idk i'm a planner so I don't really mind ordering pizza on thursday for a saturday pick up. anyways, the pickup was easy. I walked in at my pick up time, grabbed it and left! hardly 15 seconds. the longest part was walking to and from my car. pizza was awesome! I got the ez cheese to start. looked just like the photos. crispy crust was amazing. red sauce had a nice garlicky kick. cheese was parmesan and fully loaded. basil was fragrant and shredded. crust was light and airy. I loved. read more

Secret Squares - ez cheese. simple and excellent - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

This is really, really, good pie. Being from the Mitten state I appreciate a good Detroit style pizza. The crust is a perfection of light, airy, crisp with just a little bit of oiliness making it a slice of heaven. The toppings are fresh and sauce flavorful, creating for a first bite a bite of perfection. Sign up for the text reminders and you get your options for the week of what pies they'll be slanging. Schedule your pie pickup or go eat there. The pizza also heats up well and holds its original character. Secret Squares is an easy no frills pizza joint that makes bomb pies. Get some! read more

See all

This is a small outfit that primarily runs as a takeout. There are a handful of seats indoors for a small group, but when I got there I received an oddly unwarm welcome and ended up taking my pizza to go. The Detroit-style pizza is delivered with maximum crispness due to the way that cheese caramelizes on the edge of the square crust, but the crust is surprisingly light and airy in comparison. I ordered a holiday special with pesto that delivered a bright mix of both colors and flavors. They do make some pizzas vegan, though for me the cheese on pizza is one of the finite number of non-vegan things that I eat. Options outside of pizza are limited. The pizza cost enough that I figured I wouldn't finish it, but I did eventually throughout the evening, and was not hungry for some time thereafter. While there are limitations here, the style of pizza is distinctive and it's a nice bit of variety for the city. read more

Secret Squares - Christmas pizza special - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

We love Detroit style pizza and Secret Squares was recommended by my hair stylist and a YouTube video. We arrived at 4:30 and were greeted by a friendly guy who was talking pizza orders. He let us know that it would take about 25 minutes to cook our pizza which wasn't a problem. We ate the pizza there and they have a small section to dine in and 2 tables outside. We chatted with the staff while waiting. The pizza is top quality Detroit style with thick crust with buttery crispy crust and edges, then cheese and the sauce and toppings on top. Check their hours online before going and get this PIZZA read more

See all

I love the deep crust and the flavors oozing out srsly best pizza in Richmond and I've tried many many pizzas

Shit is some good ass pizza! Trust and believe me, you will not regret it! Order in advance if you could, but it's worth the wait hundred percent! read more

Secret Squares - Spicy sausage with vodka sauce, Chicago style - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

See all

This pizza is SO GOOD!!! It's a little pricy but definitely worth it. Super crunch deep dish pizza and the staff was so friendly. Only con is the inside is very small so it's more of a to-go place. read more

Secret Squares - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

The pizza was incredible! Very tasty thick and cheesy crust with a great sauce that had a little kick of heat. read more

Secret Squares - Extra Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

See all

Got the Big Red...made with love that you could taste. Incredible. I WILL be back. And the ranch is spectacular.

Finally got our hands on the infamous Secret Squares! Ordering was super easy with their text notifications to remind you when the ordering window is open. Pickup was super easy and the shop was super cute and quaint in Churchill. We ordered the spicy boi and it did not disappoint! The cheese was super stretchy, peppers were spicy, and the crust was so crunchy! Absolutely one of my top favorite pizza spots now. Sharing between two people there were no leftovers (disappointing) so we'll definitely have to get two pizzas next time. Thank you secret squares read more

Secret Squares - Spicy boi - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

See all

Easy ordering and pick up! I love that you pick a time and it's ready when you arrive at exactly that time. The space they're in on 29th currently has a few tables, though I was planning to take mine home. We got the rainbow pie and pepperoni. The crust is incredible and I loved the toppings. The cheese was not my fav, but honestly everything else is so good I'd even go without cheese next time. Or just ricotta - that ricotta is delightful on the pepperoni pie. Will definitely be back here again soon! Welcome to Church Hill :) read more

Secret Squares - Rainbow pie to go - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

Great spot for pizza. Always made right, have ordered from here about 3-4 times. Staff and owner are always nice. Always crunchy and flavorful. Worth the price of the pie and will definitely be back. read more

Secret Squares - Rainbow Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

Great pizzas. We got 2 different kinds. I don't recall the names. Worth the wait. They seem glass bottle sodas too.

Secret squares is the best thing to happen to pizza since New York thin. Killer staff, friendly and always happy to see you.. pizza combinations that are to die for, this is no longer a secret ! secret square's pizza is a well known fact of life. read more

See all

Consistent great pizza. I am a big foodie and this pizza stands out from most pizzas I tried. FR, everything on the pizza is done right. Stretchy cheesy goodness, golden brown crust, colorful sauce, and crispy cheesy outer edges. I usually order the Saria pizza and my family loves it each time. The pesto is a vibrant green, and the cook of the vegetables are delicious! No sad, dull-color, overcooked vegetables to be found! read more

