We've ordered from here probably 25+ times the past couple of years. The pizza is good and the prices are reasonable. Got a pizza tonight and still the same good quality and price like usual. It was an online order like we usually do and it was made quickly on a Friday evening, which is typically a busier time for pizza places so I have nothing but positive experience here. read more

I went back for the first time in a couple years for a slice and soda. It's really good again. The slices aren't double dough but not really thin. The only reason I didn't give it five stars is because they only had three sodas read more

The pizza from Sizzaly is seriously so good. This is the pizza we crave, and they have unique and delicious toppings. I was skeptical at First because some of the combinations seem odd, but I'm so happy I gave it a chance, it is SO flavorful and delicious. The service is not the most friendly, but it is very fast and overall really good. read more

Sizzaly Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

Lied about delivery time. Stopped answering the phone when they saw my number. Delivered the pizza an hour and fifteen minutes late. Ice f'ing cold! No plates. All lies. Like eating leftover pizza. Will never order from them again. Go pick it up. I never expected a $40+ pizza from a place 3 miles away to suck so much. read more

Sizzaly Pizza - a slice of pizza on a napkin - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Ordered via Door Dash. White pizza was very bland. Baked Zucchini, looked nothing like the menu photo and was dry and inedible. Will not order from again. read more

Sizzaly Pizza - This baked Zucchini looks nothing like the photo in the menu! Dry and inedible. - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

It was extremely unprofessional place. They were not organized. I placed the order online and still waited at store for 30 min to get order. Nobody had any idea about time frame, they all looked perplexed upon asking when my order would be ready. read more

Don't bother. They used to have great specialty pizzas but got rid of all of those. Then tonight, I called in a pickup order and was told 45 minutes. When I arrived, they had forgotten the order and told me it would be another 45 minutes. Just get a frozen pizza from the store. It's cheaper, more reliable, and less stressful. I miss the old Sizzaly. read more

Honestly, probably one of the worst thin crust pizzas I've ever had. We ordered it because we were hosting a birthday party for kid at Chasers Laser Tag and it was "recommended"/mentioned on their website. They didn't get the order right, even though it was pretty simple, 2 cheese, 2 sausage, 2 pepperoni (basically sent 3 cheese, 2 sausage and 1 pepperoni). When it came, seemed very dry and like it was made early and held in the warmer. Taste was bland. read more

Great quick lunch/dinner spot. Pizza slices are bigger than your head, warm, and baked to perfection plus it comes with a soda can. I also wanted to try their dessert, they have tiramisu and cannolis. I opted for the tiramisu and I am so glad I did. It's phenomenal. Literally so good. I'll be back for the cannoli though haha I'm glad I stumbled upon this place! I think my cashier was the manager he was very friendly, great customer service and held a great conversation while I waited for my food (only a few minutes). read more

Sizzaly Pizza - Pepperoni pizza slice, Mountain Dew can, tiramisu - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

We got takeout today. The crust is thin and crispy but not very flavorful. The tomato sauce is spicy and there's too much of it. Five minutes after eating and my mouth is still feeling the spice from the sauce. There is not enough cheese. The sausage was ok but had a weird flavor I didn't especially enjoy. They were out of mushrooms but didn't tell us when we ordered. And it was cold. read more

Good pizza at a great price. The sausage slice has sausage pieces the size of meatballs. Best value in Romeoville.

Great tasting pizza, we loved it. Super friendly and nice staff - I thought I was given wrong pizza when I got home, called and they said we'll make the right one for you in 10 minutes. Turned out I was wrong and the original was correct but they were so nice and gave me both, didn't charge me for the second even though I was the idiot! read more

Don't like their pizza. super thick "bread-like" crust. Basically like eating pizza bread instead of pizza crust. sauce and cheese are ok at best - nothing special basically taste like Chuckie Cheese kids pizza but with super thick bread crust and not very much toppings and cheese. prices are not cheap either for what you get. basically a giant slice of bread with little toppings and cost like $6 no thanks. read more

I used to go here weekly for a pizza slice and soda but they got new management and/or owners who don't keep their soda stocked. The quality of the pizza slowly declined. I kept going for a few months because I hoped they would address those issues but it kept getting worse. They're nice people and I haven't tried the other dishes so I didn't give it one star. read more

great service and pizza! Highly recommend their slices for lunch..the cheese and pepperoni were perfect. We will be going back for sure!

