A really filling pizza. Only order 1/2 what you think you will need. The crust is thick (I actually prefer thin-crust) and the toppings are twice as thick. We were eating left-overs for days! You can tell by the weight of the pizza box! read more

Holy cow. This place is great. We drove in from CDA and were looking for pizza. This place will not disappoint. They are not shy with their toppings. Just look at the pics. We WILL BE BACK. read more

Second Avenue Pizza - Look how thick their toppings are. - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

See all

This is very good pizza. The only thing is it feels very fattening because the cheese layer is like a foot high (just kidding) along with everything else on the pizza. We went several times, but stopped, just too much. Maybe we should just ask for not to go overboard on ingredients, but I think that's there signature deal. It's very very good though. read more

Bad experience tonight , short and simple . Priest Lake native, moved to Chicago . This was our go to pizza since my childhood, 20 other guess with us , my order was not submitted after paying and conversation explaining how we travel so far to come enjoy this meal. A big ball drop indeed . read more

This pizza is stupendous!!! Omg it is so good!! Nice people too and they deliver in town!

My wife and I ordered the "The Jukebox" and and order of the "Out of this World" breadsticks. The pizza was off the hook tasty and the breadsticks did not disappoint. They use quality ingredients and they were plentiful. The bad news was this was too much food for us to eat. The good news was that we were able to eat leftovers for both lunch and dinner the following day! Definitely worth a visit and return trip. read more

Second Ave pizza has always been my top pizza place! I've been eating here since kindergarten and i still do. The owner of SA is very nice, and She uses high-quality ingredients and it definitely tastes like it. Her pizzas are also on the cheap side (under $20) and you definitely get more than what you pay for. I live in California and to get a pizza this quality takes $45 and it doesn't even taste that great. You will never be disappointed! read more

Big family, ordered seven pizzas to go, got home, found FIVE long hairs baked into mine. I could accept 1. But five? That is a lack of quality control. That is pretty sad to have someone shedding over food like that. I'll never go back. read more

One star for the quaint throwback family pizza vibe, another star for decent toppings and sauce, and another just cause they really mean well. But that crust is rather awful: thick, chewy (not in a good way), bready, and without any depth of flavor. Glad this pizza style suits some folks, but we found this to be a pretty underwhelming experience. read more

Delicious pizza and the salad was great too! I forgot to ask if they make the French dressing but it was yummy!!

Best pizza in Idaho! Great pizza, great salads, great breadsticks, homemade sauces, huge portions and delicious flavor. You will have to wait a bit longer than any other pizza place but it is totally worth it! Order a salad while you wait and get ready to take some home! Love it! read more

I've been to 2nd Ave Pizza many times over the years and have always enjoyed it. Recently, I've had to eliminate gluten and dairy from my diet and haven't had pizza since :( Until 2nd Ave!!! Their gluten-free rice crust is one of the best crusts I've ever had (gluten or no gluten). They've tried out many different soy cheeses until they found one that melts and tastes the most like mozzarella. The pizza I got was so good, I went back the next day and got another!!! Disclaimer: their gluten-free crust is much thinner and crispier than their regular crust. read more

A great place for big parties of people and custom pizzas! Love the atmosphere here and laid back vibe.

The pizza here is epic! It's the thickest pizza I think I've ever had; very cheesy, and very good!! Very friendly staff, and I thought the price was really reasonable, too. Definitely give this place a try! read more

Pizza in Idaho was risky business, to be sure, but the pie itself wasn't half bad. We went for the 7lber--the Jukebox special--with all sorts of meat and mushrooms, I think. Closer to a chicago deep dish than a ny pie, it was different enough from both to be good and not step on any regional toes. The service, however, left something to be desired. As the only customers on a snowy winter lunchtime, we waited about 3 minutes for someone to even make an appearance at the order counter. When he did show and we ordered, all we got out of him was "Is that all?" along with the distinct impression that we'd ruined his afternoon nap. He perked up a bit later, but when I'm next in Sandpoint, I'll probably opt for delivery if I need a pizza fix. read more

