The theme of the restaurant needs a little bit of updating but if you are into more of a early 2000s pizza place vibe then this place is for you. The service was fast and the employees were very nice the only problem was the food. The sizes were huge, and were slightly misleading. The pizza, garlic bread, and calzone didn't have much flavor nothing realistic stood out, other then the fact that everything was over sized, which made it hard to eat cause all the toppings were falling out of the pizza. I could see this place being good for kids cause it's all plain. read more

Called and ordered pizzas. When we arrived to pick up, the staff was so very busy yet managed to stay so friendly. When they handed me the 4 pizzas (2 large, 2 small) i started to laugh. I swear it weighed about 30lbs! The pizza was so so good and beyond filling! This is not your hood old thin crust pizza. This is hearty but bomb and yet so amazing pizza! 1-2 pieces and you are filled. And I'm a big dude. Also, i never say this but their GF pizza crust was damn good. My wife got one and i was shocked how good it was. read more

Came here today because of the food. Needless to say I will not be coming back. While waiting to get my pizza to go, another patron brought a pizza back to the counter, the same kind I ordered. He just ordered his without the mushrooms. Long story short, I told the girl at the counter that I would wait for a new one. She explained to the guy working the oven about the mistake and that was why he was making a new one. Evidently he failed to notice I was standing there at the counter he and told the girl they didn't touch it and she should have passed it on to me. Don't know about you or your situation but my husband has an autoimmune issue an with the new Covid strain super wild here, I don't want to take that chance, I don't know how many people are sitting at that table where it was delivered to them..... My point being, not good business. So I am sure this just cured me of eating out, when a business is willing to compromise the health of their customers for the sake of a pizza....? read more

Great looking pizza! We ordered a calzone which was large enough to share between 2 people, plus we had leftovers! The garden salad paired well as a side. We would love to try their pizza next time. :) read more

Pizza was delicious & staff was super friendly to our large group of little kids! The portions are ginormous and totally worth it! Will come back again when visiting Sandpoint next time. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Choose 3 toppings- Canadian bacon, tomato & avocado - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

The absolute best!!!! Always in search of a great pizza and now we don't have to look any further that Second Avenue Pizza

Yummy, Amazing, Must try!!! I love this place! This place has the best pizza ever, It is huge and loaded with toppings and I mean loaded and you will want to order the Garlic Cheese bread it is delicious! Another must try is the Mexican pizza it is loaded with all of your favorite taco toppings! It is a cute location always clean Carolyn is the best, and her staff is mostly younger kids but they are always nice and helpful. Prices are great for a large Canadian bacon and pineapple plus a large garlic bread we pay about $23 and some change and it feeds my family of 6 dinner and lunch the next day (Most of the time) some of the menu prices may seem high at first but once you receive your pizza and see how much you are getting you will not be disappointed!! This is seriously a must try if you are in the area! read more

Toppings are really generous. Takes awhile to get your pizza but worth the wait. Every time we come to town this is always our first meal. read more

Best pizza we have had since we left our favorite place at home. The toppings are very plentiful and very thick. It seems to be a locals favorite. We would definitely come here again when in the area. We had a salami mushroom and Pepperoncinis Pizza. Also a pitcher of beer. Prices are very reasonable read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

HUGEST calzones!! And absolutely delicious!! If your appetite is big( I have a teen son) you will be satisfied and full!

Holy cow this pizza is the best ever!!!! Wish they had this in California!! You won't leave hungry I promise Tons of topping great service the owner is amazing too!!! Hope to eat here again before we leave town. Try the taco pizza. Great idea!! read more

Best pizza anywhere! The depth of the pizza, has to be close to 2 inches thick. The flavor, crust & ingredients are all top notch! You can not go wrong here. We ordered a large and you are full after 2 slices. Will be our only pizza place & we live in Priest River. Viki who? read more

Best pizza in town with large helpings. Amazing pizzas that remind me of Chicago's pizzas. Very unique menu not found anywhere else. Definitely try one! My fave is their Mexican pizza! Yum... read more

Absolutely the best pizza and honestly the best price around. You get a lot for your money tons of ingredients on top of the pizza! We had the best experience from Ray that works there, he showed us a couple of pizza options before we started right out of the oven. I will definitely come back great experience with good food read more

Second Avenue Pizza - The jukebox - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

If you haven't tried this place you definitely need to the pizza is so good and you get what you pay for that is so true so even though the prices may be a little bit higher here you're getting excellent quality product and that is why I recommend this place to all of my friends and family read more

