Stopped by but there was a 40 min wait so we ordered for delivery instead . Everything arrived HOT and was delicious . We got pizza and some apps and was surprised that it all costs way less than having a pizza delivered in chicago . Will definitely try and sit down and eat at the restaurant next time we are in town . read more

Recommended to us by a local and definitely a good spot to try to get the true Wisconsin experience. Burgers were nothing special but large drink menu and good prices. read more

Next Door Pub - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Of all the restaurants we dined in Lake Geneva for a long weekend getaway, this one gave us the biggest bang for our buck. We ate 4 decent sized pizzas with couple of appetizers for a family of 4 with couple of teenagers, and were able to have some leftovers for next day. It's unfortunate we missed this place on previous visits, and we look forward to eating here again during our next trip. read more

We just got to town and it was late, about 8:45. They close at ten on Fridays, and they still took our party of 9. We were so grateful, and our server was so sweet. She did a great job! Thank you guys for saving our night! read more

Stopped in here after visiting Oktoberfest. 4 o'clock and the crowds were not stirring yet this place can get busy on a Saturday night. I had the keto friendly Sicilian bowl and a cup of their delicious beer cheese bratwurst soup. Definitely a winner, the staff was very cordial and accommodating. They are known for their Pizza, so if you're ever in the area, I highly recommend it. After my last visit, they are still going strong and their quality intact. read more

Next Door Pub - Great wine & drink menu! - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

The pizza is delicious, the appetizer fried brussel sprout, pork with sauce is outstanding! I get it every time I order from this restaurant. Great service too! read more

Love there pizza ordered a pizza last night and nothing of what I ordered .. next time I'll have to look at what we bought read more

See all

What a gem in a great location! It seems many of the locals frequent as we had to wait 25 minutes for a table at 1:30 pm for lunch. It was totally worth the wait! Hostess and servers were friendly and great. Great variety of options for both drinks and food. Can't wait to go back and try more options! The cheese soup was so velvety smooth and delicious I could have had more. The fish fry is a standard menu item which I soooo appreciated! Flat bread is like half a pizza and so fresh. Tons of ample parking, spacious and clean aesthetics. read more

See all

This was a good place to have dinner we meet some people and had a fun time. We got a huge pretzel. It comes with 3 dipping sauces. It worked out well we each like different ones lol. The. We got two pizza. They were good in the flavor department. We got sausage and our friends got a something with lots of stuff. To say the least we did have some leftover and they were great still the next day. It was delicious and worth the effort read more

See all

Glad I found this place, through Yelp and Dave Portnoy. Bree, the bartender at Fat Cats, recommended the artichoke dip. Bree said, "People come from Illinois just for the dip." I will say, the chips are fried (pizza dough I think) and they make the dip 10 times better. Chef Geno makes the dip better at home. The pizza is what I am used to and very cheesy. It could have been cooked a little bit more, but it was very tasty. Portnoy gave the pizza a 7.1. I give it a 7.7. Portnoy also thinks that frozen pizza lookin ass, tiny, New England bar pies are good. I guess it's nostalgia for him, and this is the kind of pizza that I grew up on in Kenosha and Racine. It is better than a 7.1, though. Service was friendly in a rushed way. Irritation alert-there was one waitress wearing a mask, and we get her, of course. Can we done with this now, people? Get a "work from home job" if you feel the need to wear a mask 24/7. Would I return? Absolutely. The Italian beef looked good and so did a few other menu items. Definitely worth a stop if in Lake Geneva. Avoid the tourist traps and go to a local fave. read more

See all

Best pizza in lake Geneva, WI. All their food is delicious and service is Awesome. Very nice big bar and two tables in bar area, best seats in the bar. read more

This is our second time at Next Door Pub when we have visited the Lake Geneva area. This is a fantastic place to go with kids - service has always been so accommodating with our twins! The food is really good! The giant pretzel - wow, huge, soft and several great dipping sauces. I had a burger with port wine cheese and it was cooked to perfection. The perch and hot beef sandwiches were good as well. Last time we had pizzas and those were a hit! Highly recommend this as a low key place with great food and service! read more

Next Door Pub - Jumbo pretzel with three dipping sauces - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

Next Door Pub is a great option if you are looking for a variety of meal options. We've been here a couple times and it feels very hit or miss when it comes to who's the server. All around the food comes at pretty quickly after ordering. read more

