1. Sid's Pizza Calabrese

0

Blue Island, IL

Cancel

Open app

Search

Sid's Pizza Calabrese

4.5 (16 reviews)
Closed • 12:00 pm - 6:00 PM

Sid's Pizza Calabrese Photos

SID'S PIZZA CALABRESE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Sid's Pizza Calabrese

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Brownie and double chocolate cookie with pistachio
Steve W.

I lived on the south side my whole life and never knew blue island had a mini downtown area. It has an Italian deli ambiance with the hard wood floors and brick wall with vintage pictures. The staff was amazing and we even got to meet the master mind Sid behind the kitchen. The uncle Vito was phenomenal one of the best sandwich's I ever had. It's a lot similar to the Italian beef but much more seasoned and fire. The pizza is more Detroit style but it has a good crisp and dough balance. This is definitely a hidden gem and I will be back to try the other sandwiches and different pizzas as well. Also the brownie is super moist and soft don't forget to grab one or some cookies to finish off the meal

Jimbo H.

Great pizza Rectangular pizza is something I did know I would love. The crust is crispy golden brown with that good cheese. More sausage than a butcher shop.

See all

Reviews are largely positive. People highlight the fresh, flavorful pizza, friendly staff, and a comfortable atmosphere.

Read the full review summary in the app

Photo of Juan J.
0
11
41

2 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 1
Oh no 0

15 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 6
Thanks 3
Love this 2
Oh no 1

29 days ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

23 days ago

Great pizza and really nice folks. The Detroit style pizza is always very very good. Great sandwiches too.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Gina S.

Gina S.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 1

6 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 1
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Sid's Pizza Calabrese

Review Highlights - Sid's Pizza Calabrese

“The pizza is more Detroit style but it has a good crisp and dough balance.”

Mentioned in 5 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Frank's Pizza House

Frank's Pizza House

4.0(46 reviews)
1.6 mi
•$

My brother discovered Frank's Pizza after one of his coworkers recommended it. Ever since then,…read morehe's become a regular customer because of the good vibes, cheap eats, and drinks. He kept saying that he wanted me to try the pizza because he thought I'd like it. He said it reminded him of Fox's Pizza in Beverly, which is what we grew up on. Honestly, Frank's is somewhere I would've never gone without my brother's prompting. I don't frequent the area and rarely go to dive bars, but I was pleasantly surprised. The bar was quiet, clean, and comfortable. It's no frills for sure, but it's a bare-bones environment in the best way. My brother and a friend of ours were already there when I arrived. They'd already started a tab so, I just went to the bar and ordered. It was early (noon) so I didn't order alcohol. I only ordered Pepsi, but my brother and friend ordered drinks. They liked them and said they only cost $3.50. We ordered a large pepperoni and sausage pizza which arrived fairly quickly. it was piping hot too!! It was so hot that the cheese would just slide off the cracker-thin crust. The pizza was excellent though. My sister thought the cheese was too thick, but, I liked it. I thought it was fantastic. The meats were high quality and the sauce was tasty. Our friend liked it as well. The four of us ate the entire pizza. We visited on a Saturday afternoon, so the bar wasn't packed. There were a handful of regulars at the bar and a couple of people playing the slot machines. There was a baseball game playing on the TV, so it was fairly quiet. During peak hours I'd imagine that it gets pretty packed. The bartender and our server were cool, so I have no complaints about the service. I wouldn't say that Frank's pizza tastes like Fox's in Beverly, but I do understand why my bro made that comparison. They're both good for different reasons. I'd probably visit Frank's again in the future if given the choice.

