First time ordering from Sofia's Pizzeria was a success! I ordered for an office meeting. I ordered one cheese pizza, one pepperoni pizza, one BBQ chicken pizza, one supreme pizza, an order of sweet and spicy wings and one Sofia's calzone (mozzarella cheese, ricotta, grilled chicken, baby spinach and Portabella mushrooms.). While waiting for delivery I remember thinking, "Why did I order a "specialty" calzone from a place I've never eaten? I should have gotten something simple like pepperoni." Well, I'm glad I got the Sofia's calzone (also, I added banana peppers to mine). The pizzas were clearly woodfired oven-made pizza. They were beautiful and delicious. The wings were good. The ranch tastes homemade. And, the calzone was yummy and HUGE. I got two meals out of that calzone! Although, I do think charging $2.25 to add banana peppers is a little overpriced. Overall, I'm happy with Sofia's and will definitely have them again! read more

See all

Superb pizza place, the ambiance is basic as all get-out but the pies are surprisingly good. As a former New Yorker, I'm a bit fussy about my slices but these are a good NY-style pie. Note that I said 'style' - it's not an exact match but the crust has that elusive crisp texture with a little chew. Toppings, sauce, and service are decent to above average. I'll definitely be back! This place scores a 5 out of 5 on the 'CTJ Scale', as noted below. 5 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Jesus good. Would be OK passing away after finishing a plate here. 4 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Mary good. Would be OK having a nosh here with Mother Mary. 3 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Joseph good. Would be OK having a beer here with Jesus' Dad. 2 out of 5 stars: Come-to-the-Apostles good. Meh. Wouldn't have my last supper here. 1 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Nobody good. I wouldn't have my penultimate supper here, either. read more

See all

Signed up for Sofia's rewards program and was texted a code for a free 14 inch cheese pizza. No expiration date was indicated on the text. When I tried to redeem it, the cashier told me the code had expired so she had to manually apply the discount. The New York style pizza had a nice crust complimented by the right amount of sauce and cheese. It was a good slice of pizza! Wish they would offer some specials to make the prices more competitive with other independent pizza places. read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - 14-Inch Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Pizza here was great! Fresh and tasty! However there were a few hiccups during our visit. We were a party of three and one of my friends had a gluten allergy so she requested a gluten free pizza. We ordered a garden salad for the table. I ordered a veggie pizza and my other friend got a Margherita pizza. We both enjoyed our pizzas but our other friend never got the gluten free pizza. Apparently, the tried to make a cheese pizza with gluten free crust but the crust kept sticking to something, they tried twice. They apologized and said they would refund our money. I also noticed a small piece of bacon in my veggie pizza. It would be great if they can pay attention to these details. Otherwise, good bang for your buck! read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Vegetable pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Absolutely terrible. This was our first visit to Sophia Pizza, and it will definitely be our last. We paid $27.00 for a large pizza with mushrooms and pineapple, and it was one of the worst pizzas we've ever had. It was so unbelievably greasy that we had to use a stack of napkins just to soak up the oil before we could even attempt to eat it. The crust made no sense--paper thin on the bottom but excessively thick around the edges. The pizza had almost no flavor, the ingredients tasted cheap, and the "extra" toppings were laughably sparse. For what they charge, the quality is completely unacceptable. There is nothing premium about this pizza except the price. Save your money and go somewhere that actually uses quality ingredients and takes pride in what they serve. I absolutely do not recommend Sophia Pizza. read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Greasy napkins to soak up some grease - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

I've been here twice but I have got to say that I do not miss Miss Ellie's at all. Sofia's is far much better. Slices are huge, thin and not as greasy as the last place. The salad is good but the garlic knots have shrunk. For dessert just get thr tiramisu. Unless you like cheesecake then get that if you don't mind eating it plain because they don't have strawberry topping but do not get the chocolate cake. It wasn't bad but it was dry. Service was good and the seating inside is not any different from the last pizzeria. I highly recommend Sofia's. read more

I absolutely loved this place the workers were so friendly and the atmosphere is just great would definitely come back if your in the area just stop by great prices for great food read more

The only pizza with incredible crust! Jalapeño pepperoni is my jam. Brandon is so good at what he does!

I've lived here my whole life and Sofia's has the best pizza in town. If someone were to ask me where can I get the best pizza in San Antonio. I'd tell them. Sofia's. read more

Our fav NY pizza place closed its doors and now we are on a quest to find the next Best NY Pizza in SA. Well, we may have found it on our first try. Customer service was great! Prices are good. They offer lunch specials, even on Saturday. The calzone was filled with ingredients and delicious. The wings are really good. And the pizza..... it was great!! Crispy crust on bottom and ingredients were right on point. Def will be back. read more

See all

Pizza over all was the only decent thing I ordered garlic kots tasted like soap, ordered buffalo wing very dry very expensive 60$ read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Pizza over all was the only thing that was decent I order garlic kots tasted like soap ,wing very dry no sauce Very expensive - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

