Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sofie's Scoops Gelato

    5.0 (4 reviews)
    Closed Closed
    Updated 1 week ago

    Sofie's Scoops Gelato Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sofie's Scoops Gelato

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Sofie's Scoops Gelato

    You might also consider

    Gelatiamo - Fresh panettone. So good!

    Gelatiamo

    4.5(877 reviews)
    46.8 miDowntown
    $$

    gelatiamo was a cozy hideaway spot from the crazy seattle wind and rain (someone had to be by the…read moredoor to let people in and out). overall very vibey with a few tables to sit at! staff were friendly as well. for the smallest size, you can get two scoops of any flavor! the berries and cream flavor reminded me of the plain tart frozen yogurt flavor (but much creamier and a bit sweeter from the berries). the strawberry sorbet was also very good! you can taste the strawberries for sure. eggnog was an interesting flavor! i've never had actual eggnog before so i don't have a good comparison point but it was good and not overwhelming in any flavor profile. cookies and cream was good too :)

    This dessert and pastry place is close by to Benaroya hall, so I would get here by public transit…read moreif you can. When you do walk in here, you feel like you're in a fine-dining like area with dim lights yet it also has the feel of a cafe where you can sit and relax with whatever you get. Since one of my friends knew I haven't been here before for desserts, he decided to take me and out other friends here to try their gelato for the first time. I got a scoop of their marionberry swirl and had a taste of my bestie's salted caramel gelato. Both were really good though my marionberry had a lot more taste and wasn't as sweet as the salted caramel. Staff up front were very patient with us when we asked to try several of their flavors at once.

    Photos
    Gelatiamo - Grande...three flavors!

    Grande...three flavors!

    Gelatiamo - Rice and Creme Brulee - just love the Rice flavor!

    Rice and Creme Brulee - just love the Rice flavor!

    Gelatiamo - Rice flavor

    See all

    Rice flavor

    Bottega Italiana - Half chocolate and half stracciatella in a sugar cone

    Bottega Italiana

    4.4(430 reviews)
    46.7 miDowntown
    $$

    Pretty good gelato! Staff is super friendly and nice, you can try anything you want. Limited…read moreseating indoors, some picnic tables outdoors. We got the raspberry dragonfruit. Pretty amazing!

    It makes me sad to write this 2-star review because Bottega Italiana has been my favorite gelato…read moreshop in Seattle for the past 15+ years. As you can see from my review years ago, when my hubs and I came back from a trip to Italy, we wanted to find a gelato shop that had the same quality as the shops in Rome. Not all the gelato and sorbetto we had in Italy was good, some flavors tasted artificial, and during our time there, we learned how to tell the good from the meh. When we returned to Seattle, we were happy to find great-Italy-like gelato at the Bottega Italiana in Green Lake. After that shop closed (still sad about that!) we started going to their other shop by Pike Place Market. For years, this place featured delicious, fresh, quality gelato and sorbetto that tasted like the flavors they were labeled with--so strawberry tasted like eating real strawberries and so on. But on a recent visit, I got a small cup with strawberry and raspberry-dragon fruit and the first flavor I got when I tasted it was sugar. As I ate more of it, it started to remind me of Jolly Rancher candies, not totally, but enough to turn me off. They use just enough fruit to make you believe it's the flavor that it's labeled with, but the amount of sugar and other things added makes their fruit flavors as meh as the not-so-good shops we learned to avoid in Rome. Alas, I think my favorite gelato shop in Seattle has fallen prey to profit over quality. Why, Bottega Italiana, why??? It makes me and my hubs very sad. The only reason I am giving two stars instead of one is because the service was friendly and efficient, and my hubs's dairy-based gelato flavors were all right--not great but all right. Over the years, we've tried all the other gelato shops in Seattle and none of them measure up either. I guess it's time we take another trip to Italy.

    Photos
    Bottega Italiana - Mango and Nutella gelato. Mango was superb!

    Mango and Nutella gelato. Mango was superb!

    Bottega Italiana - Outdoor sitting

    Outdoor sitting

    Bottega Italiana

    See all

    Marmalade - Amarena cherry and chocolate caramel pretzel gelato (split scoop Italiano size)

    Marmalade

    4.8(27 reviews)
    49.4 miFremont

    I stopped in right before closing and the owner was welcoming and happy to let me try a few…read moresamples. The gelato had a great texture and they had a ton of fruit flavors. I ended up getting a small with vanilla and pistachio, and the pistachio (literally called "The Best") lived up to its name. I also liked that I could mix multiple flavors in any size and not stuck choosing just one. Definitely coming back to try more flavors!

    I went here for dessert after dinner and got the small gelato which is $6+tax. There is a bunch of…read moreflavors, but the fruity department is lacking. However, there are standout flavors like waffle cone that I had to get, as well as the more traditional flavors like pistachio. I sampled the pistachio as they claimed it was the best in town but was a little disappointed since the flavor was not too apparent and it's not the true pistachio hue that I usually see for natural pistachio (it was more green). The flavors I ended up getting were the waffle cone and strawberry rhubarb. I liked the quality of the gelato but it was more on the icy texture than smooth. For the price of $6+tax, it is one of the pricier options around for the portion. If this was the best gelato in Seattle, I'd have written the price off as a premium for quality, but I've had a few spots that in my opinion are better in texture and flavor.

    Photos
    Marmalade - Chocolate and Pistachio, 10oz each (7/3/25)

    Chocolate and Pistachio, 10oz each (7/3/25)

    Marmalade - Jaipur Chai 1 scoop (rating: 5/5)

    Jaipur Chai 1 scoop (rating: 5/5)

    Marmalade - Waffle cone, strawberry rhubarb split scoop small - IG @bougiefoodieboi

    See all

    Waffle cone, strawberry rhubarb split scoop small - IG @bougiefoodieboi

    Sofie's Scoops Gelato - gelato - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...