I wanted to try this place out, but apparently they like wasting people's time. I went through all…read moreof the trouble of browsing their menu and placing an order only for them to cancel it because I'm out of their delivery area...I'm less than 6 miles away and the order was through Uber eats. It doesn't say anything about the restaurant delivering orders themselves so I doubt they are. Pizzas are overpriced anyway. You can tell they price their menu based on what's the easiest to make. Things like corn dogs are super cheap while things that require actual cooking skills and prep are much more expensive than they should be. Toppings are expensive as well and they don't change the pricing based on whether it's whole or half...it's all the same price. Update: Owner says "driving outside of our area for a delivery would compromise the food for you." Compromise what? The temperature? It's a delivery so that's a given and you aren't serving $400 foie gras. That also depends on how well you pack the food when delivering so you're kind of admitting that delivery isn't your forte. You also have the ability to set your delivery limits within the app if you are using your own staff to deliver so people don't waste their time ordering food only for you to cancel it.

Photos
Frank's Pizza House - Frank's Pizza & Pub .   14331 S Western Ave, Dixmoor, IL

Frank's Pizza & Pub . 14331 S Western Ave, Dixmoor, IL

Frank's Pizza House - One of the better tavern-style pizzas in Chicagoland.

One of the better tavern-style pizzas in Chicagoland.

Frank's Pizza House

See all

Bartolini's - My bowl of angel hair with marinara

Bartolini's

4.2(327 reviews)
2.5 mi
•$$

Chef Bartoini has over 30 years of culinary expertise, turning his creations into a family-friendly…read morefair at the newest location in Midlothian, IL. Upload your pictures of your favorite dishes to this review! If I can review your location, shoot me an email: jj@jackpot-johnny.com lets boost up each other!

I stopped one evening with my little brother. He's friendly with one of the bartenders, so he likes…read moreto go and sit at the bar. He loves their pizza and said the beer selection is good too. We walked in during the bustling dinner rush and found the restaurant packed. The host greeted us warmly, and we found our way to the bar. The female bartender was there that my brother knows, so we sat down. I don't recall her name, but she was friendly and attentive. We both ordered blackened chicken caesar salads. The salads were pretty good. I honestly wasn't that crazy about the caesar dressing but it was edible. The salad and chicken were fresh though. Also, I didn't get sick, which is a plus considering the lettuce recalls lately. The portion size is generous as well. My brother had a beer flight too, which he always enjoys. The restaurant was crowded, but the bar area felt intimate. There were a lot of regulars around us, so people were familiar with each other. Everyone was friendly, which was cool. The environment was relaxed and comfortable. I'd definitely visit sometime in the future if the opportunity presented itself.

Photos
Bartolini's - Welcome

Welcome

Bartolini's - Blackened chicken caesar salad

Blackened chicken caesar salad

Bartolini's - Talk Sprecher root beer

See all

Talk Sprecher root beer

Cuzin’s Tavern & Pizza - Blue Island - Bbq chicken wings. The sauce is has a nice tang to it.

Cuzin’s Tavern & Pizza - Blue Island

3.8(11 reviews)
0.9 mi

My brother recently discovered Cuzin's and had been bugging me to visit with him. We visited on a…read moreSaturday afternoon and found the place practically empty. We sat at the bar and chatted with the bartender. I didn't get her name, but she was personable and affable. My brother was familiar with her since he visits semi-regularly. My brother loves both the burgers and pizza. He claimed the pizza rivals Fox's pizza in Beverly, so naturally I had to check it out. The pizza is good, but it's no Fox's!! We ordered double pepperoni, which was perfectly thin and crispy. It was a little too greasy for me, but other than that, I have no complaints. I also had an amaretto stone sour, which was delicious. My brother had a drink as well, but I can't recall which one. He always orders it, though, so clearly the bartender prepares it to his liking. The bar has a welcoming neighborhood vibe. The bartender knew some people by name or face, but everyone was welcomed with open arms. The bill for was about $45, which is pretty standard nowadays. The pizza was very reasonable ($18), which was awesome. There are slot machines in the corner for all the eager gamblers. Next time I'll try the burgers!

I like this bar a lot! This is a true neighborhood sports bar. The people there all knew one…read moreanother but were open to newcomers. As for the food and services, you will not go wrong. The pizza and chicken wings are a must. However, their menu had bunch of items that I really want to try. I cannot ride and not mention the bar service. My server Jess was amazing. She was attentive but not hovering and annoying. Had very good personality and I loved talking football with her.