The food is great but the door to the restaurant not so much, I almost dropped my food on the way out of the place. I have bad arthis and don't want to risk hurting myself to get a pizza. It was very difficult to open. Also, the music was obnoxiously loud!!! read more

Working in San Antonio. Needed something I could take back to the hotel. Ordered a calzone based on the guy at the counter's recommendation. Generally I hate taking food 'to go'. Always better when it's fresh and not contained. In this case, I drove back to my hotel, opened my laptop and the meal was tremendous! Great job. Next trip to San Antonio, I'll make a point to eat there again. read more

I purchased a "too good to be gone" surprise bag from here last night. My son and I enjoyed a slice at lunch today. I put them in my air fryer for a few minutes and they were perfect. The veggies were tender on my slice, the crust was both crisp and pillowy soft on the inside and perfectly toasted crust all along the bottom of the slice. The pizza was not greasy which I liked. The sliced sausage on my sons slice was sooooo good. I'm going to have to ask them what kind it was. read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Veggie pizza with sausage - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Let's start by saying the staff is very friendly and attentive! That is the very best part of this debacle. The pizza in the glass display that they are selling is a dried out mess. My goodness why would you attempt to sell this ? The calzones had the worst cheese and the sausage inside was cheap cheap cheap. None of the ingredients are high quality! The inside is run down and needs a deep cleaning. We desperately miss Ellie's. The prices aren't comparable to the low quality of the food. Will not go back. Po Po s is 100% betters as is Florios. It's a shame because they took a great place and turned it into a run down low quality pizza joint. read more

My family loved the fresh pizza right out of the oven. The staff is super friendly too!!! I'll have to come back for the garlic bread

Great food, cute themed decor for a Friday night with the family. Quick & friendly service! I have tried many individual slices, meat lovers, pepperoni, jalapeño pepperoni, bacon alfredo, margarita, supreme and cheese. All have been great but classic pepperoni & mushroom have been my favorites. I tried the calzone for the first time today and only made it through 1/3, it was huge! I completely recommend taking a visit to Sofia's and stopping at Cosmic Mayhem after for a fun night! read more

Ate here for lunch today. Had an appointment nearby and decided to get a slice. Good lunch special- had a slice of cheese and a slice of pepperoni- both were excellent. NY style. Plan to go back to try some of the other food. Looking forward to trying the garlic knots. read more

Sofia's has the convenience of being close to us. However, the decent pizza is very overpriced- $38 for an 18" and it was burnt! We won't be going back. read more

Checked out a great new spot for us at least. The location is small but the pizza is delicious! Much better quality than your typical pizza locations. I would recommend ordering ahead if you want to eat the pizza fresh. We did have to wait a bit for our pizza but it was worth it. It was a Friday night so it's an usual long wait time. Fresh ingredients = high quality results! read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Mucho Meatsa - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Lunch specials are great bargain! Tasty pizza & Fast service. Great for big crowds & carry out to office. Parking is plentiful & free. read more

Sofias is amazing they have an amazing staff a mural on the wall not much else but amazing read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

The pizza here was pretty decent, and that's a lot for me to say. And for someone whose tried 50+ pizza places in SA, that's saying a lot (only a handful are memorable). Some thing were bit odd--they cut the pie into 4 huge pieces (see attached)? Not sure what that was all about and the cheese was a bit greasy (not using the best cheese). But overall, I place I will remember and return! read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

We we're in the mood for some pizza and decided to get a large margarita pizza, 10 lemon pepper wings and mozzarella sticks w/2 Sprites delivered. Here are the issues. * Pizza was ice cold and barely had any basil on it. * Wings were dry tough and tasted like they had been reheated. * Mozzarella sticks were cooked into the 5th dimension and never saw the light of cheese ever again. Seriously though where's the cheese at??!! * The Sprites were cold and delicious. (Total dinner cost $78 w/tip) We love and support our small local businesses but this establishment needs better quality control if their going to charge these prices. Otherwise I'd rather go to Domino's where at least they understand the assignment. Both managers were polite, professional and refunded our money for the issues. read more

