This was my 1st visit ever, on Halloween night. We were pleasantly surprised it was open on a Sunday night when many places aren't. It did appear closed from the outside when we pulled up and we almost left but noted a few cars outside. The menu is pretty straight forward, nothing too fancy or odd. I forgot to snap a pic unfortunately. We spent about $32 for a large half combo and half pepperoni/pineapple along with a soda and a tap beer. When we go to other establishments, we end up with 3-4 pieces leftover. Here, we ended up with 6 pieces and was still pleasantly full. We're talking generous toppings here folks, especially the sausage! The toppings were of quality, I loved the slight taste of caraway seeds in the sausage. It could have used a tad more sauce, and the crust was a perfect balance between hand tossed and thin crust. Although, we did note on one side of the pizza the crust was a bit more darkened/crunchy and part of the middle was more doughy...so maybe a hot spot in the oven where a little more rotating is needed and perhaps would ensure evenness. Although with that being said, it still didn't take any enjoyment away. It seemed to have stayed fairly steady the whole time we were there, a handful of tables still needed to be bussed, and the plates and silverware could have been attended to a tad more, but nothing to be disgusted by. Overall it was a nice relaxing environment with a couple of different sectioned/levels of seating but plenty of space. The restrooms were fairly clean but busy and only a one stall situation. Since they were on the way past the open sided kitchen I was able to appreciate how surprisingly clean it was! All staff we interacted with were pleasant and prompt. We shall return! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Half combo and half pepperoni/pineapple pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

Looking around the sandpoint area for a dinner idea, we decided to give 2nd Ave a try. The head cook there, I think Spencer was his name? The dude is a pizza maestro. The second ave supreme was eye popping with toppings, and despite being piled inches high, the dough was perfect and toppings cooked thru. Three of us, we had two med pizzas and a garlic bread (basically a 3rd pizza) the left overs we took home had to be 8-10 lbs, for real! This place is legitimate, he brought out the pie, and I exclaimed out loud "Dude, are you serious? !?!" Unreal portions, you better be hungry, cause they aint messing around. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - 2nd Ave supreme, and pepperoni pizzas. - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

See all

Food was excellent. Pizza was massive and very good. We just picked up food to go, but staff was very helpful. Will definitely be back when in town. read more

This is the place to go for a delicious pie. While the crust may just be a decent standard crust, the quality and quantity of the toppings push these pizzas over the top. The spicy sausage is indeed spicy, and each ingredients adds is flavor to the pie. Nothing is bland or ordinary. Come hungry, these pizzas are big! Good selection of beer too... read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Medium Pizza, Pepperoni, Spicy Sausage, jalapenos, fresh garlic, extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

The pizza is amazing. Yes you wait a minute, because they make amazing pizza. Seat yourself. Nothing dance. Just good food. Order small!! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

Surprisingly great pizza! First of all, we got a large and it was HUGE. The amount of toppings was actually absurd. It's not exactly gourmet, but for the price what you get is great. We had tons of leftovers and it was an amazing post skiing snack. 10/10 read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Vegetable Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

Stopped in with friends. Everyone loved the food. Pizza was generously topped with fresh options, multiple options for different styles of crust. Great service. Family friendly restaurant. Would definitely stop in again. read more

After driving for 8 hours, I finally got to the vacation in Sandpoint and wanted a restaurant that delivered. We found Second Avenue Pizza because it got good reviews -- the delivery was here within 30 minutes and the guy who brought us the food was friendly. Schweitzer Ski Flake (with chicken): $24.95 (large) It was just okay. I honestly thought it would have more flavor (couldn't even taste the garlic). The taste just didn't quite match up to the "wow factor" of the pizza having so many toppings (& weighing like 5 lbs!). The pizza had HEAPS of fresh spinach, a lot of tomatoes, huge chunks of feta cheese galore, mushrooms, black olives and a lot of asiago cheese. When it says you can add shavings of chicken, that's just it: small amount of chicken. The toppings were so thick & abundant - you definitely get the amount you pay for. Maybe it was just an off night or just not the right pizza for us -- I would try them again based on other reviews of different pizzas. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Close up of the Schweitzer w/ chicken - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

See all

Came all the way from Lodi California took a flight and drove an hour and a half and it was way worth it. The people were amazing the food was even better. And as I was leaving I found out they deliver frozen pizzas too I will definitely be getting Second avenue pizza to Lodi in the near future. And the prices are great too! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

See all

Holy cow -- if you like boat loads of toppings on your pizza, this is the place for you! We absolutely loved the all meat pizza. Just know that you'll probably only be able to eat a couple slices! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - All-meat pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

Hubster and I got two pizzas to go on our last night in Sandpoint. Delicious freshly made pizza. Crust was wonderful - crunchy on the outside, fluffy on the inside. Hubster had the Jukebox and I had light sauce with fresh mushrooms, garlic and ricotta. We both got a small but really should have done a half and half. Very filling. read more