Next Door Pub - Caesar salad with grilled chicken - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Really great food at an affordable price - BBQ Brisket with Brussel Sprouts appetizer and Reuben sandwiches were outstanding! Service was great as well! read more

Not really understanding the hype about this place, maybe because we're used to amazing pizza in the city. We ordered wings and two pizzas both sausage and pepperoni. The pizza barely had any sausage on it, some pieces didn't have any! Service wasn't all that and a bag of chips either. Maybe the locals settle for this because there's nothing else near by but I won't be returning for this. read more

Next Door Pub - Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

I've gone there for several years excellent wonderful employees food is good ,great in the specially the pizza and they deliver too it's wonderful read more

Great menu,fast carry out. Expect them to be busy. They can handle it, they have a good system.

It was my first time there. We sat outside and the service was pretty slow at first. When she did come she was friendly and attentive. I had the pasta with meat sauce and meatballs and it was delicious. It was so big that I made two meals out of it. read more

I placed a pick up order that I had to wait 30 minutes past the time they gave me for it to be ready. Apparently an item I order was not in stock so they texted me to call them and did not bother to answer the phone for 16 minutes. I selected another item. The Nachos appetizer ($13.50) contained 17 blue tortilla chips. When ordered in restaurant they come on a huge platter! What a rip off! read more

If you're in the Lake Geneva area and looking for some good pub and pizza, this is a great go to place. They have a great family atmosphere and the ambiance is lively! The service is great and attentive without being overly annoying. The indoor and outdoor seating areas are so inviting and vast. We ordered the spinach and artichoke dip accompanied with flatbread. The dip was so creamy and the hint of parmesan on top just did it. The flatbread could have been an appetizer on its own. We also ordered some onion rings which were crispy and tasty. For dinner, we ordered a personal spinach pizza for my daughter which she absolutely loved. I had the bourbon chicken flatbread and chicken sandwich which were both excellent. read more

See all

This place never wavers - it's always THE best pizza in Wisconsin, bar none. Having grown up in Chicago, I know good pizza when I taste it.. and the pizzas at NDP are always consistently GREAT. The wings are a close 2nd. And the service at the bar is faster than anywhere! read more

This pub never disappoints. We went for dinner right before the dinner rush and got a table right away. Ordered their Buffalo wings (spicy). These were hot, spicy and definitely not soggy. We also ordered thin crust pizza. Love their crispy crust and the pizza always comes out hot! read more

Next Door Pub - Buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

Their pizza and wings are excellent! Service is always top notch with friendly staff. It's usually really busy here.

First off, on a Saturday night we were able to quickly get a seats at the bar within record time. Our waiter, Grimme, was kind, quick, and very helpful. The atmosphere was wonderful and the bar did not seem too loud at all, even though it was packed. The food, absolutely amazing. We got meatballs as an appetizer and a half sausage and mushroom, half pepperoni and pineapple pizza. Super flavorful, grading ingredients, and it held up very well. Definitely would recommend going again. read more

See all

The best pizza in town, for sure. Also, super strong and great cocktails. The vibe is very relaxed, and they do have an outdoor area to eat as well. Shockingly, the salads are incredible. Chicken on pizza is usually low quality, gross, reheated chicken. They have real, fresh chicken and it's everything. I love the monthly pizza flavor changes and the service is great. read more

The parking lot was packed on a Thursday at 630. We had to park in the back of restaurant. Once inside we were immediately seated. It is very small inside and loud. I ordered a burger and my husband ordered ribs. My burger was juicy and the ribs were tender. I give it 4 out of 5 stars due to no Prosecco available and we waited quite awhile for our food. read more

See all

The food is good and the portions are big. The pretzel is very big! We ordered some sandwiches and burgers, so everything was pretty standard American fare. They have a kids menu with crayons for the little ones. It was very busy when we came for dinner, around 5:45-6pm on a weekday. The dining room is very dark and noisy. There's not much extra room, because there was nowhere to put our stroller or the chairs that had to be removed to accommodate high chairs. They do have an outdoor seating area, but it was too cold when we visited. read more

