them for their patience don't argue minutes. For us we had a pretty good experience. We enjoyed our food and service for us was ok. As I said I can see why some find customer service rude, wait times long and such. Just remember that this is a local owned business, it can get overwhelmed as it's a very busy spot. Have some patience and kindness. If you're looking for a big chain type place this may not be for you. read more

See all

Place closes down way before closing. If you close at 9, stop sweeping the floors at 830! May get more business. With all that is coming to Vistancia soon, you reap what you sow! read more

The friendly service and great food will keep me coming back, Stevie's is a local staple!!

The service here is fairly standard for a privately owned NY style pizza place. The place itself, also standard but has comfortable dining and they are very accommodating while you are eating inside. They used to deliver but I don't think they do anymore. They are very close by for vistancia residents in far north Peoria, so it's a very convenient option. And finally, the most important part...the pizza itself is very good. Nothing bad to say about it. They also have very tasty pasta and other options...worth a try if you are in the area! read more

No way am I ever going back there. Overcharged me for a pitcher of beer, 20.67 .. Place sucks.

Excellent dinners and pizza is great they brought the sauce back from the east coast and it's great and is their service

Meh. $27 for a Large Veggie pie with no cheese. For the price alone, won't be back. Also, was charged more than what the menu said! Menu says $23 for a Large Veggie Pie, we were charged $25 AND we got less ingredients. Oh well. read more

Stevie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Pizza just wasn't good at all. Customer service was pretty good. Probably have to try again in the future to see if it was just a bad day.

Ordered a large pizza w/pepperoni and mushrooms. It was a bit pricy and they were not very generous with the toppings or the cheese. But the crust was good and the service was friendly... read more

We had a wonderful lunch here a few days ago. All the staff were warm and welcoming. We ordered the family size calzone and I loved the top of the calzone; it seemed possibly buttered with garlic. So great! We will definitely be back! read more

Just ordered a calzone, wings, and antipasto salad from Stevie's. The food was actually pretty good. My issue was with the ranch. It does not taste anything like ranch and was very watery. Even had a bitter sour taste. What is it made with? I know it's just a dip but since I wanted it for my calzone and wings it made a big difference. Fix the ranch and the food would be 4+ stars. Second issue was online ordering. I live 1 mile away off of Loan Mountain, yet their site and mobile app could not find my address. They proceeded charged me $4 extra for delivery. The house has been around since 2005 so it's not new. Google maps, Waze, and all GPS apps find this place easily too. So I'm not sure what's wrong with the mapping function Stevie's is using. Please fix this. read more

Honestly it's good ! I'm not going to sit here and say it's the best hands down . But it's the closest pizza place to our house and we are satisfied with everything we have ordered to date . The delivery can take a long time so if you do pick up instead it is a bit quicker .. but we regularly order the regular pie the pepperoni pin wheel salads are good and the pasta is bomb as well .. so you should give em a try it's a place I recommends .. being newer to the community up here we are still exploring all the mom and pop Places .. read more

Stevie's Pizza - The menu - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all