The place itself is whimsical and welcoming. The staff are friendly and attentive, and the owner clearly cares about her customers, and really takes feedback to heart. The strawberry shortcake was 3 layers of deliciousness and we couldn't have been happier. We will 100% be back! read more

If you didn't know or haven't considered it, Splurge is a great place to throw a birthday party. The program is wonderful as it keeps kids focused, busy and entertained. The staff does a wonderful job in keeping chaos controlled. You make pizza, you decorate giant cookies and it's all hands on and fun. Definitely different than the average celebration. read more

The best carrot cake--and the customer service is top notch. The owner couldn't be nicer or more accommodating. I've been getting cakes here for more than 10 years and I am never disappointed. Their original designs are some of the most creative in the area. read more

We celebrated my daughter's 4th birthday last Saturday at Splurge and it was beyond our expectations. If you are looking for a stress-free, high-energy, and absolutely delicious birthday party venue, look no further than Splurge Bakery in Millburn. We recently celebrated our child's birthday there, and I cannot rave about the experience enough! Why It Was a Huge Hit: The Vibe: From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was bright, welcoming, and perfectly set up for a group of excited kids. It's the kind of place that feels special as soon as you cross the threshold. The Activities: The staff are absolute pros at keeping a room full of children engaged. They led a fantastic cupcake and cookie decorating session that was the perfect mix of "organized" and "creative chaos." Every child felt like a master pastry chef. Stress-Free Hosting: This was the best part for me. The Splurge team handled everything from the setup to the cleanup. I actually got to sit back, take photos, and enjoy the moment instead of running around like a frantic party planner. The Verdict Splurge Bakery strikes that rare balance of being professional, whimsical, and delicious. The staff was incredibly patient with the kids and made the birthday child feel like the star of the show. If you want a party that your kids will be talking about for months (and a cleanup you don't have to deal with), book Splurge. It is worth every penny! read more

Their chocolate fudge cake was great, I also tried their butter cream cake, which was just ok. read more

Splurge Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

I was walking in the park across the street and decided I deserved a little treat, but unfortunately, I was very disappointed with everything I purchased. The bakery itself is beautiful--well-lit with a wide variety of options--but sadly, everything I tried tasted stale. The cupcakes and push pops were incredibly dry, and the frosting tasted like it had been left out for days. The pecan bars were very hard and dry in the pastry part, though the topping was good, which was the only redeeming factor. read more

These cupcakes bring me back to my childhood! Pure deliciousness in every single bite! Kind staff, clean place. My fave in the northeast!

They are getting the second star strictly off of delivering a quality cake last year for my daughters 1st birthday. This year, it was almost criminal how they over charged us and the quality was pretty bad. We ordered a cake for 8 people and the cost was $82. Again, since they did such a good job for our babies first bday we went along with it. When we saw the receipt, they charged us $35 to add "bananas" to the design!! This is straight up robbery! We should take this up w Millburn Police over Yelp! Again, if the cake was delicious I would've let it go but it was dry and pretty bland. Never again! Make sure you get a breakdown of your estimate before ordering if your going to do anything custom. read more

Splurge Bakery - Receipt - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

I will be splurging here again! the chocolate cupcake hot the spot.... the lemon blueberry cupcake of the month was like a homemade blueberry pancake... with icing on top of course.... read more

Came in for some treats for the holiday. Carrot cake was tasty.. molten cake, brownie were ok. Cute place

Great customer service!! I was leaving the park because it was getting cold. I decided to get some hot chocolate. Walked across the street and right into Splurge. The pink exterior called me in. They don't have hot chocolate, but since there was a kids party going on, and they had a hot chocolate bar the nice guy behind the counter offered me some. So kind! Based just off that, I had to try some of their baked goods. Lots of cookie bars and cake pops. Beautiful tiered cakes. St. Patrick's Day cookies and other themes. He said the carrot cake with cream cheese icing is great. And It was good! It's gone. So happy I popped in. read more

See all

Excellent, excellent, excellent! The cake they made was 20/10 it was pure deliciousness and was on point on what daughter wanted for her birthday celebration. So much love and attention went into it from the owner to the staff. The cupcakes and chocolate covered strawberries were just heavenly. Thank you Julie, Rebecca and the whole team for the attention to detail. read more

Splurge Bakery - Visual delight and deliciousness - all in one! - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

How have I not reviewed Splurge? They're my go to spot for fun gifts-send them an image and they'll reproduce it on a giant cookie for a great price. Pics of a loved one, or a building, or even a beach badge! And if my kids were young they'd be taking baking classes here as well. Fun place, delicious sweets. read more

Splurge Bakery - As I'm visiting my g/f's beach house I thought I'd bring her a special cookie! She's over the moon! - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

Ordered a custom cake for a coworker. With one week notice they were able to completely match the vision and she loved her cake! Everyone who sampled it at office said it was delicious! Also Rebecca was super kind and helpful at pick up time! Will certainly be back for other occasions. read more

staff and owners are rude and impatient. Baked goods are "meh". would not recommend.