Enjoyed the pizza and beer! Spicy sausage! Love when the local kids are working behind the counter! Cheap beer too! read more

Second Avenue Pizza - The sausage is spicy! My lips were burning, but it was delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Sandpoint, Idaho

This is probably the best pizza in Sandpoint, hands down. They have original, fresh selections that are made as you wait. The Schweitzer Ski Flake and Meat Lover's are two great pizzas.The staff and owner are very accommodating and welcoming. Second Avenue has become a tradition in my group circles - whenever there's a group outing, we know where to go. And so can you! read more

Not very happy with this. Our pizza was overflowing with cheese in the box outside of the crust. An obnoxious amount of cheese on it that wasn't even enjoyable. Caesar salad was drenched in so much dressing couldn't even eat it. Would give 0 stars if I could read more

My fav pizza! Every time I visit Sandpoint I grab large Canadian bacon. Thank you guys for your passion!!

Apparently, the attraction of Second Avenue Pizza is that they give you a lot of pizza. Unfortunately, this doesn't help if the pizza isn't that good to begin with. I had 2nd Ave. pizza once. Mind you, I'm a fan of cheese, and I like the Chicago stuffed pizzas and all, but there was so much cheese on our pizza that it was overkill and not appetizing. Nothing else about the pizza was memorable at all, and now if someone suggests pizza around here, I'm much happier getting it from one of the chain pizza places around. read more

Finally had the chance to come back to Second Ave after a 20 year hiatus. I'm happy to report that nothing has changed. Still the best pizza around, thick crust & loaded with fresh toppings. This stuff is seriously filling! (Four hungry adults couldn't finish a large). Great beer selection to help wash down your pie. All this in a casual, homey setting. If you find yourself with a hankering for a pizza in North Idaho, don't miss Second Ave! read more

Are you looking for a hearty pizza? well this is the one!!! "Caroly Special" it's AMAZING. A MUST, that you try it! You won't be disappointed. read more

Best pizza ever! Quality ingredients are much appreciated. Obviously great management! read more

Massive toppings, if you can wait 45 minutes or more. I really like their pizza but I have had to wait 3 hours for my pizza delivery before. It's worth it, the pizza is really good and totally filling. I often go here and wonder if everyone's really high, including the manager. read more

Pizza was deep dish deliciousness. The Schweitzer veggie was awesome. But the #1 Canadian bacon (Hawaiian) was the winner! So yummy!

The toppings on this pizza were piled HIGH! It was a mound of toppings like I had never seen before. I just couldn't believe my eyes! I wasn't sure how to tackle my pizza, but I managed and wow was it good!! We had been traveling and checked into a hotel for the night. I was pregnant and hungry...LOOK OUT! Knowing nothing about the area, I just wanted something good and delivered to my tired body and boy, did I get it. Wish we had something like this around here! read more

A good alternative to The Loading Dock - it's different, piled high, not cracker crust/neapolitan style. We wandered in after finding that Hope Market Cafe was closed Mon/Tues (at least the drive was nice) and were about the only people in the place. The gentleman taking our orders recommended one of the small specialty pizzas to share between two guys. To which we said, cool, but then later worried - "Two dudes? a *small?* Blasphemy." Turns out he was right. Our pizza came out, piled with black olives, mushrooms, pepperoni, and some really tasty sausage. The small was plenty, let it be known. Another diner got a calzone...which was enormous, stuffed with meat, cheese, and good looking red and green bell peppers. Topped with what he said was almost like spaghetti sauce. Like I said - I don't know that I can compare this to Loading Dock. The crust is thick, cheese is different, and toppings much thicker. So it's not better or worse...just...different. Anyway. We would probably go back. But then again, we're not kicking ourselves for just discovering this place at what is likely the end of our stay in Sandpoint. The price is just barely "two dollar signs." Honestly, this could easily be less than $10 a person, just depends on your beverage selections. read more

