Sepia how I love you so.
The first time I had ever heard of or have seen Sepia was on Check Please! (I love that show!) I was intrigued by not only the great food reviews.. but by also the beautiful room and the great story of the space that the restaurant lives within.
From the outside Sepia is pretty plain.. which is fine by me. Just a very simple sign.. no fancy awning... no unneeded craziness. The building was built in the 1800's... and is just beautiful.
We arrived about 25 minutes early for our reservation, kinda planned it that way so we could try one of their "custom" cocktails. When we stepped up to the desk they took our wet coats, down pouring rain (UGH) and they took our bottle of wine, which we brought for dinner (they do have a $25 corkage fee). Our table was not ready.. but you know the plan, cocktail here we come. The bar was full so we found a seat at this very low and firm banquette seating area which faced the huge windows. The seating up front could use a good pillow or two. The cocktail menu makes it to our table and the fun began. My husband had a Sour Cherry Old Fashioned, which was quite good (but he claimed he had better), and I had the Sepia Mule. I have heard of Mule cocktails before, Oprah herself loves them.. so I figured why not. And it was fantastic! They make their own ginger infused vodka.. which made the cocktail so fresh. They also used a great ginger beer too.. so refreshing. A very summertime cocktail.
They told us our table was ready and so we were off on our culinary adventure. And let me tell you the start was a little rocky....
We were sat at this little table for two in the main dining room... and it, the dining room, looked just like I had seen on Check Please. Just beautiful. This great little table though started off as a nightmare. It wasn't balanced.. it had a horrible rock to it. One wrong move and it would've been horrible. Our server Sal (who was AWESOME) stopped by with our menus and our bottle of wine. When he set down the bottle he realized that our table had a serious problem. (My husband was trying to do the classic coaster fold to try to help it out, but that wasn't working) Our server assistant came by, knowing our situation, and made everything better. No more rock.
So let me go on..... We were there for Restaurant Week... so we dared not look at the main menu... we put our blinders on and reviewed the fixed menu. And we went whole hog.. go for the 4 course menu for $44! We liked everything that was featured so we went for everything....
The bread came out piping hot! It was awesome... and then when you spread the lightly salted butter on it, it melted upon impact. No ripping of the bread... no mess!
*First course, followed... Hiramasa, cured with the flavors of an avation cocktail. How could you go wrong? The Hiramasa is a Japanese Whitefish.. served raw with beet micro greens, fennel and a great drizzle, we are still trying to figure it out!
*Second courses... Ricotta cavatelli, short rib sugo & grana padano. OMG! It was seasoned perfectly. You could tell they made the pasta in house, it was so good. We so wished there was more! You could see all of the work they put into the short ribs... the carrots, to the tomato.. to the fresh thyme! Comfort food in it's finest form!
*The 2nd Second course... Porcini mushroom sformato, bitter greens & sage walnut pesto. The basis is sort of a mushroom flan. Very unexpected, and very rich! They probably could've cut the portion in half due to the richness. And it could have used something, like a little bit of truffle.... what couldn't use a little bit of truffle? All and all, it was quite good!
*Entree goodness, part one... Ancho~espresso braised pork cheeks, three sister's white corn polenta, tart apple salad. You so don't need the steak knife they serve it with. With one cut of your knife.... it just cuts through like.. magic. Like butter. The polenta, just enough grit... just enough smoothness.... But then the salad... I love the difference of the textures but, there was way too much raw red onion. It was kinda intrusive.. too harsh.
*Entree goodness, part two... Pan fried rainbow trout, candied bacon, hazelnuts, haricot verts, & spoon bread. Yes spoon bread.. as in mentioned True Grit... for those who have seen the movie. Spoon bread is mentioned a lot.
The trout was great, BUT... it was under seasoned. It needed salt.... badly. The hazelnuts, bacon.... and all was great. But then again they added more onions. Red onions, like entree number one. The onion was just a tad bit overkill.
*Sweets, for my sweet, part one... Chocolate pecan cake, coconut ice cream, & butterscotch... um... just awesome. what else can I say.
*Sweetness, part 2... Marscapone cream napoleon, figs, cinnamon, oranges, & cranberries... Winter on a plate?! For sure. The only thing that was missing was maybe a drizzle of some really good honey.
In last words.. go there and be happy.. embrace it... we did.. we'll be back. read more