Great food and service. This is old school Italian at its best! The pizzas are some of the best…read moreI've ever had. Sit at the bar and enjoy a cold one with the bartender. Very friendly place. Can't wait to go back soon!

New location has a fly infestation! First time visiting the…read morenew location yesterday. We had a large party and were sat in the back room which happened to be infested with flies topped off with flouresent lighting and no music. The flies were so bad that the container of red peper flakes had about 50 flies swarming inside to point where my 2yr old pointed it out and said "Ewwww bugs!!" We told the waiter of the problem and he said they knew about it and spray once a week but essentially it is what it is. No visit from the manager or anything to make the situation right. I was probably one of the only people who truly enjoyed my meal. Everyone else mentioned the food quality or taste not being the same... or they had flies in their food. The new bathrooms only have 1 stall which is quite a downgrade from the last location. Our server was very nice overall though. Wont be back.

Of course I have been back to this place multiple times since my initial review. However, I went in…read moreNovember of 2025 and you can tell something changed. The Alfredo sauce was watery and salty. I sent the food back and left with nothing. I assumed it was a fluke because all prior experiences were amazing. I went back in December 2025 and it was clear then that something definitely changed. The bread pudding was tough, the Alfredo sauce was loose... shortly after this, I learned they closed down.

Recent take out review: The food here is very good -- super flavorful, consistent, and just as…read moretasty as I remembered from dining in a couple years ago. No complaints on quality at all. But the value doesn't match the price. I paid $17 for a very small lasagna, and $27.50 for a fettuccine that came with what looked like barely one chicken breast and maybe half a portion of noodles. For the cost, the portions were surprisingly small. For a $30 plate, i'd expect more food Overall, the food is delicious, but the portions don't justify the price. If they offered more generous servings, it would easily be a top-tier experience! 4.5/5 for the food taste 2.5/5 for the value and portion size 3.5/5 for the vibe / ambiance 4/5 staff

We went here for a birthday celebration i've been wanting to try this place for years and it turns…read moreout most of my friends had never been there. We had a great night. The food was amazing. I don't know what people were thinking that leave bad reviews. They must be had a bad experience which could happen anywhere, or they looking for a different Italian experience, this is rustic food served family style and you get to taste everything. It was amazing thank you so much for a great dinner and a great night. The service was good. It was a few times that we needed water, but we asked him and they brought pictures of water for the rest of the night. It was amazing. The food was great. The dessert was great. It's super authentic rustic Italian, and you get to try so much. The highlights were the white noodles with olive oil and green onions and the barbecue shrimp. Definitely try the Italian salad,spaghetti, meatballs ,chicken Le grande, the barbecue shrimp, and oysters Mosca's. Best thing is to order a little bit of everything, they're good at telling you how many you need for your group. They have a great bar and they make a great old-fashioned. It's their special take two or three of us really enjoyed it and they have a really good aperol drink. It could be difficult to get a rideshare home so I recommend driving but not drinking too much. We all have a friend who doesn't drink so invite them along and have a good time. Getting a Party Bus that's what we're gonna do next time. There were two party buses there and those people were having a great time. Notes: the dishes are made to order so you're gonna probably have to have a drink or two before your food comes. Attention: CASH ONLY LET ALL YOUR PEOPLE KNOW AHEAD OF TIME They have an ATM machine OK to be honest, we didn't have every dish but will be back. We had about 90% of the dishes. Don't forget to try to pineapple fluff. We ordered the last three for the night. If

I came to town to take an elderly friend of mine out to dinner. Another friend recommended Mosca's…read moreso off we went. We were greeted immediately and seated just a few moments later. Even at 6:00 on a Thursday evening it was nice to see quite a few tables occupied but it wasn't packed thankfully. The bar seats were mostly occupied with what looked like regulars so that's always a good sign too. We were seated at a table near the bar and so the bartender was also our waitress. She was also waiting on other tables in the area and for that reason I think she was a bit overextended. She was attentive but always rushing and really no personal service to speak of. We never did get bread plates and didn't have an opportunity to ask for any unfortunately. The breadsticks were brought out first, way before the meal, and weren't anything special. We each ate half of one and no more. My dinner came with a salad so that came out first. Tasty and fresh, and just an everyday side salad. Our meals arrived and at first glance, there just wasn't anything special about them. I'm not sure what I was expecting really, except with the price point I thought there would be a nicer presentation. The eggplant parmesan was cooked nicely but we were never offered any cheese and for lack of a better description, it was like something I would throw together at home, not a restaurant meal. My friend's food did not look appetizing on the plate, again, like a home cooked meal and not restaurant quality. The potato had been in the warming oven for a while it seemed, not fluffy any longer and the salmon was way overcooked and dry. I won't be giving this spot another go. Some folks here seem to like it but it's just not the quality I look for when dining out.

Yeah, so OK I'm a fussy New Yorker. I like pizza, I love pizza, I've eaten really really really…read morereally good pizza in the five boroughs, and Jersey, and New Haven. This is good pizza. Really. It's pretty good pizza not the best I've ever had but it's maybe the best I've had in the Orleans area. That's high praise come from me.