OMG! Simply the Best Pizza I've ever had, that should be the name on the sign! And trust me, over the years, I've done Pizza! The sausage, I don't know where they get it, but it just makes the flavor all around. You would think it was a deep dish option, 2" high at center, and yet cooked to perfection, the right crust, that carries every bit of that pie! They told me one time, when I picked up my pie, that they ship to New York regularly, for a special client who can't get enough! Every time I make my trek up north from CDA, I have to bring a pie back home. My normal order includes almost every topping, and weighs over 10 lbs! The best part of this well-kept secret, is that it's off the main drag, in a semi-residential part of town, so definitely not a tourist choice amongst all the others that are failing in Sandpoint due to all the new investors closing down businesses. It's surviving on word of mouth, which is the best formula for success. Every time I walk in the door, it is nearly packed, with a takeout line as well. I was almost tempted to keep this to myself, but you guys gotta know, and keep this place alive for years to come! It looks like it's going nowhere but up from here. I'm kinda glad I have to work for it, makes it even more special! read more

I mean, everyone that was born and raised in Sandpoint knows that this is absolutely the best pizza in town. Nothing else comes close. Slicemasters supreme!! And unlike most places they never skimp on the toppings. It's a literal mountain of toppings. If you pass up this place, you really need to be medicated. read more

Well worth the wait for our order. It was delicious and our family of 6 ate off a large for three days it was piled so high with toppings. Their gluten free crust was great as well. A very classic family pizza parlor feel too! read more

It took 1 hour to receive our pizza and we were one of only 4 tables. Pizza was delivered with 3 inches of ingredients piled high but it's impossible to bake a pizza this loaded, the vegetables were raw and crust below was uncooked. Sorry but one of the worst pizzas we have ever eaten. read more

Stopped in Sandpoint on our road trip down to San Francisco. So glad we picked this place for dinner. We ordered a Mexican pizza which I wasn't too sure about but boy did they have the flavors on point with their fresh tasty ingredients. read more

This was my first time visiting Sandpoint and my wife and I were looking for a good place to order pizza from. It was a busy Friday night and they told us an hour and a half for delivery which was fine. An hour and 45 minutes later I called and they said my order would be 40 more minutes. They said sorry and that is all. We had to put our infant down at this time and they called the hotel instead of my cell which woke up our baby! They delivered our pizza to another person in a different hotel with the same room number. They offered us salad as a sorry and would deliver the pizza as soon as possible. It ended up being 3 hours from order to delivery and when they called to tell me my pizza was here, they arrived at the wrong hotel. The topping were quality and the crust was good but service was obnoxious! read more

Holy moly! Piles of delicious toppings. Truly incredible pizza. Staff is friendly as well.

What a great little spot off the beaten path. After leaving a nearby pizza place die to poor service I was treated to this spot. Amazing food, great service and attentive staff. There was barely enough crust to fit all of the toppings onto. read more

Pretty lousy pizza with enormous amounts of meh cheese and a salad absolutely drowning in dressing. Wouldn't return. Also, didn't enforce mask requirements and man behind counter (getting our food) was mask less whole time we were there. read more

Good local pizza place. Plentiful toppings and friendly service. Crust is a bit breadlike. If you are looking for gourmet wood fired style, or if you hail from Chicago or NYC, this might not be your cup of tea. read more

This is hands down the best pizza I've ever had! I fly from California to Idaho for a few reasons and this place is one! The staff is friendly and make you feel at home and the pizza makes an spot in your heart that your stomach has to have more even if your 15000 miles from here! read more

Delicious pizza, you better be really hungry, because the pizzas are HUGE. Be prepared to wait, for a really good pizza, because it takes time for great pizza. read more

Came into sandpoint for a few days and got takeout from second ave! the pizza was STACKED with toppings and delicious! Would definitely recommend. Reasonably priced and absolutely worth it! read more