We were planning to go to a different place on Monday night, but it was closed so we headed towards another restaurant in New Paltz. After we parked we saw Sideshow on the way and decided to check out the menu. It sounded very intriguing so we decided to go there instead. My only complaint is that I really wanted one of their specials, the Smoked Turkey Salad Sandwich, but they were sold out. I was very disappointed as I was really looking forward to the smoked Gouda, but I can't hold the fact that it was really popular against them. Instead I settled on the Golden Goddess Grilled Chicken Wrap and the Jalapeno Corn Chowder as a starter. I think the chowder was missing a little something flavor wise (not sure what), but it had a nice kick to it and I was satisfied with it overall. Loved the cornbread on the side. The sandwich was great and the crispy potato skin fries were hot, fresh and delicious. The rest of my family inhaled the smoked chicken wings with the Jalapeno Mango glaze as a starter. They must have been good as I barely got a taste. For a main course my other half had the Sliced Steak Sandwich and my kids chose the Sideshow Burger (with a side salad) and the Spicy Shrimp Orecchiette (pasta) special. My son wasn't crazy about the special sauce on the burger, but otherwise everyone was happy. Two of us had enough left overs for our lunch the next day. I was really happy with the size of the starters as they were a great addition to the meal, but not overly filling where you couldn't eat your main entree. The inside of the restaurant was smaller than I expected, but it had a pleasant atmosphere. I was happy about the fact that although they had TVs playing the World Cup in the background the TVs didn't overwhelm the space. We did notice the employees had to bring new supplies/food in through the front door to take to the kitchen repeatedly while we were there. They don't appear to have access directly into the kitchen from outside, which is a little odd. A limitation in the design I suppose. Our waitress was very friendly and pleasant. We ended our meal with a delicious Chocolate Chip Cookie Strudel. We will definitely be back again. read more

See all

Tried to order steak sandwich well done our server insisted not Possible they only cook it to medium I did not accept that as an answer And then was aggravated with me and never checked on Our table again I had to go the bar to order a second drink food came Out and was Not Worth it read more

This place is cute and has a dog friendly patio with a dog menu! The service we had was stellar. Our waiter was super kind and ensured we had a great experience. This is the kind of service that makes patrons return. The food was plentiful and actually really tasty. The drinks were strong and good as well. The potatoes were the star and the chopped brisket was more shredded but slapped! Thank you to our server I think your name started with a K and you had a chew can in your back pocket. The owners need to know how amazing you are and how kind you are. read more

See all

Great food great service. Love the green goddess wrap. Hot Cheetos cheese curds are unique and delicious

Cute bar with fun drinks! Service was good too. Food was interesting and good. Liked the outdoor seating area that has area heaters and fire pits. read more

BEWARE IF YOU HAVE A GLUTEN ALLERGY or CELIAC. The menu labels items as GF (e.g., potato skins, wings) but cooks them in a fryer which is also used for gluten-containing foods. I explained that while the ingredients might, in origin, be gluten free, once they are put into a non-GF dedicated fryer, that dish now contains gluten; therefore, their menu is both misleading and can result in people getting extremely sick (or if a life-threatening allergy, death). The restaurant had NO concept of cross-contamination so we went elsewhere. This lack of education regarding food preparation and medical conditions is both negligent and inexcusable. read more

I have never been here and I'm so glad we came! We tried to go to bacchus but they were backed up in the kitchen for about 45 mins. This place wasn't open when I was a student so we wanted to check it out. The drinks were strong, prices fair, and the food was good! I had one of the salads which you could add mahi mahi too. I appreciate that as a healthier protein addition. Would definitely come back again! read more

See all

Spacious and cool outdoor space and nice indoor area with a nice dark sports ambiance setting. Everything is new and clean. A lot of big TVs for sports viewing while eating. Staff and server were pleasant and welcoming. Smoked chicken wings were very good. Wish more fat was rendered off though. House fries were excellent. Fresh and tasty. Angus burger was very good but for the price a little undersized. Ribs were good and decent size. House salad was tiny. Cole slaw not that good, needs some work. Corn bread was excellent. The three house sauces were okay. Prices were a little high which is okay but portions could be larger. And some healthier options on the menu would be nice addition. Overall, a very nice place with great ambiance. Good addition to New Paltz. Will return. read more