See all

We went to Sofia's two weekends in a row. Last weekend we were looking for a pizza place a friend had gone to that sold pizza by the slice, we didn't find that place, went looking for Miss Ellie's instead but found Sofia's in its place! The guy behind the counter seemed like the owner, he was pleasant and the pizza behind the glass looked well made with just the right amount of sauce and toppings. Once we received our slices I found the dough well rolled out and everything perfectly balanced. It was a 5 star experience and we planned on going back again. Well yesterday we felt like pizza again and we were starving so decided to order a whole pizza. I glanced at the pizza behind the glass and it looked too dark for pizza that was going to be reheated, and over sauced. I was disappointed the older gentleman wasn't there. But we came with a plan so ordered anyway. We got one of their specialty pizzas because the girl behind the counter said they were a better price. And I didn't see the sausage and pepperoni one on the menu we'd gotten by the slice the previous week. BIG MISTAKE! Take note, if the older guy isn't there walk away. Honestly I'm assuming the consistency was so bad because he wasn't there. But the pizza dough wasn't rolled out well, it was extremely thin on the bottom unable to hold the toppings with edge crust that was too doughy. Thank goodness we'd asked for light sauce (unnecessary the weekend before). The toppings were very unevenly spread out. Some slices had one or two toppings while others had more bacon in one bite than the whole rest of the pizza. It was terrible. If this had been our experience the week before we'd have never returned... and might never now. If we do return I'd be leery of ordering an entire pizza again and would only get slices if the pizza looked like the first time we went. It's stressful to try to eat at inconsistent places as you never know what you'll get. It's unfortunate as it was a new place to go not far from our home. read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Toppings won't stay on when you bite, and crust is too thin. - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

I ordered a pizza from their website over an hour ago. I called to check on it and they said we don't have any drivers. When I asked why nobody called to tell me I got a "gee I don't know" they didn't do anything about it just refunded the money which takes 3-4 days. So lame. read more

My buddy and I stopped by for a pizza, after reading an article about their new location on Bitters Rd. Upon entering we noticed several cooked pizzas, which I'm guessing they use for their lunch special. Unfortunately, I don't want to eat a reheated pizza that's probably been sitting out for hours. I don't do it at home, and I won't eat it while dining out. I looked around and saw they had various bottled soft drinks and water, but I didn't see any tea. They apparently don't have ice, so at this point, I was too discouraged to eat or drink anything and went elsewhere. Their pizzas may be good, but overall this isn't for me. read more

Can we just talk about the perfection of the Calzone? We Calzone eaters get a double dose of dough, so we know. This is Calzone perfection, I am a NY'er Italian Girl. To the haters...I have no idea what you think a good pizza shop is. This is a solid shop. Great ingredients, (perhaps Ezzo, maybe...for meats, and Grande for cheese?) I am not sure as I do not see a cup and char option...however, do not sleep on this place. Grazie Mille Sofia! read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Pepperoni, sausage, roasted garlic Calzone - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Excellent every time. Crust is crispy and toppings are generous. Friendly neighborhood atmosphere. read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - 18-inch Mucho Meatsa - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Stopped in since Sophia's took over the Miss Ellie's Pizza location. Pizza doesn't disappoint. We will be visiting again the next time we are in San Antonio. read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Sausage, pepperoni, ham, and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

This pizza was served during a kids birthday party hosted at SAPB (SA plastic bricks). The pizza was spectacularly authentic NY pizza. The pizza dough was on point! Highly recommend supporting this local small business. read more

Just picked up a pizza from there and not gonna lie i was very suprised it surpassed my expectations fast quick and good service i'll be back here again read more

It's not Ms. Ellie's. That said it is a good pie. The weakest part of it is by far and away the sauce. I prefer a sweet sauce like Ms. Ellie's had. I would settle for a sauce with more spice/flavor. The sauce they have is just ok. Crust and cook are on point. I would say equal to Ms Ellie's crust and cook wise. Toppings are also quality. Great replacement pizza. We are fans. read more

Worst alleged NY style Pizza I've ever eaten. The sauce has the consistency of and tastes like someone thinned out tomato paste. Was gross. The "Buffalo" wings were devoid of flavor. How is that possible. I requested crispy wings and they completely ignored this. We went here because we saw some IG posts from influencers (I've unfollowed them since) and some reviews stating it's the best NY style pizza in SA. Those are either fake reviews or they have zero clues about what good pizza is. If I could give a 0, I would. read more

We hadn't been in this area in a while and decided to stop in for lunch. Sofias is in the former Miss Ellie's space, and I'm happy to say that the pizza is even better than I remember! It was thin and crispy, with just the right amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The sauce had that salty-sweet flavor that I absolutely love. We also ordered garlic knots. They could've been a little more garlicky but were crusty on the outside and soft on the inside. I'm so glad we decided to stop in...I think I've found my new favorite pizza place! read more

Pizza was delicious. Ate a medium by myself. Phone ordering could use some improvement, but overall a good experience.

Ok, this pizza is pretty awful. Y'all giving this place five stars need to seriously have your taste buds examined. The seating is also weird, with everyone flocking to the outer booths and leaving the three two-seater tables in the middle so everyone can watch you eat. The people seem friendly enough, but I won't return for the food. read more

Very expensive and sub par pizza. Miss Ellie's was 100% better. The service was not anything special. read more

We tried this place on a quiet Friday night (not many people sitting inside but lots of pickups happening). Owner was super friendly and made us feel very welcome, even an hour before closing. We got pizza fries which were different and so good! Then our pizza was half cheese and half meatball, also super good. We'll be back! read more

Sofia's Pizzeria - Half cheese and half meatball pizza (medium) - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Food was very delicious and staff are very friendly. Clean kitchen and dining. Highly recommended.