First time patron for lunch yesterday and my cobb salad with ginger sesame dressing was delicious and plentiful. I had the juice bar cocktail and it was very watered down and lacking any slight alcohol flavor. My friend had a wrap and fries and was very happy with her selection. I would definitely go back but would probably just get a bottled drink next time. read more

Excellent food, friendly staff! Great local place. Highly recommend Reuben egg rolls, tuna steak dinner or sandwich!

Food was excellent. Both my fiancé and I got wraps. She had the chicken Caesar wrap and i had the chicken bacon ranch wrap. The sweet potato fries are outstanding. Oh, can't forget to mention the wings! Mango habanero..... out of this world delicious. read more

Nice old place. Friendly service but some regulars get deafingly loud. Reuben is as good as advertised read more

Great food!! Have the Reuben, and monkey fries. You will not be disappointed. Wide, wide beer selection. They will put the Reubens fixings on a plate for those who can't eat bread. Happily, this is within walking distance of my home. Those who were all upset by not wearing of masks in September 2020: Wisconsin's legislature rescinded the unconstitutional mask mandate in May 2020, and again for good measure in December. Nobody stopped you from wearing a mask. If masks work so well, why didn't yours protect you? read more

Love, Love, Love Siebert's! Always consistent! Food is always excellent! Best onion soup! Bang Bang Shrimp also is a nice way to start the meal. Salads are a nice size. Many nice choices, some that are not offered at other restaurants. Service is also excellent which makes the dining experience enjoyable! read more

We moved to Illinois about a year and a half ago. When speaking to people about good restaurants, we were told about Sieberts Pub. We went there and tried their Reuben sandwich. It was so good that we have been going back ever since. We were there last night. Our waitress, Shannon, had only been working there a few days. I asked for an Appletini, which was not on the beverage menu and she made a perfect one. She was a very good waitress, and the food was excellent. read more

What can I say ?? We've been coming here the last few year's and I can honestly say that I've never had a bad experience, drink or meal, ever. A great fish fry, Long Island's are powerful and the food is excellent. Very personable staff and they treat you right. I can say, "try it you'll like it " Seriously good. read more

Great food, great prices, local venue. A little tight inside, but summer it's a joy to have a drink on the deck.

Ohhhhh that was the sheeeeiiit. I came for the Ruben. Amazingly tender corned beef had an easy bite, even cross-grain. Homemade sauce and sauerkraut on marble was juicy without being oily. The sammich came with signature chips the size of a coaster that were crispy all the way through. My girl had some boneless wings with a signature stout sauce. The (chicken nuggets, cuz let's face it, that's what boneless wings are) stout sauce is a complex bbq sauce without being spicy. We then saw the next table receive bubbly crocks of French onion soup. Had. To. Have. Rich and dark with toasty brown gruyere(?) on top. There was a very friendly music trivia DJ running a fun game in the bar. The waitresses were very attentive and the drinks were well mixed. My lady had a mango Long Island that was scrumdiddly. The building has lots of history and you can tell the place is well cared for and managed. It was exactly what I hoped it would be. I invite all of you to meet us there sometime. A hidden gem. read more

Great food! Friendly staff! French onion soup is amazing! Nice local spot. Enjoyed my visit!

Love this place! Ordered 3x since moving to the Salem Lakes area and every meal was amazing! the French onion soup is a must, even to go it was very good and still pretty hot! Orders did not take long to be done and picked up, employees were friendly the sec you walk in the door and make sure you are being assisted. read more

Food was amazing!! You need to get the Reuben. Atmosphere and food were extremely welcoming. Owner stopped by to welcome us and make sure everything was perfect. Got the monkey fries as well. They were delicious as well! read more

Sieberts Pub - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

See all

Go in there for the Rubens and their sausage and kale soup. A winner every time! Staff is always friendly and welcoming!

I've been coming here for almost 10 years regularly on Saturday's...a new owner took over just over a year ago...at first nothing changed the food was still just as fabulous!! Amazing!! Talked this place up to everyone I knew...the last 10 times my husband and I have come in the food has taken a dramatic down turn. The Italian beef barely had meat in it. The "famous" Ruben, again, barely any meat and burnt rye bread. The WILD mushroom bruchetta has no wild mushrooms anymore only giant slices of over cooked portabella and the garlic cream cheese sauce is so thin you can't taste it. It is still advertised as wild mushrooms and its still the same price. I was so disappointed that I won't be giving one of my favorite spots an 11th try. So sad. I so loved Sieberts and now I'm not coming back. read more

Great local place with friendly service! The bloody Mary's and French onion soup are delicious.