So disorganized you will be lucky to get your order on time and made correctly. Very dirty place. Takes forever to order with the owner because she can't think properly. Will start talking to other people while you are on the phone with them and get distracted like a dog who saw a squirrel. Too expensive for what you get. All cakes is made and frozen for weeks ahead of time and decorated nearly a week prior. Terrible business. read more

My niece was very specific when talking about her princess birthday cake. This bakery did an amazing job making her vision come to life at just 4 years old The design and execution was perfect. These cakes are never the most tasteful, I think the artwork is what makes them special and we had a very happy birthday girl read more

Splurge Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

I stopped into Splurge yesterday. My husband and I had just gotten the envelope with the gender of our baby yesterday and wanted to do a little celebration together with it later on that day. We stopped there and on the spot they took the envelope and made us two cupcakes with the proper gender color inserted so that he and I could have our own little intimate gender reveal. They were delicious!!!! read more

Splurge Bakery - two cupcakes in a plastic container - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

When it comes to ordering a specialized cake, there aren't a lot of options nearby. I'm very grateful for Splurge. They make beautiful specialized cakes and they taste very good. I ordered a birthday cake less than 2 weeks in advance for my son's 2nd birthday. I showed them a picture of what I wanted with some edits, and they definitely delivered. I was late to my pick up time due to unrelated issues, and this was not a problem. I easily found parking right in front of the storefront and they brought the cake to me, I didn't even have to get out of my car. They gave me some instructions about the additional pieces to put on as well to not refrigerate given the timeframe. I ordered chocolate with raspberry filling and am very pleased with the flavor and the way the cake looked. Minus one star because they didn't respond to my emails but were great at picking up the phone. read more

Splurge Bakery - Birthday cake for my 2 year old - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Julie made my sock monkey themed bday party dreams come true! I had a pinterest perfect dream of a sock monkey themed bday for my toddler. The trouble was - all of the cakes I was eyeing were double my budget. What can I say - I dream big. Julie worked with me every step along the way, reviewing multiple cake ideas, and making suggestions on how I could make my dreams come true while spending less. I really appreciated her honesty. The cake also tasted as yummy as it looks - was filled with chocolate and raspberry jelly. A cake that looks good and tastes good too - what more can I ask for! read more

Splurge Bakery - Sock monkey cake - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

When you get an undersized stale cake for $300 do not go back a year later and hope for a better cake. It will be more stale, the color will be all wrong even though you spent an hour ordering it in person!! Worse than the money spent, the owner of this business could not care may less and you will be left to deal with the disappointment and embarrassment! She will look at you like you are crazy and say she is so sorry and offer to carry her botched stale mess to your car for you. Don't SPLURGE! read more

Very dry cake. Nice designs but cake is horrible. Cake pops were underbaked too. Either it was done on a bad day or they need to hire new bakers not cake artist. Would not recommend for an edible cake only if you want cake as a prop/display! read more

The presentation was lovely. This is the 2nd cake I ordered from them. The first time it was very dry. But I figured I'd give it another try. I even told the girl on the phone last time it was very dry. Assuming it was either stale or just over cooked. She assured me they would make it fresh. So needless to say I was a little upset since the cake it was over $50 and very small. They really need to work on that. If it was moist I would not mind paying the money, since it was pretty. I'm not sure I will ever order from them again. read more

My order that was placed two weeks prior to pick up was not ready. No one seemed to know what to do. They started to pack my order but were giving me wrong flavors of cake balls. Finally straightened that out. Not cheap for cake balls that did not look like what i ordered from website. They tasted awful. We tried one of each three flavors and threw them all out. A waste! read more

