Cancel

Open app

Search

Shelbell's Sugarshack

4.0 (1 review)
Closed • Closed

Order Shelbell's Sugarshack Takeout or Delivery

Shelbell's Sugarshack Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Shelbell's Sugarshack

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Shelley B.

Shelley B.

Thank you so much for trying Shelbell's Sugarshack!

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Shelbell's Sugarshack

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Desserts 345 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

New York Gourmet Deli - Cold Italian sandwich!

New York Gourmet Deli

4.5(39 reviews)
3.6 mi

The chop cheese was to die for! I'm addicted! It has a gas station feel and is not a place to sit…read moredown and eat but definitely a good snack and sandwich shop that's made to order.

The O.G.B.L.T. is the way to go. It's a hot and melty sandwich with turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato,…read morepepper jack cheese and mayo, all on a hoagie bun. The sandwich is about as long as my humerus, and I ate the whole dang thing in one sitting. New York Gourmet Deli is not to be confused with NY Gourmet Deli, also in Indy. New York Gourmet Deli is located on East 21st Street on the near east side; NY Gourmet Deli is on Ruckle Street, near The Children's Museum. Are they owned by the same people? I don't know, but someone needs to change their name so I'm less confused. Anyway, New York Gourmet Deli, on the east side, is great and located in an unassuming parking lot full of potholes. It looks like a liquor store from the outside, but step inside and you'll see the large deli counter where you order sandwiches, burgers, fries and other foods. The joint is also a convenience store, of sorts, with a wall full of refrigerated beverages, aisles of chips, candy, and lots of Mexican snacks. There's also a little corner of the store with goods like laundry detergent and other necessities. The hustle here is unmatched. The fellows behind the counter were flying all over the kitchen to fulfill the orders. I visited around noon on a weekday, which seemed to be a busy time because there were lots of people from all walks of life here, either waiting to order or waiting for their orders. The guys behind the counter were unflappable and took orders and made sandwiches at a speedy pace. Even if there's a line, you won't wait long for your food.

Photos
New York Gourmet Deli - Order here, by this stack of Fanta

Order here, by this stack of Fanta

New York Gourmet Deli - O.G.B.L.T.

O.G.B.L.T.

New York Gourmet Deli - Beans for sale

See all

Beans for sale

Tia’s - Buffalo fries with no bacon.  Such a tiny portion.  Cheese was not melted.

Tia’s

4.8(15 reviews)
3.2 mi

New Palestine's finest breakfast tacos. That sounds like I'm being sarcastic, but that ain't me…read morethrowing shade at New Pal's taco scene -- I'm being genuine! Chorizo, egg and cheese, folded into a warm corn tortilla. Boom. Simple, like the best kind of tacos. My taco came with a little bottle of mild green sauce to squeeze over everything, if I wished. (I wished.) It was a satisfying and tasty little breakfast. Other varieties of breakfast tacos include bacon, sausage or ham. But it's breakfast, and I'm Mexican, so I gravitate toward chorizo, which I think is always a good choice. Chorizo has never let me down. You can also get your taco on a flour tortilla, but let's be honest, there was no way that was happening. Corn tortillas are the way to go. Other breakfast things include a breakfast burrito (I'll be back to try that, yessiree), biscuits & gravy, and oats & toast. They also serve lunch items. I enjoyed my breakfast taco with a 16-ounce black coffee, which was great. What really impressed me: My taco and coffee cost $5 and change! What a deal! I felt like I was living in 2010. This is a great place to get a great breakfast for not a lot of money. I did not know Tia's existed before today, and my discovery of it coincided with learning that my great tia (aunt, in Spanish) passed away yesterday. She was 92, so it's not tragic, but it's still sad. So when I was looking for a place to eat on Yelp, and I saw Tia's and I saw that they had breakfast tacos, I knew this was the place to visit. And I was right! Maybe Tia Dorothy led me to this place.

Tia's was just ok for my needs. It has a utilitarian atmosphere, which is fine. I liked the kids'…read morecoloring pages taped to the counter. The one thing I hated was having to look at the Fox News playing in the background. There is, however, some delicious and tempting doughnuts in a case while you wait in line. Of course I had to get one for me and my partner. They were fresh, but clearly made from frozen doughnuts and prepackaged icing. Service was friendly, but not sycophantic. You must order at the counter, which I find annoying since I always tip, regardless. I feel it's not as great a value. They did offer us coffee refills, but also asked us to refill the salt and pepper while we were still seated. If you look at the menu, you'll see that there are no vegan options and you have to do a bit of cobbling to make anything vegetarian. The food was good, hot, and fresh. There need to be better sides and veggies to add to dishes. It's really all meat and carbs. I would return if friends or family wanted to stop in.

Photos
Tia’s - Ordering counter with kids' coloring sheets.

Ordering counter with kids' coloring sheets.

Tia’s - Chorizo breakfast taco

Chorizo breakfast taco

Tia’s - Black coffee

See all

Black coffee

New Bethel Ordinary

New Bethel Ordinary

3.9(289 reviews)
6.0 mi•Wanamaker
•$$

This place is famous for their pizza, and the reputation is well deserved. The sauce to crust ratio…read moreis perfect, the toppings are generous. The breadsticks are also very good. I have ordered pizzas for carryout and also dined in. The place is always busy, often packed. I recently dined in with a group of friends. We all ordered different menu items and everyone was happy with their choices. Between us we ordered fish, tenderloin, chicken, burgers, and pizza. Service is friendly. The parking lot is often full but street parking is available.

It is shaped like a house. "Ordinary" noticably written on a big sign. Limited parking for both…read morepizza and ice cream businesses. Outdoor covered patio with large connect 4 game. Pizza restaurant separated by bar vs. regular sit down. I sat myself in a booth by a TV which I asked to watch the NHL Stanley Cup playoff, instead of the NFL draft. Restrooms were like outhouses - very small but nicer. Watch your up and down steps. Sink shared between restroom stalls. I decided to try this restaurant because a Yelper kept raving about it at the event before and I needed a meal and wanting something around SE Indy. Yet another Yelper did not return again after trying the food. Restaurant is near my event. Here is my review. 3-4 stars. I will give it 4 stars for the service. I ordered a 10" customized pizza of cheese, chicken, and mushroom for $16.99 without tax. I did not care for the thick, cookie like crust. Cost was too much to try it. Nothing special to me.

Photos
New Bethel Ordinary - Dining room, there's also a bar room and an outside patio

Dining room, there's also a bar room and an outside patio

New Bethel Ordinary - Right from the plate

Right from the plate

New Bethel Ordinary

See all

Shelbell's Sugarshack - desserts - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...