I admit it, I am a pizza snob. I like it both ways though, so don't think I'm a prude. Thick and doughy, filled with toppings or thin and crispy, folding the only way to get it in. This was not enough of either for me to really FREAK OUT the way it seems that the rest of our friends and family do. We willingly went our first night in town to pick up a pie, and it was good and all, but nothing to shout about. Then, the next day, guess what was for lunch? Yup, DELICIOUS SECOND AVENUE PIZZA. It was good, again, but the more toppings you have, the better it seemed to taste. This was repeated until 4 times we were either fed this pizza or invited here to meet someone. Again, it's not bad, it's good, but NOT THAT GOOD. When I lived here, in this wicked little town, I thought this was pretty good pizza. Then I moved to the big city and became the pizza snob that stands before you now. If this was here in Seattle, the atmosphere would work and it would still be busy, but the pizza on it's own is just okay. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

Small, quaint pizza joint in Sandpoint. A few of the reviews I read (prior to showing up here) talked about bad customer service and wait times. However, my relative (who is a local) swears by their pizza so we had to try it out. Customer service: didn't have any problems. The counter staff was prompt, friendly, answered questions, and put up with some of our modifications without a problem. Wait: Wasn't too bad really. Maybe it's because I knew going in it might take a little longer than usual but we had our food in about 35 minutes. Pizza: Nothing to complain about. Ample amount of toppings, good sauce, even my picky kids had no problems to speak of. I thoroughly enjoyed the pizza and even had some for breakfast the next morning. Excellent experience all around and will be hitting them up when we're in town again! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Fresh toppings packed on! - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

Visited Sandpoint and this spot was recommended. It's out of the way but great food. The pizzas and salads are loaded and tasty. Well worth the 30 minute wait that it takes for them to cook your pizza. The restaurant is very clean and staff is great! read more

This is a hidden restaurant that is worth the wait! You will wait for your pizza longer than normal but it is well worth it. My friend recently had the pizza here then travel to Paris and had pizza while there and said, there is no way it compared to 2nd Ave., Pizza! The people are friendly service is great, the atmosphere is casual and comfortable. This is definitely a place to take friends when they come to visit or when I want good pizza and they have great prices you actually get more than what you pay for. read more

See all

Visiting from Texas, pizza was overflowing with the toppings, and just the right amount of sauce. Worth the stop!

Wow, if you want a loaded pizza, this is definitely the way to go. They are extremely slow and don't bother to let you know that your pizza is ready when you are getting it to go but even after an hour long wait (only to discover my pizza had been sitting there for who knows how long) and bad service I still had to give 4 stars because it was so frickin tasty. The pizza was huge and piled high with toppings and the garlic cheese bread is so delicious!!!! You will not leave hungry that's for sure! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Schweitzer pizza w/Canadian bacon - OMG, so good!!! - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

See all

Found this gem last week and it was great!! The garlic bread with meat sauce for dipping was so good!

Husband and I are in the area visiting friends. We wanted pizza and this place came highly recommend. Let me tell you it did not disappoint. The pizza was fantastic! So much good stuff pilled high, just delicious. Even the garden salad was just fantastic. Very reasonable prices. If we come through the area again this will be a must do! read more

Pizza was decent tons of toppings. I live in the Sandpoint area and trying out local places. I wouldn't make a special trip to come back but also wouldn't turn down a slice. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - You name combo. This crust - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

We ordered a pizza to go on a Tuesday night. They told us 45 minutes for pick-up. We arrived at 45 minutes. Had to wait for 10 for the people in front of us to be served (they don't have a pick-up window, so you have to wait in line while they help all of the people that are ordering their meal for dine-in and for people looking to get refills on sodas). We ended up waiting 20 minutes. Slow service. One girl was doing it all, while several employees enjoyed standing around doing very little. Got the pizza and the thing was overflowing with toppings. Probably one of, if not the best pizza I have ever had. To sum up, sloooooooooow, apathetic service, great pizza. read more

Oh my goodness, our second time here for pizza. First, customer service awesome, this feel very familyish. And I was very welcome. Small Canadian bacon and pineapple was huge and delicious again. The crust holds up to the weight of the toppings even the next day. Delicious! The Carolyn Calzone with the meat sauce on the side was even better to me than the pizza. Oh my, the chicken cesear salad was was wonderful also and HUGE! THANK you all for another great meal! read more

