If I could give 6 stars I would! Here's why:
My wife and I walked in at 6:30 without a reservation and the house was packed, but we lucked out that a table had just opened up due to a last minute cancellation. The restaurant is delightfully charming, set in a cave-like structure below street level with arched stone walls and passageways between rooms. The gracious manager, Antonio, later explained to us that the facility was originally used as a coal cellar for the home above it in prior generations but had been cleaned and outfitted with luxurious amenities to make it well suited as a 5-star dining establishment that it is today.
At the table our waiter recommended a great bottle of Valpolicella wine, and we ordered caprese and the beet salad to start. Antonio stopped by our table to check on us and offered balsamic and olive oil to go with the house-made tomato focaccia--yum! The caprese was delicious, garnished with olives, pickled peppers, olive oil, and basil. The greens in the beet salad were fresh and crisp, the beets were served warm, and the dressing was excellent.
For our main course we shared an absolutely dreamy butternut squash and goat cheese cannelloni dish (three cannelloni served in one order) and perfectly prepared garlic & parmesan sautéed spinach side. The amaretto dark chocolate mousse was a perfect dessert to finish our meal--decadent, thick chocolate mousse with just a hint of amaretto.
Bonus: our waiter delivered two chilled shots of house-made Limoncello to top us off. Antonio carries lemons in from Italy himself by the suitcase-full to prepare this drink because he says they taste better than the local variety. I'd say its worth it because it was exceptionally delicious!
Regretting that we didn't have room to try the prime rib, we asked Antonio to reserve a table for us the following evening and even though there weren't any available reservations he made room for us anyway. Love Antonio!
We arrived 1/2 hour early the next evening and had a wonderful time at the bar, hanging out with Antonio and the bar tender, Vicenzo. My wife had an artfully crafted Aperol Spritz, a classic Italian aperitif, and I enjoyed a Hendricks Gin and cucumber drink at Antonio's recommendation. We shared lots of laughs and good stories with Vicenzo while watching him and his colleagues prepare drinks behind the bar. Vicenzo suggested his favorite bottle of wine for us, a Peppoli Chianti Classico, and we liked it so much we had a second bottle at the table. :)
Antonio helped us select an incredible 4 course meal to pair with our absolutely perfectly prepared prime rib--chicken liver ragu on toast, rich and creamy fettuccini with butternut squash confetti & truffle oil, rosemary potatoes accompanying the rocket-topped prime rib (what a winning combination!) and of course another dark chocolate mousse for dessert. Mmmm, I'm getting hungry all over again as I type this...
On the way out we saw Vicenzo preparing some great-smelling Italian cappuccinos at the bar and, as if he could read our mind, Antonio invited my wife and I back for morning coffee with him and the staff before we left town. The next morning we shared more laughs and stories with Antonio and Vicenzo over delicious Italian coffee and biscotti, took a bunch of fun pictures with them for the scrap book, then walked a few blocks to the train station on out way back to London.
We can't wait for our next chance to come back to Soto Soto, and highly highly recommend it for anyone else reading this review! read more