We ordered giant stadium pizzas which were delicious and perfect for birthday parties. Highly recommend! New owner is very friendly and supports the community read more

Sizzaly Pizza - Pepperoni stadium pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

The doors and store hours online said it was open until 9 P.M. on Wednesday. I'm pretty disappointed that I drove out there only for it to be closed at 8:10 P.M. I was looking forward to trying their pizza too. Oh well. read more

The service sucks can't understand lady on phone. Never any slices ready. L Pizza Slice read more

I've had this pizza twice and both times I was pleasantly surprised with how much i liked it. It smell great from the moment i picked it up and tasted even better when i got home. I haven't tried any of the Indian fusion pizza, but the bbq chicken and supreme pizzas are delicious. Thank you for the delicious meal! read more

Loved their pizza! Used to get pizza there almost 2 times a week. However, they moved out of Lisle leaving me with a 50-dollar gift certificate. Drove to the Naperville location to use it and the women at the counter said they don't except gift cards. She was definitely not like the owner I dealt with at Lisle. Boy was that a shock! read more

Sizzaly Pizza - a piece of paper with a price tag on it - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Ordered the Stadium Pizza (26" x 18") on their website, for friends that were over on Memorial Day. I ordered the Supreme (Sausage mushroom, onion & green pepper) with extra cheese & sausage. After calling 3 times to verify the time, someone finally picked up and I was told 20 minutes. No problem. I arrive at the store and there is only 1 guy working there. He tells me it will be about 10-15 minutes. He's working by himself, not my problem, but I understand that he's doing his best. 30 minutes later he brings out 2 boxes, on Stadium size box and one large box. I look at him confused because I only ordered one pizza. I thought maybe he threw in a cheese or cheese & sausage pizza for waiting so long. I open up the Stadium box and all I see is cheese & sausage. I told him that this was not what I ordered. I ordered one pizza, a supreme with extra cheese and sausage. He then tells me, "No. This is what you ordered." I looked at the printed receipt that was attached to the smaller box and there was only on size pizza listed 26" x 18", as I had stated. After explaining to him for several minutes, what the pizza was supposed to be, he calls his manager and after being on the phone for a few more minutes, realizes that he had made the wrong pizza. He tells me hat it will be ten minutes. I said, "Ten minutes? Are you sure it won't be 15 or 20? Be honest." H said 10 minutes. I said, "Ok. GO!" and started the 10 minute timer on my phone. I frequently gave him 2 minute updates and he kept coming back to apologize and even scratched his head with his hand. I said, "You're going to wash your hand, right?!" He looked at me like he didn't understand what I was saying. I said I just saw you scratch your head and before that you were placing cheese on the pizzas without gloves. SO since you don't use gloves to apply toppings, I assume you have clean hands when preparing food, however you just scratched your head and were headed to the food and not the sink." He then proceeded to wash his hands and 20 minutes later I finally had the correct pizza. Unfortunately this was 90 minutes after I had ordered it. When I spoke to the manager later that week, and described what had happened, she asked me "What would you like me to do?" I said, "If I have to explain to you that this is an unacceptable way to run your business, maybe you shouldn't be in business." This was the first time I have EVER had an issue with this place. I'm not sure if it's under new management or a different owner, but just be forewarned. read more

Sizzaly Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

Picked up pizza here on New Years and the guy there was so friendly! He even upgraded our large pizza to an extra large being it was a holiday. We will definitely be back. Everything was delicious, even the next day reheated in the air fryer! read more

Just moved to the area and I noticed the sign saying giant slices and a drink for cheap. I ordered a Medium Mediterranean pizza online and didn't realize they changed the specialty pizza menu and that style pizza wasn't on the menu anymore. Guess what? They made it special for me without hesitation! Now that I see the specialty pizza selection I will definitely be back and order that Tika Masala pizza. Great service all around! I even forgot my phone there when we left and Raj was kind enough to email me that I had left it and that I could pick it up the next day on New years day. read more