This little place was overwhelmed with business when I arrived. It's a weird time with the corona virus scare. So I ordered and was told about 15 minutes and it turned out to be 35... the kids in the kitchen were buried in tickets. Ok so I get the pie and I literally mean pie. This pizza was 3 inches thick and close to 4 pounds. At first I was thinking the topping were gonna taste too strong and the crust wouldn't compete in all the goo... but it was surprisingly balance and tasty. Try again some day when we are really hungry. Been eating this large pizza three days now read more

They don't hold back here... over the top with the toppings and super rich sauce. A couple of slices is more than a meal. Friendly staff, worth the wait, they don't skimp. read more

We've been here a number of times before and since moving to the area. While we pretty much always get the Jukebox Special (highly recommended) I can attest, without perjury, that pretty much everything here is incredible. Last time we came in, we had my lactose intolerant sister in law along. She ordered a bacon, pineapple, mushroom and olive pizza, sans cheese, and it was unbelievable. I'd eat cheese on my pizza even if I was lactose intolerant (I don't think I am) and this anomalous disk of meat and incongruous fruits/veggies was amazing. The pizza is what I would describe as more American style pizza, not thin like NYC, and not deep dish like Chicago. All the same, it is substantial. A small Jukebox Special, with its abundance of mushrooms, olives, onions, pepperoni, and half dollar size chunks of spicy Italian sausage weighs easily five pounds. My wife and I couldn't finish it between us without leftovers. A small. Seriously, figure you're going to have leftovers. Prices are so good here, one wonders how they even turn a profit. On a prior visit, my dad was slack jawed with disbelief when he got the check, as he was certain he had been significantly undercharged. The atmosphere is nice, very inviting, particularly if you're an American Graffiti fan (the owner has signed AG movie memorabilia all over the place). It reminds me of the pizza parlors of my youth. Altogether a wonderful place. The staff appear to be family, or to operate like one, and the sense of warmth and welcome is apparent from the very moment you step up to the counter to place your order. My only complaint is that they are closed Mondays, which always ends up being the day we start craving a Jukebox and can't scratch the itch. Oh well. It's worth the wait to next time. Highly--HIGHLY--recommend this place. Also, no free refills on drinks, so be aware. Doesn't stop me loving this place. read more

Amazing pizza! Pizza taller than you have ever seen! Toppings are plentiful and so tasty! Highly recommend! Takes some time for them to make it, but worth the wait! read more

Best pizza I've ever eaten. Piled high with toppings on a perfectly cooked crust. Inside the restaurant is clean and cared for. For these prices, it's now my favorite spot in Sandpoint. Make sure to give yourself about 40 minutes for the perfection to take place! read more

This place is great! Easily some of the best pizza I've ever had. Everything made in house and super fresh. A fantastic small town feel to the place. All staff was friendly and helpful. Can wait to go back! read more

The pizza is so loaded with toppings. Very filling. Delicious. You know what you're getting when you pick up the box. It's weighty! The employees are so kind and personable no matter how busy they are. read more

The best pizza in Sandpoint. Carolyn and her staff are kind, helpful, and knowledgeable about pizza! Though they are short staffed, they bust their butts off for their customers! I will be coming back & bringing my family and friends! read more

Hard time finding this little Gem, once I found it walked in & saw a few families having a good time eating, & chatting. The juke box was turned off but a little music would of been great to. so I walked up to order a pizza & see what all the raze is about then went to go grab a seat & wait. It was a long wait but the pizza had wonderful flavor & not Greasy so worth the wait. the place was a bit dark, but looked clean & the one bathroom was tiny. other then that customer service was so so nothing to brag about, but took the rest of the pizza home & it was good the next day! read more

See all

Best pizza! This thing must weigh 7lbs! Juke Box pizza all the way. Super impressed with this place. Also like Caroline Special. Can't go wrong here. Enjoy! read more

Pizza great but this place desperately needs a pick up window. Called in an order and came at designated time only to wait another 30 minutes in a line of people who were ordering. Ridiculous read more

We have a large family, with a lot of differing tastes. Everyone gobbled up the pizzas we got, so that by itself gives 5 stars in my book. Pizza is one of those things that has a variety of costs as well, and you don't always get what you pay for, but we felt we certainly got our money's worth here. They were all delicious, and the leftovers kept well to reheat for the next day's lunch as well. read more

Food was fantastic! 5 of us ordered a calzone (excellent flavors), small pesto bread (fantastic), medium jukebox pizza (so good), and a small veggie (tasty). Come in with a big appetite and a decent size wallet, but totally worth. read more

See all

Good pizza, be patient (have a beer while you wait) they are busy. The friendly staff hustles and works hard.