Sunday wings are a bargain! Love the varied long Islands and just recently tried the Thai Chili Nachos (not spicy, has a peanut sauce) and they were yummy. The Staff are super friendly, this is a great place to visit. read more

Great place. Friendly staff, great food. Not much fancy decor but I'm not there for the art. Best Rueben Sandwich in Wisconsin. The fish fry is exceptional with potato pancakes or fries. They serve it all with a smile. read more

A vey good place to have a casual night. We had wing and nachos. Thai nachos so yummy beer is good we had it was fresh. The wings were big and naked I had sweet chili and bbq , buffalo was at the table teriyaki bang bang and one other flavor. The fries are ok. Not my favorite fries. They seem to be the natter kind. The staff was great. Food was fast will definitely be back read more

See all

Terrible - food was 5 / 10 - yuengleng on tap was new in the area but it tasted like they haven't cleaned their lines since prohibition - and something really smelled bad by the bar - will not be back read more

Amazing Ruben Sandwich at this Pub! The service has always been friendly and very efficient. Pretty decent happy hour and happy hour menu!

Great Friday Fish fry selection went with the Perch very good, would definitely come back and try the Haddock and or the Cod. read more

Sieberts Pub - Friday night Perch - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

Reuben was 5 stars, meatloaf was also phenomenal and was well over a pound. Bartender gave great suggestions and was very attentive. We're definitely going back. read more

Friendly staff, good atmosphere, great food! Portion sizes are very large. Definitely worth the trip!

Love this great local place! The food is awesome. Portions are generous and the prices are reasonable. The real pearl is the outstanding waitstaff. They treat you like family. It is a nice evening out. read more

My first time there and will definitely be back- service was great and friendly, food was prompt, hot, and excellent! The Friday night fish fry was outstanding! read more

Sieberts Pub - Fish Fry! - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

The food was delicious. We went for the Friday Fish Fry. Lots of locals, which is a good sign, and most people also ordered the fish fry. The baked fish was not as good as the fried. Ambiance was loud and busy. Long wait, but plenty of space to wait on porch. Server was a little curt but likely because of the busyness. We will certainly go again, but maybe lunch next time to avoid the Friday night rush. read more

We were there last night for dinner. Service was great . French Onion soup delicious, Cheddar Burger with bacon was also delicious cooked perfect. Fries were ok little bit greasy . Oil needed to be filtered & cleaned. Ordered an Absolute Citrin vodka on rocks with twist . It wasn't Absolute Citrin at all . They gave me some other brand . I know my Vodka's & other spirits . It's not what it used to be when the original owners owned it . But on the hole it passed . PRK read more

We made a little trip on Harley. Goin places and doin things. We stopped here for lunch. Me and the wife split a Reuben and it was delicious!! We also had the sauce on the side, and the fries were phenomenal (I hate fries usually). The sauce is very good!! Don't pass on that component. I also had a Hofbrau to go along with my sando!! You can't go wrong with German beer. The place is historical-ish and I would've bet the farm it had spooks. The server used to live there (upstairs) and gave us a few ghost stories. My spidey sense did not lie about those Caspers!! In end, don't be scared of the ghost and stop in for some good food/friendly service. We will definitely be back to try other items. read more

See all

Nice old school pub just over the border. The service was friendly and food and drinks were served in a timely manner. The Reuben was great! Only complaint was the draft beer was slightly flat. read more

Sieberts Pub - Reuben - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

I met a good friend at Siebert's for a few barley-pops and lunch. The service was excellent and patient with us as we drank and caught up on our lives before we ordered. The food was delicious and we really enjoyed ourselves. We definitely recommend this place for a drink, food and catching up life! 5 Stars read more

best lake perch outside of door county!!! well worth a special trip. crowded and small, great staff keeps people happy

Stopped by last night w/ my wife and MIL, and boy are we glad we did! Perched up at the bar with some big TVs showing the Badger game where Bucky took back the axe from the Goohers. Friendly bartenders were happy to walk us through the tap/bottle options. The three of us each started with a crock of deliciously cheesy French onion soup. Omg, incredible! For dinner we got a couple Reuben sandwiches and a patty melt. We understand why the Reuben has the amazing reputation it does. Massive sandwich piled high with corned beef, tangy & melty Swiss, and plenty of sauerkraut provided the perfect acidic compliment to the savory meat and cheese. Fries are battered and nicely crispy with a soft, hot center. Wifey loved her tasty patty melt! We'll be back! read more

Best Corned Beef on Marble Rye Amazing And the Best Fries Ever! Worth a special trip!!!! read more

Sieberts Pub - The Best Corned Beef ever on Marble Rye And the Best Fries ever!!!!! - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

Great food! Great service! We wings were nice and crispy had the honey buffalo & stinging garlic. Spinach/artichoke dip was great! Great friendly atmosphere. Will be back. read more

Food was good. I had the hand breaded chicken fingers and tots. Service was friendly.

Real good. Bar food type menu but much better than average. Good burgers, really good French onion soup, decent draft selection and good service. Will go here again. read more

Super sweet servers! Food was very good and at an affordable price. Very charming older building. I would go back!