Walked in on a Saturday with a travel baseball team with siblings and parents in tow(about 35 of us). The employees were organized, friendly, and accurate, and most of all welcoming. Food was awesome! I'm a ruben snob and theirs was one of the best! Monkey fries to die for. No complaints!! lots of bars t.v.s and clean restrooms. read more

Sieberts Pub - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

See all

Went on a Friday with my wife. This was our first visit. We planned on doing a fish fry but I had to get the Reuben to see what all the fuss is about. The Reuben is huge! With nice chunks of meat, plenty of sauce and kraut. The marble rye holds holds this bad boy together nicely. Definitely the best Reuben I've ever tasted. My wife got the cod fish fry. The pieces of fish were decent size with a nice cornmeal breading which I prefer to battered fish. Breading was crispy, not oily. Both the fries and sweet potato fries were good. Service was great! The menu has something for everyone. Looking forward to stopping by again. read more

Sieberts Pub - Cod and Reuben - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

We come here all the time. They have a good beer selection the bartenders are always super friendly the waitresses are always super friendly and then you overall is pretty good I'm pretty sure anybody can find something here read more

Came here twice ... dinner on Saturday then late lunch on Sunday last weekend. Both times food was excellent! I ended up getting the Portabella sammich both times. I saw that they showed an ahi tuna sammich and ahi steak... was so psyched... until server said they didn't have the tuna anymore and were in the process of updating their menu! Boo! Mushroom was perfect both times and *quite* large, but perfectly cooked and seasoned. It comes with choice of cheese, but really is better without (can definitely taste rich flavor without the dairy). They have full menu, and was definitely surprised at the variety and quality - definitely not just average local pub offerings! They even have Moscato wine (which is my fave) which is probably not for the distinguished wine person, but it tastes like candy and I love it! (I'm not much of a drinker) The MUST-HAVE item is / are the Monkey Fries. You may need clearance from your physician to eat these due to their sheer caloric/ fat / cholesterol content, but I assure you that you will die happy with this specialty in your gut. Imagine a loaf of freshly cooked cheesebread... now change the bread to fries and triple any imagined cheese on top! In fact, the cheese should cover ... no SMOTHER this loaf of potato perfection - it should ooze over the sides! Now add a side of a remoulade-type dipping sauce and start pulling this baby apart, horny-monkey style, yo! Yum de-fook-ayyyy! Oops - did you order entrees? Yeah, you're prolly gonna need a few Doggie Boxes for those and also for part of the Fries! Do I recommend this place? Yes - go before the Health Department shuts them down for those Monkey Fries! read more

We just got home from a late lunch/early dinner at Sieberts. I don't even want to risk forgetting to review. Let's sum this up for those that don't want details: My belly is very happy. Everything was delicious/amazing and reasonably priced. I'm very reluctant to 5 star rate but this place deserved it! Now for details: We started off with the French Onion Soup. Perfectly seasoned with the right amount of salt (sometimes this soup elsewhere can be too salty or taste like an onion took a quick bath and jumped out-this was perfect, savory and delicious). Then we had their.....Rueben Egg Rolls. No kidding. It's a real thing. I am NOT a Rueben fan...but this was so amazing....that I just may try their Rueben sandwich next time...these are large egg rolls stuffed full with tender corned beef, saurkraut, and swiss cheese. It's served with a side of 1000 island dressing. I had to limit myself since I was also getting a sandwich. I could have just had these for a meal. wow My main meal was the BBQ Pulled Pork sandwich. This wasn't the best I've had but it was definitely good. I had the sweet potato fries that were the best I've had and cooked perfectly. Nice and crisp, not overdone, seasoned well and not greasy. My husband had the penne pasta with chicken. He really liked it. He did have to add salt (but he;s a salt addict) but it had a nice rich flavor. Very very good. Lastly-the service. Our waitress's name was Eileen and she said that she's been waitressing for 20 years. I believe it! The pace of the meal was perfect. We never were with empty glasses and she checked on us the perfect amount. Not constantly popping in to where it was distracting....but we were very well taken care of and she had great recommendations. All in all- we felt very welcomed, had a delicious, well priced meal in a comfortable atmosphere. We will...without a doubt...be back...very soon! read more

From the looks of it, you'd expect this to be just another easily forgettable small Wisconsin bar. Wrong. This place is anything but. They've got a small dining area that's not the best for big groups but certainly big enough for the average family. Their bar is an average size "full bar" that's a great place to grab a couple beers with some friends. The food here is actually something to write home about and is what sets this place apart. I was surprised the first time I ate here. I expected the typical greasy bar type food served in a basket with wax paper on the bottom. However, their cooks do a great job preparing the food here and the simple but tasteful presentation of even a burger is nicely done and much appreciated. It's a welcome change to the usual boring hamburger. They use some nice ingredients here as well that are yet another welcome change, small touches that make this place stand out. If you're looking for an awesome appetizer you MUST get the monkey fries, they will not disappoint. Staff is friendly too. read more