Photos
Cuzin’s Tavern & Pizza - Blue Island - A true sports bar without the gimmicky stuff.

A true sports bar without the gimmicky stuff.

Cuzin’s Tavern & Pizza - Blue Island - Sausage pizza with a great crust

Sausage pizza with a great crust

Cuzin’s Tavern & Pizza - Blue Island

See all

Louisa's Pizza & Pasta - A horrible pizza and bad customer service

Louisa's Pizza & Pasta

3.6(223 reviews)
3.1 mi
•$$

We went to Louisa's around 3:30 on a Friday afternoon, a half hour after they open. We ordered the…read morepizza which is pan style, a medium size with half sausage, half only cheese. There can be a 45-minute wait for the pizza, so we also ordered the Polenta appetizer, which was a little mushy but still tasted good. Although I am not a big fan of pan style, I think this pizza was very good in that category. I like that the crust tasted like pizza dough, rather than cornmeal like some other places. The sauce is not that sweet and has small chunks of tomato, but not too many. The cheese had a good flavor and consistency. The sausage also tasted good. We felt very welcomed by the server, and I appreciate that he put our order in immediately so we didn't have to wait very long for the pizza to get done. Louisa's is quite nice, the decor is just right for an Italian restaurant, the music playlist is perfect, and the lighting is dark but I could still read the menu okay. There is a photo collage on one wall which includes Louisa in several photos. The bar area is well lit but still cozy. There is ample parking along the North side of the building and behind it. I want to come back to try their dinner entrees!

Old school Italian vibes. Service was quick, polite and to…read morethe point. Food options were a abundant on a single sheet menu. Ill definitely be back.

Photos
Louisa's Pizza & Pasta - Looking toward front entrance

Looking toward front entrance

Louisa's Pizza & Pasta - Polenta appetizer. Plenty enough for 4 people. Their Italian Sausage is amazing!

Polenta appetizer. Plenty enough for 4 people. Their Italian Sausage is amazing!

Louisa's Pizza & Pasta

See all

Taqueria Eden y - Alex Pizza - Sausage personal pizza

Taqueria Eden y - Alex Pizza

4.7(14 reviews)
0.6 mi

Pizza was ok. Unbeknownst to me slices are only available on Sundays. Quite hefty for a personal…read moresized pizza. Pizza sauce had a slightly sweet element but aside from that nothing warranted a return visit. It's possibly my fault because I didn't add my coveted garlic. Taste was evocative a childhood Friday night neighborhood pizza though.

Alex Pizza is hands-down worth the trip -- and I say that as a Chicago native who happily drives 40…read moreminutes from Berwyn just to eat here. The owner is incredibly friendly and personable, and the staff matches that same warm, welcoming vibe. The food? Absolutely top-notch. The tripa tacos are the best I've had anywhere in Chicago -- perfectly cooked, full of flavor, and truly unforgettable. The pizza is always crispy and bursting with flavor, even after the ride home. From the burritos to the quesadillas, every single dish hits the mark. Whether you're here for tacos, pizza, or anything in between, you can taste the care and quality in every bite. I've even shared photos because this place deserves the recognition. If you're looking for a spot that consistently delivers great food and friendly service, Alex Pizza is it. Vale totalmente la pena el viaje -- y lo dice un nativo de Chicago que maneja 40 minutos desde Berwyn para comer aquí. El dueño y el personal son muy amables y hacen que uno se sienta bienvenido. Los tacos de tripa son los mejores que he probado en todo Chicago. La pizza siempre está crujiente y llena de sabor, incluso después del viaje a casa. Desde burritos hasta quesadillas, todo es delicioso. Si buscas comida increíble y un servicio excelente, Alex Pizza es el lugar.

Photos
Taqueria Eden y - Alex Pizza
Taqueria Eden y - Alex Pizza - Asada

Asada

Taqueria Eden y - Alex Pizza

See all

Sid's Pizza Calabrese - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...