Everything was great. Atmosphere, service, food. The best. Will be going again. My wife's favorite is the Brussels sprouts. I even have to admit they are very good. read more

Make you feel at home is what you'll experience with the friendly service and comfortable atmosphere that Sieberts provides. I have never ordered anything that was not delicious! Bottom line; Food is Great! Service is Great! Great place to stop for food or drinks!! read more

Stopped here for lunch on our way home from Wilmot snow tubing and the food was delicious! Some of the best cheese curds we've ever had!! Also ordered the delicious monkey fries, and all of the sauces were made in house and so tasty. I split the boneless wings and the pub quesadilla with someone in my party and they were served hot and tasted delicious. The kids in our party had the Mac n cheese and corn dogs and loved them as well. They ever got root beer in bottles that they thought was pretty cool! We come from the Chicagoland area, but will DEFINITELY be back for Sieberts!!! read more

See all

So many reviews from Chicagoans stopping by on their way back from Lake Geneva. That's a shame as people ought to know what this is place is really like when it's not serving the Friday Fish Fry. The taps are bad, rarely changed, except for the two popular ones. Some of the beers don't taste the way they should it's so bad - flat and skunked. The food is very expensive as this place caters to tourists only. The owner is a well-known bigot and they cater to some of the worst people in this area. The locals are well taken-care of, though, but you better be the "right" kind of person or believe me you'll be chased out. Places like Siebert's are why "Wisconsin nice" is a selective phrase. Hope Lake Geneva was nice, though, but stop somewhere else on your way back. read more

This was our second time at Sieberts. The food is excellent. Wednesday is Walleye day, and everyone was very happy with the meal. Service was wonderful. We were lucky to have Tia as our waitstaff again. She is so positive, and she made our dining experience so enjoyable. It is worth the trip for a very enjoyable dining experience. Tia, you are great!! read more

Food is always amazing here. A large selection offered at the bar also. Best food in the area. Have never had a bad meal here. Service is excellent. Would be 5 stars except last 2 times we ordered coffee or pop the glass tasted like soap. We did let them know but it seems like it would be an easy fix. Rinse your glasses. read more

We have been back to Seiberts a few times since i wrote my first review in 2021. They have since added an all-you-can-eat halibut to their fish fry options, it was excellent, and the service again was outstanding. We were lucky enough to again have Tia as our server, she is terrific. She starts by calling us "kids" which made us smile, since we are seniors. it was pretty busy, but Tia was hustling and attentive. The one thing i have learned about this place, don't bother to ask to meet the owner, I have done that at least 3 times, she is always "too busy". I was going tyo just compliment her on her well-run establishment and tell her Tia is special, but she couldn't make time for that. Other than that, place is highly recommended. Best fish fry around! read more

Good food. Great Ruben sandwich. Large portions. Interesting menu .Would definitely comeback

Under newer owners. Great place for a quick lunch or dinner! Highly recommend. Great food and service.

Pork wings were fantastic. Baked onion soup was rather bland, cheese was mozzarella rather than Gruyere, Asiago, Swiss, or Gouda. Service was superb! read more

My husband and I tried this for lunch after a friend recommended it. I loved it here. The food was good, we shared the Ruben rolls and I got a steak sandwich. I also had 2 martinis which were very good. I can see how this place gets packed for dinner or on weekends. It's a little drive for us but we will definitely be coming back. Service was nice and I liked the music they had on top. read more

Sieberts Pub - Martini with peanut butter whiskey ( I forgot the name) - New American Near Me - Salem, Wisconsin

See all

Really amazing food!! Small place so there might be a wait. It doesn't much more Wi then here!

Hands down the BEST meal I've ever had in Wisconsin. Sieberts Pub has many many good reviews because they simply get the details right. From the delicious meal to the scented Bath and Works soap in the bathroom (I'm a soap snob), everything seems to be thought out. Boyfriend and I visited on a Friday so he had the Fish Fry and I found a delicious chicken spinach wrap (veggie wraps in Wisconsin? Not super common). The fish was delicious and not too greasy or salty. My wrap came with poppyseed dressing and mouthwatering house made chips! The portions were so huge I had enough for a second meal the next day!! Service was exceptional and representative of Wisconsin hospitality! The servers were friendly and checked in on us often. They were training a gentleman and he did fantastic. We were greeted and seated right away. Plenty of free parking and the check was so reasonable I had to do a double take! Thank you for a fabulous experience! Also make sure to check out their wall art and original vintage signs! read more

See all

Today I took the first bite of the Parmesan crusted chicken sandwich and had the sudden instinct to share it with my friend. Juicy, flavorful, fresh ingredients that are curated with love and care. The perfect portion of the Italian spinach side salad was included. Added bonus, the pub chips were fresh, hot and crispy with the perfect crunch. The sandwich is the Thursday August 3rd special so I recommend you hurry over tonight and try it!! read more

Great food! HUGE portions for a very fair price. We will be back when in the area again!

Stopped in after a round of golf, very glad we did. Wasn't necessarily looking for a fish fry but it was Friday afternoon in Wisconsin. Lake perch was absolutely fresh and delicious, six fillets of fish. With fries and cole slaw, this was a feast, couldn't finish it all. Everything was hot and fresh. Started out with a appetizer of their fried cheese curds which were also very good. I will mos def be back ! read more

Went here because another place was closed but what a find! Excellent service from a waitress who clearly cared about the place! She made some great recommendations. Try the mushroom bruschetta if you're a mushroom fan. I mean really a mushroom fan. Had a delicious steak sandwich with hot and fresh fries. Sat outside and enjoyed the beautiful day. read more

Fantastic Perch! The place is small so not comfortable for eating there if it's busy. Always great for take out.