Are here for the first time, and we will definitely be back. Staff was friendly, service was excellent. Had the French onion soup and Reuben that everyone raves about, and they were both in my top 3 of best I've ever had....that says a lot. Decor is great. Has the old Wisconsin feeling that I love. read more

Our group has been seeking the best fish fry for months- so much so that we have begun to expect congealed pseudo- cod with wilted potatoes and old style served by overworked and tired servers as the norm. This fish fry ranked 10 across the board - food, beer selection, service,ambience... Everything. Fish was tasty with the breAdy being soggy or impenetrable. The Tasty potato pancakes were served with sour cream and apple sauce. The bread served beforehand is a gateway drug to heroin. Highly recommend. read more

Amazing reuben sandwich, great service. They let me bring my dog on patio. Will definitely be back! read more

Sieberts Pub - Reuben sandwich, nice pulled pork style with great flavor and generous helping. Yummy! - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

Good food for a little pub. The French onion soup is a must, also get the ruben so delicious I needed to change my pants. All in all, great place. read more

My wife and I love Sieberts, but if you want COVID and don't know how to catch it, pay a visit. I walked in to pick up a takeout order and thought I had entered the Twilight Zone. No one was masked--except me--including the servers, and no one was observing any kind of distancing. To top it off, Salem Lakes, the nearest town, has had over 150 cases and a nearby school district gave up in person teaching today when 3 kids tested positive. This behavior is simply irresponsible. The food is great and the atmosphere is friendly. Current practices there are homicidal. read more

I've been here quite a few times for "trivia Tuesdays" and it's been a blast, but no matter what day you're here the food is killer. The wild mushroom bruschetta is unbelievable! I split the ribeye sandwich and the portabella sandwich with a friend and both were AWESOME! I go out of my way to go here, and it's totally worth it. read more

Sieberts Pub - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

Small place, has great charm. Has a good variety of things on the menu as well as a great drink selection. The Ruben sandwich is one of the best in the area. When your out and about and feel like a quick bite. Make sure you check this place out. read more

I liked that place. Friendly atmosphere, tasty food, great location. I ordered a burger and it was delicious! Highly recommend this pub! read more

Rueben is what you should order. Beers and drinks are solid and not too expensive. Couple tv screens at the bar, local spot. read more

Nice little place. Charming old house turned bar and restaurant over 100 years ago. If your in the area choices are limited so this place is a local stand out. We were at the ski resort near by and stopped for dinner and drinks. Had the pulled pork sandwich and corn-beef egg rolls. Was better than average and lets face it there isn't many choices. I would highly recommend if near by. read more

Small town pub, where the regular customers are like family. They always have delicious beers on draft and the food is amazing!! The Ruben will keep you coming back again and again. read more

See all

Excellent local pub that's been around since God was a baby. Good food and good beer. Try the fish fry with potato pancakes! You might have to wait for a seat on the weekends for a seat. Take out offered. read more

One word....WOW!!! Only downside of this little gem is that the restaurant is not that big & has a very small dining room......but......it was worth the wait!!! Something for everyone....even the most finickest palate. Wonderful vegetarian options. Their portobello sandwich is to die for!!!! I cannot wait to go back!!! Their baked French onion soup and monkey fries are A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!!!! The service is as fantastic as the food they serve!! This may be one of my new favorite restaurants. We will definitely go back!! read more

On a sunny Friday afternoon, we stopped in for a late lunch and yum! I have come here before with my family, but was with my mom and sister on this visit. My mom ordered the portobello mushroom sandwich, which I did not try, but my sister and I went halfsies on the grilled cheese and the Reuben. The server promised it will be the best Reuben ever and it was! Homemade corned beef, not too fatty or greasy. The grilled cheese was equally awesome. Fantastic service and the decor is eclectic, not dated. Great option for the area!! read more

Place is small and there is a reason why it's packed. Get there early. Food is good. Service is great. Place is packed because it's good. Small enough to feel like the local place but good enough to not think you are in Wisconsin. Kid friendly but always packed. read more

Old small town hotel. Perch is excellent, clam chowder, is great, and very filling! Fried Cod is also delicious. Don't order the potato pancakes, no flavor, and like rubber. Service is awesome, and the drinks are properly priced. I recommend getting there early. The place is rather small, and it is extremely popular with the locals. Friendly staff!!. read more

Grest food all around. Don't miss out on the baked onion soup and reuben. This is the only place I know of that offers a cup of baked french onion soup and/or bowl. read more

Great, close ambiance. You're one of the family when you get in. Cold drinks, hot food and fantastic waitresses! Would go again!