Julie at Splurge Bakery went above and beyond to help me with a fairly last minute custom request. I'd reached out to her to make a cake replica of a special Indian accordion like instrument called a harmonium for my mom's 70th birthday & after I balked at the cost of the replica, she offered to make a simpler design that incorporated the major details without being a full blown replica. The final result was not only beautiful but absolutely delicious! My mom loved it - a BIG thanks to everyone at Splurge!! read more

Splurge Bakery - Custom 70th birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

This place is off the beaten path. If you're not looking for it, you might miss it. But once you find it, you'll be glad you did. I have been there twice and have been more than satisfied with their confections. First time I got a chocolate covered strawberry which was to die for. I also purchased a raspberry pecan crumb bar, s'mores bar and a cookies 'n cream bar. The bars were so fresh. The s'mores bar had so much marshmallow oozing out. I think it was my favorite. The cookies'n cream bar had chucks or chocolate it it. My second trip I got the s'mores and cookies 'n cream bars again and a lemon curd bar (was recommended last time saying it was made right there) and a blondie. I ate half the blondie. Also so good as the other two. The lemon curd bar was not my cup of tea. The lemon curd was good but the base was just too dry for me. The are also know for their cakes and other confections. This is definitely a bakery to stop by and try. I've found my new "sweets" location in Millburn. read more

Splurge Bakery - Bars: S'mores (upper left), cookies 'n cream (upper right), blondie (lower left), and lemon curd (lower right). - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

I needed a cake for a friend/coworker's birthday and Splurge delivered... both literally and figuratively! The cake was absolutely beautiful, tasted delicious, and was a win. Will definitely be ordering from them again. Highly recommend! read more

Splurge Bakery - Vanilla cake with chocolate cream filling. - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Awesome bakery and service! Try the cookies, s'mores bar , and coconut cake! Delicious!

Soooo disappointing... I needed a cake for my husband's 30th birthday and asked them to make blue ombre cake I saw in their Instagram. You can see at the photos what I get as the result. My relative picked it up, and he didn't know how I expected it to look. The cake looked not bad, but IT'S NOT AN OMBRE CAKE! I don't see a point paying $55 when you don't get what you want. And it was the design they advertise! Also it was way too sweet, pure sugar. My guests barely had finished their slices. Not to mention I've spend almost 40 minutes in the bakery when I was making an order, waiting when the staff would have time for me, carrying infant in my hands. The cake definitely didn't worth it. read more

Splurge Bakery - An ombre cake from their instagram account and what I got as the result - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Beautiful cakes, excellent service, great selection, very professional snd the cakes are delicious.

Placed an order for a 6 inch mini rainbow cake on Tuesday and picked it up Friday. The design of the cake exuded joy and fun!! My 6 year old absolutely loved it. While the cake part was a teensy bit dry the icing was delicious and fluffy. While only 6 inches round, it's a super tall shape. The cake was the perfect size for 10-12 slices. Absolutely would recommend for any fun celebration! read more

Splurge Bakery - Rainbow cake 6 inch mini - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

This bakery is so fun and delicious! Also great for birthday parties! Splurge is my go to when I'm in Millburn. read more

Splurge Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

I had a great experience ordering a birthday cake for delivery from Splurge Bakery. The cake was delicious and beautifully made, and the person on the phone was very friendly. Will definitely come back again! read more

Splurge Bakery - Chocolate hazelnut birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Customer service is excellent and the bars are incredible. Highly recommend!

Thank you for the incredible cake and customer service. In less than 24 hours, you had a gorgeous rainbow cake at my coworker's door. I love you guys!! read more

I ordered a 50th birthday cake and was completely blown away! The cake exceeded my expectations. I have never seen a more stunning cake. I will definitely use Splurge for all my future parties. read more

Splurge Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

So disappointing.... cake I ordered looked good on the outside but completely dry even when thawed for several hours.

I got exactly what I asked for and the cake was delicious! Really impressed. Julie and her team did good. read more

Splurge Bakery - Godzilla themed cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

I attended a party with a vanilla buttercream/chocolate sheet cake. This cake was the best I've had since moving from NYC 4 years ago. Absolutely delicious! read more

Ordered 10 custom sugar cookies for a baby shower. The cookies are definitely satisfactory, but for the price I was expecting more care in the decorations. Also the cookies themselves are small and very very thin. I was expecting them to look more like the cookies they have displayed in the shop and I was a tad disappointed to have paid over 60$ for something that was not very custom or decorative. I highly recommend sending a picture of what you are interested in, even if they tell you not to. They told me not to send a picture and I wish I had. read more