decent bar and pub-like menu in main building. the unnamed, unsigned little oyster+other sea delectables with an extensive whiskey collection right next door, is beyond awesome. read more

When my fiancé is in town, Shakey Jakes is one of the places we go to for wings. We are known there by face so when we walk in, the bartender knows exactly what our order is. We were there Friday night, enjoying a cigar, drinks and wings on the outside patio. We even mingled with the table next to us, as they too, were cigar smokers. The owner, Nancy came out, we said hello, and I proceeded to tell her how much we enjoyed the wings there. She was quite standoffish and really didn't care what we had to say. This was the first time she treated us this way. We returned there on Saturday and while my fiancé was taking a seat on the patio, Nancy walked out and pulled me aside. She asked that we leave her establishment right away, because we were offending the other customers. I was so taken aback, I was at a loss for words. We left. A few hours went by and I turned to my fiancé and asked that he take me back there so that I can have a word with her. As I entered the bar area, she was standing there. I asked if I can speak to her. The bartender, Heather, followed. I asked, "In what way did we offend others customers?" She didn't have an explanation, instead her response was, "I have the right to refuse service to anyone I please!!!" I asked if it due to the color of our skin? Myself being olive toned, (half Afro American) and my fiance, a "VERTERAN" of African American decent. (He is an "active" LT COL in the U.S. Army working on his 3rd Master's Degree) The bartender quickly responded, "We have "Black" friends." I didn't say anything about being "Black," I simply asked if it was due to the color of our skin. What a disgusting case of "DISCRIMINATION!" SHAME ON THIS ESTABLSHMENT. AND SHAME ON BOTH NANCY, OWNER, AND THE BARTENDER, HEATHER. I feel sorry for you. What a slap in the face to a man of such statue, a man who protects and defends our freedom. Rest assured that I will do everything in my power to make sure people know that this place discriminates against People of Color. In the meantime, I'll pray for you. read more

The chili was outstanding with great a blend of Mexican spices! My family scraped the bottom of the takeout containers until our plastic spoons finally snapped ... that good! read more

They do not accept military IDs. This is unacceptable I have served for four years and I'm in my late 20s and and I have been overseas for several years. This is a shame. I'm only giving this one star because they have good chicken wings. read more

Was skeptical walking in, but pleasantly surprised. The wait staff was right on top of everything and the drinks were perfect. Food was good, would go back again for sure. read more

A wonderfull little place, with great food, people, and service. Discovered the place by accident, while doing work in area. It has become a regular stop for me when I'm in the area. Great menu, along with great specials. Excellent, and friendly service, I highly reconmend. read more

Had the mild wings, really good like a slightly sweet buffalo sauce. Buffalo chicken wrap was very good and was a large portion for 8 dollars. Only reason I gave it four stars and not five was because we went at mid afternoon and there was just one bartender to serve and wait the whole place. Overall very good would definitely go again. read more

great watering hole, makes you feel at home.

Went in for the first time got ignored by two servers. Ended up walking out. Will never go back there again!

Went in here for a bite to eat shortly after we moved into the area. I was totally against going just based on the way the place looked (very dive bar-ish). Was really, really surprised. The wings are really excellent and my husband said the burger was good. We've since had a number of their appetizers and have never walked away disappointed. Service was good (and I wasn't sure it would be since we're not regulars). We've gone back and ordered out from here a number of times. read more

I thought this place would be a dive full of local losers, but surprise, it's really good. Our table was wobbly, but "shakey" is in the name, so can't come down too hard. The service is great and we love to order the clams and wings. Most people are at the bar, so it's easy to get a table. read more