This is a pop-up Detroit style pizza place. The crust is focaccia-esque bread, with a good layer of cheese, then sauce, then whatever toppings you've ordered. The pop-up has very limited hours, but it so delicious and worth it. I really hope they expand into a full restaurant! The ordering process is interesting (and exciting) - only opening at 5pm on Thursdays. They sell out fast, so make sure to get online quickly! You order on that Thursday to pick up on Tuesday at the Kitchen Classroom in Henrico, so just make sure to know that going in. Sign up for text alerts online to better your odds at securing one. The pizza itself though is incredible. I ordered the extra cheese to get a good standard glimpse at the pies, and I was blown away. It is flavorful, perfectly sweet tomato sauce, and wonderful crust. I also loved the ricotta cheese on top, what a sweet and great touch! Each is $25, which I initially thought was a little pricey, but I honestly started to get too full after 1.5 slices (and I can EAT pizza). With that focaccia-like crust, even one pie could easily be shared by 3-6 people. I can't wait to try more pop up orders, and I hope to try more pies soon!! read more

If you're looking for amazing Detroit style pizza this is the place to go! I was on the waitlist for a few weeks and kept missing the drops due to pick up days I was away for work. The longer I had to wait, the more I wanted to try it! The ingredients are fresher than I have ever had on pizza. The home made sourdough crust was such a soft, crispy edged base for delicious toppings! The sauce was so sweet and tangy and really set off the ricotta on top. I am normally a New York style pizza person but this Detroit style was very good and I will try it again! Loved meeting the chef when picked up, it's made with love for sure! read more

Secret Squares - Roni Pie(on the left) and Ok Boomer (on the right) - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

A pop up / drop off kind of set up that requires you to place an order online on a Thursday for a delivery the following Tuesday. It's pain enough to have to decide nearly a week ahead that I may want a pizza. But the website says the last "drop date" was over two months ago, and clicking on the "notify me" box hasn't yielded any emails or offers to place an order in the weeks since I did so. Food may be good, but as a business it is not worth the hassle. read more

This was the new Richmond location in Church Hill (located where Nile used to be!) The pizza was pre-order and allows you to place an order for a specific date and time. Honestly, I liked the exclusivity idea. There being only a finite number of pizzas available, you have to be ready at the countdown to snag a pizza. The ordering system was a little confusing initially because it was like trying to buy Taylor Swift tickets. Like Kmart on Black Friday, people were grabbing pizzas left and right. I had to wait a moment for a pizza to be released from someone's cart. To reiterate, the pizza shop only has a specific number of pre-order pizzas available so once its sold out, its gone until next release/week. Once it was time to select a pizza, you had SECONDS to try to snag a pre-order and place it in your cart for purchase. SUGGESTION: know what you want and be ready to add it to your cart immediately. I was able to snag a Roni Detroit style pizza. Since it is a small operation, you are given a specific date and time to pick up your pizza. Picking up the pizza was easy seamless. The pizza was lukewarm upon pickup. I like my pizza hot, but it wasn't a deal breaker. The pizza itself was beautiful in its presentation. Thick crust, substantial sauce, evenly distributed toppings. Now, the size of the pizza was small. I'm 5'3 and have small hands and took a pic for reference. There were 6 squares and if I wanted to do damage, I could have eaten the pizza myself (maybe for lunch and dinner). My husband ate 4 out of 6 squares and he was still snacking afterwards. The serving size is modest. The flavor Profile was good. The sauce was sweet and not too acidic. The pepperoni was beautifully stacked and crust offered a spectacular bite. The Roni was a good pizza but felt like it wasn't "adventurous" in flavor. I believe I may find what I'm looking for in the other pizza choices. For $30 (pizza+tip+taxes), the pizza was okay. I would try the other options. I am happy there is a Detroit style pizza closer to the city! Excited for what's to come :-) read more

See all

I ordered to the Church Hill location. I was a bit early so they said I could sit inside to wait. I had my dog with me and they were very friendly and happy to see him. They washed their hands (obviously important) after they said hi to him. So 5/5 for service The pizza (in my opinion was underwhelming) they gave me a "rainbow pizza" with pesto, vodka sauce, ricotta and hot honey, and red sauce lines. Presentation? 5/5. But the size is small for what I paid. $33 including tax and tip. I feel like I could've gotten a better deal at Bottoms Up. But it was deep dish and the experience that I paid for. The flavors just didn't hit like I wanted them to. Maybe it was because there were so many fighting? Idk. But that hot honey is no joke. It hits you in the back of the throat. Nice to have with ricotta to cool it down. My husband would disagree and say it's 4/5. I say if you want to try it and it's pay day go ahead. read more

Secret Squares - A slice on a small plate - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

See all

How can I know when it's open I drove 1/2 an hour for it to be closed Having a phone number and allowing someone to call ahead would of been nice read more

This pizza is so tasty!! Crispy, crunchy, delicious sauce and cheese on the bottom, love it and will be back for more

The rainbow is a MUST. Definitely will be back. Did not disappoint one bit. I am already counting down to my next cheat day. read more

This is Incredible pizza. Best in RVA. Great staff too! This is definitely a must try.

Crust was wonderful but price was too steep for the size of the pizza. The tomato sauce on the cheese wasn't flavorful but heard that the boomer was better. read more

The pizza served at this establishment is truly extraordinary, captivating the senses with each delectable bite. read more

Secret Squares - RONI PIE - Pizza Near Me - Richmond, Virginia

Great light and airy pizza. Unique flavor combinations and they all go together very well. Delicious pizza, give this place a try. I was greeted with the biggest smile and most welcoming hello. So service is right on time and perfect. I took my pizza to go but the restaurant looks clean and simple like a pizza parlor should be. Price point is worth it!! read more

I can't stop ordering Secret Squares. It's got a real hold on me and I can't wait until the menu is released. I'll eat anything here and it's always delicious. A big shout out to the crust and the pesto. Delicious! read more

Best pizza in the city. This dude is an artist and will be opening a shop in Churchill soon. Keep on the lookout for it and follow him on Instagram for updates read more