Saturday 4P dinner w/husband. In a little strip mall. Cozy, welcoming inside. Told to seat…read moreourselves and menus brought promptly. Nice amount of customers and obvious regulars. Had a Heineken Zero and husband had Coke. I ordered the Penne Buratta, husband wanted the traditional Lasagna, and we ordered a small Take & Bake Lasagna Pie pizza. My Penne Burrata was to die for! Husband's lasagna was super as well. Service was timely without being rushed. We had a few leftovers, though I have to admit, should have been more but I couldn't stop munching. Bill came with cash and credit card amount on it, which I appreciate. ($67.55 w/tax cash) Check out was quick, and for the amount of food, the pricing was reasonable. We did cook the pizza the next day (suggested not to wait more than 24 hrs) and it was very good. I think next time though I will choose a different flavor. Will return.

Service was absolutely awful, asked for vanilla and caramel, and I get a burnt pizza with a…read moresprinkle of vanilla and no ice cream Not to mention, they refunded only five dollars Don't ever order from them DoorDash Uber eats This got a five dollar refund and it was missing ice cream and was wrong and burnt

We ordered here last night because I'd heard that the Detroit style pizza was good. Both pizzas…read morewere absolutely delicious and that is why I'm still giving three stars, but at $20+ per pizza the size completely surprised me. We've ordered Detroit style elsewhere and while they can be smaller, this feels a bit extreme. So taking stars away for cost and sizing. We had to stop elsewhere for additional food because two pizzas were not enough for my family at this size.

My husband had a club sandwich loaded with ham, turkey,bacon, Swiss, cheddar and bacon, it was…read morehuge! He ate only half and said it was delicious and took the rest home. I had the eggplant parmigiana and it was very well cooked with lots of eggplant and loads of pasta with sauce. Everyone was friendly, waitress was new but she was polite enough to say she was. The male staff member (owner/manager?) asked how everything was and made sure we had everything we needed. He took my dish and my husband's and put them in to go containers. The ambiance was great there were two dining areas one i couldn't see very well but looked clean and neat with the appropriate decor. We will go back.

Excellent Italian/Sicillian American restaurant. Good foods @ great prices…read more Park front or rear. Full bar. No pizzas. Clean.

Evening I have ordered Dinner two nights in a row and just wanted to all the great service I…read morereceived and food really was awesome taste full reason why went twice Thank you Ashli great service

First of all, how can you not go to a place that serves both New York and Chicago style pizza??? We…read moreordered the spinach dip appetizer and out came this decadent cheesy bread (aka gooey cheese pizza) and rich spinach dip. It was massive, so we packed it up and shared it with friends. We had two, good sized side salads and then...the pizza! We chose Chicago (which takes 45 minutes to make) and it was AMAZING!!! The sauce‼ you will love the food but love the service even more. They were personal, attentive, and kind. Darren was a pleasure to visit with. It felt like I had lived here all my life. The decor is fun with nods to both NY and Chicago. Overall, this is a must visit place if you haven't been!!!

Clean restaurant, good service and good pizza! They don't sell pizza by the slice unless it's…read moreDetroit style which is fine, but I think it's good to know for those going for a quick bite. I decided to order a small build your own pizza and it came out in a very timely manner. It's 6 slices and for me, very filling!

Love this Reginelli's Pizza. It's the perfect place for a quick bite between movies and their…read moresandwiches are so tasty! Love the Meatball sandwich and The Uptowner is Turkey perfection!

Okay, this may be one of the more difficult reviews for me to write. Why? Because Blue Tomato…read moreconfuses me as much as it delights me! How do you categorize a restaurant that offers a full menu of Mexican food, a full menu of Italian food, a full menu of local fare and American classics, AND why not throw a little Asian food in as well. Now, do all of it VERY WELL, and you have quite the conundrum when you sit down to eat. "What am I in the mood for?" Luckily, you can mix and match to your heart's desire. Garbage nachos and Thai ribs? Sure! Chicken alfredo with a couple of tamales? No prob. A good steak with a Cuban quesadilla? Why not? The possibilities are endless. Now, mix in some killer drinks, and we're talking about somewhere you'll want to bring all your friends who can't decide what they want. It's all there for them, and if they can't find something at Blue Tomato, you might want to reconsider your friends. The service staff at BT is wonderful and homey. I always feel like a local when I eat there. It's comfortable and quaint whether you're eating seared tuna with a margarita or a batch of wings with a Mic Ultra. Lunch is actually my favorite time to visit. Quick service and reasonable prices make this a lunch destination. You might need to ensure you have a refrigerator at work though...the serving portions are generous. So, what are you waiting for? Is it lunchtime yet?

I wish I could eat here every day. I am sorry it took me so long to discover this wonderful place!…read moreGreat service. Amazing food. Ambience is the perfect fit for me. I'm an 83 year old prior hippie who is most comfortable in this type of environment.