We were visiting Lake Geneva and wanted a casual place for pizza. Looked up some local places and found this gem. It was quite busy on a Monday night so we sat at the bar. We were waited on right away and the pizza came out nice and hot. The pizza was awesome ordered a 12" sausage and it was a BIG 12". It was also a great value too. The sausage was real big hunks of ground sausage and there was plenty of cheese the crust was slightly crispy and chewy. We had some leftover we took with us and had the next night for dinner. Saw some of the other menu items and they looked good too. We would definitely go back again. read more

My family and I were visiting the Lake Geneva area for a long weekend and stumbled upon this gem. Next Door Pub has an old-school rustic vibe. They have a small patio outside and also a waiting area where you can order drinks. Service was good. Everyone was super friendly except for the hostess. Now to the food! Everything was so yummy! I was pleasantly surprised! We ordered a spinach pizza, bbq chicken pizza, a grilled chicken sandwich, spinach artichoke dip, and onion rings. The pizza was delicious, and the crust was perfect ( I didn't try the bbq one, just commenting on the spinach)! The spinach artichoke dip with the Flatbread was amazingly good. I can still taste it! Haha! I couldn't get enough of it! And the onion rings were awesome, perfectly crispy. If we ever end up back in Lake Geneva, will definitely go back! read more

See all

I love coming here for lunch. Dinners okay too, but I like their many choices of luncheon specials. I've had the beef cheesesteak for lunch with extra crunchy crispy onion rings. This Monday I enjoyed the chicken wings for $2 off 10 wings and I like the Korean inspired BBQ sauce. I wanted a hearty salad with no meat and the wedge salad was perfect! Their soups are also good and my husband likes the Wisconsin cheese soup. When my grandkids are here, they enjoy the pizza here, too. Restrooms recently updated and very clean tidy and amenities are touchless! Very casual atmosphere, but occasionally there will be a very loud conversation that can be very disruptive, but the person being so vocal often isn't aware of it. The wait staff is awesome, quick to refill drinks and quick to clean off dirty dishes. read more

See all

3.5 We were told 45 min-1hr wait but we got seated a bit earlier which we appreciated! Our server was very nice but the reason why I docked it a couple stars is because the food took SO. LONG. to come out. To be fair, we were a larger table but we waited well over an hour since we gave our order to get our food. Ambiance is very pub-hole in the wall- family vibes. The food itself was decent in terms of taste but the food took absolutely way too long to come out. I might come back with a smaller table to see if the experience is different. read more

Amazing pizza at a reasonable price! We found this place via Dave Portnoy's social media account and were thoroughly impressed.

Best ribs! The cheese curds blew my mind. The staff was very friendly. Plenty of options. Just a little advice, come early, the place gets packed read more

very friendly staff. great food and atmosphere. Waldo was very friendly. staff is amazing .

What can you say about quality ingredients and a top notch staff. Best Pizza around. Highly recommend .My mouth is watering just thinking about it. read more

I continue to take guests to NDP and they are fully impressed. Next Door Pub Lake Geneva and NDP Lakeshore read more

Next Door Pub - Side salad - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

We went here today for my daughter's 22nd birthday! We LOVED it!!! The food was amazing so were the drinks! The service was great with Alan! We sat on the patio and it was amazing we had the best time! The spinach artichoke dip was AMAZING!!! We loved the chicken tenders kids meal and the salads and soup! Cheese curds were great also!!! Great place would highly recommend!!! read more

See all

We visited Next Door Pub & Pizzeria with a large group while staying in Lake Geneva. We arrived right when they opened for lunch so we had no issues being seated. The atmosphere was nice and our service was good. The staff was friendly. We chose Next Door Pub & Pizzeria because it had good reviews and a large menu. They have a little bit of everything which worked well with our large group of adults, kids, and someone who eats gluten-free. They are also centrally located between downtown (where we were spending the day) and Timber Ridge Lodge (where we were staying). The prices are also reasonable. Unfortunately, between a plethora of different drinks, and dishes (including pizza and several fish fry options), no one in our group thought the food was anything great. It wasn't good or bad, but suffice it to say when we were looking for a place to eat on a different evening no one wanted to return there either. If I were back in Lake Geneva I'd probably give this place another whirl and try something else on the menu (I had a cod fish fry) but at this point, I don't feel like it lived up to the hype/reviews. read more

I drive up from Illinois for their delish lasagna no makes this kind of been enjoying it for years now. The pizza great wings good verity excellent menu read more

Great for pizza. Skip the rest. Their famous lasagna wasn't what i cared for. Mushy pasta