You will never find another pizza place that goves you your money's worth like this one. I am a big eater and my wife and I split a Small, and usually have a slice left over. It takes a little longer than most pizza places because it takes longer to cook that much topping to perfection. Try the Jukebox or the Mexican Pizza and you'll be hooked for life. read more

We came to visit some friends here in Sandpoint, ID and ordered the large Jukebox Special through delivery which consisted of Pepperoni, Spicy Italian Sausage, Mushroom, Olive, and Onion. Holy flippin' cow, this is a monstrosity of a pizza pie and was forewarned! This sucker probably weighed like 10 lbs. Exercise curls with this pie is probably highly suggested between bites, that's how massive this thing is. Very topping heavy. Can easily serve 5-6 people, for sure. The flavor of the ingredients was good, however, wasn't a big fan of their sauce. Can't really pinpoint why other than it seemed very acidic and maybe too tomato-ey if that's a thing but it had zest. The Italian sausage had a nice spicy kick to it and they sprinkled fresh parm over the whole pie which is a new one on me. I'm use to getting packets of dry parm and crushed red pepper in other places which I kind actually prefer. The crust had a nice crisp. This isn't one of my favorites but it's still a good option. The ordering process was super easy and the people are way cool. It took about an hour to get the pie delivered. The price is RIDICULOUSLY affordable!! Everything (with tip) was still less than $30. Definitely worth a try if you happen to be in the neighborhood. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - The Jukebox Special. - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

I've only ever done takeout or delivery from this place and it's always the meat lovers cuz it's definitely worth every penny cuz I feel the whole pizza feels like it's 20lbs! You won't ever find a better pizza place that can match the quality or quantity. read more

Second Avenue Pizza is the best in Northern Idaho! You will wait a little while but it is always worth the wait and while you are waiting, they have great local brews on tap! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Family time at the best pizza restaurant ever! - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

Fantastic pizza. The red sauce with the cheese sticks is in the top 10 best things our family ever put in our mouths.

I can eat any pizza but I cannot eat whatever this was. Not sure what kind of dough they used but it was thick and chewy like bread dough, not pizza dough. The cheese looked like it came from (and tasted) the Kraft mozzarella pre-shredded cheese. The "sauce" was not seasoned, it tasted like Hunts tomato sauce from a can. I will hand it to them for their toppings. But the first bite was like biting into a day old tough roll that has been sitting out on the counter. Again, I will eat any pizza, but I couldn't finish this. There was an absence of flavor, like pizza called from the other room, but forgot to come into the room. Oh the cardboard was soaked. So possibly I was also eating cardboard. Well done cardboard. read more

See all

Don't let the quiet side street fool you. Delicious pizza, great service, and very fair price for the portion. A skiers delight! Thanks 2nd Ave read more

Second Avenue Pizza - a person cutting a pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

A little hidden gem! Huge portions, cooked to perfection, friendly staff, and clean! They have a little something for everyone. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Mini pizza and calzone cooked to perfection! - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

Great pizza. Good take out The toppings are very thick. Amazing pizza. It is very tasty. read more

If you're going through Sandpoint, you need to stop here if you like pizza. The best pizza we've eaten. Their pizzas do not skimp on toppings and the size of a large is like a family size in other pizza places. Their breadsticks or should say bread pizza was amazing! Will definitely will stop by again on our way through. read more

Pizza dough is never cooked enough and the toppings are raw. Staff us friendly enough but food has gotten bad.

This pizza is amazing! Great crust, sauce, toppings. Not really close to anything I have had. Try it for yourself! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

I don't know how they dry in business with these prices. A mini pizza is more than enough for one person to eat. And it's like $6. Friendly staff. Good sustainability practices. Pepperoni was great. I want to try the margherita next. read more

The portions are big. We ordered a small pizza split between two of us and couldn't eat it all. The sausage was the best I've ever had just the right amount of spiciness and plenty of it. It is a deep dish pizza from Chicago, which we don't normally like, but it was nice and crispy on the bottom, although slightly under done in the middle, they are very generous on their toppings. And the cashier was very friendly and even let me try a little of their huckleberry lemonade. read more

Good pizza, good atmosphere this is the second time eating there food its a must go to when your in sand point idaho

Currently only doing takeout and delivery but still soooo good! My Carolyn Special Calzone takeout was PERFECT today! Yum! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Before the sauce! - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

See all

For those wanting a quick review: Pizza is amazing but it does take longer than other pizza places. Large 1 topping (good amount for 2 people) was $13.75. For those wanting a longer review: Pizza is still amazing, and the cost is also the same. Atmosphere was average. There was a hockey game being played with high volume (hard to concentrate/talk to others) and there were several tables which had not been cleaned (yikes, just looks bad). Watched several waiters walk by and do nothing... However, we fixed these problems by getting our pizza to go. We were also there late on a Sunday night, so there weren't too many people there. With more people, I am guessing they would have been forced to clean the tables in order to serve people and perhaps the general babble would have drowned out the game. However, the pizza time would have been longer as well. I highly recommend Second Ave based on the overall quality and size of pizza. You will be full of good pizza when done. This is a rare case where the food quality was high enough to compensate for below average other factors. We will be coming back again! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