A diamond in the rough! We lived near Stanhope for 8 years before going into Shakey Jake's Cafe/bar--my husband thinking it was not going to be a nice place . Now, in the last 6 months, we've been there at least 8 times. The chef/owner always has some amazing specials, but the regular menu has gems as well especially their elegant house salad that I had topped with grilled chicken. The burgers are 8 oz. that can be served so many ways (mine blackened with pepper jack cheese on c Kaiser roll. Chef makes wonderful soups (I've had mushroom, haddock chowder, shrimp bisque). My husband has had an amazing pork saltimbocca, a stuffed meatloaf with sundried tomatoes etc. and my personal favorite and appetizer of seared tuna on won ton tacos and wasabi sauce. Strangely, friends of mine who have been to the bar, never knew they had great food and a restaurant area in back as well. The main improvement I would suggest is an entrance (now,just a store glass door) that would show what a pleasant place it is. We usually go around 6:00 or 7:00, and must not get the bar scene. We've brought our granddaughter and felt quite comfortable. The owner's are very family friendly and the wait staff is generally amazing and fast. In the summer they have a sizable private outdoor eating area behind the restaurant We used to go to some of the other local restaurants (gastropubs), but find the quality and variety much better here. read more

My favorite Friday night place! I haven't had a better burger anywhere in NJ, and the menu has plenty of other tasty choices.

This place is amazing. Pure and simple amazing. It is not often that you find a place where every bite is phenomenal. Out family had the habanero wings (my husband who likes it as hot as you can make it) and my son and i shared the mild buffalo wings----both fantastic. Then we had the french onion soup and boston oyster chowder---homemade to perfection. For dinner, my husband had a burger, my son the kids homemade mac & cheese and i had the ahi tuna taco app as my entree. Three words: Oh. My. God. I'm not kidding, I could spend an hour describing each dish in detail, but I don't have that kind of time, and neither do you, but seriously each dish was made to perfection----homemade, great ingredients and lots of love. I would give them six stars if I could. Our server was so awesome---an absolute delight---drinks were fantastic too. I can't say a bad word----and I don't lie when it comes to food. If you haven't been to Shakey Jakes then go! And if you've been and for some reason didn't like it, then you are a complete idiot and probably think mcdonald's and olive garden are good! read more

My favorite place to go for food or drinks! Amazing staff and owners! The food is phenomenal! Amazing daily specials. Fun atmosphere and great prices! Definetly the place to go in the area!! read more

Had a good time at Shakey Jakes. I had the fried pickles and the buck naked wings. The pickles were battered spears that were then deep fried. The batter was delicious, it was almost like a panko coating. The wings were a nice size and quite crispy. They were done to perfection. The wait staff were friendly and attentive. If there was a downside, it is that you get charged for every drink refill. I only had a Diet Coke but had it refilled several times since it was a 12 oz. glass. It was a surprise when I got he check and it was like I ordered another entree. Still the food was good and so was the service. read more

Pure fuego, that place to be any night. The food is phenomenal and the service just as good.

First time at Shakey Jakes, don't know why I have waited so long to stop in, what a mistake not stopping in sooner!!! We were greeted by Nancy with a great big smile and "welcome to Shakey Jakes" we were seated quickly and asked if we would like something to drink, they have a great assortment of Beers with several on tap in addition to bottles. We ordered two bottles of Beer and the Wings with Teriyaki Sauce as an appetizer. They came out hot and really good tasting, I could live on these. For lunch The Classic Burger an 8oz patty of ground chuck served with Fries and Lettuce and Tomato. We also ordered The Iron Bound Cheese Steak which came with Sautéed Onions, Mushrooms, Cherry Peppers, Sweet Vinegar Peppers, Cheese Sauce and American Cheese. Both of these were served hot and great tasting made with fresh ingredients. This place is a great place to relax and enjoy a leisurely lunch or dinner. They also have another building that opens on Thursdays only that is a Cigar Bar with a Seafood Bar that serves Oysters and Clams on the half shell food menu is limited but great for this type of place. I will be back for the Oysters. Overall a great dining experience Nancy did several table checks, and answered any questions. This is a must stop in place, Good Food, Good Service, Nancy, and did I mention 2 Dart Boards!!! Don't Forget the Pig as your leaving!!!!!! read more