Sideshow - Smashed angus burger - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

The food was spectacular and unique, with a variety of flavors and sauces. The outside porch was a wonderful option, especially being dog friendly. The only thing that really was not spectacular was the speed of the service. I went to this restaurant three times in two weeks, always on the porch, with three different servers. Each time, I was left after the first round of drinks for 15-20 min. Was it because I was a table of one? One time, the restaurant was definitely busy with a party, but the other two times, there was hardly anyone there. That slow service will definitely impact whether I will return. read more

LOVED!!!!drinks food service and vibes alll are amazing !!!! Cute day n night vibes ... drinks are tasty and the fall menu is awesome! read more

See all

The server was so nice and brought our food out so fast! The outside was so pretty with a fireplace and the couches and tables! Definitely recommend!! read more

See all

we've been to sideshow three times now and each time has been a hit! all of the food we've tried so far has been excellent (my favorite so far is probably the chicken tacos honestly) and the service is exceptional. we love the outdoor patio seating (which is dog friendly!) but the inside is nice as well. 10/10 recommend. read more

Sideshow - Salad - Sports Bars Near Me - New Paltz, New York

See all

The staff here is great and the atmosphere during the summertime is unmatched in the summertime with their patio and fireplace, but I have not enjoyed their food any of the times I have been here. Worth checking out if you are just looking for an outdoor drink and a chat with friends. read more

Nice friendly bar. Plenty of space. Good selection of liquor and food. Unfortunately, we just had wine. Definitely, will go again. Also, have lot of space outside and plenty of parking. read more

It's a sports bar. It's fine. It's nothing special. It's just a sports bar. The ambiance is bleak and grey. Food was fine. One would think with a name like sideshow that it would be fun or perhaps Coney Island themed, but it's not. Overall, disappointing. read more

GREAT outdoor patio!!! PET FRIENDLY!!!! Service is fantastic, food is delicious and well priced. Mac and Cheese is OK....Burgers are great...Fries are fantastic! Will def be back and highly recommend if you bringing pets! read more

We come up from Long Island often and we were excited for this place to open. We went twice this weekend. Everything seemed fairly priced and the Cheetos cheese curds are freaking amazing. The other food was good too. The craft beer selection was awesome. It's refreshing to see a clean, modern bar in the area. Will be back. read more

The main meals we very good and well prepared. Don't expect large portions. We didn't and it was fine. The 20 minute wait for seating was actually about 50 minutes. No explanation. Food came quickly, Staff was professional. Kona draft beer was FLAT! The GIANT chicken wings were the smallest chicken wings I have ever seen. Great atmosphere. 3 stars is all you get due to the wait, the flat beer, and the bogus wing description. read more

Went to Sideshow again and again, was so pleased with my dinner. They never disappoint. .

Food was fantastic, best burger I have had in a long time. Wait staff was amazing. Highly recommend.

The food was good, I will say the Mac and cheese being $27 is criminal! Def not worth it.

Really cool what they did with the place. Old laundromat turned cool place. Summer will be cool with music hopefully on the nice deck. The food is.... Okay. The salads are pretty good but they have these marinated tomatoes that taste rotten. My friend and I both thought it was disgusting. Oh and corn belongs on a tex-mex salad not all salads!!! They would 100% benefit from being able to order just sides. A whole menu. 1/4lb, 1/2lb, ext of all meats and their sides. They could make bank and that's what people want. You aren't allowed. Not cool. It's new paltz. You could make a killing that way. Easy money side show. Drinks are way too expensive and the staff is not attentive. read more

Tried this place with a party of 6. Service was excellent, food was tasty. Outside patio area is very nice. Definitely going to return to try more items from the menu. read more

We've been to this place twice. I like the decor and the outdoor patio area will be nice in the good weather. Our bartender, Bailey, was terrific. She's friendly, pleasant and observant. Great job! The price on beer is a bit much for New Paltz- $5.00 for a Coors light. I ordered brisket tacos and they were the greasiest tacos I've ever had. I think I went through 8 napkins. Hopefully someone will read this. read more

The food was lack luster compared to the price. Service was very good and ambiance was solid.

food and service was great! a bit pricey but was worth it for the experience. would definitely be beautiful in the summer to sit outside and eat! read more