I love this place. The pizza is filling & the service is great. They have a good size seating area & high chairs. They have a decent selection of drafts on tap & have great pizza ranch. Would recommend. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Small Pineapple & Jalapeño Pizza (Thick Crust) - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

We loved eating here! The owner was great describing the pizzas and making recommendations. We ended up getting the Jukebox Special and Carolyn Special. Both were great. They are MASSIVE pizzas and feed a ton of people. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Jukebox Special - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

See all

This is our go to pizza place! Pizza is always delicious and so many toppings!! The staff are always so friendly and welcoming!!!

After a long wait in line to order, the wait for our pizza to be made took nearly 2 hours. The inside of the restaurant was outdated and divey, and the more crowded it became, I didn't feel comfortable being somewhere where there wasn't good air circulation. When our pizza was finally ready, we found the crust to be too thick (and normally I love a substantial crust!). The vegan cheese wasn't that great either. read more

This was actually about a year ago but what the heck. We were in Sandpoint for a couple days on a long motorcycle trip. Well, I wanted pizza and this place came highly recommended. It was awesome. Great pizza and really cool atmosphere for this type of food venue. Best Pizza of the road trip and it was thick. They tell you from the start that it will be a while as the thick pizza has to cook longer. It was worth it and I would recommend to anyone in Sandpoint. Nothing like great pizza and great brew on a motorcycle read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Great food - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

This definitely hands down the best pizza I have ever had!! Thick crust and truly delicious pizza! They use top notch quality ingredients and it definitely tastes Great!! The staff is always friendly and accommodating if needed!! I highly recommend Second Avenue Pizza!!! read more

Amazing Pizza! Best pizza ever. My town in Davis, CA always has Lampost Pizza and it's always voted best pizza in town but this blew my mind. Great employees and the most honest pizza you'll ever order. Hat's off to ya'll! read more

Ok pizza but definitely not my favorite. What it has going for it: - place is rather large, so plenty of seating - they are generous with the toppings - plenty of parking - they deliver What it has going against it: - place needs to be renovated - kind of expensive for what you get - rather slow from the time you order to the time your picking up your pizza - pizza crust is too light for my taste So this place was a little hard to find. It's not on the main part of 2nd Ave. You walk in and you notice a lot of seating. The decor is really not too appealing and i guess it's a thing for the local kids to tag anything that is wood in this place. If you want a good time there are plenty of phone numbers to choose from on the seating. The customer areas are for the most part clean but everything is dated and worn. Guessing it's owned by retirees since there is a lot 50's memorabilia up. They even have juke box....but it doesn't work. What really puts the decor over the top is the toilet seat they have mounted on the wall. As for the pizza...well let's just say there are better options in Sandpoint in my opinion. The crust is like something you would find at a take and bake place. Too light and airy for my taste. Would I come here again?....probably not read more

Best pizzas we have ever had! Freshest and most generous toppings. No grease. Crust is perfect (NOT WET, even though ours was packed with fresh veggies)! Expect a wait, because their pizza is amazing....the wait is worth every minute. We had the Schweitzer SKI FLAKE with chicken (amazing combo) and pepperoni (yeah, even simple pepperoni is incredible). If you love garlic, order extra. We ordered triple garlic and it was perfect for our garlic obsession. PS-great beer selection and tasty wine. FUN people. read more

The ladies at Best Western sent us over to 2nd Ave., Pizza. We were looking for a pizza and a beer. We got what we came for absolutely great pizza and excellent hospitality. Employees were pleasant and the owner came out and spoke to us for several minutes. She was truly a customer oriented people person. I would highly recommend 2nd Ave if you are looking for pizza. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Side view of 2nd Ave., Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

See all

Amazing local pizza place! Incredible service and huge pies! They even have gluten-free and vegan options.

I work here so let me give you the scoop. Awesome speciality pizzas piled high with toppings & cheese. Everything fresh from scratch even the the dough. Calzones the size of footballs. Veggie, vegan, and GF options (rice crust is great!). Cheesy garlic bread (yum), salads, bbq legs, and sandwiches also. There is a thin crust option if you don't like the deep dish style. A small will feed 2-3 people. There is a minimum of 30-35 minute wait once you order at the counter, and this is because it takes that long to cook thru the giant pizzas. On Friday and Saturday nights, expect to wait longer- possibly over an hour. We have 4 big ovens rolling and we bust our butts to cook them as fast as possible- but we don't sacrifice quality for speed. If you're looking for fast cheapo pizza try a chain. Ours is worth the wait- just leave some time for dining in or call ahead. Locally owned & operated and one of a kind! read more