Well worth trying, great pizza and Friendly Service! We ordered a large half veggies and half sausage and let me tell you they are fresh and delicious as well as generous! Give them a try, I know we'll be back. read more

Today was the first time my wife and I tried the pizza at Sizzaly! We know our pizzas and the pizza we had today was super delicious and it was a 10+. Loved the diced tomatoes and the purple onions on the pizza and a perfect blend of sauce and cheese as well as a great crust. Outstanding Sizzaly. read more

Our family tried this Pizza place recently. It's fairly new and our family is adventurous... we love trying new places. We ordered their family bundle that included Italian Beef & Giardiniera thin crust large pizza and a family size salad. Wow... loved it! Very tasty and equally important not greasy! Finally an Italian Beef Pizza I can recommend. Next time I am going back for their Garlic White Pizza. read more

Sizzaly Pizza - Family attacking the Italian Pizza already - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

Great local pizza place! Highly recommend the Garlic White pizza & the Italian beef/giardiniera toppings. Everything we ordered was tasty (combo, jalapeño poppers, pepperoni slice) Fast & friendly service. You won't be disappointed. read more

Sizzaly Pizza - Stadium pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

I would give zero stars if could! Placed an order for delivery was told everything was fine. I had to remind staff that it was delivery and repeated my address several times, when notice the door dash tracking was to the wrong address, I called to notify and the food was delivered to a place that's not my address! Asked to speak to manager and was hung on with no call back, no pizza, and no refund! Absolutely the worst! Do not order from here!!! read more

Ordered 1 large supreme put in notes 1/2 sausage only - they didn't understand it and made it all a supreme- I give them credit they offered to send a new one - just frustrating they can take orders digitally but can't use it to verify - definitely will go to another place in future. read more

Sizzaly Pizza - Pizza made incorrectly - Pizza Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Not the worst pizza in Naperville, but not the best either. Ordered a stadium pizza with a $7 off coupon and everyone enjoyed it. Best part was that the pizza contained REAL mozzarella cheese. Give these guys a try if you want good taste at a great value read more

Gyro XL was disappointingly weak in flavor, too much wet ingredient and too shy on a weaker Gyro (something like Greek Islands) let the flavor wash out to tomato and (perfectly cooked) red onion. Consider switching to Kronos or some other saltier spicier gyro or tossing on more. 3 instead of 2 for a nice Cannoli. read more

Bad service-horrible pizza, dry, tasteless, disgusting!!!!! Plus the place is filthy inside.

Great pizza.. awesome prices.. customer service is excellent... Kathy is the best and makes the best pizza and is always very polite and respectful read more

Awful ,,.. ...,. Worst.. awful lol. Management no was aful. They vocally abuesed our party. Never recommend. I hope higher be management hears this read more

I work in the area and I stopped by for the first time for a slice on my lunch. The slice was HUGE! Definitely get a good bang for your buck. Very friendly staff. Love the crust. Will definitely be back read more

Great food and timely delivery! All their food is baked, nothing fried. Highly recommend the Parmesan bread bites and the bbq chicken pizza. They also deliver right on time whenever I've asked for a specific time and it's always hot. Ordered 3 times and always impressed! read more

Tried this new place for dinner, got a thin crust sausage mushroom pizza. The crust was tasty and the ingredients all tasted fresh and a good amount of toppings used. I plan on returning in the future. read more

I thought I'd try this pizza place since it was so close to my home and I had a $5 off coupon. Worst pizza ever! I usually don't complain about pizza but this one was so soggy from about 1/2" from the edge of the pizza all the way in. I got a 4 topping specialty pizza and ate 1 piece. Threw the rest out along with the coupons. Looking at the reviews, I'm not sure why people usually love it or hate it. Maybe a different chef on one day? read more

Delicious--The vegetables are super fresh-Crust is crispy light --excellent pizza sauce --baked appetizers were really really good. Cheese and sausage are really good --it's going into my pizza rotation read more

Better than expected for a grab and go place. You are definitely getting a large quantity for your money.The staff there was what made the difference hard to find good people like that these days read more