This as a well stocked, friendly, helpful place. I thoroughly enjoy shopping there. O the rare occasion that they do not have what I need, they order it for me. This is one of, if not the best hardware store I have been to any where. read more

I love going to Shinnecock Hardware in Hampton Bays. Always have what I need in a pinch and I'm in and out. The people are friendly and we'll informed. Top notch. Proud to have this resource in our town read more

FREAKING PHENOMENAL! All young people were helpful, kind, welcoming and nice. The Owners SON! Was unbelievable professional and was able to get my Christmas Decorations as promised. Now being in a tourist trap area though tit wasnt going to go so well.BOY was I surprised! EXCELLENT competitive pricing, if they dont have it they will get it for you and it was such a great experience and i drive over 1 hour to get there! Parking is ample, accessible, local to the LIE, Sunrise and Montauk Hwy. They have the Green egg, BBQs, Fir pits, Supplies for cleaning the weekend house, etc. Also COOL keys ! A must visit. WONDERFUl. I need to let people know because I have ben in 30 +stores this weekend shopping and most places dont even say hi and they are small businesses.. or ignore you for a cell phone. NOT HERE they are AWESOME PEOPLE read more

Rob is right.. Ace is awesome. Not a sleepy little hardware store. They are always on and ready to get you things lickety split. Propane, keys, etc. Fastest key making in the Hamptons. Everytime I go it they have help ready to get you in and out. read more

Shinnecock Hardware - Ace! - Hardware Stores Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Love that they recognize their local clientele, like myself, and still warmly greet those visiting or just passing through HB. If you don't see it on the shelves, most likely they can order it for you. And when getting your keys made, unlike the big box stores, you can get your keys made with the emblem of your favorite sports team, paraphernalia, theme and everything inbetween. It truly amazes me every time I go into the store, how much variety it carries within their moderately sized space. I really do love the convenience factor of not having to leave town to find tools or DIY materials at my fingertips right in town. read more

So I arrive at 259pm, right before 3p closing. Understood, had a cracked pool housing and needed quick fix of epoxy. Young man thru the door says we're closed. I said I need something quick. Walks away. Comes back to let a customer out, says sorry been here 6 hours. Yes, I get it, everyone works. Closes door in my face. Then proceeds to let 2 more customers out of the store over next few minutes. Complete disregard for a customer, I'll take my business elsewhere. For 3 minutes, you lost a customer and now have a nice Yelp review. read more

Quality hardware store with friendly service and most all of the things you'd be searching for in a hardware store. It's nice to walk into a hardware store and feel you could ask for help if you want it, but not being hit over the head by attempts to help you. Also, the cashiers were wearing Islanders gear! Definitely recommend. read more

I moved back to Hampton Bays in March of 2020 after living in Riverhead for 16 years. I went to Shinnecock Hardware, what seems like, every day. The staff has always been so helpful. I needed things for my new home (and my Riverhead home to sell it). Granted, I could've gone to Home Depot & Lowes while in Riverhead to save a few pennys but there is something about supporting a local family owned business. I came onto Yelp to see what time they open this morning and read reviews... the two critical reviews inspired me to write my own. I never received the level of service from the big companies that I do at this store. The staff (Randy, Autumn & Jan- specifically) have always been great. They are always interested in whatever project I'm working on and if they don't know something they've been extremely helpful in figuring it out for me. If it's not in stock, they've ordered it from their supplier. I'd rather pay a few bucks more to stay in town and support my neighbors then drive 20 minutes to have an impersonal experience and save a buck. From random nuts and bolts, keys made, Benjamin Moore paint & birdseed... this is by far my favorite hardware store ever and I'm proud to call it my hometown store. Ace is my place. read more

The best retail shopping experience I have had a really long time. super friendly staff and really knowledgeable help. I went in with a thing I needed help with, they knew what they were talking about and sold me the thing I needed to fix it- and they were super nice. freakin amazing! read more

There's always a friendly, knowledgable staff member to help you...unlike Home Depot...and they carry close to everything you could need. A+ for Shinnecock Hardware!!! read more

Spoke with the manager and she apologized for their employees' behavior and also addressed it with them. It is a relief to hear someone in that store does seem concerned about customers' quality of experience at their store. read more

Big difference in service from the Lowe's and Home Depot here. The staff (especially Dana) really know there stuff. Very accommodating and really seem happy to help you read more

ACE on West Montauk Hwy is the best by far. The people that work there make you feel comfortable about things you're not sure about they guide you and treat you like family. Dana runs the business and is so sharp there nothing she doesn't know about. We love her. read more

Amazing staff! Last weekend my car broke down a block away from the store. I showed up to their store with a dead phone and dead car battery 15 minutes before closing and they went above and beyond to help. Corey searched 10 minutes for a spare set of jumper cables that I could use and even offered to help me use them. After he found the only spare set was defective, he took a set of the shelf and gave it to me saying I could return them tomorrow if I needed to. The female cashier at the front also went out of her way to help me- even offering to buy the jumper cables for me as she probably needed a spare- I could return them to her tomorrow as well! I was blown away by their kindness and generosity. If I was a local, I would frequent this hardware store as often as I could. Next time I'm in the Hamptons in need of some equipment, I definitely know where I'll be going. read more

Always someone to help you when you walk in the door...what a pleasure ! The epitome of what a small town, well stocked hardware store is...with a wonderful staff. read more

Feels like Howard Cunnigham runs this place. The local hardware stoe in Hampton Bays has everything the do-it-yoursefer needs to ruin his or her weekend. I have been a customer for over 16 years now, and the staff is always there to help you find exactly what you need. read more

I went in to get 4 screws for a hd wall mount. They greeted me at the door and helped me find exactly what I needed. I needed metric screws and they had them. Very fast and great service. read more

Nicest people in Hampton's. Have (almost) everything you could need. If they don't have it - you belong in another store. Neighborhood standard for locals - and an all-in-one stop for vacationers needing anything. read more

Amazing service, great prices. Great staff always willing to help. I love this place. Best hardware I've ever been 2

I love these guys. I am a beginner "do-it-yourself" person and they are always very helpful without making me feel stupid for not knowing some of the basics. There are a few choices in the area, but I will always stop here first. More often than not, it's the only stop I have to make. read more

Very helpful and knowlegable... Helped me troubleshoot and fix my kitchen sink plumbing problems... Wouldn't take a dime extra for parts i didn't need. This should be careful MODEL for how a hardware store should be. Special thanks to Randy..... read more

The prices on the merchandise are very high. The merchandise is inferior and is not worth the price. However, the worst part of this store is that the service is positively awful. The owner Tom is nasty and uses foul language to customers; They do not stand by there products. I rate this store 0 stars. I would recommend take the trip to home depot or lowes. read more

We love our local hardware store. Everyone there is helpful, friendly, willing to help you think through a project. In the Summer I can confidently send renters there because I know they will be well taken care of. The rest of the year, I'm there every weekend. Couldn't live without the good folks at my Ace. They really put the Home Depots of the world to shame. read more